Said Akbar Babrak

Victims
1 killing attributed, Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan, 1951. Never tried; police and a commission of inquiry named him as the killer; he died before any charge.
Years active
October 16, 1951
Location
Rawalpindi, Punjab, Pakistan (killing; his own death); Abbottabad, Pakistan (residence)
Method
Shot (police and commission accounts; never tested in court).
Status
Never tried. Commission report submitted February 28, 1952, found his own act. Killed by police at the scene in Rawalpindi, Pakistan, October 16, 1951.

On October 16, 1951, Liaquat Ali Khan, the first Prime Minister of Pakistan, rose to address a Muslim League meeting in Rawalpindi and was assassinated moments into his speech. The man the police named as his killer was dead within seconds, killed at the scene by an officer on duty, before anyone knew who he was. The prime minister died later that day, and Radio Pakistan announced his death that evening. By then the police had identified the dead man as Said Akbar, an Afghan of 29 who lived in Abbottabad.

Said Akbar never faced a court. Rawalpindi police registered a murder case and closed it because the accused was dead. A commission of inquiry concluded that the killing was his own act and uncovered no conspiracy, and a Scotland Yard detective who reviewed the case in 1954 and 1955 found that he had acted alone. Those findings never settled the matter in Pakistan, and whether anyone stood behind him has stayed an open question ever since.

He came from the Afghan side of the frontier. By the Afghan government's account, as the United States ambassador in Kabul reported it in October 1951, he took part as a minor figure in a failed tribal rising in the country's southern province in 1944, and Afghanistan later said he had been expelled that year for conspiring against its government. In January 1947, while the subcontinent was still under British rule, he surrendered to the British authorities in North Waziristan and was detained under Bengal Regulation III of 1818. By 1951 he was living in Abbottabad. That summer he offered to raise a tribal force, a lashkar, for the fighting in Kashmir. The commission of inquiry later dismissed the offer as a "hoax."

The man he was named for killing had helped build the state he died serving. Born on October 1, 1895, in Karnal, in British India, the prime minister studied law at Oxford, returned to India in 1923 and rose in the Muslim League to become a trusted lieutenant of Muhammad Ali Jinnah. He served as finance minister in the interim government before partition, and when Pakistan became independent in August 1947 he became its first prime minister. His years in office were crowded. In March 1949 he moved the Objectives Resolution in the Constituent Assembly. In 1950 he signed the Liaquat-Nehru Pact with India and visited the United States, where he spoke of a "spiritual bridge" between the two countries. In March 1951 he announced the discovery of a plot by army officers to overthrow his government, which became known as the Rawalpindi conspiracy. He led a new country through tribal rivalries on the frontier, a border dispute with Afghanistan and the unresolved conflict with India over Kashmir. The night he died, the cabinet named Khwaja Nazimuddin, the Governor General, to succeed him.

The investigation into a wider plot was led first by the Criminal Investigation Department in Lahore and then by the Inspector General of Special Police. In August 1952 that officer died in an air crash, the case papers he carried were destroyed with him, and the findings of his inquiry were never made public.

The commission of inquiry had been appointed on October 25, 1951. A judge of the Federal Court headed it, with the Financial Commissioner of Punjab as its second member. It heard 66 witnesses and submitted its report on February 28, 1952. Said Akbar's death, it noted, meant that his motives could not be established. It uncovered no conspiracy and concluded that the killing was his own act. When the report was published, 73 names, clauses and sentences had been removed, mostly for reasons of security.

The last official word came from London. A Scotland Yard detective was given access to the case from November 1954 to June 1955, and his report, published in Pakistan on June 25, 1955, concluded, like the commission, that Said Akbar had acted alone.

The official finding that Said Akbar acted alone has never been widely accepted. Since 1951 the police of the time, Pakistani radio and the press have each raised theories of a hired killing, of accomplices at the meeting and of foreign or domestic backing, including an Afghan role that the government in Kabul denied; no court or inquiry has proved any of them.

Accounts of his own death also differ. The police account says an officer on duty killed him; a contemporary magazine report said the crowd killed him.

Because he died before he could be questioned, everything about why he did it rests on an investigation that ended without a trial and on official papers published only in part.

Timeline

1944: Takes part, by the Afghan government's account, in a failed tribal rising in southern Afghanistan; Afghanistan later says he was expelled that year.

January 1947: Surrenders to the British authorities in North Waziristan; detained under Bengal Regulation III of 1818.

August 1947: Pakistan becomes independent, with the man he would be named for killing as its first prime minister.

Summer 1951: Offers to raise a tribal force for Kashmir; the commission later calls the offer a hoax.

October 16, 1951: The prime minister is assassinated at a Muslim League meeting in Rawalpindi; Said Akbar is killed by police at the scene.

October 1951: Rawalpindi police register a murder case; it is closed because the accused is dead.

October 25, 1951: A commission of inquiry is appointed.

February 28, 1952: The commission submits its report, finding the killing his own act and uncovering no conspiracy.

August 1952: The Inspector General of Special Police leading the conspiracy inquiry dies in an air crash; his case papers are destroyed.

November 1954 to June 1955: A Scotland Yard detective reviews the case.

June 25, 1955: The Scotland Yard report is published, concluding that Said Akbar acted alone.