On the morning of Wednesday, May 26, 2021, Samuel James Cassidy, a 57-year-old maintenance employee of the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, walked into the authority's Guadalupe Yard in San Jose, California, and killed nine of his co-workers. When sheriff's deputies and San Jose police officers reached him, he took his own life. He was never arrested, never charged and never tried, and no court has ever ruled on what happened that morning. The account rests on the Santa Clara County Sheriff's Office, which attributed the nine deaths to him, and on a workplace investigation the transit authority commissioned and released in December 2022.
The nine men were all VTA employees, colleagues at the yard where the authority maintains its light rail fleet.
Cassidy joined the VTA in January 2001 as an electro-mechanic, earning $22.50 an hour, and he was represented throughout his career by Amalgamated Transit Union Local 265. In 2014 he was promoted to substation maintainer, a job that kept him at the Guadalupe division, the authority's light rail operations and maintenance base on the north side of downtown San Jose. By 2020 he was earning about $160,000 a year, and a 2021 work schedule listed him to lead the morning shift.
His personnel records, released by the authority in June 2021, show a man who was for most of two decades an unremarkable employee. In 2004 he received a warning about missing work, the only written complaint from his early years. In 2005 he hurt a knee on the job and drew disability payments for a time. Managers praised his work at least twice in 2020.
The same records show a run of conflicts in his last two years. In July 2019 he refused to sign a release form for a portable work radio, an essential piece of equipment in his job, and was sent home without pay for insubordination. It was the only suspension of his career. During the annual vacation sign-up in January 2020 he had a verbal confrontation with another employee, which led to a written complaint, and he was counseled on the agency's rules for workplace conduct. Through late 2020 he repeatedly refused mandatory recertification classes, citing his fear of catching COVID-19, and he finished them only in late January 2021. Twice he broadcast his frustrations with the authority over the work radio channel, and each time a supervisor spoke to him about proper use of the radio; the second warning came in February 2021.
A cyberattack on the authority's systems disrupted his pay, and he was required to repay money to the agency. The investigator the VTA later hired listed that episode among the things that might have fed his anger. As she set out his grievances, he seemed frustrated with his co-workers and with management: in his view, managers did not supervise his colleagues properly, he carried more of the work than they did, management favored certain employees, and only managers had been allowed to work from home during the pandemic.
Outside his work, little about Cassidy's life entered the public record. Investigators said he had no known criminal history beyond a minor arrest in San Jose in 1983 and a misdemeanor charge of obstructing or resisting an officer. He lived alone in San Jose.
On August 8, 2016, Cassidy flew back into San Francisco International Airport from a trip to the Philippines, and United States Customs and Border Protection officers sent him to secondary inspection. He was not arrested, and the encounter left no mark on his FBI criminal history. What the officers learned was never passed to the San Jose Police Department, the Santa Clara County Sheriff's Office, the district attorney or the transit authority. Local agencies found out about the stop from the news, in the last days of May 2021, after the killings.
The Guadalupe Yard was busy before dawn that Wednesday, with the night crew and the day crew overlapping and more than a hundred people on the grounds. Cassidy killed nine men there. Eight of them died at the yard, and the ninth died later that day. Workers who heard the alarm over their radios left the buildings or sheltered where they were. When deputies and police officers reached him, he took his own life.
That same morning San Jose firefighters were sent to a fire at his residence in San Jose. It left the building uninhabitable.
Because Cassidy died at the yard, the work that followed was an investigation without a defendant. The Santa Clara County Sheriff's Office led it, with the FBI's San Francisco field office and the San Jose Police Department. Detectives reviewed security video and cellphone evidence and examined Cassidy's relationship with his employer, and investigators said they believed he had acted alone. On June 1, 2021, the county medical examiner ruled his death a suicide.
No charge was ever filed. With the man responsible dead, no case could be brought, and no court, jury or judge has examined the evidence.
In July 2021 the VTA hired the San Francisco law firm Liebert Cassidy Whitmore to examine what the agency had known. The investigator, a labor and employment lawyer, was asked to find facts only, and she made clear that hers was a workplace investigation, not a criminal investigation or a psychological evaluation of Cassidy or anyone else.
To the central question her answer was no. No report to the VTA would have put the agency on notice that Cassidy might turn violent, and no employee or supervisor had known of any plan that the agency could have stopped. Five witnesses had told supervisors or colleagues that his demeanor or behavior seemed to be changing. Two complaints had carried remarks from co-workers that he might one day become violent at work, the written complaint after the January 2020 vacation sign-up and a later complaint by a worker he had yelled at over a question about his paycheck, but neither, the investigator found, specifically warned the agency that he was going to commit an act of workplace violence. His personnel file recorded five disciplinary events, each handled by his supervisors. The documents seized at the border in 2016, she noted, showed that he hated the VTA but contained nothing about planning a mass killing, and no government agency or person had told the VTA about the detention.
The VTA board voted to release the findings on December 12, 2022, seventeen months after the investigation began.
No court ever tested the account of May 26, 2021. Cassidy was never charged, and the attribution of the nine deaths to him, like the conclusion that he acted alone, belongs to the sheriff's office and the VTA's investigator, not to any judge or jury.
His motive was never settled. The sheriff's office named his long resentment of his employer as a possible reason, and the transit authority's investigator listed the workplace frustrations that might have contributed, but neither made a final finding on why he did it.
Whether the killings could have been prevented also remains contested. The 2016 information never reached local agencies, and the VTA's investigator found that nothing the agency itself knew would have warned it.
January 2001: Cassidy joins the Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority as an electro-mechanic.
2004: He receives a warning about missing work.
2014: He is promoted to substation maintainer.
August 8, 2016: Customs and Border Protection officers send him to secondary inspection at San Francisco International Airport after a trip to the Philippines. Local agencies are not told.
July 2019: He is suspended without pay for refusing to sign for a work radio.
January 2020: He is counseled after a confrontation during the vacation sign-up.
Late 2020 to January 2021: He repeatedly refuses required recertification classes, completing them in late January 2021.
February 2021: He is warned after a second outburst over the work radio.
May 26, 2021: He kills nine VTA co-workers at the Guadalupe Yard in San Jose and dies by suicide as deputies and police reach him; a fire breaks out at his San Jose residence the same morning.
June 1, 2021: The medical examiner rules Cassidy's death a suicide.
July 2021: The VTA hires an outside law firm for an independent workplace investigation.
December 12, 2022: The VTA board releases the findings, which conclude the agency had no prior warning.