On October 6, 2010, the Supreme Court of India upheld the conviction of Santosh Kumar Singh for the rape and murder of Priyadarshini Mattoo, who died in Vasant Kunj, in south Delhi, on January 23, 1996. The same judgment set aside the death sentence the Delhi High Court had passed four years earlier and replaced it with imprisonment for life. That ruling closed a criminal case that had turned on itself twice. A sessions court in Delhi had acquitted Singh in December 1999, giving him the benefit of the doubt. The Central Bureau of Investigation appealed, and in October 2006 the High Court found the acquittal perverse, convicted him of murder and rape under the Indian Penal Code and ordered that he be put to death.
The case turned in part on what happened before that January. In the fourteen months before she died, Singh, who had already finished his law degree, kept returning to the campus where she was enrolled, and she went to the police about him again and again. Every court that heard the case accepted that the harassment was proved, and the trial judge, the High Court and the Supreme Court all found that Delhi Police officers had failed to act properly on her complaints. Since 2021 a second contest has run alongside the first: Singh's applications for premature release, refused by Delhi's Sentence Review Board, sent back by the High Court, refused again and, as of April 2026, still before the courts.
Singh took his LL.B. at the Campus Law Centre of the University of Delhi and completed it in December 1994. At the trial he was described as an advocate, and the trial court recorded that he was also enrolled at the Indian Law Institute in New Delhi. The Supreme Court treated him as 24 in January 1996.
The courts dated the harassment to November 1994, and after he graduated Singh kept coming back to the law faculty. From February 1995 she made a series of complaints to Delhi Police. One ended with two written apologies from Singh and a written undertaking that he would not harass her again; another was withdrawn after he gave a further undertaking. The police assigned her a personal security officer, a head constable, but the arrangement did not stop him. In August 1995 she complained again at Vasant Kunj police station, and senior officers persuaded her to leave that complaint pending. From October 1995 Singh also wrote to the university alleging that she was enrolled in two courses at once, which the rules did not allow. The university issued her a notice to show cause and withheld a semester result, and the inquiry was still open when she died.
The trial court found, and the Supreme Court agreed, that officers had not acted properly on the complaints and that some had pressed her to compromise.
She died in Vasant Kunj on January 23, 1996, and a case of murder was registered at Vasant Kunj police station that evening. Her personal security officer had seen Singh at the law faculty earlier the same day. A neighbor later testified that he saw Singh nearby that afternoon, and the Supreme Court accepted him as a credible witness. Two other witnesses who told investigators they had seen Singh leaving the colony turned hostile at the trial.
Singh was brought in that night, examined by a doctor at Safdarjung Hospital and released with an instruction to report to the police station the next morning. On January 24 the Delhi Government asked the Central Bureau of Investigation to take the case, and the CBI registered it on January 25. The bureau referred scientific testing to the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology in Hyderabad, a government science laboratory. It also collected records from two Delhi medical facilities that Singh said had treated him after a traffic accident on January 14, 1996, the account he gave for an injury to his hand. Two doctors at Safdarjung Hospital gave their opinion that the injury was recent.
On April 11, 1996, the CBI filed its charge sheet. On August 29, 1996, charges of rape and murder were framed against Singh, and he pleaded not guilty.
The trial opened in August 1997. The prosecution examined 50 witnesses; the defense called none. After final arguments the case passed to another additional sessions judge, who summoned further witnesses before ruling.
On December 3, 1999, the sessions court acquitted Singh. The judgment listed 13 circumstances that the prosecution relied on and accepted several of them: the harassment was proved, and so was the motive it supplied. But the judge rejected the scientific evidence, finding that doubts about how the samples had been kept and handled left room for tampering. He held that the defense explanation for the injury to Singh's hand had not been conclusively disproved, and that the prosecution had not proved rape. The trial court also found deliberate inaction by Delhi Police, criticized one Delhi Police inspector as having helped create false evidence and faulted the CBI for failing to produce a domestic employee as a witness. It gave Singh the benefit of the doubt.
The CBI appealed to the Delhi High Court on February 29, 2000. The appeal then waited more than six years, through repeated requests from the bureau for an early hearing. In 2006 the High Court fixed the hearing and ordered that it run from day to day, and a division bench reserved judgment on September 27, 2006.
On October 17, 2006, the High Court set aside the acquittal as perverse and convicted Singh of murder and rape under Sections 302 and 376 of the Indian Penal Code. The bench found no evidence that the samples had been tampered with and no proof that the laboratory's procedure was flawed. It rejected Singh's account of the traffic accident. It agreed with the trial judge that some Delhi Police officials had acted unfairly to protect the accused and that the police had failed to act on the victim's complaints. Singh was in court for the judgment and was taken into custody by the CBI on the bench's direction.
At the sentencing hearing on October 30, 2006, the CBI asked for death. The defense argued that the conviction rested wholly on circumstantial evidence, that Singh had been young at the time and that since the acquittal he had married and become a father. The High Court, relying on the Supreme Court's decisions in Bachan Singh and Machhi Singh, did not accept these as grounds for a lesser sentence and sentenced him to death.
Singh appealed. On February 19, 2007, the Supreme Court admitted the appeal and stayed the death sentence until it was decided. A bench of two judges heard the appeal, reserved judgment on July 29, 2010, and delivered it on October 6, 2010.
The court began from the rule that an acquittal deserves great weight and that an appellate court should be slow to set one aside, but held that interference is justified where the trial judgment is perverse, meaning contrary to the evidence as a whole. The High Court had applied that test correctly, it said. On the scientific evidence, it held that the trial judge had gone wrong by substituting his own view on a technical subject for that of the experts without putting his doubts to them, and it found that the samples had been properly preserved. It set aside the trial court's findings that the CBI had conducted the investigation unfairly.
On the injury to Singh's hand, the court accepted the evidence of three doctors that the fracture was recent. The defense had placed hospital documents on record but called no witness from either facility, and because the history of the injury lay within Singh's special knowledge, the court held that the burden of proving it rested on him under Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act. It accepted the neighbor's testimony. Motive alone, it said, could not convict anyone, but here it strengthened a chain of circumstances that was complete without it. The murder, the court added, was proved independently of the finding of rape.
The court upheld both convictions and turned to the sentence. Where a court has difficulty choosing between death and life imprisonment, it said, it should impose the lesser. It weighed the reversal of an acquittal on circumstantial evidence, Singh's age of 24 at the time, his marriage and the birth of his daughter, and the absence of anything to show that he could not be reformed, and concluded that the balance tilted marginally in his favor. The order commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for life and, with that modification, dismissed the appeal.
Singh served his sentence in Delhi and continued studying law in custody, enrolling in an LL.M. program in 2012. On May 14, 2019, the High Court granted him three weeks of parole to sit his final-year examinations. From 2019 he was held in an open prison in Delhi, and his counsel later told the courts that he was practicing law in a trial court during the day.
Under Delhi's remission policy, a life prisoner in Singh's position became eligible to be considered for premature release after 20 years of imprisonment, counting remission. Delhi's Sentence Review Board, chaired by the territory's home minister, considered his case on October 21, 2021, and refused it. In 2023 he petitioned the High Court to quash that decision. While the petition was pending, the board rejected him again in 2024, applying the 2004 policy that had been in force at the time of his conviction.
On July 1, 2025, a single judge of the Delhi High Court set aside the board's refusal and sent the matter back for fresh consideration. The court found an element of reformation in Singh and directed that a formal psychological assessment by a qualified professional be carried out before the board decided again. The board refused once more on November 27, 2025. On December 3, 2025, the High Court granted Singh parole while he challenged the new refusal.
On March 19, 2026, a different single judge of the High Court refused to extend that parole, directed Singh to surrender and said the court would take up his remission petition only after he had done so. On April 10, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear his challenge to the refusal and asked the High Court to decide the remission petition quickly. On April 16 the High Court listed the petition for April 20, together with those of other life prisoners raising the same questions. As of late April 2026 more than 22 such petitions, Singh's among them, were pending as a batch before the same judge.
Singh pleaded not guilty and has maintained that position through every appeal. His defense rested chiefly on the traffic accident of January 14, 1996, which he said accounted for the injury to his hand. The trial court found that account not conclusively disproved; the High Court and the Supreme Court rejected it, noting that no witness from the facilities named in his documents was called.
The rape conviction rested on the scientific evidence; the Supreme Court acknowledged that the medical evidence on its own did not establish it. The trial court had rejected that scientific evidence because of doubts about how the samples were stored and handled. Both appellate courts held that the doubts had been explained, and the Supreme Court said that the murder conviction would stand on the other circumstances even without the finding of rape.
The extent of any influence exercised on Singh's behalf was never the subject of a separate finding. The trial court held only that influence on junior investigators could not be excluded, and found no direct interference. The Supreme Court rejected the trial court's criticisms of the CBI while upholding its findings on how Delhi Police officers handled the complaints before January 1996.
Two witnesses who told investigators that they saw Singh leaving the area on January 23 turned hostile at the trial, and the courts did not rely on them. On release, the High Court found an element of reformation in 2025, while the Sentence Review Board refused him three times; that question was still before the High Court as of April 2026.
November 1994: Harassment of the victim begins, on evidence accepted at trial.
December 1994: Singh completes his LL.B. at the University of Delhi.
February 1995: The first police complaints; Singh gives written apologies and an undertaking.
January 23, 1996: The victim dies in Vasant Kunj, New Delhi; Delhi Police register a case of murder.
January 24-25, 1996: The Delhi Government hands the case to the CBI, which registers it.
April 11, 1996: The CBI files its charge sheet.
August 29, 1996: Charges of rape and murder are framed; Singh pleads not guilty.
August 1997: The trial opens.
December 3, 1999: The sessions court acquits Singh.
February 29, 2000: The CBI appeals to the Delhi High Court.
October 17, 2006: The High Court reverses the acquittal and convicts Singh of murder and rape.
October 30, 2006: The High Court sentences him to death.
February 19, 2007: The Supreme Court admits his appeal and stays the death sentence.
October 6, 2010: The Supreme Court upholds the conviction and commutes the death sentence to life imprisonment.
May 14, 2019: The High Court grants three weeks of parole for his final LL.M. examinations.
October 21, 2021: The Sentence Review Board refuses premature release.
2024: The board refuses premature release a second time.
July 1, 2025: The High Court sets aside the refusal and sends the case back to the board.
November 27, 2025: The board refuses premature release again.
December 3, 2025: The High Court grants parole while he challenges the refusal.
March 19, 2026: The High Court refuses to extend his parole and directs him to surrender.
April 10, 2026: The Supreme Court declines to hear his parole challenge and asks the High Court to decide his remission petition quickly.
April 16, 2026: The High Court lists his petition for April 20.