In the spring of 1993 the Crown in Ontario had, as a federal Justice Department paper later put it, a strong case against Karla Homolka and nothing to convict Paul Bernardo. It needed her. The price, settled in negotiations in Toronto and finalized on May 14, 1993, was two concurrent prison terms of twelve years for manslaughter. Sixteen months later the police received a set of videotapes that, the same paper concluded, would have kept the agreement from ever being signed.
Every prosecution of two people for the same killings carries that risk. When the case against one partner stands or falls on the testimony of the other, the state has to bargain, and the only thing it has to offer is time. In six prosecutions in California, Washington, Nevada, Michigan and Ontario between 1979 and 2004, one partner pleaded guilty and took the witness stand, and the other went to trial. The distance between the two sentences, in almost every pair, was set less by what each had done than by who came forward with something to sell.
Five teenage girls were abducted and killed in Los Angeles County between June and October 1979: Lucinda Schaefer, 16; Andrea Hall, 18; Jacqueline Gilliam, 15; Jacqueline Leah Lamp, 13; and Shirley Ledford, whose age the Associated Press gave as 16 and the California Supreme Court as 18. Roy Norris, a Redondo Beach man, was arrested first, by the Hermosa Beach police. Lawrence Bittaker, a machinist living in Burbank whom Norris had met in a California prison, was arrested next on a warrant sworn out by a Hermosa Beach sergeant.
Norris made the deal. As the California Supreme Court later described his plea agreement, he would face neither the death penalty nor life without the possibility of parole. In exchange he would cooperate with investigators, testify at Bittaker’s trial and plead guilty to five counts of murder without special circumstances, with other charges. The agreement obliged him "to give a complete and truthful account of both his and Larry Bittaker’s participation in the murders."
He became the prosecution’s chief witness at Bittaker’s trial in early 1981. United Press International summed up his testimony in a sentence: he admitted killing one of the girls and blamed Bittaker for the other four. Bittaker’s defense turned the account around and blamed Norris for all five. Because Norris was an accomplice, his word alone could not convict anyone, and the trial judge instructed the jurors that his testimony had to be corroborated. The prosecution supplied it from physical evidence and from witnesses who had no stake in the bargain.
On February 17, 1981, a jury of seven women and five men convicted Bittaker of five counts of murder with special circumstances, with other charges. A week later the same jurors chose death over life without parole, and he was formally sentenced to death in March, UPI reported. Norris was sentenced after him, to 45 years to life.
The California Supreme Court affirmed Bittaker’s convictions and death sentence on June 22, 1989, in a unanimous opinion by Justice Broussard. Part of the appeal was an attack on the bargain itself, and the court rejected it. "Nothing in the bargain requires or permits Norris to testify falsely against defendant," it wrote. It did take issue with one clause, which left it to the district attorney, subject only to limited review by a judge, to decide whether Norris had told the truth. The final word on whether a witness has testified truthfully, the court said, should belong to the court rather than to the prosecutor. It held that the flaw did not require reversal.
Neither man went free. Bittaker was never executed; he died of natural causes at San Quentin State Prison on December 13, 2019, at 79, the Associated Press reported. Norris had been refused parole in 2009 and again in March 2019, CBS San Francisco reported, and he died of natural causes at the California Medical Facility in Vacaville on February 24, 2020, at 72. His bargain had bought him his life. It had not bought him a release date.
Ten women and girls, the youngest of them 12, were killed in the Los Angeles area between October 1977 and February 1978 in the series the press called the Hillside Strangler murders. The case broke in Bellingham, Washington, where Kenneth Bianchi, a security guard, was arrested on January 12, 1979, after the deaths of two Western Washington University students, Karen Mandic and Diane Wilder, came to light. Los Angeles detectives soon connected him to the Hillside series.
Bianchi first pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity and claimed a second personality. That defense came apart under examination by a psychiatrist retained by the prosecution, Martin Orne, who concluded that Bianchi was simulating, and in October 1979 he accepted a deal that ran across two states. HistoryLink, the online encyclopedia of Washington history, records its terms: he would plead guilty to the two Bellingham murders and to five in Los Angeles, serve his time in California, and testify "truthfully and completely" against his adoptive cousin, Angelo Buono, a Glendale auto upholsterer. On October 19, 1979, the Whatcom County prosecutor withdrew his notice that the state would seek death, and Bianchi was sentenced to two consecutive life terms. Three days later, in Los Angeles, he pleaded guilty to five counts of murder, with other charges, and received concurrent life terms. Within half an hour of the Bellingham plea, task force detectives arrested Buono. When the Ninth Circuit later rejected Bianchi’s claim that his plea had been coerced, it gave his reason in a phrase: he had pleaded guilty to avoid the death penalty.
As a witness, he nearly destroyed the case he had been bought to make. Through a ten-month preliminary hearing he contradicted himself so often that in July 1981 the Los Angeles County district attorney’s office moved to dismiss all ten murder counts against Buono. Superior Court Judge Ronald M. George refused, ruling that the evidence was sufficient to go forward. The district attorney declared a conflict, and the case passed to the office of the state attorney general, where two deputies, Roger Boren and Michael Nash, took it to trial. Bianchi was their 200th witness and spent 80 days on the stand. At one point he claimed to remember nothing; at another he denied even the Bellingham killings. The trial ran two years and two days.
The jury convicted Buono of nine of the ten murders. On the tenth, the death of Yolanda Washington, the jurors had heard only Bianchi’s account, Boren later explained, and without independent support for it they returned no guilty verdict. In the penalty phase Buono’s lawyer, Gerald Chaleff, argued that his client should not be punished more harshly than Bianchi, who had been given life in exchange for his testimony, UPI reported. On November 18, 1983, the jury chose life without parole. Boren wrote that its reluctance to impose death reflected how hard Bianchi’s evasions had made it to divide responsibility between the two men.
On January 9, 1984, Judge George sentenced Buono to nine concurrent terms of life without parole and said he would have imposed death without hesitation. He then turned to the witness. Bianchi, he ruled, had not testified truthfully and completely, as his agreement required, and he ordered him returned to Washington rather than to the California prison he had bargained for. "It is my firm belief that Mr. Buono and Mr. Bianchi should never see the outside of prison walls," the judge said, as HistoryLink records it.
Buono died of a heart attack in his cell at Calipatria State Prison on September 21, 2002, at 67. Bianchi, who legally changed his name to Anthony D’Amato in 2023, has spent the decades since in the Washington State Penitentiary at Walla Walla. On July 14, 2025, Washington’s Indeterminate Sentence Review Board declined to release him and added 120 months to his minimum term, writing that he had "spent dramatically more time pursuing legal challenges to his conviction than toward rehabilitative efforts." In October 2026 the state Department of Corrections still listed him at Walla Walla.
Charlene Gallego, recorded in court and in the press under her family name, Williams, as well, met Gerald Armond Gallego in 1977, when she was almost 21. Between September 1978 and November 1980, according to the account she later gave investigators, ten people died in California, Nevada and Oregon. The couple were arrested in Omaha, Nebraska, in November 1980, after the deaths earlier that month of two Sacramento State College students, Craig Miller and Mary Beth Sowers.
Her first statement to police was, by her own later admission, invented, and it kept her at a distance from the killings. She then changed lawyers and gave a second statement, in which she described earlier deaths she had not mentioned before. Under her California agreement, as the California Supreme Court set it out, she pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder for the deaths of Miller and Sowers in exchange for a term of 16 years and 8 months, subject to approval by the state Board of Prison Terms. She was required to testify truthfully and, the court noted, "enjoyed no immunity for perjury." In Nevada she pleaded guilty to two counts of second-degree murder for the deaths of Stacey Redican and Karen Twiggs, both 17.
Her testimony carried two juries. In Martinez, in Contra Costa County, where the California case had been moved, Gerald Gallego conducted his own defense, and much of it was an attack on her. She had every reason to blame him, he argued, and she and her lawyers had invented the earlier killings to win a better deal. On April 11, 1983, the jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree murder and two of kidnapping, and in May it took less than three hours to choose death, UPI reported. In June 1984, in Lovelock, Nevada, a second jury convicted him of the murders of Stacey Redican and Karen Twiggs, with kidnapping, and returned a second death sentence. Nevada law requires that an accomplice’s testimony be corroborated, and the Nevada Supreme Court held in December 1985 that the state had met that requirement.
The difference in their punishments followed him through the appeals. In 1997 the federal Ninth Circuit ordered a new Nevada penalty hearing, because his jury had been wrongly told he might be paroled if it spared him. At the retrial in Pershing County in September 1999 he wanted Charlene called as a witness. The visiting judge, John McGroarty, refused, ruling that her plea agreement and her credibility had no bearing on his punishment, the Las Vegas Sun reported. His lawyer told the jurors anyway that she had taken an active part in the crimes, had lied to the authorities several times and had been rewarded with a plea bargain. After about an hour they returned death again. The Nevada Supreme Court affirmed that sentence on May 17, 2001, noting that she was no longer serving prison time.
Gerald Gallego died of cancer at the prison medical center in Carson City on July 18, 2002, a day after his 56th birthday. He was never executed in either state. Charlene had been released in 1997 under her plea agreement, CBS Sacramento reported, and had lived under another name since. In 2013 she told the station that she had never wanted any part of the killings and that he had controlled her through fear. "I did not kill any of them," she said. The father of Mary Beth Sowers gave the station his own verdict: she "was just as guilty as he was."
Several elderly residents of Alpine Manor Nursing Home in Walker, Michigan, a suburb of Grand Rapids, died in the first months of 1987, and their deaths were recorded as natural. The case came to light more than a year later, when the former husband of a nurse’s aide named Catherine Wood went to the police with what she had told him: that she and a co-worker, Gwendolyn Graham, had suffocated patients. The two aides had been lovers. By December 1988 Graham was back in Texas, held on a 1 million dollar bond; she waived extradition in January 1989.
Wood had been ordered to stand trial on two counts of open murder. She never went to trial. Before Kent County Circuit Judge Robert Benson she pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the death of Marguerite Chambers, 60, and to conspiracy to commit second-degree murder, and under the agreement she became the witness against Graham. Her account was that Graham did the killing while she kept watch or drew supervisors away.
Graham’s trial in Grand Rapids in September 1989 turned on that account. Graham testified that no one had been killed at all: the two of them, she said, had made up the story to shock a co-worker, and Wood had later told it as true out of revenge after Graham left her in August 1987. The medical examiner told the jury that his examinations could neither confirm nor rule out the prosecution’s theory. The jury, nine women and three men, convicted Graham of five counts of first-degree murder and one count of conspiracy to commit murder, UPI reported on September 20, 1989. In Michigan that verdict carried a mandatory sentence of life without parole.
Wood was sentenced in October 1989 to 20 to 40 years. Judge Benson told her he believed her remorse was genuine and that without her cooperation, "it would never have been cleared up," UPI reported.
The distance between the two women grew over three decades. The Michigan Parole Board refused Wood eight times, most recently in 2016, and voted to release her on its ninth review, in 2018. Relatives of the victims went to court to stop it. In May 2019 Attorney General Dana Nessel filed a brief on their side, stating that Wood had confessed to helping kill at least five patients and had said that she and Graham planned to kill many more. "Repeatedly, the parole board determined Ms. Wood to be a threat to the public," Nessel said. In October 2019 Kent County Circuit Judge Joe Rossi ruled that the board had not abused its discretion. Wood left a federal prison in Tallahassee, Florida, in January 2020 and moved to South Carolina to live with her sister. Roger Kaliniak, a retired Walker police sergeant who had worked the case, told WSOC-TV in Charlotte that he believed Wood had been the mastermind. Graham’s sentence offered no parole board to persuade.
Sante Kimes and her son Kenneth were tried together in Manhattan in 2000 for the July 1998 murder of Irene Silverman, an 82-year-old widow who rented rooms in her Upper East Side townhouse. On May 18, 2000, the jury convicted both. Justice Rena K. Uviller sentenced the mother to an aggregate term of 120 years to life; her son received about 125 years to life. The Appellate Division affirmed Sante Kimes’s conviction on December 7, 2006, holding that the circumstantial evidence of murder was legally sufficient.
The second prosecution was the one in which talking counted. In May 2002 a Los Angeles County grand jury indicted both for the March 1998 murder of David Kazdin, 63, a businessman and longtime acquaintance, with special circumstances that made a death sentence possible. In November 2003 Kenneth Kimes pleaded guilty and agreed to testify against his mother; in exchange he avoided a possible death penalty and would receive life without parole, the Associated Press reported. In January 2004 prosecutors announced that they would not seek death against Sante Kimes either.
At her trial in 2004 the son testified that his mother had planned Kazdin’s killing and sent him to carry it out, because Kazdin had discovered a loan of $280,000 that she had taken out in his name with a forged signature. In July 2004 the jury convicted Sante Kimes, then 71, of first-degree murder, and held true the special allegations that the killing was committed for financial gain and that Kazdin had been killed because he was a witness to a crime. Both mother and son were sentenced to life.
In this pair the bargain closed no gap at all. Kenneth Kimes had already been sentenced to more than a century in New York, and his testimony saved him only from the possibility of execution. His mother died at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in Westchester County, New York, in May 2014, at 79. Under her New York sentence, the Associated Press noted, she would not have been eligible for parole until 2119.
Leslie Mahaffy, 14, of Burlington, Ontario, died in June 1991. Kristen French, 15, of St. Catharines, died in April 1992. Paul Bernardo was arrested on February 17, 1993. His wife, Karla Homolka, had retained a lawyer, George Walker, on February 11.
Walker first asked for blanket immunity. The Ontario attorney general refused, but agreed to consider a reduced sentence, and the proposal moved to guilty pleas to two counts of manslaughter for ten years. The final agreement, reached in mid-May after negotiations between Walker and senior Crown officials in Toronto, set twelve. It was signed by Murray Segal, director of the Crown’s criminal law office. As Maclean’s later reported its terms, Homolka owed the Crown "a full, complete and truthful account" of the deaths of Kristen French, Leslie Mahaffy and her own younger sister, Tammy Homolka, 15, who had died on December 24, 1990. The deal could be cancelled if it emerged that she had actually killed either schoolgirl. On July 6, 1993, in St. Catharines, Justice Francis Kovacs of the Ontario Court, General Division, sentenced her on her pleas to two concurrent terms of twelve years. She was never charged in her sister’s death.
On September 22, 1994, the police received six videotapes Bernardo had made. His first lawyer, Ken Murray, had held them for about sixteen months. The federal Justice Department’s later review of plea bargaining was blunt about what that meant: "Had the authorities been in possession of the tapes on 14 May 1993, the prosecutor would never have entered into the resolution agreement with Homolka." By then she had been in prison for more than a year.
She testified at Bernardo’s trial in Toronto from June 19, 1995, for seventeen court days, seven of them under cross-examination by his lawyer, John Rosen, who put it to her that she had been devoted to Bernardo and far more involved than she admitted. Justice Patrick LeSage told the jurors that her credibility was in issue, because witnesses in her position often play down their own part. On September 1, 1995, the jury convicted Bernardo on all nine counts, including two of first-degree murder, with other charges. The sentence was life with no eligibility for parole for 25 years, and on November 3, 1995, Justice LeSage declared him a dangerous offender, a designation that permits indefinite detention.
The anger that followed fell on the witness. The press accused the prosecution of making "a deal with the devil," The Canadian Encyclopedia records, and by October 1995 a petition with more than 300,000 names had reached the Ontario legislature asking for a review. The attorney general appointed Patrick T. Galligan, whose report is dated March 15, 1996. Galligan concluded that, given what it knew at the time, the Crown "had absolutely no choice" but to make the agreement, and that a sentence in the range of ten to fifteen years was the appropriate sanction for her part. Charging her with murder after the tapes surfaced was not feasible, he held, because it would have broken the agreement, and she had made "full, complete and truthful disclosure." A separate review by Justice Archie Campbell, completed the same year, examined the police investigation rather than the deal.
Homolka never applied for parole. In March 2001 the National Parole Board ordered her held to the end of her sentence, and the order was upheld at each annual review. She walked out of prison on July 4, 2005, at 35, having served all twelve years. Bernardo has been refused parole three times, in October 2018, June 2021 and November 2024. A fourth review set for October 2026 was postponed to January 2027, CP24 reported on September 21, 2026.
In Toledo, Ohio, the bargain was struck in the open, with the release date written into it. The brothers Anthony and Nathaniel Cook had been suspected for years in killings in Lucas County in 1980 and 1981, but investigators lacked the evidence to charge them until testing ordered in the late 1990s linked both men to an attack in May 1980. They were charged in 1998. Before trial their lawyers asked the county prosecutor, Julia Bates, whether she would consider a deal, and she put the question to the victims' families, who agreed. On April 3, 2000, in videotaped interviews, the brothers confessed. Nathaniel admitted taking part in three killings, among them that of Dawn Rene Backes, who was 12. Anthony confessed to eight killings in Lucas County and one from the 1970s.
Nathaniel pleaded guilty to kidnapping and attempted murder in the 1980 case and was sentenced to 21 to 75 years, with release promised after twenty. Anthony, already convicted of murder in 1982, is serving two life sentences. When the twenty years ran out, Bates explained why she would keep her side. "If my word isn’t my word then nobody is ever going to trust the prosecutor in the future ever again," she told the Associated Press, adding that she had agreed only not to oppose the release. On August 9, 2018, Lucas County Common Pleas Judge Linda Jennings granted it. "Frankly, Mr. Cook, I was trying to find a legal basis to prevent your release," she told him, WNWO reported. He left prison under five years of community control. Anthony’s parole hearing was postponed in December 2024, WTVG reported.
Courts have been plain about the limits of these agreements. The California Supreme Court held that a bargain may not require a witness to lie, and said that the question of whether he told the truth belongs to a judge. Judge George, on that principle, stripped Bianchi of the one benefit he had negotiated for. Galligan, weighing the Homolka agreement after the tapes had surfaced, called dealing with an accomplice the lesser of two evils and concluded that the Crown, knowing what it knew in May 1993, had no alternative.
What none of the courts claimed was that the sentences measured guilt. Gerald Gallego’s lawyer made the point to a jury in 1999, and a judge ruled it irrelevant to punishment. Chaleff made it for Buono in 1983, and the jury chose life. Norris died in custody under a sentence that let him ask for parole; Bittaker died under a sentence of death. Wood was paroled at 57; Graham’s sentence allows no parole at all. Only in the Kimes case, where both were already serving more than a century, did the bargain leave the two partners in the same place. In the others the term was fixed at the moment the first partner offered testimony the state could not get any other way, and it was fixed by what that testimony was worth.
• 1977 to 1978: Ten women and girls are killed in the Los Angeles area in the Hillside Strangler series.
• January 12, 1979: Kenneth Bianchi is arrested in Bellingham, Washington.
• June to October 1979: Five teenage girls are abducted and killed in Los Angeles County; Roy Norris and Lawrence Bittaker are arrested.
• October 19 and 22, 1979: Bianchi pleads guilty in Washington and Los Angeles under an agreement to testify against Angelo Buono, who is arrested the same day as the Washington plea.
• November 1980: Charlene and Gerald Gallego are arrested in Omaha, Nebraska.
• February 17, 1981: Bittaker is convicted on Norris’s testimony; he is sentenced to death in March, and Norris to 45 years to life.
• July 1981: The Los Angeles district attorney’s office moves to dismiss the murder counts against Buono; Judge Ronald M. George refuses.
• April 11, 1983: Gerald Gallego is convicted in Martinez, California; a death sentence follows in May.
• November 18, 1983: The jury that convicted Buono of nine murders chooses life without parole.
• January 9, 1984: Buono is sentenced; Bianchi is ordered returned to Washington.
• June 1984: Gerald Gallego is convicted in Lovelock, Nevada, and sentenced to death a second time.
• June 22, 1989: The California Supreme Court affirms Bittaker’s death sentence and rules on Norris’s agreement.
• September 1989: Gwendolyn Graham is convicted of five counts of first-degree murder; Catherine Wood is sentenced to 20 to 40 years in October.
• May 14, 1993: Karla Homolka’s resolution agreement is finalized; she is sentenced to twelve years on July 6.
• September 22, 1994: Police receive Bernardo’s videotapes.
• September 1, 1995: Bernardo is convicted; he is declared a dangerous offender on November 3.
• March 15, 1996: The Galligan report on the Homolka agreement is issued.
• 1997: Charlene Gallego is released.
• April 3, 2000: Anthony and Nathaniel Cook confess in Toledo under a plea agreement.
• May 18, 2000: Sante and Kenneth Kimes are convicted in Manhattan of the murder of Irene Silverman.
• July 18, 2002: Gerald Gallego dies in Nevada custody, still under sentence of death; Buono dies in prison on September 21.
• November 2003: Kenneth Kimes pleads guilty to the Kazdin murder and agrees to testify against his mother.
• July 2004: Sante Kimes is convicted of the murder of David Kazdin.
• July 4, 2005: Homolka is released at the end of her sentence.
• May 2014: Sante Kimes dies at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility.
• August 9, 2018: Nathaniel Cook is released under the 2000 agreement.
• December 13, 2019: Bittaker dies on death row at San Quentin.
• January 2020: Wood is released on parole.
• February 24, 2020: Norris dies in custody in Vacaville.
• July 14, 2025: Washington’s review board declines to release Bianchi.
• September 21, 2026: Bernardo’s next parole review is reported postponed to January 2027.