Sarah Johnson

Victims
2 murders, her parents, 2003. Convicted of two counts of first-degree murder, March 16, 2005.
Years active
September 2, 2003
Location
Bellevue, Idaho (killings); Hailey, Idaho (trial court hearings and sentencing); Boise, Idaho (trial)
Method
Shot with a rifle (prosecution case, accepted by the jury).
Status
Two fixed life terms plus 15 years, no parole (2005). Affirmed 2008; relief denied 2014, 2017; habeas denied 2023, affirmed 2024. Imprisoned in Idaho as of October 2024.

On the morning of Tuesday, September 2, 2003, a married couple were killed in Bellevue, a small town at the southern end of Idaho's Wood River Valley, a few miles south of Hailey and the resort country of Sun Valley. Their daughter, Sarah Marie Johnson, was 16 years old and was there with them. Eight weeks later a Blaine County grand jury indicted her on two counts of first-degree murder, and on March 16, 2005, after a six-week trial moved to Boise because a fair jury could not be found in Blaine County, a jury convicted her of both.

She was sentenced to two fixed life terms and a further fifteen years, with no possibility of parole. Johnson has never admitted the killings. Her lawyers have argued in state court and federal court that another person committed them, that her trial lawyer failed her, that newer testing of the evidence could clear her, and that a life sentence with no chance of release cannot lawfully be imposed on someone who was a child at the time of the crime. Every one of those arguments has been rejected, most recently by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in October 2024.

Her parents

Alan Scott Johnson and Diane M. Johnson had been married since April 23, 1983, and had built their life in the valley for two decades. They had two children: a son, who was away at the University of Idaho in Moscow in the fall of 2003, and Sarah, the younger, who was a junior at Wood River High School.

By the account of those who knew him, her father loved his children and the outdoors. He hunted ducks and geese with his dog, Sage, and was counted among the best clay-target competitors in southern Idaho, and the people he worked with knew him for hard work and an eye for detail. Her mother had spent many years working in the valley and was remembered as a loving, giving woman who never treated anyone as a stranger.

Sarah was born on January 1, 1987. In the summer of 2003 she was involved with a 19-year-old man from Hailey, and her parents opposed the relationship. On Friday, August 29, she stayed out overnight. Her parents found her with the young man the next day, and investigators later said the couple had become engaged that Friday night. Her father told the young man to stay away from his daughter and threatened to report him to the police, though he never did. Those few days at the end of August became the center of the prosecution's case.

Eight weeks

The Blaine County Sheriff's Office took charge of the case on the day of the killings, and investigators obtained a detention warrant for Sarah before the day was out. Evidence from the property and from the neighborhood went to the state crime laboratory in Boise. A week later no one had been arrested. Investigators had ruled out a murder-suicide and were looking at three people of interest, none yet considered a suspect.

The investigation was large by the standards of a rural county. Officers interviewed 50 to 60 people of Sarah's age and more than 100 people in all, and gathered more than 200 items of evidence. At various points five people were described as people of interest. The young man Sarah had been seeing was one of them; he was never a suspect, and he testified before the grand jury as a material witness.

Sarah spent those two months in Caldwell, west of Boise, living with an aunt and uncle who had become her legal guardians. The laboratory results came back in mid-October, and investigators said they linked her to the killings. In the last days of October a grand jury heard the case over two days and returned an indictment.

Blaine County officers arrested her on the evening of Wednesday, October 29, 2003. She was charged as an adult with two counts of first-degree murder, each of which carried a possible sentence of ten years to life, or death, and the prosecuting attorney announced at the outset that he would not seek the death penalty. On November 3, 2003, she pleaded not guilty to both counts in the Fifth District Court in Hailey. Bail was set at $2 million, and she remained in custody.

Six weeks in Boise

The case was large. By July 2004 the defense counted 9,000 pages of records, 407 potential witnesses and hundreds of items of evidence, much of it only recently returned from out-of-state laboratories. Four trial dates were set in all, the last with Sarah's own agreement to the delay, and the court agreed that impartial jurors would be hard to find in the valley and moved the trial out of Blaine County to the Ada County Courthouse in Boise. It became the most expensive prosecution in the county's history.

The trial opened in February 2005 and ran for six weeks, and the cost of the case passed $1 million. The prosecution's account was one of motive and opportunity. Prosecutors told the jury that Sarah had fought with her parents over the relationship, that her parents had threatened to have the young man arrested, and that she had wanted to marry him and live on her inheritance. They pointed to the physical evidence gathered in the hours after the deaths and to the changing accounts she had given investigators. She had spoken of an intruder, but there was no sign that anyone had broken in. The young man testified for the prosecution.

The defense case was that someone else had killed the couple and had arranged the evidence so that the blame would fall on their daughter. Her lawyer argued that the physical evidence did not fit a teenager who had acted alone that morning and that the investigation had settled on her too early. Sarah did not confess at any stage. Later courts summed up the evidence at trial in the same way: she had consistently denied any part in the killings, but she had given several inconsistent accounts of what she did, saw and heard before and after them.

Verdict and sentence

On Wednesday, March 16, 2005, the jury found Sarah Johnson guilty of two counts of first-degree murder. She was 18. In May 2005 the trial judge denied her motion for a new trial, finding no evidence of juror misconduct.

Idaho law required a life term for each count of first-degree murder, with at least ten years to be served before any parole eligibility, and left the court the discretion to make the terms fixed, which in Idaho means the prisoner is never eligible for parole. The state asked for consecutive life terms. At the sentencing hearing in Hailey a psychiatrist and a neuropsychologist testified for the defense about her development and about adolescent impulsivity, and the court's remarks before it pronounced sentence returned again and again to her youth. Before sentence was passed, Sarah spoke. She told the court she was "deeply grieving the loss of my parents," that she loved her parents and her family, and that she hoped to rebuild her life.

The court sentenced her to two fixed life terms, plus fifteen years under a sentence enhancement, with no possibility of parole.

Appeals in Idaho

The first appeal never reached the merits. Her notice of appeal was filed late, and the appeal was dismissed as untimely. A petition for post-conviction relief, filed in 2006, succeeded on one point: her lawyer's failure to file the appeal in time was ineffective assistance. The judgment was entered again so that she could appeal properly. On the second attempt she argued that the charging document and the jury instructions were flawed and that the selection of the jury had biased the case against her. In June 2008 the Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the conviction, and the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear the case later that year.

The rest of the post-conviction case turned in a new direction in February 2009, when her lawyer asked the court to review newly discovered evidence. The state's Bureau of Criminal Identification laboratory had made a new identification on an item of evidence belonging to a tenant who rented quarters on the Johnson property, and her lawyer argued that the finding might entitle her to a new trial. The prosecution said the identification pointed to a former roommate of the tenant. That man was never charged.

The question of a third person had been put to the jury at trial, and in 2011 the district court ruled that neither the claims of ineffective counsel nor the new evidence justified a new trial. Her new lawyers, now working with the Idaho Innocence Project at Boise State University, appealed. The Idaho Supreme Court affirmed the denial of relief on February 18, 2014. It held that she had not shown that her trial lawyer's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, and that she had not shown that questioning further witnesses or the new evidence would probably have produced a different result at trial.

The testing petition and the sentencing claim

While that appeal was still pending, Sarah's lawyers, working pro bono, opened a second front. In April 2012 they filed a combined petition for new testing of the trial evidence and a successive petition for post-conviction relief in the district court for Blaine County.

The petition asked for two kinds of testing. Some profiles developed from the evidence before trial had never been matched to anyone, and her lawyers wanted them run against the larger law enforcement databases that now existed. Other samples had been too small to test in 2005, and they argued that newer techniques could now produce results. Behind both requests was the theory the defense had pressed from the start: that someone else had been there that morning.

The petition also raised a constitutional claim that had not existed when she was sentenced. In 2012 the Supreme Court of the United States decided Miller v. Alabama, holding that mandatory sentences of life without parole for juvenile offenders violate the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. Her lawyers argued that her two fixed life terms, imposed for crimes committed at 16, were unlawful under that ruling.

At the end of October 2014 the district judge rejected both arguments. On the testing claim he found that the possibility of a third person had been presented at trial and that the jury had heard it and still convicted her of first-degree murder. On the sentencing claim he ruled that the argument should have been raised in her first post-conviction case and that Idaho had no mandatory fixed life sentencing scheme, so her sentence had been a matter of discretion.

The Idaho Supreme Court, 2017

The Idaho Supreme Court decided the appeal on May 12, 2017, in a unanimous opinion that affirmed the district court on every point.

On the first category of testing, the court held that running existing profiles against a larger database was not new "technology" within the meaning of the Idaho statute. On the second, it held that the statute requires a district court to weigh the possible results of testing against the evidence at trial, and that results from the small samples could not show that Sarah was more probably than not innocent. Nothing in the record showed that the samples had come from the person who committed the killings, and the evidence against her at trial had been substantial.

On the sentencing claim, the court for the first time accepted that Miller v. Alabama and the later decision in Montgomery v. Louisiana apply in Idaho, and it found that her claim had been brought within a reasonable time. It then held that the requirement those decisions impose had been met in her case. The sentencing court had heard expert testimony about adolescent development and impulsivity, and its remarks had addressed her youth at length; in the Idaho Supreme Court's words, the court "clearly considered Johnson's youth and all its attendant characteristics" before deciding that life without parole was still the right sentence. The court also declined to overrule its earlier decision in Murphy v. State, under which the ineffective assistance of a post-conviction lawyer is not a sufficient reason to allow a successive petition, and the remaining claims of the petition failed with it.

That year Idaho held about 8,000 prisoners, and four of them, Sarah Johnson among them, were serving life without parole for murders committed as teenagers. Her lawyers took the sentencing question to the Supreme Court of the United States, which denied review on November 27, 2017.

The federal case

Her federal petition for a writ of habeas corpus was heard in the United States District Court for the District of Idaho. The court first granted the state's motion for partial summary dismissal of five of her claims on the ground that they had not been properly presented in state court, rejecting two of those on their merits in the alternative, and it allowed her to try to show that three of the defaulted claims fell within the narrow exception the Supreme Court had recognized in Martinez v. Ryan.

Two claims went forward on their merits: a Sixth Amendment claim that her trial lawyer had been ineffective, and an Eighth Amendment claim against the fixed life sentences. In a memorandum decision and order dated August 2, 2023, a United States magistrate judge denied the amended petition and dismissed it with prejudice. The court found that the two exhausted claims failed on their merits, that the defaulted claims had no excuse and failed on their merits in any event, and that there was no likelihood an Idaho appellate court would have set aside the sentences as an abuse of the trial court's discretion. It granted a certificate of appealability on the sentencing claim alone.

Before the Ninth Circuit, Sarah's lawyers argued that the Idaho Supreme Court had decided only a procedural version of her Eighth Amendment claim and had never addressed the substantive question of whether her crimes reflected the transient immaturity of youth. They asked for a hearing on whether she was permanently incorrigible.

The panel rejected each point in an unpublished memorandum filed on October 30, 2024. It held that the Idaho Supreme Court had addressed the substantive claim, and that even if it had not, a federal court would presume the claim had been rejected on its merits. The state court had recited the correct rule, that life without parole is unconstitutional for juveniles whose crimes reflect transient immaturity, and had never suggested she could receive that sentence if hers did. Under the Supreme Court's decision in Jones v. Mississippi, no finding of permanent incorrigibility was required, so no hearing on the question was needed either. The court's judgment was one word: affirmed.

That decision left both fixed life terms in place, and as of October 2024 she was serving them in the custody of the state of Idaho.

Disputed and unproven points

Sarah Johnson has denied killing her parents from the beginning, and her lawyers maintain that she is innocent. Her defense argued at trial that another person committed the killings and framed her, and in post-conviction proceedings her lawyers pointed to the identification evidence found after the trial and to evidence they wanted tested with newer methods. The prosecution answered that the identification belonged to a man who had handled the item before the killings and had nothing to do with the deaths. No other person has been charged. The jury heard the third-person theory in 2005 and convicted her, and every court that has reviewed the case since, in Idaho and in the federal system, has upheld that verdict.

The motive given at trial was the prosecution's account: that she acted in anger over her parents' opposition to her relationship and with a wish to marry and live on an inheritance. She has never accepted it.

Timeline

April 23, 1983: Her parents marry.

January 1, 1987: Sarah Marie Johnson is born.

August 29 and 30, 2003: She stays out overnight; her parents find her with the young man the next day.

September 2, 2003: Her parents are killed in Bellevue, Idaho.

October 29, 2003: Arrested after a Blaine County grand jury indicts her on two counts of first-degree murder; charged as an adult.

November 3, 2003: Pleads not guilty to both counts in the Fifth District Court in Hailey.

February 2005: Trial opens at the Ada County Courthouse in Boise.

March 16, 2005: The jury finds her guilty of two counts of first-degree murder.

May 2005: Motion for a new trial denied.

2005: Sentenced in Hailey to two fixed life terms plus fifteen years, without parole.

2006: First petition for post-conviction relief filed; it later restores her right to appeal.

June 2008: The Idaho Supreme Court affirms the conviction; the Supreme Court of the United States declines review later that year.

February 2009: Her lawyer asks the court to review newly identified evidence.

2011: The district court denies a new trial on the post-conviction claims.

April 2012: Petition for new testing and successive post-conviction petition filed.

February 18, 2014: The Idaho Supreme Court affirms the denial of post-conviction relief.

October 2014: The district court rejects the testing and sentencing claims.

May 12, 2017: The Idaho Supreme Court affirms.

November 27, 2017: The Supreme Court of the United States denies review.

August 2, 2023: The federal district court denies her habeas petition.

October 30, 2024: The Ninth Circuit affirms.