Santino William Legan

Victims
3 people killed, 17 wounded, Gilroy, July 28, 2019; never charged or tried (died by suicide the same day)
Years active
July 28, 2019
Location
Gilroy, California (killings and death); Walker Lake, Mineral County, Nevada (residence from spring 2019)
Method
Shot with a rifle; the coroner ruled all three deaths homicides
Status
Coroner ruled his death a suicide, August 2, 2019. DA cleared the three officers, March 10, 2020. Died by suicide before trial at Gilroy, California, July 28, 2019; never charged.

On the evening of Sunday, July 28, 2019, the last day of the Gilroy Garlic Festival in Gilroy, California, three people were killed and seventeen more wounded. Police and the county medical examiner-coroner identified the man responsible as Santino William Legan, who was 19. Two of the dead were children from San Jose, a boy and a girl. The third was a young man from upstate New York. Three Gilroy police officers working the festival reached Legan in less than a minute and fired on him; wounded, he took his own life where he fell. The Santa Clara County medical examiner-coroner ruled the three deaths homicides and his own a suicide.

Because he died at the scene, no charge was ever filed and no court ever heard the evidence. In place of a trial there is a coroner's ruling, a district attorney's review of the officers' conduct, and a federal domestic terrorism investigation that never announced a motive. A year after the killings, the Gilroy police still had not identified one.

Gilroy sits at the southern end of Santa Clara County, about 30 miles southeast of San Jose. Its garlic festival, a volunteer-run summer gathering of food, music and cooking that began in the late 1970s, was the town's signature event and drew more than 100,000 visitors in a typical year. In 2019 it ran from July 26 to July 28.

Legan grew up in the Gilroy area. From the fall of 2013 to the spring of 2016 he attended a private Christian high school in Watsonville, about half an hour away, then transferred to Gilroy High School for his senior year and graduated in 2017. By the spring of 2019 he had moved to Walker Lake, a remote community in Mineral County in western Nevada. Officials said he had no criminal record.

The festival's final day was winding down when Legan reached the grounds. Within a few minutes twenty people had been wounded or killed. Three of them died: the two children from San Jose, and Trevor Deon Irby of Romulus, a small town in upstate New York. He had grown up there, played several sports and stayed a loyal fan of the Pittsburgh Steelers. The medical examiner-coroner ruled each of the three deaths a homicide.

Three Gilroy officers, a detective and two officers, reached Legan less than a minute after the violence began. When he turned on them, they fired. He was wounded several times and, as he fell, took his own life. In the first days the Gilroy police said the officers had killed him, and that is how the case was reported across the country for most of a week. On August 2, 2019, the medical examiner-coroner ruled his death a suicide.

Through the night and into the next day, officers from several agencies searched for a possible second person. Some witnesses had described someone who seemed to be with Legan, but their accounts did not agree. By Tuesday, July 30, the police said the evidence pointed more and more firmly to his having acted alone, though the FBI went on examining whether anyone had known of or helped with the plan.

On August 6, 2019, the FBI's San Francisco division announced that it had opened a domestic terrorism investigation into the killings. Agents were still trying to establish what, if anything, Legan believed and whether he had been in contact with anyone else about the attack. Neither the FBI nor the Gilroy police ever publicly assigned him an ideology or a motive.

The Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office spent nearly eight months reviewing the officers' use of deadly force. Its report, released on March 10, 2020, found that the three officers had reasonably believed deadly force was needed to protect innocent lives and that their actions were lawful and justified. It found no evidence that anyone other than Legan and the three officers had used deadly force that evening, and no evidence that the officers had harmed any civilian. None of the officers was hurt. The review addressed only their conduct and made no finding on why Legan had come to the festival.

By July 2020 the official count stood at three dead and seventeen wounded, and the Gilroy police said the motive was still unknown. No trial or public hearing ever tested the evidence, because there was no living defendant.

The first public account of Legan's death, given by the Gilroy police in the days after the killings, was that officers had killed him. The coroner ruled on August 2, 2019, that he had died by suicide after being wounded by the officers, and the district attorney's report of March 2020 agreed.

The number of wounded rose as the investigation went on. Early counts were twelve, then thirteen, and a sixteenth person with a slight wound was identified in the first week. The district attorney's report put the number wounded or killed at twenty, three of them fatally, and a year later the official count was seventeen wounded.

Witnesses that evening described a possible second person, but their accounts did not agree, and by July 30, 2019, the police said the evidence pointed away from any accomplice. The FBI kept that question open while it examined whether anyone had known of or helped with the plan.

His motive was never established. The FBI opened a domestic terrorism investigation, but no finding on his beliefs or his reasons was ever made public.

Timeline

Fall 2013 to spring 2016: Legan attends a private Christian high school in Watsonville, California.

2016 to 2017: He transfers to Gilroy High School and graduates in 2017.

Spring 2019: He moves to Walker Lake, Mineral County, Nevada.

July 26 to 28, 2019: The Gilroy Garlic Festival is held in Gilroy, California.

July 28, 2019: On the festival's last day, Legan kills three people and wounds seventeen. Three Gilroy officers confront him within a minute, and he dies by suicide.

July 29, 2019: Police and other agencies search for a possible second person.

July 30, 2019: The Gilroy police say the evidence increasingly points to Legan acting alone.

August 2, 2019: The Santa Clara County medical examiner-coroner rules Legan's death a suicide.

August 5, 2019: The coroner's office classifies the three victims' deaths as homicides.

August 6, 2019: The FBI announces a domestic terrorism investigation.

March 10, 2020: The Santa Clara County District Attorney's Office releases its review, finding the three officers' actions lawful and justified.

July 2020: The Gilroy police say the motive remains unknown.