SEVEN CASES BROKEN BY THE FAMILY

Most serial cases are closed by strangers. A detective rereads a file, a laboratory returns a match, a patrol officer stops the wrong car. A smaller number are broken from much closer in. In the seven cases that follow, the move that mattered came from inside a family, either the offender’s own or one left behind by a victim. It was a daughter reading a television station’s website, a son letting himself into his mother’s apartment, a mother writing letters to a man she could not name, a younger brother who heard a boast, a dead woman’s sister who had handed over her savings, and a wife who agreed to keep an appointment.

None of them did police work. Most of them paid for what they did.

Margaret Waters: Brixton, 1870

In the spring of 1870 a man paid two pounds for the care of an infant boy, John Cowen, born on May 14 of that year. The money went in answer to an advertisement placed under the name "Mrs. Oliver," which, according to the execution historians at Capital Punishment UK, was an alias of a woman named Sarah Ellis. The boy disappeared into a system of paid nursing that the Victorians called baby farming, in which infants, many of them born to unmarried mothers, were handed over to strangers for a fee.

Following the advertisement, Sergeant Richard Relf and the man who had paid for John’s keep reached the lodgings of Ellis and her sister, Margaret Waters, a 35-year-old widow. They found John and five other infants in what Capital Punishment UK describes as a pitiable state, all of them badly underweight.

Waters was charged with five counts of wilful murder, along with neglect and conspiracy. She and Ellis were tried at the Old Bailey from September 21 to 23, 1870. Waters was convicted of one murder, John’s. Ellis was convicted of obtaining money by false pretenses and sentenced to 18 months. On October 11, 1870, Waters was hanged at the Surrey County Gaol on Horsemonger Lane. She was 35. The law professor Kristin Kalsem, writing for The Victorian Web in 2024, records that she was suspected in the deaths of some forty other children. None of those deaths was tried.

Her case became the argument for a new law. When the Infant Life Protection Bill came before the House of Commons on March 6, 1872, the member who had brought it in, Mr. Charley, began by reminding the House that it was "familiar with the case of Margaret Waters, the Brixton baby-farmer." Three months later, in a debate on the bastardy laws, he named the officer who had made the case: "Mr. Serjeant Relf, who had had great experience in cases of infanticide, and who brought Margaret Waters to justice." The bill became the Infant Life Protection Act of 1872, which required people who took in infants for payment to register.

Johann Hoch: Chicago, 1905

The man who called himself Johann Hoch had been suspected of murder for ten years before anyone could prove one. In 1895, as Jacob Huff, he had married a widow, Caroline Hoch, in Wheeling, West Virginia. She died that June, and he staged a drowning in the Ohio River and vanished, leaving a watch on the bank with his photograph inside. Her pastor, the Rev. Herman C. A. Haass, kept the photograph and spent years reading marriage notices and obituaries from across the country, according to A. I. Schutzer’s account of the case in American Heritage in 1964. In 1898 the pastor’s file helped Chicago police identify a bigamist they were holding, but an exhumation in Wheeling found nothing that could be tested, and the man went free in 1900.

In December 1904 an advertisement in a German-language Chicago newspaper brought him to Marie Walcker, a widow who, CBS Chicago reported in 2021, ran a candy store and sold it at his urging. They married within days of meeting. She fell ill and died on January 12, 1905, about a month after the wedding. By Schutzer’s account, Hoch was courting her sister through the funeral and for four days after it. The sister agreed to marry him on January 16. Within a week she had advanced him 750 dollars, and that night he disappeared.

It was the sister who went to the police. She was shown into the office of Inspector George Shippy, the same Chicago officer who had shown Hoch the Wheeling photograph in 1898. On January 22, 1905, a court order was obtained to exhume Marie Walcker’s body, and the autopsy found a large quantity of arsenic.

Hoch had gone to New York and taken a room in a Manhattan boardinghouse as Henry Bartels. The woman who kept the house saw his picture in a newspaper on a trolley and recognized her lodger, and detectives arrested him in his room that night. The arrest came on January 30, 1905. His trial for the murder of Marie Walcker opened in Chicago on April 19, and a month later he was found guilty. "It serves me right," he said, according to American Heritage. He was hanged in the Cook County jail on February 23, 1906, a date confirmed by the execution files held at the University at Albany. American Heritage later put the number of his marriages at roughly 43 to 50, while conceding that no one knew the true figure. Only one death was ever put before a jury.

Peter Kürten: Düsseldorf, 1930

Through 1929 the city of Düsseldorf lived with a run of killings and attacks by someone the police could not find. The Berlin detective Ernst Gennat came west to support the local force, and, as the legal historian Martin Rath wrote in Legal Tribune Online in 2014, it was in connection with this case that Gennat coined the German word for serial murderer, "Serienmörder." The newspapers named the unknown man the Vampire of Düsseldorf. For all the modern method brought to bear, Rath concluded, he was found in the end by what Germans call "Kommissar Zufall," Inspector Chance.

The man was Peter Kürten, born in Mülheim am Rhein in 1883, a veteran of nearly 30 prison sentences who by then lived quietly in Düsseldorf with his wife and presented himself as a respectable working man. In 1930 a woman who had survived one of his attacks led investigators to the address where the couple lived, according to a 2023 report by the German Press Agency on a long-lost file in the case. Kürten sensed the danger and slipped away at the last moment. His wife was taken into custody. He was arrested soon afterward by the Rochus church in Düsseldorf, at a meeting with his wife that had been arranged as a trap, and there he confessed.

His wife had heard it first. Carl von Ossietzky, the editor of Die Weltbühne and an opponent of the death penalty, complained in May 1931 that not even Kürten’s wife, "to whom he had made the first confession of murder," had been questioned in court. Ossietzky argued that the prosecution rested almost entirely on Kürten’s own words.

On April 22, 1931, the jury court in Düsseldorf convicted Kürten of nine murders and seven attempted murders and sentenced him to death. The first of the nine was the 1913 killing of a nine-year-old girl, Christine Klein, in Mülheim, a crime that by Rath’s account would have stayed unsolved without Kürten’s confession seventeen years later. He was guillotined in the yard of the Klingelpütz prison in Cologne on July 2, 1931.

The cost to his wife did not end with the verdict. According to the 2023 report, she suffered a nervous breakdown when his crimes became known. The divorce she began was not completed before the execution, which left her his widow. When she was recognized under a new surname, the investigating judge helped her change it a second time.

Trevor Joseph Hardy: Manchester, 1974 to 1976

Lesley Jane Stewart was 15 when she was killed on New Year’s Eve 1974. Wanda Skala, 17, was killed in July 1975. Sharon Mosoph, also 17, was killed in March 1976 and found in Failsworth. For the three killings, in and around Manchester, Trevor Joseph Hardy was given three life sentences at Manchester Crown Court in 1977, according to the Shaw and Royton Correspondent in 2018.

The family’s part came early, and it did not save the last of the three girls. Hardy boasted about the killings to his brother, eight years his junior, NME reported in a 2018 preview of a documentary in which the brother told his story. In 1975, according to the television magazine What to Watch, the brother went to the police and told them Hardy had confessed to killing Wanda Skala. Hardy produced an alibi and was released. Sharon Mosoph was killed the following March. The brother, the documentary’s researcher told What to Watch, still felt that she "died when she didn’t need to."

What finally held was physical evidence. The retired detective Ian Kirkpatrick, who worked on the Mosoph case, told the Shaw and Royton Correspondent that fibers from a young man’s coat had passed to Sharon’s coat and then from both to Hardy’s. Hardy was arrested in August 1976, according to NME. Officers found him hiding in a loft in Stockport, the Correspondent reported, and he told them, "I will come down if you don’t hit me." He confessed, then retracted the confession in letters to the authorities, What to Watch reported.

Hardy died of a heart attack in Wakefield prison in 2012, aged 67. Kirkpatrick believes Hardy was also responsible for the 1971 killing of Dorothy Leyden in Collyhurst, Manchester, which came days after Hardy’s release from prison. That case remains unsolved, and NME reported that DNA from that case failed to match him. According to What to Watch, he tried to cast suspicion for it on his brother.

Thomas Lee Dillon: eastern Ohio, 1989 to 1992

Jamie Paxton was 21 and lived in Bannock, in Belmont County, Ohio. In November 1990 he was shot and killed while deer hunting near Uniontown. There was no witness, no weapon and no motive. "We knew absolutely nothing," his mother told CBS News years later.

She did not wait in silence. In the months after his death she wrote letters addressed to the person who had killed him. Some she posted in the field where he died; others were printed by The Times Leader, the daily paper in Martins Ferry. In one she told the killer that his hands were "the hands of a murderer" and that "you can’t wash Jamie’s blood from them."

On November 4, 1991, six days before the first anniversary of Jamie’s death, The Times Leader received a typed reply. It was signed "The murderer of Jamie Paxton." The writer said that when he left home that day he knew someone would die, though not who or where, and he blamed drink and a voice in his head. CBS News quoted other lines from it: a "compulsion that has taken over my life," and the sentence "the motive for the murder was the murder itself." The FBI’s behavioral science specialists at Quantico studied the letter, The Times Leader reported.

The killings went on. A jogger had already been shot in Tuscarawas County in 1989. Eighteen days after Paxton, Kevin Loring, 30, of Duxbury, Massachusetts, was killed while hunting in Muskingum County. In 1992 two fishermen died: Claude Hawkins, 48, of Mansfield, in Coshocton County, and Gary Bradley, 44, of Williamstown, West Virginia, in Noble County. Fred Thompson, a Belmont County investigator working the Paxton case, connected the shootings and built a task force that came to include the FBI and the Ohio Division of Wildlife.

When the task force warned the public before another deer season, a friend of Thomas Lee Dillon’s came forward. Dillon, a draftsman for a local water department with a wife and a son, liked to drive the back roads with his guns and had killed animals, CBS News reported. Investigators followed him for months and arrested him on a weapons charge. When his photograph appeared in the newspaper, a gun dealer recognized him as the man who had sold him a Mauser rifle. The FBI laboratory tied the rifle to one of the killings.

Offered a deal that spared him the death penalty, Dillon confessed on videotape. Of the men he had shot, he said they were "just there," in "the wrong place at the wrong time." In 1993 he pleaded guilty to five counts of aggravated murder and was sentenced to five consecutive life terms, The Times Leader reported. He died in state custody in Columbus in 2011, aged 61. After his death the former sheriff Fred Thompson said he had spoken with Jamie Paxton’s mother, and that they agreed it brought "final closure."

His name surfaced again in Michigan. In 2023 the state attorney general’s office reported that a file naming Dillon as an alternate suspect in the 1990 killing of two hunters in Kalamazoo County had never been given to the defense of J.T., the man convicted of those deaths in 2002. J.T.'s convictions were vacated that February. Dillon was never charged in Michigan.

Edward Wayne Edwards: Wisconsin and Ohio, 2009

On the night of August 9, 1980, Tim Hack and Kelly Drew, both 19, left a wedding reception at a dance hall in the Town of Concord, Jefferson County, Wisconsin. They never reached the friends they had planned to meet. Their remains were found in the Town of Ixonia on October 19, 1980. Over the next 29 years the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office worked through more than 100 suspects, the Watertown Daily Times reported.

One of the men questioned in 1980 was a handyman who worked at the hall and lived with his family at a campground next door. Edward Wayne Edwards had been on the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list in the early 1960s and had since toured as a reformed criminal, urging young people to stay out of trouble. About a month after the couple disappeared, and shortly after his contact with police, he left Wisconsin with his family.

The break came in 2009. In 2007 the state crime laboratory had developed a DNA profile from evidence on Kelly Drew’s clothing. In the spring of 2009 NBC 15, the Madison station, reported on the case. One of Edwards’s daughters, living in Ohio, read the station’s coverage online and called investigators about her father, the Daily Jefferson County Union later reported. A sample of his DNA was matched to the profile, and on July 30, 2009, he was arrested at his home in Louisville, Kentucky. He was 76.

The arrest brought a second case back to life. In April 2010, while awaiting trial, Edwards wrote to the Summit County prosecutor in Akron, Ohio, about a double killing in a park in Norton. Investigators matched it to the August 1977 shooting of Billy Lavaco, 21, and Judy Straub, 18, and in May he confessed to them. On June 9, 2010, he admitted the Wisconsin killings, and on June 11 he pleaded guilty in Akron to the aggravated murders of Lavaco and Straub and received two consecutive life terms. On June 21 a Jefferson County judge gave him two life sentences for the deaths of Tim Hack and Kelly Drew.

Edwards was not finished. In a jailhouse interview with the Associated Press that June he said he had also killed his foster son, Dannie Boy Edwards, in 1996 near Burton, Ohio, and that he would rather be executed than spend his last years in prison. On March 8, 2011, he pleaded guilty in Geauga County and a three-judge panel sentenced him to death. He died of natural causes on April 7, 2011, months before the execution date.

Camille Cleroux: Ottawa, 2010

In late May 2010 a man let himself into his mother’s apartment in south Ottawa with a spare key. Her furniture and belongings were gone, and a stranger was living there. The stranger was Camille Cleroux, a former dishwasher who lived in the same building, and he told the son that his mother had gone on a trip and left the apartment to him, Agence France-Presse reported. To neighbors he had said that Paula Leclair, 64, had won 50,000 dollars in a lottery and gone away. She had won nothing.

The son reported her missing, and the investigation began on May 29, 2010, CTV News reported. Four days later Cleroux was charged with first-degree murder. About three weeks after that, Ottawa police charged him in the deaths of two more women: his wife, Lise Roy, who had disappeared in 1990 at 27, and his later partner, Jean Rock, last seen in 2003 at 32. Neither had been reported missing. Both families believed the women had moved away and chosen silence, police said. Rock’s family had letters to prove it. Cleroux, the court later heard, had hired someone to write them in her name, telling of a new partner, a pregnancy and a birth.

In June 2012 Cleroux pleaded guilty in Ontario Superior Court to first-degree murder in Leclair’s death and second-degree murder in the deaths of Roy and Rock. The Crown said he had killed Leclair because she would not let him have her apartment. Justice Lynn Ratushny called the motive "stomach churning," AFP reported. He was sentenced to life with no chance of parole for 25 years. When the facts were read, Jean Rock’s father broke down in court; he said he had welcomed Cleroux into the family home, and that if he had seen through him his daughter would still be alive. Cleroux died in custody at Pacific Institution in Abbotsford, British Columbia, on January 17, 2021, Correctional Service Canada announced.

What the families saw

The family’s word did not always finish the work. Hoch’s sister-in-law took her suspicion to Inspector Shippy, and on January 22, 1905, a court ordered the exhumation that gave Chicago its proof. Paula Leclair’s son reported his mother missing, and the charge against Cleroux followed four days later; the two older deaths came to light only because detectives then went back through the women in his life. Kürten’s wife held his confession before the police did, and her appointment with him was the one he kept.

In the other cases a relative unlocked the door and something else carried the case through it. In Wisconsin it was a DNA profile developed from a victim’s clothing. In Ohio it was a rifle that a gun dealer had kept, and a friend who told the task force what he knew. In Manchester it was fibers on a coat, a year after a brother’s warning had been answered with an alibi. In Brixton, a single paid-for infant gave Sergeant Relf the case that Parliament would cite two years later.

What the families had was nearness. A daughter could measure her father against a cold case on a television station’s website. A son knew what his mother’s apartment was supposed to look like. A sister knew why she had handed over 750 dollars, and that her husband had not come home.

Timeline

• May 14, 1870: John Cowen, the infant whose death would be tried against Margaret Waters, is born.

• September 21 to 23, 1870: Waters and her sister are tried at the Old Bailey.

• October 11, 1870: Waters is hanged at Horsemonger Lane, Surrey.

• 1872: The Infant Life Protection Act is passed after debates that cite her case.

• 1895: Caroline Hoch dies in Wheeling, West Virginia; her husband stages a drowning and disappears.

• January 12, 1905: Marie Walcker dies in Chicago, about a month after marrying Johann Hoch.

• January 16, 1905: Hoch marries her sister, who soon gives him 750 dollars; he vanishes and she goes to the police.

• January 22, 1905: Marie Walcker’s body is exhumed; arsenic is found.

• January 30, 1905: Hoch is arrested in New York.

• February 23, 1906: Hoch is hanged in Chicago.

• 1913: Christine Klein, nine, is killed in Mülheim am Rhein.

• 1929: A series of killings and attacks in Düsseldorf.

• 1930: Kürten confesses to his wife and is arrested in Düsseldorf.

• April 22, 1931: Kürten is convicted of nine murders and seven attempted murders.

• July 2, 1931: Kürten is guillotined in Cologne.

• December 31, 1974: Lesley Jane Stewart, 15, is killed.

• July 1975: Wanda Skala, 17, is killed.

• 1975: Hardy’s younger brother tells police of a confession to her killing; Hardy gives an alibi and is released.

• March 1976: Sharon Mosoph, 17, is killed.

• August 1976: Hardy is arrested in Stockport.

• 1977: Hardy receives three life sentences at Manchester Crown Court.

• August 1977: Billy Lavaco and Judy Straub are shot in Norton, Ohio.

• August 9, 1980: Tim Hack and Kelly Drew disappear in Jefferson County, Wisconsin.

• 1989: A jogger is shot in Tuscarawas County, Ohio, the first of Dillon’s five killings.

• 1990: Lise Roy disappears in Ottawa.

• November 1990: Jamie Paxton and Kevin Loring are killed in eastern Ohio.

• November 4, 1991: The Times Leader receives the letter signed "The murderer of Jamie Paxton."

• 1992: Claude Hawkins and Gary Bradley are killed while fishing.

• 1993: Dillon pleads guilty to five counts of aggravated murder.

• 1996: Dannie Boy Edwards is killed near Burton, Ohio.

• 2003: Jean Rock is last seen in Ottawa.

• July 30, 2009: Edwards is arrested in Louisville after his daughter’s tip and a DNA match.

• May 29, 2010: Police in Ottawa begin investigating Paula Leclair’s disappearance after her son’s report.

• June 2010: Edwards pleads guilty in Wisconsin and Ohio; two life terms in each state.

• March 8, 2011: Edwards is sentenced to death in Geauga County, Ohio.

• April 7, 2011: Edwards dies of natural causes.

• 2011: Dillon dies in state custody in Columbus.

• June 2012: Cleroux pleads guilty in Ottawa to one first-degree and two second-degree murders.

• 2012: Hardy dies in Wakefield prison.

• January 17, 2021: Cleroux dies in federal custody in British Columbia.