Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury was a sitting member of Bangladesh's parliament, a member of the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party's standing committee and a former adviser to Prime Minister Khaleda Zia when a war crimes tribunal in Dhaka sentenced him to death on October 1, 2013. International Crimes Tribunal-1 found that in April 1971, in the first weeks of the war in which East Pakistan broke away to become Bangladesh, he had led Pakistani army units into the Hindu neighborhoods of Raozan, in Chittagong district, and taken part in the killing of their residents. It also found him guilty of the abduction and killing of a founder of the Awami League in Chittagong and his son, and of the abduction and torture of men held in Chittagong that summer.
The tribunal convicted him on 9 of the 23 charges it had framed and sentenced him to death on four. On July 29, 2015, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh acquitted him of one charge and maintained every other conviction and sentence. He denied all of it from the day of his arrest to the end, and he told the court that he had not been in East Pakistan at all during the months in question. He was executed in Dhaka on November 22, 2015, the first leader of the Bangladesh Nationalist Party to be put to death for crimes of 1971.
Chowdhury was born in 1949 into a Chittagong family prominent in Muslim League politics. In the 1970 election the Awami League won a majority in the new National Assembly, and in Chittagong a young Awami League worker defeated his father, A.K.M. Fazlul Quader Chowdhury. The tribunal later found that one of the men killed in April 1971 had helped bring about that defeat and that his killing was an act of revenge for it.
On March 25, 1971, the Pakistani army began its crackdown in East Pakistan, and the war of independence began. The Appellate Division later described a campaign in the Chittagong area that spring of deportation, persecution and killing directed at the Hindu community, at Awami League leaders and at supporters of independence. The prosecution's case was that Chowdhury took part in the killings himself.
The heart of the case was a single day. On April 13, 1971, according to the charges the Appellate Division upheld, Chowdhury and a group of local followers guided Pakistani troops through a string of Hindu villages and neighborhoods in Raozan, moving from one to the next over the course of the day.
The first was Maddhya Gohira Hindu Para, in the village of Gohira. The tribunal found that Poncha Bala Sharma, Sunil Sharma, Joti Lal Sharma and Dulal Sharma were killed on the spot. Dr. Makhon Lal Sharma died three or four days later, and another man was gravely injured. This was charge 2, and the tribunal convicted him of genocide under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act of 1973.
From there the soldiers went to Kundeshwari, also in Gohira, the complex built by Nutan Chandra Singha. A son of Gohira, he had spent his early years in Akyab, in Arakan, before returning to his native village. There he built the Kundeswari temple, a primary school, a girls' school, a women's college and a post office. In the first weeks of the war he took in members of the Chittagong University faculty and their families who had fled the campus, and he arranged their passage to safety in India. The tribunal found that Chowdhury told the soldiers he had his father's instruction to kill the village's benefactor, and that he took part personally in the killing. It described the victim as one of the most popular figures in Chittagong and a man whose word carried weight with Hindu voters, and it held that the killing was revenge for the father's defeat in 1970. This was charge 3, a crime against humanity, and it carried a death sentence.
Next the soldiers reached Jogotmollo Para, another Hindu neighborhood. Thirty-two people were killed and three were seriously injured, the houses were looted and set on fire, and survivors fled to India as refugees. That was charge 4, on which the tribunal found him guilty of genocide, deportation and other crimes against humanity.
After that the troops entered Bonikpara, in Sultanpur. Nepal Chandra Dhar, Monindra Lal Dhar, Opendra Lal Dhar and Anil Baran Dhar were killed, and the neighborhood was set on fire. The tribunal convicted him of genocide on this fifth charge and sentenced him to death for it.
Later in the day the troops came to Unsattarpara, a large Hindu settlement in Raozan. Chandra Kumar Paul and 49 others were killed there, together with 19 or 20 people whose names were never established, and a woman was gravely injured. The tribunal convicted him of genocide and deportation on this sixth charge and sentenced him to death a third time.
The next day, April 14, 1971, Satish Chandra Palit was killed in the Raozan municipal area. The prosecution charged that Chowdhury had pointed him out to the soldiers and asked them to kill him. The tribunal convicted Chowdhury on this seventh charge and sentenced him to 20 years in prison. The Appellate Division later found that the killing had happened as charged but that the prosecution had produced no reliable, corroborated evidence tying Chowdhury to it, and it acquitted him of the charge.
Sheikh Mozaffar Ahmed had been the founding president of the Awami League's Chittagong unit and a member of the Provincial Assembly. On April 17, 1971, in Chittagong, soldiers took him and his son, Sheikh Alamgir, into custody at an army camp, and both were killed.
The central prosecution witness was a member of the family who was with them that day. She testified that Chowdhury was with the soldiers and pointed the two men out to them, and she identified him in the dock. The tribunal convicted Chowdhury of abduction and murder as crimes against humanity on this eighth charge and sentenced him to death for it, the fourth death sentence in the judgment.
The last two convictions concerned men held in Chittagong in July 1971. On July 5, according to charge 17, Chowdhury, two or three associates and Pakistani soldiers took three men in the Kotwali area of Chittagong and held them at a place where detainees were interrogated and tortured. One was released; the other two were kept in army custody until the end of the war. In the third week of July, according to charge 18, a young man was taken from the village of Mohara by an associate of Chowdhury's father and brought to the same place, where he was interrogated and tortured in Chowdhury's presence. The tribunal convicted him of abduction, confinement and torture as crimes against humanity on both charges and sentenced him to five years on each.
By the end of September 1971 Chowdhury had left East Pakistan, and the cases filed against him after the war listed September as the month he fled. A secret report of the provincial Special Branch recorded that on September 20 independence fighters had attacked his car at Chandanpur, near Chittagong, injuring him and killing his driver, and a Dhaka newspaper reported the same incident on September 29. Both documents later became evidence against his claim that he had been far away in West Pakistan.
Bangladesh won its independence in December 1971. Between January and April 1972, six criminal cases were filed with the Raozan police accusing him of murder, arson, looting and other atrocities, one of them over the killing at Kundeshwari. Because he had left the country, he was listed as an absconding accused. None of the cases came to trial; the Kundeshwari case stopped moving after 1974, and the others were closed in 1976.
Chowdhury came back to Bangladesh in April 1974 and entered politics in 1978. He would be elected to parliament from Chittagong six times. By 1993 he led the National Democratic Party, a small center-right party, and sat in parliament in opposition as a former cabinet minister. He changed parties more than once before settling in the Bangladesh Nationalist Party, where he rose to its standing committee, the party's top policy body.
When the Bangladesh Nationalist Party formed a government in 2001, Khaleda Zia made him her adviser on law, justice and parliamentary affairs with the rank and status of a minister, a post he held until 2006. That government also put him forward as its candidate for secretary general of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. He later sat for the Chittagong-2 seat. In the ninth parliamentary election he listed his educational qualification as "none," and the Election Commission tried without success to annul his membership over it.
On March 25, 2010, the Awami League government set up the International Crimes Tribunal to try crimes of the 1971 war under a law passed in 1973. The tribunal's investigators opened an inquiry into killings, persecution, deportation and arson in Raozan, Gohira and Chittagong town.
On December 16, 2010, police and the Rapid Action Battalion detained Chowdhury in Dhaka, formally in connection with an unrelated case. The tribunal issued its own warrant, and within days he was shown arrested in the war crimes case. He called the allegations political and questioned the tribunal's jurisdiction.
On April 4, 2012, International Crimes Tribunal-1 framed 23 charges against him: genocide and other crimes against humanity including murder, rape, arson, abduction, confinement and complicity, set out in 23 separate incidents in Raozan, Boalkhali and Chittagong. The tribunal entered a plea of not guilty on his behalf.
The prosecution called 41 witnesses and put in dozens of documentary exhibits, among them issues of Dhaka newspapers from 1971 and 1972. Survivors from Raozan, relatives of the dead and men who had been held in Chittagong identified him in the dock.
The defense was limited to four witnesses, one of them Chowdhury himself. His case was an alibi. He told the tribunal that he left Dhaka for Karachi on March 29, 1971, spent the summer in Lahore studying for his final bachelor's examinations in political science at the University of the Punjab, sat them in August, traveled in the northern hills with friends, and then left for London. He placed his departure for Britain around September 25 in one part of his evidence and on December 16, 1971, in another, and said he stayed abroad until April 1974. Two school friends testified that they had seen him off at the Dhaka airport and met him in Karachi. The defense also produced sworn affidavits from people in Pakistan, Britain and the United States, among them a former caretaker prime minister of Pakistan, and a testimonial from a member of the university's political science faculty issued in January 2013.
International Crimes Tribunal-1 delivered its judgment on October 1, 2013. It found Chowdhury guilty on charges 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 17 and 18 and acquitted him on the other 14, eight of them because the evidence did not prove his part and six because the prosecution called no witnesses at all. He was sentenced to death on charges 3, 5, 6 and 8; to 20 years in prison on charges 2, 4 and 7; and to five years on each of charges 17 and 18. The tribunal found that he had acted with the Pakistani army to destroy the Hindu community of the area and to persecute it, together with the Awami League and supporters of independence, on religious and political grounds. He was the first leader of his party, and the only sitting member of parliament, to be convicted by the tribunal.
He appealed to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court, which heard the case in the summer of 2015. The defense's main ground was the alibi: it argued that the witnesses, affidavits and university records proved he had been out of East Pakistan, and that the tribunal had been wrong to rely on the September 1971 newspaper report and the Special Branch document.
The court rejected the alibi. It held that the affidavits sworn abroad could not be admitted because none carried the certificate of a Bangladesh consul or diplomatic agent and none had been stamped as Bangladeshi law requires. It asked why, if he could collect affidavits and a testimonial, he had not produced a certificate from the university itself, and it held that a claim to have been studying in West Pakistan, as the sheet anchor of his defense, had to be proved beyond doubt and had not been. Against it the court set the 1971 documents placing him near Chittagong in September and the sworn evidence of witnesses who had seen him at the scenes.
On July 29, 2015, the court gave its judgment. It found that the Raozan municipal killing of April 14 had happened as charged but that nothing reliable connected Chowdhury to it, and it acquitted him of charge 7. It maintained the convictions and sentences on charges 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 17 and 18, holding that the death sentences were proportionate to the gravity of the crimes and to his direct part in them. The court found that he had acted with the intention of eliminating the Hindu community of the area and his political opponents there.
His lawyers asked the Appellate Division to review its own judgment. On November 18, 2015, the court dismissed the petition and with it the university documents he had submitted, finding anomalies in the certificates.
On the eve of the execution the home minister announced that President Abdul Hamid had rejected Chowdhury's mercy petition; his family said he had never filed or signed one.
He was executed in Dhaka on November 22, 2015.
The alibi was the central dispute of the case, and it was never accepted by either court. Chowdhury maintained to the end that he had spent the spring and summer of 1971 in Karachi and Lahore and that he could not have been in Raozan in April. Both courts preferred the evidence of eyewitnesses from the villages and the 1971 records that placed him near Chittagong in September. The affidavits and university papers offered in his defense were excluded or rejected, so they were never weighed as proof.
The fairness of the trial was challenged by several international bodies. Human Rights Watch said the tribunal held his defense to four witnesses against the prosecution's 41 and refused to hear his alibi witnesses while still requiring him to prove the alibi beyond reasonable doubt; Amnesty International said the appeal court had relied on a prosecution witness's claim that a corroborating witness was dead when that person was alive, and the International Commission of Jurists and United Nations human rights experts said the tribunal's trials did not meet international fair trial standards. The government maintained that every tribunal trial had followed proper judicial procedure.
Whether Chowdhury asked for clemency is contested: the government said he had and was refused, and his family said he had not.
1949: Born.
1970: His father loses his Chittagong seat to an Awami League candidate.
March 25, 1971: The Pakistani army's crackdown begins the war of independence.
April 13, 1971: Killings at Maddhya Gohira, Kundeshwari, Jogotmollo Para, Bonikpara and Unsattarpara in Raozan (charges 2 to 6).
April 14, 1971: A killing in the Raozan municipal area (charge 7; acquitted on appeal).
April 17, 1971: An Awami League founder and his son are abducted in Chittagong and killed (charge 8).
July 1971: Men abducted, held and tortured in Chittagong (charges 17 and 18).
September 20, 1971: The Special Branch records an attack on his car near Chittagong.
January to April 1972: Six criminal cases filed against him with the Raozan police; closed or stalled by 1976.
April 1974: Returns to Bangladesh.
2001 to 2006: Adviser to Prime Minister Khaleda Zia with the rank of minister.
March 25, 2010: International Crimes Tribunal established.
December 16, 2010: Detained in Dhaka.
April 4, 2012: Indicted on 23 charges.
October 1, 2013: Convicted on 9 charges and sentenced to death on 4.
July 29, 2015: Appellate Division acquits him on charge 7 and maintains the rest.
November 18, 2015: Review dismissed.
November 21, 2015: Government announces that the President has rejected his mercy petition; his family denies he filed one.
November 22, 2015: Executed in Dhaka.