A hospital is the one place where a death needs no explaining. Patients arrive sick, some of them very old, and a certain number of them die. The drugs that can kill are kept within reach, signed out for someone, given by people trained to give them. When a nurse decides to kill, the ward supplies the means, the cover and the alibi at once. That is why killings of this kind have run for months, sometimes years, before anyone looked, and why, once someone did, the courts so often arrived at a number far smaller than the one investigators feared.
Elizabeth Wettlaufer was a registered nurse in southwestern Ontario. Between 2007 and 2016 she gave overdoses of insulin to fourteen people in her care, most of them elderly residents of long-term care homes. Eight died: James Silcox, 84, a Second World War veteran and father of six; Maurice Granat, 84, a retired mechanic; Gladys Millard, 87, a seamstress well known in Woodstock; Helen Matheson, 95; Mary Zurawinski, 96, who had hoped to reach a hundred; Helen Young, 90; and Maureen Pickering, 79, all residents of Caressant Care in Woodstock; and Arpad Horvath, 75, who owned a tool and die business in London and lived at the Meadow Park home there.
None of the deaths was treated as suspicious. Over the years she told a former girlfriend, a student nurse, a pastor and his wife, a criminal lawyer and others what she was doing, and none of them stopped her. Caressant Care let her go in 2014 after a string of medication errors, and she was working again within a month. The case began only in September 2016, when she checked herself into the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health in Toronto and told her psychiatrist what she had done.
On June 1, 2017, in Woodstock, she pleaded guilty to eight counts of first-degree murder, four of attempted murder and two of aggravated assault. Justice Bruce Thomas sentenced her on June 26 to life with no parole eligibility for twenty-five years, and said that without her confessions the crimes would never have come to justice. The public inquiry led by Commissioner Eileen E. Gillese reached the same conclusion in its report of July 31, 2019. Families, co-workers, managers, inspectors, coroners and the nurses' regulator had all missed her. The commissioner made no findings of misconduct against any individual. She traced the failures to weaknesses in the system itself, among them medication management, staffing, and the way deaths in care homes were reported and investigated. "It is not possible to detect or deter something unless you are aware it exists," she said. In March 2019 Wettlaufer was reported back at Grand Valley Institution for Women in Kitchener.
The hospital in Sonthofen, in the Allgäu region of the Bavarian Alps, did not at first suspect its patients' deaths. It suspected its drug supply. In July 2004 police looked into reports that medicines were missing, found unsealed vials in the apartment of a young nurse, Stephan Letter, and identified him by matching the times of patients' deaths to his hours on duty, the Associated Press reported. He was arrested that month and admitted some of the killings, saying he had wanted to spare patients senseless suffering.
Investigators then reviewed more than eighty deaths from his time at the hospital, exhumed more than forty bodies and questioned more than two hundred witnesses. The charges that reached the Kempten Regional Court in February 2006 covered twenty-nine deaths. Most of the dead were elderly, but relatives said some had been recovering and expected to go home, and the prosecutor, Peter Koch, told the court that the mercy explanation might fit half the cases at most. "He killed as though he was on an assembly line," he said, as Agence France-Presse reported.
On November 20, 2006, the court convicted Letter of twelve murders, fifteen manslaughters and one killing on request, covering twenty-eight patients, and sentenced him to life, with a ruling against release after fifteen years and a lifetime ban from nursing. His lawyers said they would appeal; the judgment was not yet final in August 2007. That month the psychiatrist Karl H. Beine, writing in Deutsches Ärzteblatt about killings in German hospitals and care homes, listed the warning signs that had been noticed too late in case after case: drugs given without a prescription, uncanny predictions of when patients would die, nicknames such as "angel of death," and colleagues who preferred not to know.
On April 1, 1989, an 80-year-old patient on Pavilion V of the Lainz hospital in Vienna, a man without diabetes, suffered a sudden collapse in blood sugar after an insulin injection. He survived, and the Austria Press Agency later reconstructed how that one inexplicable reading brought the police to the ward. On April 7, Waltraud Wagner and Irene Leidolf, nurse’s aides in the First Medical Department, made their first confessions. Two more aides, Stefanija Mayer and Maria Gruber, were arrested later.
The four women at first admitted involvement in forty-two deaths, then retracted most of what they had said. Wagner marked thirty-nine names in the ward’s death book before withdrawing that confession too. The killings were by drug overdoses and by drowning with water, according to the evidence at trial, methods chosen because they were barely detectable in clinical terms. The prosecutor, Ernst Kloyber, told the court that the charges were "only the tip of the iceberg," and that its size "will never be known."
In March 1991 a jury convicted Wagner of fifteen murders, seventeen attempted murders and two counts of bodily harm, and she was sentenced to life. Leidolf received life for five murders and two attempted murders; Mayer twenty years for seven attempted murders and one manslaughter; Gruber fifteen years for two attempted murders. Wagner told the court she had acted out of compassion. Against that stood testimony that she had injected one elderly man because he was a burden. Wagner and Leidolf were released on parole on August 7, 2008.
Efren Saldivar’s case began with a confession and no evidence. In March 1998 the respiratory therapist, who worked nights at Glendale Adventist Medical Center, told Glendale police that he had caused the deaths of forty to fifty patients since 1989. With nothing to show a crime had been committed, he was released after two days, and he soon retracted everything, saying he had lied because he was depressed and wanted the state to execute him.
Detectives went back through the deaths on his shifts. A doctor reviewed the charts of 150 patients who had died while he was working and found fifty he regarded as suspicious; twenty were exhumed. The drug at issue, the paralyzing agent Pavulon, was thought almost impossible to find in buried remains. The Glendale task force took the problem to the Forensic Science Center at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, where the chemist Brian Andresen adapted methods built to trace chemical weapons. He found Pavulon in six of the twenty.
That figure, and no other, became the case. Saldivar was arrested in January 2001, and on March 12, 2002, he pleaded guilty to the first-degree murders of Eleanora Schlegel, 77; Salbi Asatryan, 75; Jose Alfaro, 82; Luina Schidlowski, 87; Balbino Castro, 87; and Myrtle Brower, 84, and to the attempted murder of a woman who survived. The plea spared him a possible death sentence. Judge Lance Ito sentenced him on April 17, 2002, to six life terms plus fifteen years to life. Whatever the true total, in his own later statements it ran far beyond six; none of those figures was tested in court.
Niels Högel worked in intensive care at the Klinikum Oldenburg from 1999 to 2002 and at the hospital in nearby Delmenhorst from late 2002 to 2005. He gave patients heart drugs that no doctor had ordered, brought on a cardiac arrest, and then joined the team that tried to revive them. The courts found that he did it for the recognition a successful resuscitation earned him.
Oldenburg had noticed. In 2001 staff on his unit kept a tally of the nurses present at resuscitations and deaths, and his name had the most marks, the newspaper taz reported. A handwritten note on the list judged the suspicion too weak to take to prosecutors. Instead he was moved, then encouraged to leave, and he went with a good written reference, which he took to Delmenhorst. There, in June 2005, a colleague caught him giving a patient a drug that had not been prescribed.
The full scale took more than a decade to emerge. A police special commission, named "Kardio," exhumed 134 former patients from 67 cemeteries and evaluated about 500 patient files, the Ärzte Zeitung reported in 2017. Its head, Arne Schmidt, said that more than 130 other patients who died on Högel’s shifts had been cremated, so that the cause of their deaths could hardly be proved, and that he had no doubt some of Högel’s victims were among them. Investigators said in 2018 that the full toll could exceed two hundred.
The Oldenburg Regional Court had already convicted Högel in February 2015 of two murders and two attempted murders at Delmenhorst. On June 6, 2019, after a trial held in a conference center in Oldenburg, the same court convicted him of 85 more murders and acquitted him of fifteen for lack of evidence. He received life with a finding of particular gravity of guilt, and the Federal Court of Justice rejected his appeal in September 2020. Seven of his former superiors were tried in 2022 for their part and acquitted on October 13 of that year; the presiding judge said the court had found no intentional wrongdoing, not merely a lack of proof. In March 2026 a sentence enforcement chamber set his minimum term at 28 years, and in April 2026 he remained in prison.
In the pediatric intensive care unit of Bexar County Hospital in San Antonio, so many children suffered sudden seizures, bleeding and cardiac arrests on the 3 p.m. to 11 p.m. shift in 1981 that nurses called it the death shift. The licensed vocational nurse at the center of it was Genene Jones. The hospital held internal reviews, replaced all of the unit’s vocational nurses with registered nurses, and let her go in March 1982 with a letter of recommendation. It did not call the police.
That August she went to work for a pediatrician opening a practice in Kerrville. Within a month children were being rushed from the clinic to the local hospital. On September 17, 1982, Chelsea McClellan, fifteen months old, died after a visit to the clinic. Local doctors acted quickly where the San Antonio hospital had not. Chelsea’s body was exhumed in May 1983, and the toxicologist Fredric Rieders took tissue samples to Stockholm, where a newly developed test detected the drug succinylcholine. In February 1984 a jury in Georgetown convicted Jones of Chelsea’s murder and sentenced her to 99 years. In October 1984 a San Antonio judge found her guilty of injury to a child, a four-week-old boy who had survived.
The San Antonio deaths went uncharged for more than thirty years. Part of the reason was paper. The former Bexar County medical examiner Vincent DiMaio told Texas Public Radio in 2016 that the hospital’s records were shredded in March 1984 while under grand jury subpoena, and ProPublica’s reporter Peter Elkind found in 2017 that most of the 1980s records were missing from both the hospital and the district attorney’s files. Then a 1977 Texas law, meant to ease prison crowding, set her release for March 2018. Bexar County prosecutors indicted her in 2017 for the murders of five children, and on January 16, 2020, she pleaded guilty to the 1981 murder of Joshua Sawyer, eleven months old, and was sentenced to life. The other four charges were dismissed. The district attorney had said investigators believed she may have killed as many as sixty children; she stands convicted of two murders.
Charles Cullen worked as a registered nurse for sixteen years, at nine hospitals and a nursing home in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, and killed patients at several of them with overdoses of medication, most often the heart drug digoxin. Hospitals suspected him, fired him or let him resign, and none of those suspicions followed him to the next job.
The end came at Somerset Medical Center in Somerville, New Jersey. In 2003 the state’s poison control center flagged a run of overdoses that made no medical sense, and its director, Dr. Steven Marcus, urged the hospital to go to the police. About three months passed before it did, CBS News reported, and in that time Cullen killed five more patients. When two Somerset County detectives, Tim Braun and Danny Baldwin, asked for the computerized records of the hospital’s drug cabinets, they were told the data did not go back far enough. The manufacturer said otherwise. Asked later whether the hospital had lied to them, Braun said, "Yes they did." A fellow critical care nurse who was Cullen’s friend agreed to help the detectives, and he partly admitted his crimes to her, Salon reported.
He was arrested on December 12, 2003. To avoid the death penalty in seven counties he agreed to help identify his victims, and between 2004 and 2006 he pleaded guilty to twenty-nine murders and six attempted murders, among the dead a 72-year-old municipal court judge and a Roman Catholic priest. He told 60 Minutes in 2013 that he had given investigators a number between thirty and forty. In December 2025, News 12 New Jersey reported, he was still serving consecutive life sentences in the state. In May 2005 New Jersey enacted a law requiring hospitals to report to the state within seven days when they dismissed a licensed professional or accepted a resignation during a review, and to answer other employers truthfully when asked about such reports.
Kristen Gilbert worked the evening shift on Ward C of the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in the Leeds section of Northampton, an acute care ward with a small intensive care unit. Between August 1995 and February 1996 veterans on the ward went into sudden cardiac emergencies with unsettling regularity, and nurses who worked beside her began to look into missing ampules of epinephrine, a synthetic form of adrenaline. When the government later gave notice that it would seek the death penalty, it cited more than thirty-seven deaths on her shifts between January 1995 and February 1996. The government’s theory was that she injected the drug to bring on the emergencies and win the attention they brought, above all from a hospital police officer with whom she was having an affair.
The case was federal because the hospital stood on federal land, and the government sought the death penalty in a state that had abolished its own. It was built in part on toxicology, and on January 5, 2001, in the middle of the trial, the government told the court that its laboratory results on epinephrine levels in the dead men’s tissue were wrong and withdrew them; ABC News reported that the toxicologist had been dropped as a witness after a calculation error. The federal appeals court had already identified the government’s principal evidence as the toxicology and two admissions Gilbert had made to the officer. With the science withdrawn, the admissions, the pattern of emergencies and the testimony of her colleagues remained.
On March 14, 2001, the jury convicted her of first-degree murder in the deaths of three veterans, Henry Hudon, Kenneth Cutting and Edward Skwira; of second-degree murder in the death of a fourth, Stanley Jagodowski; and of the attempted murder of two others. It acquitted her on one attempt count. The jury declined to impose death, and she was sentenced to life without parole. In October 2026 the Federal Bureau of Prisons listed her at the Federal Medical Center, Carswell, in Fort Worth, Texas, with a release date of "LIFE."
Over about four weeks in the spring of 1981, patient after patient died at night in the six-bed intensive care unit of Community Hospital of the Valleys in Perris, in Riverside County. A confidential informant told the district attorney’s office that seventeen patients had died there in circumstances "identical in many respects." Health department records showed twenty-four deaths at the hospital between March 8 and April 20; a coroner’s investigator put the usual rate at about three a month. Robert Rubane Diaz, a registered nurse on the night shift, had been on duty for every one of the deaths later charged; according to the California Supreme Court, no other nurse was present on more than five of those nights.
Most of the dead had been embalmed and buried. Their bodies were exhumed, and toxicologists at the University of Utah measured the heart-rhythm drug lidocaine in their tissues. Diaz waived a jury, and Riverside County Superior Court Judge John H. Barnard convicted him of twelve counts of first-degree murder: eleven patients at Perris and one at San Gorgonio Pass Hospital in Banning, where he worked briefly after the Perris unit closed. The dead included Irene Graham, 89, John Rainwater, 95, and Bertha Boyce, 75. The judge imposed a judgment of death, and on August 31, 1992, the California Supreme Court affirmed it, writing that the evidence "pointed unerringly to defendant as the killer."
Diaz never stopped contesting the science. His experts had testified that the tissue levels were consistent with ordinary treatment doses, and in 1993 he went to court in New York for the records of an unpublished study of lidocaine in human tissue from more than 140 autopsies, arguing that many of those people had levels the prosecution had treated as lethal. On November 16, 1993, the New York Court of Appeals ruled that he had a substantial interest in the records, which, it wrote, "may enable Diaz to show that he was convicted and sentenced to death for murders that did not occur." The court was describing his aim, not endorsing it. At that date he remained under sentence of death.
At about 6 a.m. on October 11, 1987, a 73-year-old cardiac patient at Good Samaritan Hospital in West Islip, Long Island, told staff that a bearded man in a white coat had injected something into his intravenous line. He needed resuscitation and recovered. Weeks later his blood and urine tests came back positive for Pavulon, a paralyzing drug no one had prescribed for him. A vial of it was missing from a nursing unit. Richard Angelo, a 25-year-old intensive care nurse and volunteer paramedic, was suspended and then arrested. He told investigators he had wanted to be a hero, reviving patients from crises he had caused.
His confession could not carry a murder charge on its own. "We have to prove there was a crime, and we have to produce a corpse," the chief of the Suffolk County homicide bureau said. Investigators exhumed thirty-three patients who had died in suspicious circumstances during his months at the hospital, and found Pavulon in six, the Deseret News reported. In December 1989 a jury convicted him of two counts of second-degree murder, one of second-degree manslaughter and one of criminally negligent homicide, covering the deaths of four patients, among them Frederick LaGois, 60, and Milton Poultney, 75, and of assault concerning five others. He was sentenced in January 1990 to 61 1/3 years to life, a term state law limits to 50 years to life, and the New York Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction in March 1996.
Lucy Letby was a neonatal nurse at the Countess of Chester Hospital. In August 2023 a jury at Manchester Crown Court convicted her of the murders of seven babies and the attempted murders of six others on the unit between June 2015 and June 2016. The jury found her not guilty on two attempted murder counts and could not agree on six more. A second jury convicted her in July 2024 of the attempted murder of another baby girl. All of the children are known only by letters under a court order.
Sentencing her in her absence on August 21, 2023, Mr Justice Goss imposed a whole life order on each count and found that she had acted with "premeditation, calculation and cunning." A fifteenth whole life order followed the retrial. The Court of Appeal refused her permission to appeal against the first convictions on May 24, 2024, and against the retrial conviction on October 24, 2024. She maintains that she is innocent. In February 2025 a panel of fourteen neonatologists and pediatricians assembled for her defense said it had found no murders, attributing the deaths and collapses to natural causes or poor care; the prosecution’s lead expert rejected its criticisms. The Criminal Cases Review Commission confirmed in February 2026 that a review of her convictions was under way, and in August 2026 the Crown Prosecution Service upheld its decision not to bring further charges over other babies.
The public inquiry chaired by Lady Justice Thirlwall did not reexamine the convictions. Its report, published on September 15, 2026, found "a complete failure to protect babies" at the hospital, described dysfunctional management and a gulf between hospital leaders and clinicians, and concluded that the hospital’s safeguarding policy had not considered the possibility of deliberate harm by a member of staff.
Set the cases side by side and the pattern is plain. The medical evidence, where it existed at all, usually came last, and it fixed the count rather than starting the inquiry. Saldivar’s six convictions are the six exhumed patients in whom Pavulon could be found. Högel’s victims among the cremated could not be counted. In San Antonio the paper record went missing, and Diaz spent years arguing that the science behind his twelve convictions was wrong.
What began the investigations came from elsewhere. At Lainz it was a patient without diabetes whose blood sugar collapsed. In Sonthofen it was missing drugs. On Long Island it was a patient who saw the needle and said so. At Somerset it was a poison control center that would not let the matter drop, and a drug cabinet’s memory that outlasted the hospital’s account of it. In Delmenhorst it was a colleague who saw what Högel was doing. In Ontario it was the nurse herself, walking into a psychiatric hospital in Toronto after nine years in which no one had come close.
The inquiries that followed reached for the same remedies. Beine urged closer scrutiny of unexplained drug orders and stricter checks of death certificates. Gillese called for better tracking of deaths so that clusters could be seen. Lower Saxony, after Högel, required every hospital to review its deaths and unusual cases at regular conferences and to employ ward pharmacists. New Jersey, after Cullen, made hospitals report the nurses they let go. Each reform answered the same question from a different side: how a death that looks natural on a ward can be made to look like what it is.
• March to April 1981: patients die at night in the intensive care unit at Perris, California; Robert Rubane Diaz is later convicted of twelve murders.
• 1981 to March 1982: the "death shift" in the pediatric intensive care unit at Bexar County Hospital, San Antonio; Genene Jones resigns on March 17, 1982.
• September 17, 1982: Chelsea McClellan, fifteen months old, dies after a visit to the Kerrville clinic where Jones works.
• February 1984: Jones is convicted of murder in Georgetown, Texas, and sentenced to 99 years.
• October 11, 1987: a patient at Good Samaritan Hospital, West Islip, reports a man injecting his line; Richard Angelo is arrested that November.
• April 1, 1989: a patient without diabetes survives an insulin injection on a ward of the Lainz hospital, Vienna; Waltraud Wagner and Irene Leidolf confess on April 7.
• December 1989: Angelo is convicted over the deaths of four patients.
• March 1991: Wagner is convicted in Vienna of fifteen murders and sentenced to life.
• August 31, 1992: the California Supreme Court affirms Diaz’s convictions and death judgment.
• March 1998: Efren Saldivar tells Glendale police he caused dozens of deaths, then retracts.
• March 14, 2001: Kristen Gilbert is convicted of murdering four patients at the veterans' hospital in Northampton, Massachusetts.
• March 12, 2002: Saldivar pleads guilty to six murders after Pavulon is found in six of twenty exhumed patients.
• December 12, 2003: Charles Cullen is arrested in New Jersey.
• July 2004: Stephan Letter is arrested in Sonthofen after drugs go missing.
• June 2005: Niels Högel is caught giving a patient an unprescribed drug in Delmenhorst.
• March 2006: Cullen is sentenced in New Jersey and Pennsylvania after pleading guilty to twenty-nine murders.
• November 20, 2006: Letter is convicted in Kempten of twelve murders, fifteen manslaughters and one killing on request.
• August 7, 2008: Wagner and Leidolf are paroled.
• February 26, 2015: Högel is convicted of two murders and two attempted murders.
• September 2016: Elizabeth Wettlaufer confesses at a Toronto psychiatric hospital.
• June 2017: Wettlaufer pleads guilty to eight first-degree murders and is sentenced to life.
• June 6, 2019: Högel is convicted of 85 further murders and acquitted of fifteen.
• July 31, 2019: the Ontario public inquiry reports.
• January 16, 2020: Jones pleads guilty to the murder of Joshua Sawyer and is sentenced to life.
• August 2023: Lucy Letby is convicted at Manchester Crown Court of seven murders and six attempted murders.
• May 24 and October 24, 2024: the Court of Appeal refuses Letby permission to appeal.
• March 2026: Högel’s minimum term is set at 28 years.
• September 15, 2026: the Thirlwall Inquiry publishes its report on the Countess of Chester Hospital.