Most murder investigations begin with an absence. Someone fails to come home, a relative calls the police, and a name goes into a file. In fifteen cases on four continents, from Houston in 1970 to Toronto in 2017, that first step broke down. Sometimes no one made the call. More often someone did, and the report was logged as a runaway, an overdose, a woman who had left of her own accord, or a drifter who had moved on. The killings continued in the gap between a disappearance and the moment anyone with authority treated it as a crime.
Between 1970 and the summer of 1973, boys and young men kept disappearing from the Houston Heights, an old neighborhood northwest of downtown Houston. Their parents went to the police and were told, again and again, that their sons had run away. When Jimmy Glass and Danny Yates, both 14, vanished together during a church youth service in December 1970, police labeled them runaways. A father whose sons Donald, 15, and Jerry, 13, disappeared on their way to a bowling alley in January 1971, said he "camped on that police department door" for eight months, and recalled officers asking him why he kept coming in, since he knew his boys were runaways.
Skip Hollandsworth, who read the Houston and Pasadena police files for Texas Monthly in 2011, found that missing juvenile reports were shared out among officers in the juvenile division and that parents were told no official search could begin without clear evidence of foul play. He found no officer in the reports who suspected it. After the deaths came to light in August 1973, Police Chief Herman Short said most of the boys had been classified as runaways.
The case broke on August 8, 1973, only because Elmer Wayne Henley Jr., 17, shot Dean Corll, a 33-year-old electrician, dead in Pasadena and then told detectives what he knew. Within days the deaths of 27 boys and young men had come to light. Corll was never charged; police named him as the leader, and the deaths of at least 28 boys and young men are attributed to him. Henley was convicted of six murders and David Owen Brooks of one. Henley was denied parole again on November 7, 2025. One of those young men still has no name, and the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children released a new likeness of him in 2023.
Chandrakant Jha came to Delhi from Bihar in 1990 and worked around Azadpur Mandi, the city’s great wholesale produce market. Between October 2006 and May 2007 the deaths of three young men came to light in west Delhi, and the courts later tied all three to handwritten letters in Hindi that mocked the Delhi Police. The dead were hard to name. The first, whose death came to light on October 20, 2006, went unidentified for months until police matched his fingerprints to their records for Anil Mandal, also called Amit, a man from Bhagalpur district in Bihar; his widow then recognized him from a photograph, and DNA from his daughter confirmed it. The second, Upender, from Maharajganj in Uttar Pradesh, was unknown to investigators until Jha, after his arrest, gave leads that took police to a relative working in Rajasthan. The third, whose death came to light on May 18, 2007, was never claimed by any family, and both the trial court and the Delhi High Court held that his identity had not been proved.
Jha was arrested on May 20, 2007, convicted of all three murders in 2013 and sentenced to death twice. In January 2016 the High Court upheld every conviction and replaced the death sentences with imprisonment for the rest of his natural life. Delhi Police attribute seven killings to him from 1998 onward, most of them young migrant workers he had befriended, fed and helped to find work. Released on parole in 2023, he failed to return, and the Crime Branch caught him at Old Delhi Railway Station on January 17, 2025.
Joel Rifkin, an unemployed landscaper from East Meadow, was arrested on Long Island on June 28, 1993, after a traffic stop, and charged in the death of Tiffany Bresciani, 22. He confessed to killing 17 women between 1989 and 1993, most of them sex workers he had picked up in New York City. A Nassau County jury rejected his insanity defense in 1994, guilty pleas followed in Suffolk County, Brooklyn and Queens, and news reports give his total as nine murder convictions. A State Police task force identified 15 of the women he described.
His first victim waited 24 years for a name. Her death came to light in Hopewell Township, New Jersey, in March 1989, and for decades no one could say who she was. Heidi Balch, 25, had used many names and Social Security numbers, and her parents did not report her missing at first. An aunt filed a report in 2001, but it was set aside because it said she had last been seen in 1995. The forensic anthropologist Donna Fontana later matched her to an old arrest photograph, and DNA from her parents confirmed the identification, which New Jersey State Police announced in March 2013. She was linked to Rifkin, who was not charged in her death. Two other women he described, known to investigators only as Number Six and Number Nine, remain unidentified. In June 2024 he was held at Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora.
In December 1995 two men who rode the freight lines were killed in Oregon: William Pettit Jr., whose death came to light at Millersburg on December 3, and Michael Clites, 24, whose death came to light in Portland three days later. Both died of a blow to the head. In March 1996 police in Roseville, California, arrested Robert Joseph Silveria, a 37-year-old transient, on a parole violation, and officers from Oregon and Montana went to question him about the deaths of train-riding men in California, Oregon, Montana, Kansas, Arizona, Utah and Texas.
Silveria called himself "Sidetrack." Over five days with Detective Michael Quakenbush of Salem, Oregon, he allegedly confessed to killing 12 people, among them a college student and an accountant, and then recanted. In a letter to a former cellmate he reportedly wrote, "I preyed on the weak." The Southern Poverty Law Center, reporting on the case in 1998, quoted the investigator Bob Grandinetti on the men who died on the rails: they were people "no one cared about or even knew," and inquiries into their deaths "usually came up with zero." As of the spring of 1998, Silveria was awaiting trial in Salem.
The Venezuelan case shows that a report is not enough. Between November 1998 and January 1999, at least ten men disappeared around Táriba, in Táchira state, according to Infobae: runners who used the Parque 12 de Febrero and workers who walked along the Torbes River. Their relatives went to the police and kept going back. Investigators looked first at score-settling between drug gangs, and the theories ran as far as satanic ritual.
The break came from an old file. An officer remembered a homeless man who had been sent to a psychiatric institute in 1995 over the death of Cruz Baltazar Moreno, a homeless man who had shared his sleeping place under a bridge; Moreno’s death had come to light only because a friend went looking for him and reported him missing. On February 12, 1999, the deaths of men at Táriba came to light, and Dorángel Vargas was arrested that day. Police said he admitted the killings. Psychiatrists diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia, and he was declared not criminally responsible. He has never been tried or sentenced. In November 2024, more than 25 years later, he was still held in the Táchira state police jail in San Cristóbal, where a court had placed him provisionally in 1999.
Between 1975 and 1979, seven young women disappeared in and around Auxerre, in Burgundy: Christine Marlot, Jacqueline Weiss, Françoise Lemoine, Bernadette Lemoine, Madeleine Dejust, Chantal Gras and Martine Renault. All had mild intellectual disabilities, and all were wards or former wards of the state, placed by the child welfare services with foster families or in homes and special schools. Most rode to their day institutions on a bus driven by the same man, Émile Louis. When they vanished, the institutions recorded them as runaways. According to the inspection report that the French justice ministry commissioned in 2001, only three of the seven disappearances were formally reported to the police or the gendarmerie, and the homes had generally been content to record a runaway or a voluntary departure rather than ask anyone to search.
Martine Renault was 16. She left her care home on September 26, 1979, and Louis was seen nearby that day; questioned, he said he had been looking for his dog. The file reached the Auxerre prosecutor on October 15 and was closed on December 4, 1979, as a runaway. In 1981 the gendarme Christian Jambert questioned Louis about several of the missing women, and nothing came of it. The inspectors, in a report signed by Jean-Louis Nadal, later described the handling of the case as a failure of the prosecution service and an institutional breakdown.
Only a complaint brought by the women’s families in 1996 reopened the matter. Louis was arrested in December 2000, admitted killing all seven, and then retracted. In 2004 he was convicted of the seven murders, with other charges, and sentenced to life imprisonment, a verdict confirmed on appeal in 2006. He died in custody in October 2013, aged 79. Five of the seven women have not been located.
For twelve years, from 1978 to 1990, children and young women disappeared along the railway lines around Rostov-on-Don and, later, in other parts of the Soviet Union. Investigators told the British reporter Peter Conradi in 1992 that up to 70 percent of the victims were vagrants, tramps or sex workers, and the rest children and young people from stable homes. The vagrants were rarely missed. The children were, and their parents were not believed.
Ivan, 12, disappeared in Zaporizhzhia, in Ukraine, in 1987 while picking apricots. His mother learned of his death three days later, after searching for him herself. "I told them something happened to my son, some sort of trouble," she told United Press International at the trial. "The police laughed at me. They didn’t believe it." Chikatilo, she said, "knew the police wouldn’t pay much attention." Police threatened to commit another mother to a psychiatric hospital after she went through the city showing residents photographs of her missing son.
Andrei Chikatilo, a former teacher and factory supply agent from Shakhty, had been held by police and released twice before his arrest in November 1990. In October 1992 the Rostov Regional Court convicted him of 52 murders and sentenced him to death. Judge Leonid Akubzhanov said the incompetence of the militia had played a part in the failure to catch him, and he singled out the officers who had mocked women reporting their children missing. Chikatilo was shot on February 14, 1994.
Alto Hospicio sits on the desert plateau behind Iquique, in northern Chile. In the late 1990s it was a fast-growing town of social housing and informal settlements, and its girls walked to and from school in uniform along roads with little public transport. Between 1998 and 2001, girls and young women began to vanish on those walks. When the disappearances became a public matter in July 2000, described then as five girls lost in nine months, the police explanation was that they had left of their own accord. Officers searched for them in Tacna, across the border in Peru. The regional governor suggested the girls had problems at home and did not want to return. In 2001 Jorge Burgos, undersecretary of the Interior, linked the cases to family violence and extreme poverty and said some might not be forced disappearances at all.
The families heard it as contempt. The grandmother of one victim told Inter Press Service that officers called the families loose-living and measured the distance between beds in their homes. Ivón Carrillo’s mother said officials would not take her missing-person report. Macarena Sánchez’s mother was told her daughter was probably begging in Iquique or enjoying herself in Tacna. Requests for a special investigating judge were refused on the strength of police reports.
On October 4, 2001, a surviving girl went to the Carabineros, and her account led them to Julio Pérez Silva, an unlicensed taxi driver. He confessed to fourteen killings. In February 2004 a court in Iquique convicted him of 14 aggravated homicides, with other charges; his sentence was raised on appeal to qualified life imprisonment, which the Supreme Court ratified in October 2006. In March 2026 he was held at the Colina 1 prison, and that same month the mausoleum in Iquique where most of the victims lie was declared a national historic monument.
In east London the victims were not missing so much as dismissed. Between June 2014 and September 2015, four young men died after meeting Stephen Port, a chef from Barking, through gay dating or escort websites: Anthony Walgate, 23, a fashion student from Hull; Gabriel Kovari, 22, from Slovakia; Daniel Whitworth, 21, a chef from Gravesend; and Jack Taylor, 25, a forklift driver from Dagenham. For more than a year the Metropolitan Police treated the deaths as separate, non-suspicious drug cases. PinkNews contacted Scotland Yard early in 2015 about claims linking them and was told nothing suspicious connected them. Jack Taylor’s father reported him missing when he failed to turn up for work; after his death came to light, police told the family it was an overdose, and his sisters pressed detectives until they looked again.
In November 2016 an Old Bailey jury convicted Port of the four murders and of 18 further offenses of drugging and sexually assaulting other young men, and Mr Justice Openshaw imposed a whole life order. The police watchdog served misconduct notices on 17 officers in 2017 but found in 2018 that none had a case to answer. Fresh inquests reached a different view: on December 10, 2021, a jury found that all four men had been unlawfully killed and that police failings probably contributed to the deaths of Kovari, Whitworth and Taylor. In November 2023 the Independent Office for Police Conduct told eight current and former officers that they were under investigation for possible gross misconduct.
Chester Turner’s victims died during the crack cocaine epidemic, in a stretch of South Los Angeles where, the Associated Press reported, more than 100 women were killed in that era. For a time police grouped many of the deaths under a single unknown offender they called the "Southside Slayer." The women Turner killed between 1987 and 1998 had histories of drug use; some were homeless, and some had been arrested for prostitution. For years no one connected their deaths to each other or to him.
What tied them together was a DNA sample. Turner, a former pizza delivery driver, was convicted in 2002 of raping a homeless woman on Skid Row, and the profile taken from him went into the state database. In September 2003 detectives in the department’s cold case unit, a squad of six facing thousands of unsolved killings, learned that it matched the 1998 killing of Paula Vance and a 1996 killing. On October 23, 2004, the Los Angeles Police Department announced that DNA linked him to 13 killings and called him the most prolific serial killer ever identified in the city.
The same review freed another man. In 1992 four women had been killed in South Los Angeles, and police arrested a janitor, D.A.J., a man with an intellectual disability who confessed under questioning and was convicted. DNA cleared him in 2004, and in 2006 the city paid him 720,000 dollars. Turner was convicted of ten murders in 2007, a verdict the California Supreme Court affirmed in 2020, and of four more in 2014. He was on death row at San Quentin as of June 2024, the month Salt Lake County prosecutors charged him with aggravated murder in the 1998 death of Itisha Camp; that charge has not been tried.
The boys who sang for coins around the Pulogadung bus terminal in East Jakarta called the snack vendor Baekuni "Babe," an affectionate word for Dad. Some slept in his rented room. They were children who lived and worked on the streets, aged six to twelve in police accounts reported by the Associated Press, and when one of them did not reappear there was often no family nearby to raise the alarm.
The case turned on a boy who did have one. In January 2010 the father of Ardiansyah, 9, reported his son missing, and his mother, who knew the boy had been visiting Baekuni, told police of her suspicion. Police arrested Baekuni on January 9, 2010, and he confessed to killing 14 boys since the 1990s. In Magelang, police took blood from a farming couple whose son had vanished in 2002 to compare with evidence from the case; the outcome of that comparison has not been made public. Baekuni was sentenced to life in October 2010, the sentence was raised to death that December, and the Supreme Court upheld it. As of September 2022 he was held at Cipinang prison awaiting execution.
Volker Eckert, a truck driver from Hof, in Bavaria, was arrested near Cologne on November 17, 2006, after Catalan police traced him through the death of Miglena Petrova, a young waitress from Dobrich in Bulgaria, which had come to light at Hostalric, in Girona province, earlier that month. Within days he confessed to killing five women in France and Spain between 1999 and 2006, women he had met along the roads he drove. He then told German police about a sixth death, that of a 14-year-old schoolmate in East Germany in 1974, which had passed for years as a suicide.
His arrest sent police across Europe back to their files. The Catalan police sent his details to forces across Europe and asked them to search their records for unsolved killings of women beside roads and compare them with his routes. Eckert died by suicide in his cell in Bayreuth on July 2, 2007, before any trial. He was never convicted of a killing. Diario UNO reported in 2019 that by the time German police closed the inquiry in December 2007, investigators had linked as many as 19 deaths to him.
For years, women disappeared from Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, many of them Indigenous and many working in the sex trade. Families and community groups marched and pleaded for police attention. The Missing Women Commission of Inquiry, led by Wally Oppal, found in 2012 that the women had been treated as "nobodies," a word the commission chose deliberately, and that the police investigations had been a "blatant failure." The first of the seven critical failures it listed was poor report taking and follow-up.
A Vancouver deputy chief, Doug LePard, reached similar conclusions in his own department’s 2010 review. Police had received information pointing to the pig farmer Robert Pickton in 1998 and 1999; managers had been slow to accept that a serial killer was targeting women in the neighborhood; and a bias against sex workers was partly to blame. LePard said the delay likely cost the lives of more than a dozen women. Pickton was arrested in 2002. In December 2007 a jury convicted him of the second-degree murders of six women, and in 2010 prosecutors stayed 20 further murder charges. In all, the investigation tied 33 women to the case. Pickton died in custody on May 31, 2024, after another inmate attacked him at Port-Cartier Institution in Quebec.
Between 2010 and 2017, Bruce McArthur, a landscaper, killed eight men in Toronto, most of them with ties to the city’s Gay Village. Two were never reported missing at all. Kirushna Kumar Kanagaratnam had reached Canada in 2010 as one of 492 Tamils aboard the MV Sun Sea and lived in Toronto without legal status, working as a handyman and sending money to his parents. Dean Lisowick, who had grown up partly in foster care, had no fixed address when he was killed in 2016. Others were reported promptly: Abdulbasir Faizi’s cousin reported him missing the day after he was last seen in December 2010, and officers suggested at the time that he had left his family.
Toronto police formed a task force, Project Houston, in 2012 to look into three of the disappearances, interviewed McArthur as a witness in 2013, and closed the task force in 2014. He was caught only after Andrew Kinsman, a long-time HIV and AIDS volunteer, disappeared in June 2017. McArthur pleaded guilty to eight counts of first-degree murder in January 2019 and was sentenced to life with no parole eligibility for 25 years. In 2021 an independent review led by the retired judge Gloria Epstein found that the disappearances "were often given less attention or priority than the cases deserved" and that systemic discrimination had contributed to deficiencies in several investigations.
In 2009 the deaths of eleven women and girls, and of the unborn child one of them was carrying, came to light on Albuquerque’s West Mesa. Within a year all had names: Monica Candelaria, Victoria Chavez, Virginia Cloven, Syllannia Edwards, Cinnamon Elks, Doreen Marquez, Julie Nieto, Veronica Romero, Evelyn Salazar, Michelle Valdez and Jamie Barela. They had gone missing in 2003 and 2004. A New Mexico Senate memorial passed in 2009 recorded that some families had filed missing person reports that "go nowhere."
Jamie Barela, 15, and her cousin Evelyn Salazar, 27, left a family gathering together in the spring of 2004 and did not come home. Jamie’s relatives said the police never questioned them and treated her as a runaway. Syllannia Edwards, also 15, had left a group home in Lawton, Oklahoma, in August 2003, and Lawton police listed her as an endangered runaway; she was the only one of the eleven not reported missing in Albuquerque. No one has been arrested or charged. The Albuquerque Police Department and the FBI have offered a reward of up to 100,000 dollars, and in February 2026 the president of the Albuquerque City Council marked the seventeenth anniversary of the discovery with the killings still unsolved.
The victims ranged from Houston schoolboys to a Slovak poet in east London, from Chilean schoolgirls to Tamil refugees in Toronto. What joins them is the point at which each disappearance stalled. In some cases no one was positioned to make a report: a street child in Jakarta, a man without legal status in Toronto, a drifter on a freight car. In more of them the report was made and then filed under a heading that required no search: a runaway needs no investigation, and an overdose needs no suspect. Official findings in Vancouver and east London went further and said the delay itself had cost lives. LePard put the cost of the lost years in British Columbia at more than a dozen women; the Barking inquest jury found that police failings probably contributed to three of the four deaths.
• December 1970 to August 1973: boys and young men disappear from the Houston Heights; many are classified as runaways.
• August 8, 1973: Dean Corll is shot dead in Pasadena, Texas; the deaths of 27 boys and young men come to light that month.
• 1975 to 1979: seven young women in care disappear around Auxerre; only three disappearances are formally reported.
• 1978 to 1990: the killings later charged against Andrei Chikatilo take place in the Soviet Union.
• 1987: Ivan, 12, disappears in Zaporizhzhia; police laugh at his mother’s report.
• 1987 to 1998: Chester Turner kills women in Los Angeles.
• March 1989: the death of a woman later identified as Heidi Balch comes to light in Hopewell Township, New Jersey.
• October 1992: Chikatilo is convicted of 52 murders; he is shot on February 14, 1994.
• June 28, 1993: Joel Rifkin is arrested on Long Island after a traffic stop.
• December 1995: two men are killed in Millersburg and Portland, Oregon; Robert Silveria is arrested in Roseville, California, in March 1996.
• 1998: the first killing Delhi Police attribute to Chandrakant Jha.
• November 1998 to January 1999: at least ten men disappear around Táriba, Venezuela; Dorángel Vargas is arrested on February 12, 1999.
• 1998 to 2001: girls and young women disappear from Alto Hospicio, Chile; Julio Pérez Silva is arrested on October 4, 2001.
• December 2000: Émile Louis is arrested; he is convicted in 2004.
• 2002: Robert Pickton is arrested in British Columbia.
• 2003 and 2004: eleven women and girls go missing in and around Albuquerque.
• September 2003: DNA links Chester Turner to unsolved killings; the LAPD announces the case on October 23, 2004.
• 2006 and 2007: the deaths of three young men come to light in west Delhi; Jha is arrested on May 20, 2007.
• November 17, 2006: Volker Eckert is arrested near Cologne; he dies in custody on July 2, 2007.
• December 9, 2007: Pickton is convicted of six second-degree murders.
• 2009: the deaths of the West Mesa victims come to light in Albuquerque.
• January 9, 2010: Baekuni is arrested in Jakarta after Ardiansyah’s disappearance.
• 2010 to 2017: Bruce McArthur kills eight men in Toronto; two are never reported missing.
• 2012: the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry reports in British Columbia.
• March 2013: Heidi Balch is identified.
• June 2014 to September 2015: Stephen Port kills four young men in Barking.
• November 2016: Port is convicted and given a whole life order.
• February 8, 2019: McArthur is sentenced to life.
• April 2021: the Epstein review of Toronto missing person investigations is released.
• December 10, 2021: inquest jury finds police failings probably contributed to three of Port’s murders.
• November 2023: eight Metropolitan Police officers are placed under gross misconduct investigation.
• May 31, 2024: Pickton dies in custody.
• January 17, 2025: Jha is rearrested after absconding on parole.
• November 7, 2025: Elmer Wayne Henley Jr. is denied parole.
• February 2026: the West Mesa killings remain unsolved on the seventeenth anniversary.