WON ON APPEAL, CONVICTED AGAIN

A successful criminal appeal is rarely the end of a case. It is a ruling that something went wrong in the way the case was tried: a confession taken the wrong way, a jury drawn from a county that had already made up its mind, a lawyer who never put on a defense. What the appellate court almost never says is that the defendant did not do it. That question goes back to a trial court, and in the cases that follow it usually came back with the same answer.

Leslie Irvin and the jury that had already decided

Six people were killed near Evansville, Indiana, in the winter of 1954 and 1955, two in December and four in March. Leslie Irvin was arrested on April 8, 1955, and police and prosecutors let it be known that he had confessed to all six. He was indicted for one of them, the murder of Whitney Wesley Kerr on December 23, 1954, in Vanderburgh County.

His lawyers won one change of venue, to neighboring Gibson County, and Indiana law allowed only one. The coverage followed the case there. For six or seven months, the United States Supreme Court later wrote, the community was subjected to a "barrage of newspaper headlines, articles, cartoons and pictures." Of 430 people called for the jury, 268 were excused because they had fixed opinions of his guilt. Eight of the twelve who finally sat said during questioning that they thought he was guilty. On December 20, 1955, the jury convicted him and recommended death.

On January 18, 1956, before his motion for a new trial had been filed, Irvin escaped. He was recaptured in California about three weeks later. The trial court refused his motion for a new trial because he had been a fugitive, and the Indiana Supreme Court, while upholding that ruling, went on to reject his constitutional claims as well. The case went to the Supreme Court twice. In 1959 the justices held, over four dissents, that the federal courts could hear his constitutional claim. On June 5, 1961, in Irvin v. Dowd, Justice Tom Clark wrote for the Court that the jury had been drawn from a community gripped by a "pattern of deep and bitter prejudice," and that "a fair trial in a fair tribunal is a basic requirement of due process." Justice Felix Frankfurter, concurring, warned that the Court kept being asked to review convictions that pretrial publicity had poisoned.

The Court did not set Irvin free. It vacated the judgments of the lower federal courts and directed that Indiana be given a reasonable time to try him again on the same indictment. The other five deaths near Evansville were attributed to Irvin by the police and prosecutors who announced his confession; the Supreme Court cases concerned only the Kerr indictment.

Michigan v. Bladel: the lawyer who never arrived

On December 31, 1978, three railroad employees were killed at the Amtrak station in Jackson, Michigan. The man charged with their murders, a disgruntled former railroad employee named Bladel, was arrested on New Year’s Day 1979, questioned twice and released. On March 22, 1979, he was arrested again and agreed to talk to police that evening without a lawyer.

The trouble began the next day. At his arraignment on Friday, March 23, Bladel asked for a lawyer to be appointed because he could not afford one. Notice of the appointment went to a law firm by mail and did not arrive until the following Tuesday. On Monday, March 26, two officers came to the county jail, read him his rights and took a confession. He had asked several times about his lawyer and had not been told one had been named.

The trial court let the confession in, and Bladel was convicted. The Michigan Court of Appeals at first affirmed, then reversed itself and ordered a new trial. The Michigan Supreme Court, taking his case together with that of another Michigan defendant named Jackson, held in 1984 that both men’s statements after arraignment should have been suppressed. On April 1, 1986, the United States Supreme Court agreed, five to four, in Michigan v. Jackson. Once a defendant has asked for counsel at an arraignment, Justice John Paul Stevens wrote, "any waiver of the defendant’s right to counsel for that police-initiated interrogation is invalid." Chief Justice Warren Burger concurred only in the judgment, and Justice William Rehnquist, joined by Justices Lewis Powell and Sandra Day O’Connor, dissented.

The ruling corrected the way the confession had been taken. It said nothing about who had killed the three railroad employees. That question went back to Jackson County for a new trial.

Joseph Christopher: the verdict that did change

In about a day and a half beginning on September 22, 1980, a Black teenager and three Black men were shot dead in the Buffalo and Niagara Falls area. The youngest, Glenn Dunn, was 14. Harold Green, 32, of Cheektowaga, and Emmanuel Thomas, 30, of Buffalo, died in the Buffalo area, and Joseph McCoy, 43, in Niagara Falls. United Press International, describing the prosecution’s case, reported that the same .22-caliber weapon was used to kill Dunn, Thomas and Green over a span of 25 hours. Police would later suspect the same man in 12 deaths in all, ABC News reported in 2023.

That man was Joseph Christopher, a white Buffalo resident who had joined the Army in November 1980. He was identified in the spring of 1981 while held in the stockade at Fort Benning, Georgia, after a knife attack on a Black soldier. On April 27, 1982, a State Supreme Court justice in Buffalo, sitting without a jury, convicted him of three counts of second-degree murder in the deaths of Dunn, Thomas and Green. On May 24, Justice Frederick Marshall sentenced him to consecutive terms of 15, 20 and 25 years to life, a minimum of 60 years. His lawyers had already said they would argue that errors were made at the trial and at the competency hearings held before it.

Three years later the convictions were overturned on appeal, WGRZ-TV in Buffalo reported. This is the one case in the group in which the second trial did not simply repeat the first. Christopher’s new lawyers conceded that he had done the shootings and argued that he was insane, relying in part on a videotaped psychiatric interview in which he spoke of hearing voices and of fighting a race war. The jury did not accept the insanity defense, and it did not convict him of murder either. It found him guilty of manslaughter, on the ground that he had acted under extreme emotional disturbance. ABC News placed that trial in 1987. Christopher died in prison in 1993, at 37.

Elmer Wayne Henley Jr.: the same verdict, a different sentence

On August 8, 1973, a 17-year-old from the Houston Heights named Elmer Wayne Henley Jr. telephoned the Pasadena, Texas, police to say he had shot Dean Corll. The deaths of 27 boys and young men came to light over the following days, in a case that became known as the Houston Mass Murders. The killings are attributed to Corll, who led them. Henley admitted bringing boys to Corll for money.

Both sides agreed in January 1974 that he could not get a fair trial in Houston, and the case was moved to San Antonio. In July 1974 a jury there convicted him of six counts of murder, for the deaths of Charles Cobble, Marty Jones, Billy Lawrence, Homer Garcia, Frank Aguirre and Johnny Delone. He received six consecutive terms of 99 years, reported at the time as 594 years. Prosecutors did not seek death, the Texas Observer noted; KPRC has reported that the death penalty was then halted in Texas.

In December 1978 those convictions were overturned on appeal. Henley was tried again in June 1979, and a second jury convicted him on the same six counts. This time he received six life sentences, which the Dallas Voice and the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children have described as consecutive. The appeal had changed the form of the sentence and nothing else.

Henley has now spent more than five decades in prison. The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles has refused him parole every time his case has come up. On November 7, 2025, KPRC in Houston reported that the board had denied him again and set his next review about ten years away. "Henley deprived over 20 boys of their lives and all we can do in return is deprive him of his liberty," said Andy Kahan of Crime Stoppers of Houston, who speaks for many of the families.

Frank Athen Walls: deception in the jail

Edward Alger, an airman stationed at Eglin Air Force Base, and Ann Peterson, his girlfriend, were killed in Okaloosa County, in the Florida Panhandle, early on July 22, 1987. Frank Athen Walls, 19, was arrested the next day after a former roommate went to police, and he confessed on tape. A jury convicted him in 1988 of two counts of first-degree murder, with burglary, kidnapping and theft charges, and he was sentenced to death for Peterson’s murder.

On April 11, 1991, the Florida Supreme Court threw out the convictions and the death sentence. Before trial, a correctional officer had drawn statements from Walls through subterfuge, and those statements were then used by the experts who examined whether he was competent to be tried. The court held that this violated due process and ordered a new trial on every issue.

Publicity in Okaloosa County sent the retrial to Jackson County. The state played the full taped confession; the defense called no witnesses. On June 18, 1992, the jury found Walls guilty as charged, and it recommended death by a vote of 12 to 0. On July 29 Judge G. Robert Barron imposed it. The Florida Supreme Court affirmed on July 7, 1994, and the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the case in January 1995.

DNA evidence later tied Walls to the 1987 killing of Audrey Gygi, and he pleaded no contest to her murder and received a life sentence in October 1994. Under a deal with prosecutors he admitted two earlier killings, of Tommie Lou Whiddon in 1985 and Cynthia Sue Condra in 1986; no conviction for either was reported.

The rest of his life was spent in appeals over whether he was intellectually disabled. In 2016 the Florida Supreme Court ordered a new hearing on the question in light of Hall v. Florida; in 2020, in another case, it reversed course and held that Hall did not apply retroactively. No court ever found him disabled. Walls was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison on December 18, 2025, at 58. The new trial he won in 1991, on a genuine constitutional defect, had led back to the same sentence, and in December 2025 that sentence was carried out.

Juan Corona: the lawyer who wanted the story

In May and June 1971, Sutter County sheriff’s deputies recovered the bodies of 25 men near Yuba City, California, most of them older transient farmworkers. On May 26 they arrested Juan Vallejo Corona, 37, the labor contractor who hired crews for the ranches where the men were found. A Solano County jury in Fairfield convicted him of 25 counts of first-degree murder on January 18, 1973.

His lawyer, Richard Hawk, had taken as his fee the exclusive literary and dramatic rights to Corona’s life story. At trial, after the prosecution called more than 100 witnesses, Hawk rested without calling one. On May 8, 1978, the California Court of Appeal reversed. Faced with substantial evidence of Corona’s history of mental illness, the court held, Hawk had never investigated whether his client was competent, whether he had diminished capacity or whether he was legally insane, and in abandoning that defense he had reduced the trial to a sham. Because of the literary contract, the court added, "trial counsel assumed a position virtually adverse to his client."

The retrial opened in Hayward, in Alameda County, on February 22, 1982. With a new lead lawyer, Terence Hallinan, Corona testified and denied the killings, and the defense blamed his half-brother, who had died in Mexico in 1973 and was never charged. The prosecution added a statement Corona had made in 1978 to the Mexican consul in San Jose. After more than 53 hours of deliberation, the jury convicted him again on all 25 counts in September 1982. He was sentenced to 25 concurrent terms of 25 years to life.

The Court of Appeal affirmed on June 14, 1989. It ruled that the consul’s testimony should not have been admitted, since the privilege covering it belonged to Mexico, but that Corona could not complain of an error in a privilege that was not his. "A defendant is entitled to a fair trial but not a perfect one," the court wrote. Corona died in custody on March 4, 2019, at 85.

Christine Paolilla: the appeal that did not succeed

On the afternoon of July 18, 2003, four young people were shot dead in a home in Clear Lake, a Houston suburb: Tiffany Rowell, 18; Rachael Koloroutis, 18; Marcus Precella, 19, Tiffany’s boyfriend; and Adelbert Sanchez, 21, Marcus’s cousin. Rowell and Koloroutis had been high school classmates and close friends of Christine Paolilla. The case went unsolved for nearly three years, until a Crime Stoppers tip pointed to Paolilla and her boyfriend, Chris Snider. Snider took his own life after learning that police were looking for him, and Paolilla was arrested in a San Antonio hotel room.

At her trial, her lawyer, Mike DeGuerin, argued that Snider had done the killing. Paolilla had told police that she was inside the house and that she had held a gun while Snider fired it. The jury convicted her of capital murder. Because she had been 17 at the time, she could not be sentenced to death, and she received the mandatory life term.

Her appeal did not succeed. On May 26, 2011, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston rejected her arguments that a mandatory life sentence for a juvenile violated the Eighth Amendment, that her recorded statements should have been suppressed and that a mistrial should have been granted over the prosecutor’s closing argument, and affirmed the conviction. The four deaths were a single event, not a series. Her case belongs in this company only as an appeal that changed nothing because it was lost.

Angus Sinclair: the acquittal that was taken back

Every one of those appeals ran in the defendant’s favor. In Scotland in 2007 the system faced the reverse problem: an acquittal it could not touch.

On the night of October 15, 1977, Christine Eadie and Helen Scott, both 17, were last seen in Edinburgh’s Old Town. The next day both were found dead in East Lothian. Christine had started work in an office after leaving school; Helen, whom the judge would later describe as shy and retiring, worked in a shop and wanted to be a children’s nurse. For almost three decades no one was charged.

The man eventually tried was Angus Robertson Sinclair, a Glasgow-born offender who had killed a seven-year-old girl, Catherine Reehill, in 1961, a killing that ended in a conviction for culpable homicide, and who in 2001 was convicted of the 1978 murder of Mary Gallacher, 17. A DNA match on Helen’s coat in 2004 made him a suspect in the World’s End case for the first time. His trial opened at the High Court in Edinburgh in August 2007. At the close of the Crown case the defense submitted that there was no case to answer, and on September 10, 2007, Lord Clarke agreed and acquitted him. The jury never reached a verdict. The Crown had no right of appeal against an acquittal by a judge, and the Lord Advocate, Elish Angiolini, told the Scottish Parliament that she would have appealed if the law had allowed it.

The Parliament changed the law. The Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Act 2011 allows the High Court to set aside an acquittal where new evidence has emerged that could not have been found at the first trial, that substantially strengthens the case, and that makes it highly likely a reasonable jury would convict. The Act came into force in November 2011, and the justice secretary, Kenny MacAskill, referred to the World’s End case when it did. It was a general reform, not a law aimed at one man, but Sinclair’s was the first application made under it. Forensic scientists had used a new light source to find fresh DNA traces on the clothing, and on March 27, 2014, three judges led by the Lord Justice Clerk, Lord Carloway, set the acquittal aside.

The retrial opened at the High Court sitting in Livingston on October 13, 2014. On November 14 a jury of nine women and six men, out for less than two and a half hours, unanimously convicted Sinclair of murdering both girls, with other charges, acting together with his late brother-in-law, Gordon Hamilton. Lord Matthews set a punishment part of 37 years, the longest a Scottish court had imposed. Sinclair dropped his appeal against conviction in August 2015, and the appeal court refused his challenge to the sentence on March 24, 2016. He had been in prison without a break since 1982, serving a life sentence for offenses against children, and he died in HMP Glenochil on March 11, 2019.

Gilles de Rais: an acquittal with no force

Gilles de Rais, a Breton baron who fought beside Joan of Arc at Orléans and was made a Marshal of France in 1429, was tried at Nantes in October 1440 by two courts at once. The church court, under Bishop Jean de Malestroit, tried him for heresy and related offenses; the secular court of John V, duke of Brittany, tried him for the murder of children. He first refused to recognize the church court and was excommunicated, then submitted and was absolved. When the testimony closed, the prosecutor reminded the court of its power to apply torture. Gilles chose to confess instead, and he confessed again in open court. On October 25, 1440, he was condemned, and on October 26 he was hanged and burned outside Nantes with two of his servants.

Writers have questioned the verdict for about a century. Skeptics point to the threat that preceded the confession and to the duke of Brittany’s financial interest in his downfall; among the arguments Douglas Linder lists for his innocence is the claim that the duke and the bishop gained property from the conviction. In 1992 the writer Gilbert Prouteau, who had published a book arguing that Gilles was innocent, called for a retrial, and an unofficial panel convened in Paris declared him not guilty. It had no legal standing and changed nothing in law. Linder reports that its participants did not study the primary documents closely, and that Prouteau himself later called the event "an absolute joke." Most historians who have studied the trial record, Britannica says, still believe Gilles killed children.

Where the appeals did not reach

Set against these cases are the defendants whose convictions were later shown to be unsafe. The appeals process did not deal with them uniformly.

Rolando Cruz is the case in which the appellate courts did act, twice, and still could not end it. Jeanine Nicarico, 10, was killed in DuPage County, Illinois, in February 1983. Cruz, a young man from Aurora, came to police with a story about the crime that, according to the National Registry of Exonerations, he made up in the hope of collecting a reward. On February 22, 1985, he and Alejandro Hernandez were convicted and sentenced to death. The Illinois Supreme Court overturned both convictions in January 1988, by the Daily Herald’s account (the Registry dates the ruling to 1989), holding that they should have been tried separately. Cruz was convicted again on February 1, 1990, and again sentenced to death, and in December 1992 the same court affirmed by four votes to three. Weeks later three justices retired. The reconstituted court granted a rehearing, and on July 14, 1994, it reversed. On November 3, 1995, at his third trial, Judge Ronald Mehling acquitted Cruz after hearing that a sheriff’s lieutenant who had testified to a telephone call about Cruz’s supposed admissions had been on vacation in Florida at the time. Governor George Ryan pardoned him on grounds of innocence in December 2002. Brian Dugan, who had offered to admit the killing as early as 1985, was indicted on DNA evidence in 2005 and pleaded guilty to Jeanine’s murder on July 28, 2009.

Frank Lee Smith was not so fortunate. Shandra Whitehead, 8, was attacked in Fort Lauderdale on the night of April 14, 1985, and died about a week later. Smith was arrested on April 29, and on January 31, 1986, a Broward County jury convicted him of first-degree murder, with other charges. He was sentenced to death, and the Florida Supreme Court affirmed in 1987. In 1989 a key trial witness, shown a photograph of another man, Eddie Lee Mosley, signed an affidavit saying he was the man she had seen. A trial judge found the recantation not credible. In October 1998 Judge Mark Speiser refused DNA testing and a new hearing. Smith was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer on January 1, 2000, and died on death row on January 30, at 52. That July the state agreed to DNA testing. On December 15, 2000, the FBI laboratory reported that the evidence did not come from Smith and was consistent with Mosley, and Smith’s convictions were vacated and the charges dismissed. Mosley, charged with murder in a separate case in 1987, was found incompetent to stand trial and was never tried for any killing.

Billy Glaze’s case did not end in an exoneration. A Hennepin County jury convicted him in February 1989 of the first-degree murders of three Native American women in Minneapolis: Kathleen Bullman, 19; Angeline Whitebird Sweet, 26, a mother of three; and Angela Green, 21. The Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed in 1990. Years later, lawyers from the Innocence Project said DNA testing of dozens of items had found nothing from Glaze and had matched another man at two of the three scenes; prosecutors answered that it was "not a DNA exoneration case." Glaze died of lung cancer in a Delaware prison on December 22, 2015, at 72, with his petition for a new trial still pending. In November 2016 a Hennepin County judge dismissed it as moot, writing that "nothing in the record supports a finding that Petitioner (Glaze) was actually innocent." In March 2018 the Minnesota Supreme Court dismissed the appeal because no one with standing remained to bring it. No court ruled on the DNA evidence, and the convictions stand.

Kathleen Folbigg’s four children died between 1989 and 1999: Caleb at 19 days, Patrick at eight months, Sarah at ten months and Laura at 18 months. On May 21, 2003, a New South Wales jury convicted her of murdering three of them, of the manslaughter of Caleb and of grievous bodily harm to Patrick. She was sentenced to 40 years, reduced on appeal to 30. A judicial inquiry led by Reginald Blanch reported in July 2019 that the evidence reinforced her guilt, and in March 2021 the Court of Appeal dismissed her challenge to that finding. What turned the case was science. Research on a rare CALM2 genetic variant carried by both daughters led to a petition in 2021, a second inquiry under the former chief justice Tom Bathurst in 2022 and 2023, and, on June 5, 2023, a pardon and her release. On December 14, 2023, the Court of Criminal Appeal quashed all of the convictions and entered verdicts of acquittal. "There is now reasonable doubt as to Ms Folbigg’s guilt," Chief Justice Andrew Bell said. "The system preferred to blame me rather than accept that sometimes children can and do die suddenly," Folbigg said afterward.

What an appeal decides

The appellate courts in these cases did what they are built to do. They found a confession taken after a defendant had asked for counsel, a jury drawn from a county saturated with one side of the story, a jail officer’s deception, a lawyer whose fee was the rights to his client’s story. Each time the remedy was a new trial, and in Henley’s, Walls’s and Corona’s cases the new jury heard much the same evidence and reached the same verdict. Christopher’s second jury moved only from murder to manslaughter.

Where the question was not how a trial was run but whether the right person had been convicted, the answers came from elsewhere: from DNA results in Smith’s case, from a third trial and a governor’s pardon in Cruz’s, from genetic research and a judicial inquiry in Folbigg’s. In Glaze’s case they did not come at all before he died. And in Scotland it took an act of Parliament to let a court ask the question a second time about a man it had already acquitted.

Timeline

• October 26, 1440: Gilles de Rais is hanged and burned at Nantes after his conviction by the church and secular courts.

• December 1954 to March 1955: Six people are killed near Evansville, Indiana; Leslie Irvin is arrested on April 8, 1955.

• December 20, 1955: A Gibson County jury convicts Irvin of the murder of Whitney Wesley Kerr and recommends death.

• January 18, 1956: Irvin escapes; he is recaptured in California about three weeks later.

• May 4, 1959: The U.S. Supreme Court rules that federal courts may hear Irvin’s constitutional claim.

• June 5, 1961: Irvin v. Dowd: the Supreme Court vacates the judgments and gives Indiana time to retry him.

• May and June 1971: The bodies of 25 men are recovered near Yuba City, California; Juan Corona is arrested on May 26.

• January 18, 1973: A Solano County jury convicts Corona of 25 counts of first-degree murder.

• August 8, 1973: Elmer Wayne Henley Jr. shoots Dean Corll in Pasadena, Texas.

• July 1974: A San Antonio jury convicts Henley of six murders.

• October 15 and 16, 1977: Christine Eadie and Helen Scott are last seen in Edinburgh’s Old Town and found dead in East Lothian the next day.

• May 8, 1978: The California Court of Appeal reverses Corona’s convictions.

• December 1978: Henley’s convictions are overturned on appeal.

• December 31, 1978: Three railroad employees are killed at the Amtrak station in Jackson, Michigan.

• March 26, 1979: Police in Jackson question Bladel after his arraignment and obtain a confession.

• June 1979: Henley is convicted again on retrial; six life sentences.

• September 1980: A Black teenager and three Black men are shot dead in the Buffalo and Niagara Falls area.

• April 27, 1982: Joseph Christopher is convicted of three counts of second-degree murder in Buffalo.

• September 1982: A Hayward jury convicts Corona again on all 25 counts.

• February 1983: Jeanine Nicarico is killed in DuPage County, Illinois.

• February 22, 1985: Rolando Cruz and Alejandro Hernandez are convicted and sentenced to death.

• April 1985: Shandra Whitehead dies in Fort Lauderdale; Frank Lee Smith is arrested on April 29.

• January 31, 1986: Smith is convicted of first-degree murder, with other charges.

• April 1, 1986: Michigan v. Jackson: the U.S. Supreme Court upholds the suppression of Bladel’s confession.

• 1987: Christopher’s retrial, as dated by ABC News, ends in a manslaughter verdict.

• July 22, 1987: Edward Alger and Ann Peterson are killed in Okaloosa County, Florida.

• 1988: Frank Athen Walls is convicted and sentenced to death; the Illinois Supreme Court reverses the Cruz and Hernandez convictions (January 1988 per the Daily Herald; 1989 per the National Registry of Exonerations).

• February 1989: Billy Glaze is convicted of the murders of three women in Minneapolis.

• February 1, 1990: Cruz is convicted a second time and sentenced to death.

• April 11, 1991: The Florida Supreme Court reverses Walls’s convictions.

• June 18, 1992: A Jackson County jury convicts Walls again; death is reimposed on July 29.

• 1992: An unofficial panel in Paris declares Gilles de Rais not guilty.

• July 14, 1994: The Illinois Supreme Court, on rehearing, reverses Cruz’s second conviction.

• November 3, 1995: Cruz is acquitted at his third trial.

• January 30, 2000: Smith dies on death row; on December 15, 2000, the FBI laboratory reports that the evidence did not come from him, and his convictions are vacated.

• May 21, 2003: Kathleen Folbigg is convicted in New South Wales.

• July 18, 2003: Four young people are shot dead in Clear Lake, Houston.

• September 10, 2007: Lord Clarke acquits Angus Sinclair of the World’s End murders.

• July 28, 2009: Brian Dugan pleads guilty to Jeanine Nicarico’s murder.

• May 26, 2011: The Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston affirms Christine Paolilla’s capital murder conviction.

• November 2011: The Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Act 2011 comes into force.

• March 27, 2014: The High Court sets aside Sinclair’s acquittal.

• November 14, 2014: Sinclair is convicted at Livingston; punishment part 37 years.

• December 22, 2015: Glaze dies in prison with his new-trial petition pending.

• March 21, 2018: The Minnesota Supreme Court dismisses the Glaze appeal for lack of standing.

• March 4, 2019: Corona dies in custody, at 85.

• March 11, 2019: Sinclair dies in HMP Glenochil.

• June 5, 2023: Folbigg is pardoned and released.

• December 14, 2023: The New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal quashes Folbigg’s convictions.

• November 7, 2025: Henley is denied parole, with a ten-year set-off.

• December 18, 2025: Walls is executed at Florida State Prison.