Samir Kuntar was 16 when he came into Israel from Lebanon with three other members of the Palestine Liberation Front in April 1979. By the end of the night of April 22, four Israelis in the coastal town of Nahariya were dead: a police sergeant, a father, the father's small daughter and the family's younger daughter. Two members of the cell died in the fighting that ended the raid. Kuntar and the fourth man were captured. In January 1980 the Haifa District Court sentenced both of them to life imprisonment.
He spent the next 29 years in Israeli custody and became, in Lebanon, the best-known prisoner Israel held. Israel kept him back from one exchange with Hezbollah in 2004 and let him go in another. On July 15, 2008, the President of Israel signed his pardon. The next day he crossed into Lebanon in a Red Cross convoy, part of the deal that returned two Israeli reservists captured by Hezbollah in 2006, both of them dead. He then became a public figure in Hezbollah. The United States designated him a terrorist in September 2015, and on the night of December 19, 2015, he died in a strike on a building in Jaramana, a suburb of Damascus. Israel neither confirmed nor denied that it had carried it out.
Kuntar was a Lebanese national and a Druze. He was born in 1962 and came from the mixed Druze and Christian district of Mount Lebanon, and the village he went back to on his release in July 2008 was Abeih. He was 16 at the time of the raid and 17 when he began his sentence.
The group he joined was the Palestine Liberation Front, a small faction within the Palestine Liberation Organization. Of the four men it sent into Israel in April 1979, two survived to stand trial: Kuntar, the Lebanese, and Ahmed al-Abras, a Syrian national.
Nahariya is a town on the northern coast of Israel. The cell came into it from Lebanon on the night of April 22, 1979, and before the night was over four people were dead.
Eliyahu Shahar was a sergeant in the Israel Police. He was killed in Nahariya that night, the first of the dead.
Danny Haran and his daughter Einat did not survive the night. Their deaths were the center of the case against Kuntar and the core of the court's judgment.
A younger daughter of the family, Yael, also died that night.
The raid ended in an exchange of fire with Israeli forces. Two of the four members of the cell died in it. Kuntar and al-Abras surrendered and were taken into custody.
The two survivors of the cell were tried together before the Haifa District Court for murder. The court found both men guilty. It held that Kuntar himself had killed the father and the child. In January 1980 it sentenced Kuntar and al-Abras to life imprisonment.
Kuntar's sentence was afterward described as multiple life terms, and in Lebanon it was given as 542 years. Israel's count of the dead of April 22, 1979, was four: the sergeant, the father, his daughter Einat and the younger daughter. The sentencing in January 1980 concerned three of them, the sergeant, the father and the elder girl.
Kuntar denied that he had killed the girl. He did so at trial and for the rest of his life, and for the rest of his life Israel held that he had.
He spent 29 years in Israeli custody.
Over the same years his name became a fixture of every Lebanese demand for prisoners held in Israel. He became the longest-held Lebanese prisoner in the country, and in Lebanon he was called the dean of the Lebanese prisoners.
In January 2004 Israel and Hezbollah carried out a large exchange. Israel freed two Lebanese men it had long held, Sheikh Abdul Karim Obeid and Mustafa Dirani, along with others. Kuntar, the longest-serving of the prisoners Hezbollah had sought, was not on the release list.
The scale of the deal made his absence plain. In return for an Israeli businessman held by Hezbollah and the remains of three Israeli soldiers killed in 2000, Israel released 436 prisoners, Palestinians and other Arabs among them.
The deal left him to a second stage. Israeli security officials said Hezbollah had been given a period of grace in which to produce information on Ron Arad, the Israeli air force navigator who had come down over Lebanon in 1986 and whose fate was unknown. If that information came, Israel would put Kuntar on trial again with a view to commuting his sentence to the time he had already served. His release, in other words, was made to hinge on Arad. The second stage never freed him, and he remained in custody for four more years.
The way out for Kuntar came from the war of 2006. On July 12, 2006, Hezbollah captured two Israeli reservists, Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev, in a cross-border raid, and the capture set off a 34-day war between Israel and Hezbollah. In 2008, under German auspices, the two sides agreed an exchange. Israel would free Kuntar and four other Lebanese prisoners and return about 199 dead fighters; Hezbollah would return the two reservists. Israel had hoped to keep Kuntar as a bargaining chip for information on Arad, and the deal gave that up.
The Israeli government approved the deal in two stages. On Sunday, June 29, 2008, the cabinet gave the outline a tentative approval. Under the outline the government then made public, he and four Lebanese fighters held by Israel would be released to Lebanon, and in return Israel would receive the two reservists and a report on Arad. Final authorization waited for that report. Hezbollah sent it in the days before the second vote, with photographs and an 80-page account that claimed Arad had died but did not settle what had happened to him. Israel went ahead with the deal.
Two legal steps stood between Kuntar and the border. The first was the Israeli cabinet, which approved the exchange on Tuesday, July 15, 2008, by 22 votes to 3. The second was a pardon, because Kuntar was serving life sentences imposed by an Israeli court. President Shimon Peres signed it about half a day before the planned exchange, and his office made the release depend on Hezbollah keeping its side of the agreement. He sent the signed pardon to the Minister of Justice with a covering letter.
The final terms fixed the order of events. The handover was to take place at the border under United Nations supervision, through a German official appointed by the United Nations to mediate. None of the Lebanese prisoners would be handed over until the two reservists had been positively identified, by DNA testing if necessary.
The exchange took place on July 16, 2008, at the border between Naqoura, on the Lebanese side, and Rosh Hanikra, on the Israeli side. Hezbollah handed over two coffins, and only then was it confirmed that Goldwasser and Regev were dead; whether they had died in the 2006 raid or later in captivity was not known. Israeli army forensic teams identified the bodies as those of the two missing men. Israel then released Kuntar and the four other prisoners, all of them Hezbollah fighters captured in the 2006 war. The Red Cross drove the five men to the base of the United Nations peacekeeping force at Naqoura. They crossed the border in a convoy of four International Committee of the Red Cross vehicles and were flown by Lebanese army helicopters to Beirut.
On July 17 he returned to his village in Lebanon.
Kuntar did not return to private life. He joined Hezbollah and became one of its most visible public figures.
On September 8, 2015, the United States Department of State designated him a Specially Designated Global Terrorist under an executive order. The designation froze any assets he held under American jurisdiction and barred Americans from doing business with him. The department said he had played an operational role, with the help of Iran and Syria, in building up Hezbollah's terrorist infrastructure in the Golan Heights.
The Secretary of State had signed the determination on August 31, 2015, and it was published in the Federal Register on September 9. The notice listed him under eight forms of his name, from Samir Kuntar and Samir Quntar to Sameer Kantar and Samir Cantar, and found that he "committed or poses a significant risk of committing, acts of terrorism that threaten the security of U.S. nationals or the national security, foreign policy, or economy of the United States." Because funds can be moved instantly, the notice said, no prior notice of the designation needed to be given to him.
On the night of Saturday, December 19, 2015, a strike hit a residential building in Jaramana, a suburb on the southeastern edge of Damascus. Kuntar was killed. Hezbollah confirmed his death the next morning and blamed Israel. Syrian state media blamed armed rebel groups and did not name him. Israel, holding to its long-standing practice, neither confirmed nor denied responsibility.
The American designation outlived him only briefly. On April 27, 2016, the Secretary of State signed a notice that found that he no longer met the criteria for designation and revoked it. The revocation was published in the Federal Register on May 20, 2016.
The central dispute in the case was always the death of the child. The Haifa District Court found in 1980 that Kuntar had killed her, and Israel held to that finding from the trial until his death. Kuntar denied it at trial and kept that denial in Lebanon after 2008.
The number of dead is a second point of difference. The sentence of January 1980 concerned three murders. Israel's figure for the raid is four dead, counting the younger daughter, whom the sentence of January 1980 did not include.
Responsibility for the strike that killed him in 2015 was never formally established. Hezbollah blamed Israel within hours, Israel kept to its policy of neither confirming nor denying, and Syrian official media blamed armed rebel groups.
1962: Kuntar is born in Lebanon.
April 22, 1979: A four-man Palestine Liberation Front cell enters Nahariya from Lebanon; a police sergeant, a father and his daughter are killed and the family's younger daughter also dies; two members of the cell die, and Kuntar and Ahmed al-Abras are captured.
January 1980: The Haifa District Court sentences Kuntar and al-Abras to life imprisonment.
January 2004: Israel leaves Kuntar out of its exchange with Hezbollah and ties his case to information on the navigator Ron Arad.
July 12, 2006: Hezbollah captures two Israeli reservists; a 34-day war follows.
June 29, 2008: The Israeli cabinet gives the exchange a tentative approval.
July 15, 2008: The Israeli cabinet approves the exchange by 22 votes to 3 and President Shimon Peres pardons Kuntar.
July 16, 2008: Kuntar is released at the Naqoura crossing and flown to Beirut.
August 31, 2015: The Secretary of State signs the determination designating Kuntar.
September 8, 2015: The United States announces Kuntar's designation as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist.
December 19, 2015: Kuntar dies in a strike on a building in Jaramana, Syria; Hezbollah confirms the death the next day.
April 27, 2016: The Secretary of State revokes the designation.