Salih Mustafa commanded a small unit of the Kosovo Liberation Army known as the BIA, and in April 1999 its base in the village of Zllash, in the Gollak region of Kosovo, became a place of detention. At least six Kosovo Albanian civilians were held there without charge, and the men under his command tortured them. When a Serbian offensive approached around April 19, the unit released most of its prisoners and left. It did not release two of them. One of them died before the end of the month.
On December 16, 2022, Trial Panel I of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers in The Hague found Mustafa guilty of the war crimes of arbitrary detention, torture and murder, and acquitted him of cruel treatment. It was the court's first war crimes judgment, and the panel sentenced him to 26 years. On December 14, 2023, the Court of Appeals Panel affirmed the convictions and reduced the sentence to 22 years. On July 29, 2024, the Supreme Court Chamber annulled that sentence, and on September 10, 2024, the appeals judges imposed 15 years, a term the Supreme Court Chamber upheld on February 25, 2025. His convictions were never disturbed. He has denied the crimes from his first day in court.
Mustafa was born on January 1, 1972, in Priština, the capital of Kosovo. He came of age as the conflict between the Kosovo Liberation Army and Serbian forces moved toward open war. The trial panel found that by May 1998 the KLA had the features of an organized armed group able to fight a non-international armed conflict, the threshold that made the events at Zllash war crimes rather than ordinary offenses.
That same month Mustafa was appointed commander of a newly created KLA unit called the BIA. The judges found that he was its overall and only commander from then until about mid-June 1999, when the unit was disbanded, and that he was also in charge of intelligence gathering. He could appoint men within the unit, give them orders and discipline them. Much of this came from his own words, given in an interview with the Specialist Prosecutor's Office that the trial panel admitted and relied on. The BIA operated within the KLA's Llap Operational Zone, north of Priština, from a compound in Zllash, also written Zlaš, which the panel found was under the sole control of the unit and its commander.
Between about April 1 and April 19, 1999, at least six people were taken from places around Zllash by BIA members or other KLA fighters and handed over to the BIA at the compound. All of them were Kosovo Albanians, held on accusations that they were spies, collaborators, traitors or thieves. None was told why he was being held, brought before a judge or given any way to challenge the detention. The trial panel found that the detainees were denied adequate food, water and medical care and were routinely mistreated, physically and psychologically, to extract information or confessions, to punish, intimidate and coerce them, and to discriminate against them on political grounds. It found that the mistreatment left them with lifelong injuries.
Mustafa was not a distant commander. The evidence placed him at the compound on several occasions in the first two weeks of April 1999. He personally interrogated and tortured two of the detainees, on different occasions, ordered the mistreatment of at least one, and was present at other times when his men mistreated the prisoners. The panel found that he knew who was being held and the conditions they were held in.
Around April 19, 1999, with a Serbian offensive approaching, BIA members under Mustafa's authority released a number of the detainees and evacuated the compound. Two were not released, and the trial panel found that they were the two most severely mistreated. One of them died between about April 19 and the end of April 1999. The court protects his name.
Because Mustafa was the BIA's only commander and had full control of the compound, the judges found that the only reasonable conclusion was that he decided which detainees went free and which stayed, and that he chose to keep this man in detention. The panel found that the conduct of Mustafa and his subordinates over almost three weeks was a substantial cause of the death. One factor in the death could not be traced beyond reasonable doubt to either the BIA or the advancing Serbian forces, and the judges set it aside in sentencing. They found that Mustafa intended to kill the detainee.
The war ended in June 1999 after a NATO air campaign forced Serbian forces to withdraw. Mustafa's later career took him into Kosovo's own security institutions, where he served as intelligence chief of the Kosovo Security Force.
The Kosovo Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor's Office were created to try crimes alleged to have been committed in Kosovo between January 1, 1998, and December 31, 2000, and Mustafa's was the first of their cases to reach a courtroom. A pre-trial judge confirmed the indictment on June 12, 2020, charging four counts of war crimes: arbitrary detention, cruel treatment, torture and murder. On September 24, 2020, the Specialist Prosecutor's Office arrested him, and he was transferred the same day to the Specialist Chambers' detention facilities in The Hague. He pleaded not guilty to all counts on October 28, 2020.
The trial opened on September 15, 2021, and closed a year to the day later. Over 53 trial days the panel heard 28 witnesses, 13 for the prosecution and 15 for the defense. Eight victims took part through their own counsel, all under protective measures that hid their identities from the public. The defense put forward an alibi and asked for acquittal on every count. On the last day Mustafa waived his right to a final statement, but he maintained his innocence.
The panel delivered its judgment on December 16, 2022. It found the prosecution witnesses consistent and corroborated, treated much of the defense evidence with extreme caution, and found the alibi mostly vague or inconsistent against the ample evidence placing Mustafa at the compound. It convicted him of torture by direct commission for his personal part in the mistreatment of two detainees, and, as a participant in a joint criminal enterprise, of arbitrary detention and torture against at least six detainees and of murder against one. He was found not guilty of cruel treatment, a charge the panel held was fully consumed by the torture conviction.
The judges rated the gravity of the crimes as high and found two aggravating factors: the particular cruelty of the torture and the vulnerability of the victims. They imposed 10 years for arbitrary detention, 22 years for torture and 25 years for murder, and a single sentence of 26 years with credit for time served. On April 6, 2023, the same panel issued the court's first reparation order, directing Mustafa to pay 207,000 euros in compensation to the eight participating victims. It recognized that he lacked the means to pay and recommended that Kosovo create a mechanism to compensate victims of crimes within the court's jurisdiction. Mustafa did not appeal the order.
Mustafa appealed his convictions and sentence; the prosecution did not appeal. On December 14, 2023, in the court's first appeal judgment in a war crimes case, the Court of Appeals Panel rejected every challenge to the convictions. It upheld the trial panel's assessment of the witnesses and its rejection of the alibi, and it held that Mustafa's interview with the prosecution had been taken lawfully. On murder, it agreed that the conduct of Mustafa and his men was a substantial cause of death, and held that the factor of uncertain origin did not break the chain of causation even if it came from Serbian forces, because it fell within the risk his own conduct had created. The sentence was another matter. After comparing war crimes sentences from international tribunals and Kosovo courts, the panel found the trial terms out of reasonable proportion with sentences for similar offenses, cut them to eight years for arbitrary detention, 20 for torture and 22 for murder, and reduced the single sentence to 22 years.
On March 14, 2024, Mustafa asked the Supreme Court Chamber for protection of legality. On July 29, 2024, it rejected his renewed attack on the murder conviction as a disagreement over facts, but it held that the appeals panel had been obliged to identify the most lenient sentencing range in Kosovo law and take it into account. That range, it found, came from Kosovo's 2019 criminal code: five to 25 years. It annulled the appeal judgment as far as it concerned the sentence and sent the question back to the same appeals panel.
On September 10, 2024, the appeals panel kept its earlier findings on the gravity of the crimes and Mustafa's role, again found the trial sentences out of proportion, and imposed eight years for arbitrary detention, 13 for torture and 15 for murder, with a single sentence of 15 years and credit for time served since his arrest on September 24, 2020. Both Mustafa and the Specialist Prosecutor's Office challenged that term, and on February 25, 2025, the Supreme Court Chamber dismissed both requests in their entirety. Two referrals to the court's Constitutional Court panel also failed: on April 17, 2025, it found no violation of the Kosovo Constitution or the European Convention on Human Rights, and on July 9, 2025, it declared his claim that 15 years was disproportionate inadmissible. The court lists the case as at the end of appeal. As of January 5, 2026, when a single judge declared moot his request for temporary release, Mustafa remained in custody under the 15-year sentence.
Mustafa has denied every charge. At trial his defense contended that he was elsewhere during the period of the crimes, that the prosecution witnesses contradicted one another, and that the BIA was not a fighting unit with a real command structure. The trial panel rejected each argument, and the appeals panel and the Supreme Court Chamber found no error in its findings.
One element of the death was never attributed to anyone. The trial panel found it most probable that BIA members were responsible for the third factor before they left the compound, but it could not exclude the advancing Serbian forces and excluded that factor from sentencing. Both higher panels held that the question did not affect his responsibility. The exact date of death was not fixed beyond the span from about April 19 to the end of April 1999, and the appeals panel held that no closer finding was needed.
His acquittal on the cruel treatment count was a legal ruling, not a finding that the mistreatment did not happen: the panel held that the conduct was already covered by the torture conviction.
January 1, 1972: Salih Mustafa is born in Priština, Kosovo.
May 1998: He is appointed commander of the newly created BIA unit of the Kosovo Liberation Army.
About April 1 to 19, 1999: At least six Kosovo Albanian civilians are held at the BIA compound in Zllash/Zlaš.
About April 19, 1999: With a Serbian offensive approaching, the unit releases most detainees and evacuates the compound; two are not released.
About April 19 to the end of April 1999: One of the two remaining detainees dies.
Mid-June 1999: The BIA unit is disbanded.
June 12, 2020: A pre-trial judge confirms the indictment.
September 24, 2020: Mustafa is arrested and transferred to the Specialist Chambers' detention facilities in The Hague.
October 28, 2020: He pleads not guilty to all four counts.
September 15, 2021: The trial opens.
December 16, 2022: Trial Panel I convicts him of arbitrary detention, torture and murder as war crimes, acquits him of cruel treatment and sentences him to 26 years.
April 6, 2023: The panel orders him to pay 207,000 euros in reparations to eight victims.
December 14, 2023: The Court of Appeals Panel affirms the convictions and reduces the sentence to 22 years.
July 29, 2024: The Supreme Court Chamber annuls the sentence and returns it to the appeals panel.
September 10, 2024: The appeals panel imposes a single sentence of 15 years.
February 25, 2025: The Supreme Court Chamber dismisses requests from both Mustafa and the prosecution, upholding the 15-year sentence.
April 17, 2025: The Constitutional Court panel finds no constitutional violation.
July 9, 2025: The Constitutional Court panel declares his proportionality referral inadmissible.
January 5, 2026: He remains in custody under the 15-year sentence.