Saburo Aizawa

Victims
1 murder: Major General Tetsuzan Nagata, Director of the Army's Military Affairs Bureau, Tokyo, August 12, 1935.
Years active
August 12, 1935
Location
Tokyo, Japan (killing and trial); Formosa (Taiwan) (other, the posting he was ordered to in August 1935)
Method
Stabbed with a sword.
Status
Sentenced to death by the Court Martial of the First (Tokyo) Division, May 7, 1936 (announced May 9); appealed May 8, 1936. Executed July 3, 1936.

On the morning of August 12, 1935, Lieutenant Colonel Saburo Aizawa of the Imperial Japanese Army killed Major General Tetsuzan Nagata, Director of the Military Affairs Bureau of the War Ministry, while Nagata was on duty in Tokyo. Nagata was one of the most senior administrators in the Army and the leading figure of the group of officers known as the Control faction. Aizawa belonged to the rival Imperial Way faction. He made no attempt to deny what he had done. The military police took him into custody the same day, and he was later tried before the Court Martial of the First Division in Tokyo.

The case became far larger than one officer's crime. Aizawa's public trial opened on January 28, 1936, and turned into a platform for the grievances of the young officers who shared his views. It was still in session when, on February 26, 1936, a group of those officers led troops into the streets of the capital and killed several of the country's senior statesmen. After a second trial held behind closed doors, the court sentenced Aizawa to death on May 7, 1936. He was executed on July 3, 1936.

Aizawa was an infantry officer. In the announcement it issued the day after the killing, the Army described him as Infantry Lieutenant Colonel Saburo Aizawa. He came from a samurai family, and at his trial he said that his father had taught him to revere the Emperor. A Tokyo newspaper extra published after the killing called him a master of kendo.

His views took shape over several years. The indictment later laid out their course. From about 1930, it said, he had been troubled about the future of Japan. By June 1933 he had become convinced that the War Ministry needed reform. He came to resent Nagata as the man standing in the way of that reform, and his hostility deepened in the summer of 1935.

Aizawa described the change he wanted as the Showa Restoration, which he defined in court as the return of political and financial powers to the Emperor. He believed that officers of the Army were colluding with senior statesmen and financiers, and he despaired of what he called corruption within the service. In his account Nagata was the chief obstacle to the restoration he sought.

Nagata was born in Nagano on January 14, 1884. He graduated from the Army War College and was sent to the Japanese legations in Germany, Denmark and Sweden, where he studied the problem of national mobilization, the organization of a whole country's resources for modern war. In 1921 he became military attaché to the legation in Switzerland. That year, at Baden-Baden in Germany, he and two fellow officers, Yasuji Okamura and Toshishiro Obata, pledged themselves to the reform of the Army.

His career after that ran through the administrative heart of the service. In 1926 he became the first Mobilization Chief of the War Ministry's Development Bureau. He later headed the Army Affairs Section of the Military Affairs Bureau and then the Second Department of the General Staff. In March 1934 he was appointed Director of the Military Affairs Bureau, the post he held at his death, and by then he was the central figure of the Control faction. He had spent comparatively little of his career on the General Staff and had little experience of command in the field.

A political figure who met Nagata three times in his last years remembered him as an honest, intellectual officer who seemed more like a university professor than a soldier. After an inspection tour of Manchuria and Korea, Nagata argued that the Kwantung Army should end its internal guidance of Manchukuo early and that Korea should be given internal autonomy, with defense and diplomacy kept under central control. He looked toward a future in which Japan, Manchukuo and Korea would be tied by alliance. He opposed the assassination of senior officials and the idea of a coup, calling such schemes dangerous and foolish, and argued that reform had to come through concrete plans carried out step by step.

The Army of the early 1930s was divided. On one side stood the Imperial Way faction, centered on General Sadao Araki, a Military Affairs Councilor, and General Jinzaburo Masaki, the Inspector General of Military Education. Its adherents favored a spiritual, Emperor-centered program and included a circle of young officers impatient with party politics and big business. On the other side stood the Control faction, which favored discipline within the Army and the planned mobilization of the nation for total war. Nagata led it. After he became Director of the Military Affairs Bureau, he pressed for the removal of Imperial Way generals from the Army's central posts, and he carried out many of the demotions and transfers by which the War Minister's group removed its opponents from the Army's leadership.

The rivalry hardened in the autumn of 1934. On November 20, 1934, Captain Koji Muranaka, Paymaster Asaichi Isobe and five cadets of the Military Academy were arrested over an alleged plan for a coup, in what became known as the Military Academy Incident or the November Incident. They were not charged with insurrection, but the officers were suspended and the cadets were expelled. The men later presented at the Aizawa trial as his associates believed that Nagata had frustrated the plot and that officers of his faction had framed them to discredit the Imperial Way. While suspended, Muranaka and Isobe wrote a pamphlet dated July 11, 1935, titled Memorandum on the Army Purge, which attacked Nagata. Both men were dismissed from the Army over their writings.

The event that Aizawa's indictment treated as decisive came in July 1935. General Senjuro Hayashi, the War Minister, had criticized the personnel appointments made by Araki and Masaki, and he had the backing of officers outside the Imperial Way and of the senior statesmen. On July 16, 1935, Masaki was removed as Inspector General of Military Education and replaced by General Jotaro Watanabe.

The young officers of the Imperial Way faction called the dismissal a violation of the Emperor's prerogative of supreme command, and the pamphlet that circulated among them laid the blame on Nagata. Aizawa accepted that version. His indictment stated that his hostility toward Nagata grew after Masaki's dismissal, which he attributed to him.

In the Army reshuffle of August 1, 1935, Aizawa himself was transferred from a post in northern Japan to Formosa, the island now called Taiwan. He was on his way to that posting when he went to the War Ministry in Tokyo on August 12.

Aizawa killed Nagata on the morning of August 12, 1935, in Tokyo, while the general was on duty. The death was officially confirmed that afternoon. Aizawa offered no resistance. The military police detained and questioned him, and he was held in military custody in Tokyo until his trial.

On August 13 the Army named him as the man responsible. Its announcement said that his motive was not yet fully clear, but that he appeared to have acted after blindly believing erroneous rumors about Nagata. The rumors in question were the charges in the pamphlet that blamed Nagata for Masaki's removal.

The trial opened on January 28, 1936, before the Court Martial of the First Division in Tokyo, with a serving major general presiding. Aizawa was defended by an Army lieutenant colonel and a civilian lawyer.

Aizawa admitted his guilt at the outset, so the question of who had killed Nagata was never in dispute. The hearings turned instead on motive and politics, and the defense used them to set out the young officers' claim that senior statesmen and financiers had interfered with the Army's supreme command.

When the prosecutor invited him to explain himself in full, Aizawa returned to the lessons of his father and said that he had acted to support the Throne. His answers about what punishment he deserved were vague. He said that his inspiration had come from on high. Asked about his associates, he said it was not their words that had moved him but what he called the communion of their souls. The pamphlet by Muranaka and Isobe was presented in court as the secret evidence of the defense.

On February 25, General Masaki gave evidence in a closed session.

The next morning, February 26, 1936, young officers of the Imperial Way faction led troops in an uprising in Tokyo. Among those killed were Viscount Makoto Saito, General Watanabe, who had replaced Masaki in July, Finance Minister Korekiyo Takahashi and Colonel Matsuo. Muranaka and Isobe, Aizawa's associates, were among the instigators.

The Aizawa trial did not sit again in public. It was postponed indefinitely.

Under the Court Martial Law, a trial suspended for fifteen days had to be heard again from the beginning, and by mid-March the Aizawa proceedings had passed that limit. A complete retrial was required.

The second trial opened on April 22, 1936. It sat for five hearings, all held in camera on the presiding judge's order, on grounds of public order, and the public was not told that it had resumed until the sentence was announced.

On May 7, 1936, the Court Martial of the First (Tokyo) Division sentenced Aizawa to death for the murder of Nagata. He appealed the next day, May 8. The War Office announced the sentence on May 9. Under the Army Criminal Code the higher court martial had to sit within thirty days of the appeal. The death sentence was carried out on July 3, 1936, when Aizawa was executed.

Aizawa's motive was set out in the indictment and in his own testimony, and the Army's first announcement attributed his act to his belief in false rumors about Nagata. The record also differs on Nagata's rank: the American embassy's despatches call him a major general, while the Army's announcement of August 13 and Time call him a lieutenant general. Nagata's alleged role in Masaki's dismissal and in frustrating the 1934 plot formed the case made by Aizawa and his associates, not a finding against Nagata. The words he spoke in court about inspiration from on high and the communion of souls were his own account. The ruling of the higher court martial on his appeal is not on record.

Timeline

1921: Nagata, military attaché in Switzerland, joins two fellow officers at Baden-Baden in a pledge to reform the Army.

June 1933: by the indictment's account, Aizawa becomes convinced that the War Ministry needs reform.

March 1934: Nagata becomes Director of the Military Affairs Bureau of the War Ministry.

November 20, 1934: Muranaka, Isobe and five cadets are arrested in the Military Academy Incident.

July 11, 1935: date of the Memorandum on the Army Purge, the pamphlet attacking Nagata.

July 16, 1935: General Masaki is removed as Inspector General of Military Education.

August 1, 1935: Aizawa is transferred to Formosa in the Army reshuffle.

August 12, 1935: Aizawa kills Nagata in Tokyo and is detained by the military police.

August 13, 1935: the Army names Aizawa as the man responsible.

January 28, 1936: the public court-martial opens before the First Division in Tokyo.

February 25, 1936: General Masaki gives evidence in closed session.

February 26, 1936: the uprising in Tokyo; the trial is postponed indefinitely.

April 22, 1936: the retrial opens in camera.

May 7, 1936: Aizawa is sentenced to death.

May 8, 1936: Aizawa appeals.

May 9, 1936: the War Office announces the sentence.

July 3, 1936: Aizawa is executed.