On the morning of Sunday, May 31, 2009, Scott Roeder killed Dr. George Tiller in Wichita, Kansas. The doctor ran one of the few clinics in the country that performed late-term abortions. Two men tried to stop Roeder, and he threatened them both before he left. Within about three hours he was in custody near Gardner, Kansas. He never denied what he had done, and on January 29, 2010, a Sedgwick County jury convicted him of premeditated first-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault.
The verdict settled the question of guilt but not the question of punishment. Roeder was first sentenced to life with no chance of parole for 50 years. The Kansas Supreme Court upheld his convictions in October 2014 but struck down that sentence, and two years later, days before a new jury was to hear the question, he was resentenced to life with parole eligibility after 25 years.
Roeder spent most of his adult life in and around Kansas. By 2009 he was 51, lived in the Kansas City area and drove an airport shuttle.
His one earlier serious case began in April 1996 in Topeka, when Shawnee County deputies stopped his car because it had no valid license plate. What they found in the car led to a felony charge under Kansas law, and a judge found him guilty and sentenced him to two years' probation. In 1997 the Kansas Court of Appeals overturned the conviction, holding that the evidence against him had been obtained unlawfully, and the case went no further.
The doctor was born in Wichita in 1941. He earned a degree in zoology from the University of Kansas in 1963 and his medical degree from the university's School of Medicine in 1967, then served his residency at the US Naval Hospital at Camp Pendleton, California. In 1970 he came home to Wichita to take over his father's general practice. Over the following years the practice grew into a clinic, Women's Health Care Services, and he also directed an alcoholism treatment program for women run by the Sedgwick County Health Department.
Roeder was arrested about three hours after the killing near Gardner, a town in the Kansas City suburbs, then taken back to Wichita and held without bail. On June 2, 2009, Sedgwick County prosecutors charged him with first-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault, the second and third counts covering his threats against the two men who had tried to stop him. By the time his trial opened in January 2010, his role was not in dispute.
The trial was held in Wichita before a Sedgwick County District Court judge. The prosecution kept its case narrow and confined it to the events of May 31. Roeder was the only witness for the defense. He took the stand on January 28, 2010, admitted the killing and did not contest the prosecution's account of it.
After the defense rested, the judge refused to let the jury consider voluntary manslaughter, finding that the legal test for it had not been met. He also refused an instruction on second-degree murder, finding the evidence of premeditation clear.
The case went to the jury on the morning of January 29, 2010, and jurors returned verdicts of guilty on all three counts: premeditated first-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault. First-degree murder in Kansas carried a mandatory life sentence. The only open question was how long Roeder would serve before he could ask a parole board for release: 25 years under the standard term, or 50 if the court imposed what Kansas called the Hard 50. The district attorney's office sought the longer term.
On April 1, 2010, at the end of a hearing that ran the whole day, the judge sentenced Roeder on the murder count to life in prison with no possibility of parole for 50 years, the most severe sentence then available under Kansas law. He based the Hard 50 on two findings: that the evidence showed Roeder had stalked his victim before the killing, and that killing a man in a house of worship made the crime an especially aggravated one. He added one year on each of the two aggravated assault counts. With credit for good behavior, Roeder would not have been eligible for parole for 51 years and 8 months.
Roeder appealed to the Kansas Supreme Court, which heard argument in Topeka on January 29, 2014, four years to the day after the verdict. The court issued its opinion on October 24, 2014. It affirmed the murder conviction and both aggravated assault convictions, and it agreed with the district court that Roeder could not present a necessity defense and that the facts did not support one. The challenge to the refusal of a manslaughter instruction did not win him a new trial.
The sentence did not survive. The court held that the Hard 50 had been imposed in violation of Roeder's Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial, because a judge, not a jury, had found the aggravating factor, and had done so only by a preponderance of the evidence. The ruling followed the US Supreme Court's 2013 decision in Alleyne v. United States, which held that any fact raising a mandatory minimum sentence must be found by a jury, and Roeder's sentence, imposed under the older version of the Kansas Hard 50 statute, was one of many in the state vacated as a result. The court sent the case back to Sedgwick County for resentencing, and the district attorney's office said it expected to ask a new jury to impose the Hard 50 again.
A jury sentencing hearing was set for the end of November 2016. On November 23, 2016, days before it was to begin, the court held a hearing that had not been announced in advance. Prosecutors withdrew their request for the Hard 50, and with the agreement of the defense the court resentenced Roeder to life in prison with parole eligibility after 25 years, plus two years for the two counts of aggravated assault. Roeder was 58.
As of his resentencing in November 2016, Roeder was serving a life sentence in Kansas. Under the terms imposed that day he may seek parole only after serving 25 years on the murder count, and the two aggravated assault convictions add two more years to his term.
Roeder's guilt was never contested; he admitted the killing before and during his trial. What the courts rejected was any claim that his reasons could reduce the crime or excuse it: the trial judge and the Kansas Supreme Court both held that his belief did not meet the legal test for voluntary manslaughter or for a necessity defense. No one else was charged in the killing.
April 1996: Shawnee County deputies stop Roeder's car in Topeka; he is charged with a felony and later convicted and given probation.
1997: The Kansas Court of Appeals overturns the 1996 conviction.
May 31, 2009: Roeder kills the doctor in Wichita and is arrested about three hours later near Gardner, Kansas.
June 2, 2009: Roeder is charged with first-degree murder and two counts of aggravated assault.
January 28, 2010: Roeder testifies and admits the killing; the judge refuses instructions on voluntary manslaughter and second-degree murder.
January 29, 2010: The jury convicts Roeder on all three counts.
April 1, 2010: Roeder is sentenced to life with no parole for 50 years, plus one year on each assault count.
January 29, 2014: The Kansas Supreme Court hears Roeder's appeal in Topeka.
October 24, 2014: The Kansas Supreme Court affirms the convictions and vacates the Hard 50 sentence.
November 23, 2016: Roeder is resentenced to life with parole eligibility after 25 years, plus two years.