Satwant Singh

Victims
Prime Minister Indira Gandhi assassinated in New Delhi, 1984. Convicted of her murder in pursuance of a conspiracy and of attempt to murder an escort officer; executed January 6, 1989.
Years active
October 31, 1984
Location
New Delhi; Aghwan, Gurdaspur district, Punjab
Method
Murder in pursuance of a criminal conspiracy, with common intention; attempt to murder
Status
Death sentence January 22, 1986; confirmed by Delhi High Court December 3, 1986; Supreme Court appeal dismissed August 3, 1988; review dismissed; executed January 6, 1989

On the morning of October 31, 1984, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was killed in New Delhi by two members of her own security detail. One of them was Satwant Singh, a constable of the Delhi Police who had been posted to guard her for more than a year. The other was a sub-inspector on the same detail, who died in custody within hours and never stood trial. Satwant Singh survived, was tried inside a Delhi jail with two alleged co-conspirators, and on January 22, 1986, was convicted of murder in pursuance of a criminal conspiracy, of attempt to murder an officer of the Prime Minister's escort, and of an offense under the arms law. He was sentenced to death.

Every court that heard the case came to the same conclusion about him. The Delhi High Court confirmed the sentence in December 1986. In August 1988 a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court of India dismissed his appeal in a judgment that ran to more than a hundred pages and settled questions that reached well beyond his own fate: whether a criminal trial held behind prison walls could still be an open trial, whether a confession recorded in the wrong form could be saved, and what had to be proved to make a man a conspirator. Satwant Singh was executed in New Delhi on January 6, 1989. He was 25.

A constable on the Prime Minister's detail

Satwant Singh joined the Delhi Police as a constable on January 11, 1982. After his initial training he was posted to the Fifth Battalion of the Delhi Armed Police, and after further commando training to its Second Battalion. From there he went to "C" Company of that battalion, quartered on Teen Murti Lane in New Delhi, and on July 2, 1983, he reported for security duty at the Prime Minister's residence. He was still on that duty sixteen months later.

The sub-inspector who would stand beside him on October 31 was a more senior officer on the same detail. A third member of the Prime Minister's security staff, another sub-inspector, was later charged with them and acquitted. The fourth man in the case was not a policeman at all. He was an assistant in the Directorate General of Supplies and Disposals in New Delhi, a civil servant, and he was related by marriage to the senior sub-inspector: he was the husband of that officer's wife's aunt.

The case the prosecution built

The prosecution's account began in June 1984, when the Indian Army entered the Golden Temple complex at Amritsar in the operation known as Operation Blue Star. The operation cost lives and damaged the Akal Takht, and the Supreme Court recorded that it gravely offended the religious feelings of members of the Sikh community. According to the charge-sheet, all four accused were Sikhs who had come to hold the Prime Minister responsible for the army action, had spoken of their resentment openly, and had met at different places and times to discuss it and to listen to speeches and recordings meant to provoke retaliation. Out of that, the prosecution said, came a criminal conspiracy to commit her murder.

The case against the civil servant rested on his influence over his relative. The prosecution said that he had drawn the senior sub-inspector, and through him Satwant Singh, toward a more intense religious commitment, and that the two officers went through the initiation ceremony of the Sikh faith at a gurdwara in the R.K. Puram area of New Delhi, the sub-inspector on October 14, 1984, and Satwant Singh on October 24. The civil servant was also said to have taken the sub-inspector to the Golden Temple at Amritsar in late October, and to have been in close and secret company with him in the weeks before the killing. A gold bangle and a ring belonging to the sub-inspector were later recovered from him.

The case against the second sub-inspector was different in kind. He had been posted at the Prime Minister's residence and was said to have shared the others' resentment, to have discussed his own intentions with the senior sub-inspector, and to have urged Satwant Singh on, speaking to him about it as late as October 30, 1984.

October 31, 1984

The Prime Minister had returned to New Delhi from a tour of Orissa on the night of October 30. On the morning of the 31st she was expected at her office, which stood beside her residence in New Delhi and was joined to it by a narrow pathway and a sentry gate. She left the residence a little after nine o'clock, accompanied by members of her personal staff and her police escort.

The courts found that the two officers had arranged their duties that morning so that both of them would be posted at that gate, in furtherance of the conspiracy. Satwant Singh had been entered in the duty diary for another post, and had his place changed on a pretext. When the Prime Minister reached the gate, the two officers turned on her. She was taken to the All India Institute of Medical Sciences and died of her injuries the same day. An assistant sub-inspector who was walking behind her in the escort was also struck and suffered injuries that the courts found to be grievous and dangerous to life. That injury became the basis of the charge of attempt to murder.

Both men were seized by personnel of the Indo-Tibetan Border Police and taken to a guard room. Both were critically injured in custody there. The senior sub-inspector died that day; Satwant Singh survived.

Unrest in the capital after the killing decided where the case would be tried.

The investigation

The first information report was registered at the New Delhi police station with jurisdiction over the Prime Minister's residence. It was first registered as an attempt to murder and was converted to murder once news of the Prime Minister's death came in. The officers present in the escort that morning, and members of her personal staff, became the prosecution's principal witnesses.

Satwant Singh was formally arrested on November 15, 1984. Because of the security situation in the capital, the Chief Justice and judges of the Delhi High Court, at the request of the Delhi Administration, designated an Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate to deal with his remand, and he was remanded to police custody until November 29. On that date an application was put before the magistrate saying that Satwant Singh wished to make a statement about the assassination. The magistrate did not record it at once. He told Satwant Singh that he was not bound to make any statement and that anything he said might be used against him, gave him until December 1 to reconsider, sent him to judicial custody, and directed the Legal Aid Committee to provide him a lawyer at state expense.

On December 1, 1984, Satwant Singh said again that he wished to make a statement. He was allowed to confer privately with counsel for about fifteen minutes. A doctor examined him and certified him fit to make a statement, and a link magistrate, after warning him once more that he was not obliged to say anything, recorded his confessional statement. The certificate attached to it stated that no police officer or anyone else was within sight or hearing. He later retracted it.

The civil servant was arrested on November 30, 1984, and the second sub-inspector on December 3. The second sub-inspector was also produced before the magistrate, and an application was filed saying that he too wished to confess, but after two appearances he declined to make any statement.

While the police investigation went on, the central government appointed a judge of the Supreme Court to inquire into the assassination under the Commission of Inquiry Act, 1952. The commission, which was set up by a notification of November 20, 1984, examined the sequence of events and the security arrangements around the Prime Minister. It submitted an interim report on November 19, 1985, and a final report on February 27, 1986. Several of the prosecution's witnesses at the trial had also given evidence before it, in proceedings the commission had made confidential.

Charges and a trial inside the jail

The charge-sheet was filed before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate against Satwant Singh, the civil servant and the second sub-inspector. All three were accused under the Indian Penal Code of conspiracy, abetment and common intention to commit murder, and of the substantive offenses of murder and attempt to murder, together with offenses under the arms law. The dead sub-inspector was named in the charge-sheet as one of the accused, but because he had died the others were described as having abetted him. The case was committed to the Court of Session.

On May 10, 1985, the Delhi High Court issued two notifications. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure it directed that the trial of the case, State v. Satwant Singh and others, be held in the central jail at Tihar, in Delhi. By the second it assigned the case to a named Additional Sessions Judge of New Delhi. The Supreme Court later explained why: the remand and committal proceedings had already been moved into the jail because the magistrate and the prosecutor had been threatened, and the government had asked for the trial to be held there for the security of the judge, the witnesses, the police officers and the accused themselves.

The defense objected. On May 17, 1985, an application filed for the civil servant asked the court not to hold the trial inside the jail. It was rejected on June 5, 1985, on the ground that the trial in the jail was an open trial and that nothing prevented members of the public who wished to attend from doing so. The trial judge allowed the press and the relatives of the accused to attend, said that members of the public would be admitted as space allowed, subject to the usual security check, and in practice admitted visitors, including law students in batches.

The prosecution's direct case against Satwant Singh rested on three members of the Prime Minister's escort and staff who had been beside her at the gate and who identified both officers, on the duty records and the officers who kept them, and on expert evidence matching the injuries to the two men's service issue. The confession was offered in corroboration. Against the civil servant the case was circumstantial, built on his association with his relative, on testimony about their meetings and conversations, and on what he was said to have done and said on the day of the killing. Against the second sub-inspector it rested largely on the evidence of a fellow police officer and on a document said to have been found on him at his arrest.

On January 22, 1986, the Additional Sessions Judge found the accused guilty of all the charges framed against them. Satwant Singh was convicted under the Indian Penal Code of murder in pursuance of a criminal conspiracy and with common intention, of attempt to murder, and of an offense under the arms law. The civil servant and the second sub-inspector were convicted of murder in pursuance of a criminal conspiracy. All three were sentenced to death, and Satwant Singh received further terms of imprisonment on the other counts.

Two appeals went to the Delhi High Court, one by Satwant Singh and one filed jointly by his two co-accused. They were heard together with the reference for confirmation of the death sentences. On December 3, 1986, the High Court accepted the reference, dismissed both appeals, and confirmed the convictions and the death sentences of all three men, together with the other sentences imposed on Satwant Singh. The High Court examined the principles the Supreme Court had laid down for death sentences, under which death is reserved for the rarest of rare cases, and gave its reasons for holding that this was one of them.

The Supreme Court

The three men appealed by special leave to the Supreme Court. The court appointed senior counsel as amicus curiae to argue for them, one for Satwant Singh and another for his two co-accused, and the Additional Solicitor General appeared for the state. The bench was made up of three judges, each of whom wrote a separate opinion. Judgment was delivered on August 3, 1988.

The appellants raised sixteen grounds in common, and the second sub-inspector raised several more of his own. The most important for Satwant Singh were three. The first was that holding the trial inside the jail had denied him the open and public trial that the Code of Criminal Procedure guaranteed and that, the defense argued, the Constitution required. The second was that the courts had refused to give the defense copies of the statements made to the commission of inquiry by witnesses who later testified at the trial, or the commission's report. The third was that his confession had not been recorded in the form the Code required and could not be used.

On the first point, all three judges held that the trial had been valid. They read the High Court's notification as adding the jail to the places where a Court of Session in the Delhi division might ordinarily sit, beside Tis Hazari and New Delhi, and held that the High Court had power to issue it. Once a court sits in a place, they held, the Code makes that place an open court to which the public may have access so far as it can conveniently hold them. What the appellants had to show was that someone had in fact been kept out, and there was no material that anyone who wished to attend had been turned away. The office block where the trial was held was not the part of the jail where prisoners were confined. The court added that the circumstances of the time, the threats to those conducting the case and the violence after the assassination, amply justified the decision.

On the second point, the court held that the statements made to the commission were protected by the Commission of Inquiry Act. A statement made before such a commission could not be used against the person who made it in any later civil or criminal proceeding, except a prosecution for giving false evidence, and the commission had treated its own proceedings as confidential. The central government had also used a 1986 amendment to the Act to decline to lay the commission's reports before the Lok Sabha, on the ground that doing so would not be in the interest of the security of the state. The trial court had been right not to call for those statements.

On the confession, the court held that the magistrate had not recorded it in the form the Code required, but that the defect could be cured because the Code's mandatory safeguards had been observed: Satwant Singh had been told that he was not bound to make a statement and that it might be used against him, and the magistrate's evidence showed that the statement was voluntary. A confession could be used against the man who made it even after he retracted it, if the court believed it, though courts usually looked for corroboration. In this case, the court found, it was corroborated by the independent evidence. One judge went further and said the case against Satwant Singh was so strong on the eyewitness and other evidence that there was no need to rely on the confession at all.

On sentence the judges were unanimous. The opinion that led the court noted that Satwant Singh and his fellow officer had been posted to protect the Prime Minister and held that this left no mitigating circumstance to consider. Another judge set out the "rarest of rare" test and agreed with the High Court's application of it.

The court dismissed the appeals of Satwant Singh and the civil servant and upheld their convictions and death sentences. It allowed the appeal of the second sub-inspector, set aside his conviction and ordered him freed at once. It held that the evidence against him was defective and deficient and did not prove his part in the conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt, and that Satwant Singh's confession could not supply what the other evidence lacked, since its reference to the second sub-inspector was not within Satwant Singh's own knowledge.

Review and clemency

Satwant Singh and the civil servant asked the Supreme Court to review its judgment, arguing among other things that the three separate opinions were inconsistent on whether the trial in the jail had been vitiated. The review petition was dismissed on September 7, 1988. A further writ petition was dismissed as well.

Petitions for mercy then went to the President of India under the Constitution's power of pardon, and the Ministry of Home Affairs handled the mercy petitions of both men in a single file. On October 14, 1988, a petition for pardon was filed with the President on the civil servant's behalf, arguing that the evidence at trial showed his innocence and asking that a representative be heard in person. The request for a hearing was refused, and on November 15, 1988, the Secretary to the President wrote that the President could not go into the merits of a case finally decided by the Supreme Court. The petition was rejected, and the execution was fixed for December 2.

On December 1 a petition was filed in the Delhi High Court and dismissed the same afternoon. The Supreme Court took up a writ petition that day and stayed the execution. On December 16, 1988, a Constitution Bench of five judges held that the President was wrong to think he could not examine the merits. Under that power the President could look at the evidence afresh and reach a different view of guilt and sentence, without altering the judicial record. The court held that a condemned prisoner had no right to an oral hearing, declined to lay down guidelines for the exercise of the power, and declined to reopen the question of whether the death penalty was constitutional. It directed that the petition be treated as pending before the President, to be decided afresh. The petition was again rejected.

Satwant Singh and the civil servant were executed in New Delhi on Friday, January 6, 1989, a little more than three years after the trial court sentenced them. Satwant Singh was 25 and the civil servant 53. Police and paramilitary units were placed on alert in New Delhi, Punjab, Haryana and Himachal Pradesh in the days around the executions.

Context: the law the courts applied

The courts' handling of this case turned on a small number of provisions, and each shaped what happened to Satwant Singh.

The Indian Penal Code punishes criminal conspiracy, and when that provision is read with the murder provision, a conspirator is liable for murder committed in pursuance of the agreement. That is how the civil servant, who was not at the gate, came to be convicted of murder and executed. Satwant Singh was convicted of murder read with both the conspiracy provision and the common-intention provision, which applies when a criminal act is done by several people in furtherance of their common intention. The Supreme Court treated the conspiracy as a matter of proof by circumstance: a conspiracy is usually hatched in secret, and it may be proved by evidence that the parties shared the unlawful design. In the civil servant's case the judges held that his association with his relative, his conduct before and after the killing and the other evidence, taken together, were stronger proof than direct testimony would have been.

The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, requires a court that imposes death for murder to give special reasons. The Supreme Court read it as marking a shift in policy, under which life imprisonment is the normal sentence for murder and death the exception. Its 1980 and 1983 rulings had confined death to the rarest of rare cases with no extenuating circumstance. Both the High Court and the Supreme Court held that the murder of the Prime Minister by men posted to protect her met that test.

The Constitution gives the President power to pardon or commute. The Constitution Bench held in December 1988 that the President exercises it on the advice of the government, and that the courts may review the President's order only within the narrow limits set by its own earlier ruling on remission.

Disputed and unproven points

The question of who else had been part of the conspiracy was argued at every stage. The Supreme Court held that the second sub-inspector's part in it was not proved, and he was acquitted after more than three years under sentence of death. The court also held that the passage in Satwant Singh's confession that referred to the second sub-inspector rested on what Satwant Singh had heard from someone else, and was of little use even as corroboration.

The civil servant's conviction rested on circumstantial evidence, and his innocence was argued through the review, the mercy petition and the writ petition that followed. The Supreme Court upheld the finding of conspiracy against him, though one judge accepted the High Court's conclusion without accepting all of its reasons. The papers on the mercy petitions record an early note that, in the circumstances of the case, the question of clemency hardly arose.

The defense also argued in the Supreme Court that parts of the scientific and medical work in the investigation were incomplete. The court rejected those arguments, holding that the evidence of the witnesses who had been at the gate, with the other circumstances proved, left no doubt about Satwant Singh's guilt. Satwant Singh retracted his confession after it was recorded, but the courts held that it was voluntary and corroborated.

The commission of inquiry's reports, which dealt with the security arrangements around the Prime Minister, were withheld from Parliament under the 1986 amendment while the case was before the courts. The defense never obtained the statements made to the commission by witnesses who later testified at the trial.

Timeline

January 11, 1982: Satwant Singh joins the Delhi Police as a constable.

July 2, 1983: He reports for security duty at the Prime Minister's residence in New Delhi.

June 1984: The Indian Army enters the Golden Temple complex at Amritsar in Operation Blue Star.

October 24, 1984: Satwant Singh goes through the initiation ceremony of the Sikh faith at a gurdwara in New Delhi.

October 31, 1984: The Prime Minister is killed in New Delhi; an officer of her escort is injured; the senior sub-inspector dies in custody.

November 15, 1984: Satwant Singh is formally arrested and remanded to police custody.

November 20, 1984: The central government appoints a commission of inquiry into the assassination.

November 29, 1984: Satwant Singh asks to make a statement; the magistrate gives him time to reconsider.

November 30, 1984: The civil servant is arrested.

December 1, 1984: A link magistrate records Satwant Singh's confessional statement.

December 3, 1984: The second sub-inspector is arrested.

May 10, 1985: The Delhi High Court directs that the trial be held in the central jail at Tihar and assigns it to an Additional Sessions Judge.

June 5, 1985: The objection to a trial inside the jail is rejected.

November 19, 1985: The commission of inquiry submits its interim report.

January 22, 1986: The three accused are convicted and sentenced to death.

February 27, 1986: The commission submits its final report.

December 3, 1986: The Delhi High Court confirms the convictions and death sentences.

August 3, 1988: The Supreme Court upholds the convictions and death sentences of Satwant Singh and the civil servant and acquits the second sub-inspector.

September 7, 1988: The Supreme Court dismisses the review petition.

October 14, 1988: A mercy petition for the civil servant is filed with the President.

December 1, 1988: The Supreme Court stays the execution set for the following day.

December 16, 1988: A Constitution Bench rules on the President's clemency power and directs that the petition be decided afresh.

January 6, 1989: Satwant Singh and the civil servant are executed in New Delhi.