In April 1985 Henry Lee Lucas told the Dallas Times Herald that all but three of his murder confessions were false, and that he had staged the whole performance to show that law enforcement did not do its job. By then police across the United States had closed 210 killings on the strength of what he said. That month the attorney general of Texas, Jim Mattox, was asked whether Lucas had committed all the murders he had confessed to. "No," he said. In many of the cases, he added, "there’s no evidence there with the exception of his own confessions."
Most large victim counts come from a verdict. A smaller number begin in an interview room, spoken by the man under suspicion to detectives who need cases closed, and the courts that later weigh the evidence arrive at a figure a fraction of that size, or at none at all. The pattern did not begin or end with Lucas. In Boston, Lucerne, Nagoya, Rio de Janeiro, Tehran, Los Angeles and a jail in Tampa, the number that traveled furthest was the one the man supplied himself.
Lucas came to Texas with a record. He had served 15 years in Michigan for killing his mother in 1960, a conviction for second-degree murder. Once in Texas custody he began to confess, and he did not stop. The figure he reached was about 600 killings, which he placed over a period of ten years. Mike Feary, an investigator for the Texas attorney general, later said that Lucas would sometimes admit to 70 or 80 slayings in a single day.
The confessions did not stay in Texas. Officers from other states came to question him, and cases closed behind him. By April 1985, according to the Associated Press, 210 killings across the country had been cleared on his word. In Utah, police attributed three murders to him, among them the 1978 killing of a Brigham Young University student, Marla Rae Scharp.
The courts dealt with a narrower set of facts. Texas gave him life sentences for a 1982 murder and for the murder of an elderly woman from Ringgold, and a jury in 1984 sentenced him to death for the killing of an unidentified young woman found near Georgetown in October 1979, known only by the orange socks she wore. Amnesty International, reviewing the case in June 1998, wrote that the capital trial had rested almost entirely on his confession. Besides the death sentence, Amnesty listed six life terms, two 75-year terms and one 60-year term for nine other killings.
By the spring of 1985 Mattox’s office had examined 13 Lucas cases and declined to help prosecute some of them. In April 1986 it issued what became known as the Lucas Report. The report concluded that Lucas had been "perpetrating a massive hoax," and that he had taken much of his information from officers who showed him crime reports and photographs of victims. In the Orange Socks case it found reliable alibi evidence, including work records, placing him in Jacksonville, Florida, when the woman was killed. "Mr Lucas is, of course, a totally unsympathetic individual," Mattox said. The question, in his view, was whether Texas should execute someone it knew, in all probability, was not guilty.
Utah police kept their three cases closed. When the Associated Press asked in 1990, officers there said they had never heard of the Texas report. Feary, who had spent months on the confessions, gave his own estimate that year: police were "pretty sure" that Lucas had killed three people.
His execution was set for June 30, 1998. The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles recommended that the sentence be commuted, and Governor George W. Bush accepted the recommendation. The jurors, Bush said, did not and could not have known of Lucas’s pattern of lying and confessing to crimes that evidence later showed he did not commit. Lucas was found dead in his bed at the Ellis I Unit in Huntsville in March 2001, at 64, of what officials said appeared to be natural causes. The Associated Press reported that he was then serving sentences for nine murders.
The woman in orange socks was identified in August 2019 as Debra Jackson, 23, of Abilene. She had left home in 1977. The Williamson County sheriff’s office said it had identified no suspect in her death.
Between June 1962 and January 1964 a series of women were killed in and around Boston. Investigators grouped 11 of the deaths as the work of one man, the Boston Strangler; other lists ran to 13. The last of the 11 was Mary Sullivan, 19, who was killed in Boston on January 4, 1964.
In 1965 Albert DeSalvo, a factory worker held on unrelated charges, confessed to all 11 killings and to two more. He was awaiting trial at the time for a separate series of attacks on women, the so-called Green Man offenses. By Smithsonian’s account, he first told a fellow inmate, who passed the story to his own attorney, and from there it reached the authorities.
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts never charged him with murder. In January 1967 a jury in Middlesex County convicted him on eight indictments arising from attacks on four women in 1964, all of whom survived, and he was sentenced to life in prison. His statements about the stranglings reached that jury only as part of the history he had given psychiatrists, and the judge told the jurors it was not evidence that he had committed them. The Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the judgments on January 4, 1968.
DeSalvo later took back his confession. In November 1973 he was stabbed to death in prison, and the confession had never been tested in any court. Not until 2013, the Suffolk County district attorney’s office later said, could officials confirm his responsibility for any homicide.
Science first seemed to break that link. On December 6, 2001, forensic scientists announced that DNA evidence in the Sullivan case did not match him. In 2013 Boston police returned to the case. A DNA sample from one of DeSalvo’s nephews implicated him while excluding 99.9 percent of the male population, and a direct test of DeSalvo’s own DNA followed that July. On July 19, 2013, District Attorney Daniel F. Conley announced that the odds that a white man other than DeSalvo had left the evidence were one in 220 billion, which gave his office, he said, "an unprecedented level of certainty" in the Sullivan case.
The same release drew the limits. DeSalvo had confessed and recanted and had never been convicted of any of the killings. His account of Mary Sullivan’s death had proved accurate to a high but not perfect degree. Investigators had long looked for biological evidence at the other scenes and had found none. One of the 13 confessions has been tested against physical evidence. The other twelve rest where they began, with DeSalvo.
Roger Andermatt was a nurse in central Switzerland, a sociable man known in the region as a dancer and a disc jockey. He was arrested in Lucerne at the end of June 2001, after a suspicious death at the nursing home where he worked, and admitted killing nine patients there, elderly women in his care. He said he had acted out of pity.
Investigators widened the inquiry to the other homes where he had worked, among them a home in Sarnen, in the canton of Obwalden, where a former colleague told Blick that his views on active euthanasia had been the most extreme in the room. Under further questioning he confessed to 18 more killings, 12 of them at the home in Sarnen. On September 11, 2001, the investigating magistrate, Orvo Nieminen, announced the total at a news conference in Lucerne: 27 elderly or ill patients over six years. Andermatt gave his motives as sympathy and a wish to end suffering, though he also conceded, according to the Associated Press, that in some cases he had simply been overwhelmed by the stress of the work.
He was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. When Blick listed the most serious murderers in Swiss history in May 2016, it put the number of people he had killed between 1995 and 2001 at 22. The gap between the two figures is five deaths. They remain part of his confession and not of his sentence.
Kiyotaka Katsuta, recorded by Amnesty International under the name Fujiwara Kiyotaka, was sentenced to death in March 1986 for the murder of eight people. The sentence became final in January 1994. On December 1, 2000, Amnesty reported that he had been executed the previous day at the Nagoya Detention Centre, at 52. He was one of three prisoners executed that day, the day before the Diet session ended. He had spent 14 years and nine months under sentence of death. The number on which the Japanese courts acted, and on which the state took his life, was eight.
In December 2014 the homicide division of the Baixada Fluminense, in Rio de Janeiro state, arrested three people over the death of a woman named Fátima Miranda. One of them, Sailson José das Graças, confessed to her death and then kept talking. He called himself a professional killer, and he told investigators that he had killed 38 other women over seven years, the Jornal do Brasil reported. He named a woman, Cleusa Balbina, and her former husband as the people who had paid for the Miranda killing. Police found four more open inquiries in their own files that resembled his account and began checking his statements against them.
The number grew as he spoke to the press. Reuters, in a report carried by Gulf News, gave his age as 26 and his claim as 42 killings over a decade, most of the victims women; the agency reported that police had so far matched four crimes to his confessions and that experts urged caution with his claims. MaltaToday put his count at 41: 37 women, three men and a two-year-old child, over nine years. A police commissioner, Pedro Henrique Medina, called him a psychopath. Sailson said he felt no remorse.
The courts moved slowly and case by case. Prosecutors in Rio de Janeiro state charged him in 2017 with the killing of Raimundo Basílio da Silva, who died in the early hours of November 30, 2014. The jury trial began on February 27, 2023, before the 4th Criminal Court of Nova Iguaçu, and on February 28 the jury convicted him. He was sentenced to 21 years in a closed regime. Cleusa Balbina de Paula was convicted with him; according to the prosecution she had provided the money for the weapon and kept watch. The public defender argued that Sailson had not committed the killing and, in the alternative, that he was only partly responsible because of his mental state. The jury rejected both arguments, although the prosecutors' release noted that juries in other trials of the same defendant had accepted the claim of diminished responsibility. Each of those verdicts answers for a single death, tried on its own evidence.
Ali Asghar Borujerdi, remembered in Iran as Asghar the Murderer, was the first serial killer tried in that country, according to IranWire, and his trial took place on May 27, 1934. IranWire’s 2021 account counted at least 33 young boys and teenagers killed, in crimes that reached beyond Iran’s borders into Iraq and other neighboring countries. The count is a single total for two countries, and the trial took place in only one of them.
Stephen A. Nash was a 33-year-old drifter and former San Quentin inmate when he was arrested in Los Angeles on November 29, 1956, on a warrant for an assault on a man who survived. That November he had killed John Berg in Long Beach and, three days later, a 10-year-old boy, Lawrence Rice, at Ocean Park. A jury convicted him of both murders in the first degree and of two counts of assault, found him sane at a separate trial, and fixed the penalty at death on each murder count.
After his arrest Nash described 11 homicides, beginning in December 1955, as revenge on society. Police confirmed five, according to the California Supreme Court. The others went unconfirmed because he refused to give the names of the victims or the places they died unless someone paid him, and nobody did. He treated questions about his feelings the same way, as information with a price. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment on April 24, 1959, declining in the same decision to replace the M’Naughton test of insanity. Of the 11 deaths he claimed, two were tried.
On October 4, 1972, a Hillsborough County sheriff’s detective in Tampa named Marchetta arrested Julian Eugene Kennedy, an escaped prisoner from Raiford, Florida, and placed him in the county jail. Kennedy stayed there about two months. On December 11, 1972, he sent out a note: "Tell Detective Marchetta that I am ready to talk."
When the detective came, Kennedy first offered to trade a statement for drugs. The detective refused. Kennedy then asked him to check two things: whether the police in Valdosta, Georgia, had a report of a woman missing since September 11, 1972, and whether her car had been found abandoned in Pasco County, Florida. Both were true. Elva Lee Jones had disappeared from Valdosta that day, and her car had been recovered in Pasco County the next. Kennedy signed a waiver and gave a statement describing how he had taken her from Georgia into Florida and killed her in Pasco County. On that statement a Florida court convicted him of her murder. In August 1973, while in a Florida prison, he gave substantially the same confession to an FBI agent, and a federal grand jury indicted him for kidnapping her across a state line.
At the federal trial Kennedy described the two months that had led to the note. He testified that he had been held in solitary confinement on half rations, that Marchetta questioned him every day about other crimes he might be able to clear up, that officers suggested sentences for anything new he admitted would run concurrently with his Florida term, that drugs were available to him in the jail, and that his requests for a lawyer were ignored. The district judge heard the claims outside the jury’s presence and did not credit them. The jury convicted him of kidnapping, and on July 5, 1974, the Fifth Circuit affirmed, holding that the trial judge’s findings were not clearly erroneous and that there was ample evidence Elva Lee Jones had been kidnapped and carried into Florida. Hers is the one killing the courts attached to his name.
What these cases share is less a type of man than a type of room. Kennedy, by his own testimony, was asked every day what else he could clear, with the suggestion that anything more would cost him nothing extra. Lucas, by the Texas attorney general’s finding, learned the details of crimes from the officers who came to hear him confess to them, and by an investigator’s account confessed to 70 or 80 killings in a day. Nash put a price on every name he had not given. DeSalvo’s confession passed from an inmate to a lawyer to the authorities before a single piece of evidence had been compared with it.
What separates the confessed number from the proven one, each time, is evidence that arrives from outside the room. In Texas it was work records that placed Lucas in Florida at the time the woman in orange socks was killed. In Boston it was crime scene evidence from 1964 and a DNA sample from a nephew, which turned one of DeSalvo’s 13 confessions into a scientific finding and left the other twelve exactly as he had told them. In Lucerne, Rio de Janeiro and Los Angeles the courts took the cases they could prove and set the rest aside. The largest number in each of these cases belongs to the man who said it. The smaller one belongs to the record.
• May 27, 1934: Ali Asghar Borujerdi is tried in Iran.
• December 1955: The first of the 11 killings Stephen Nash later claimed.
• November 26 and 29, 1956: Nash kills John Berg in Long Beach and Lawrence Rice, 10, at Ocean Park; he is arrested in Los Angeles on November 29.
• April 24, 1959: The California Supreme Court affirms Nash’s convictions and death sentences.
• 1960: Henry Lee Lucas kills his mother in Michigan; convicted of second-degree murder, he serves 15 years.
• June 1962 to January 1964: Eleven killings of women in and around Boston are attributed to the Boston Strangler; Mary Sullivan, 19, the last of them, dies on January 4, 1964.
• 1965: Albert DeSalvo, held on unrelated charges, confesses to the 11 Strangler killings and two others.
• January 1967: DeSalvo is convicted on eight indictments involving four women who survived and is sentenced to life; affirmed January 4, 1968.
• September 11, 1972: Elva Lee Jones disappears from Valdosta, Georgia.
• October 4, 1972: Julian Eugene Kennedy, an escaped Florida prisoner, is arrested in Tampa.
• December 11, 1972: Kennedy sends word from the Hillsborough County jail that he is ready to talk.
• August 1973: Kennedy repeats his confession to an FBI agent.
• November 1973: DeSalvo is stabbed to death in prison.
• July 5, 1974: The Fifth Circuit affirms Kennedy’s federal kidnapping conviction.
• October 1979: The woman later identified as Debra Jackson is found near Georgetown, Texas.
• 1984: Lucas is sentenced to death in the Orange Socks case.
• April 1985: Lucas tells the Dallas Times Herald that all but three of his confessions are false; 210 killings have been closed on his word.
• March 1986: Kiyotaka Katsuta is sentenced to death in Japan for the murder of eight people; the sentence becomes final in January 1994.
• April 1986: The Texas attorney general’s Lucas Report calls his confessions a massive hoax.
• 1990: A Texas investigator says police are "pretty sure" Lucas killed three people.
• June 1998: Governor George W. Bush commutes Lucas’s death sentence to life.
• December 1, 2000: Amnesty International reports that Katsuta was executed the previous day at the Nagoya Detention Centre.
• March 2001: Lucas dies in prison in Huntsville, Texas, at 64.
• End of June 2001: Roger Andermatt is arrested in Lucerne and admits nine killings.
• September 11, 2001: The investigating magistrate announces that Andermatt has confessed to 27 killings over six years.
• December 6, 2001: Forensic scientists announce that DNA from Mary Sullivan’s remains does not match DeSalvo.
• July 19, 2013: The Suffolk County district attorney announces a DNA match between DeSalvo and evidence from the Sullivan case.
• December 2014: Sailson José das Graças is arrested in the Baixada Fluminense and confesses to the killing of Fátima Miranda and dozens of others.
• May 2016: Blick puts the number Andermatt killed between 1995 and 2001 at 22; he is serving a life sentence.
• August 2019: The woman in the Orange Socks case is identified as Debra Jackson, 23, of Abilene.
• February 28, 2023: A jury in Nova Iguaçu convicts Sailson of the killing of Raimundo Basílio da Silva; he is sentenced to 21 years.