On November 20, 1803, a special court sitting in Mainz passed judgment on Johannes Bückler, known across the Hunsrück as Schinderhannes, and the robber band he had led through the hill country between the Moselle and the Nahe. The court sentenced him and 19 of his co-defendants to death. The next day, November 21, 1803, all twenty were executed in Mainz.
Bückler was not a man of one crime. The investigating files compiled against his band list 211 offenses between 1796 and the spring of 1802: 96 thefts, 71 robberies, 35 extortions and nine killings. The current German national biography, published in 2005, records that he took part in two of those killings, one in 1797 and one in 1798, and the German Historical Institute counts murder among the crimes he committed in the Hunsrück.
Johannes Bückler was born in Miehlen, near Nastätten in the Taunus, at the end of the 1770s or the start of the 1780s; his exact year of birth is uncertain. By the mid-1790s he was living in the Hunsrück, the upland region west of the Rhine, and it was there that his criminal career began around 1796.
His first offenses were small. He stole a gold coin from an innkeeper at Veitsroth, took hides from the man he worked for at Bärenbach and stole sheep that he sold in Kirn. In December 1796, after cattle thefts around Kirn, the first warrant for his arrest was issued. The mayor of Kirn had him publicly flogged in 1797. Arrested a second time in Kirn, he escaped on the first night.
From that point Bückler moved into the company of seasoned thieves. At Hennweiler he joined a group of men who lived mainly by horse theft. He took pigs near Boppard and sheep from Abtweiler. In 1797 and 1798 he ran with what was known as the Hunsrück band and took part in robberies at Birkenfeld and Spall.
The band turned violent early. Its files record one killing in 1797 and two in 1798, and the 2005 national biography places Bückler in two of them.
The first victim was Niklas Rauschenberger, killed in 1797. When the Mainz court heard the band's cases in 1803, a co-defendant was sentenced to six years for his part in that murder, so the killing was among the matters the special court tried.
The second victim was Simon Seligmann of Seibersbach, killed in the Soonwald district in 1798. His was one of two deaths the band caused that year.
The French authorities who now governed the left bank of the Rhine caught Bückler several times in these years, and each time he slipped away. In 1798 he was seized by French chasseurs, taken to Oberstein and questioned, and there he admitted to many horse thefts. He was moved to Saarbrücken, arriving on July 16, 1798, and escaped the next day.
In 1799 he was arrested twice more, at Schneppenbach and at Kirn, and escaped both times. On the night of February 25 to 26, 1799, French gendarmes took him and locked him in the tower at Simmern. He broke out of that as well, and from then on the band's character changed.
Until 1799 the band lived mainly on simple theft. After Bückler's escape from Simmern, robbery by large groups of men and the extortion of money under threat became its main business. Sixty-eight of the band's 71 recorded robberies fall after that escape, and 1800 was its busiest year, with 57 recorded offenses, among them 32 robberies, 14 extortions and four killings.
The band worked at first in the cantons of Grumbach and Herrstein, then spread into the districts of Birkenfeld and Simmern. Farmers and millers were among its most frequent victims. Jewish merchants and whole communities at Hundsbach, Hottenbach, Weierbach, Merxheim and Meddersheim were forced to pay the band.
Few bystanders came to the victims' aid. Witnesses later told investigators they were afraid of being hurt or killed themselves, that the French had disarmed the population and that many feared revenge if they helped the authorities. Some local officials were close to the robbers they were meant to pursue, and in March 1800 the government commissioner at Simmern was replaced for exactly that reason.
In September 1800 Bückler held an open gathering of the band at Griebelschied, tolerated by corrupt officials. Around Easter 1800 a young woman from Weierbach, near Kirn, joined him as his companion; she later stood trial with him. Through the winter of 1800 and 1801 he spent eleven weeks at a mill near Schloßborn, on the right bank of the Rhine, and in 1801 he passed himself off as a peddler under the name Jakob Ofenloch.
The turning point came in January 1801, when the states along the Rhine met at Wetzlar and agreed to act together against the robber bands. The convention signed there on January 28, 1801, tightened passport controls, put more mounted patrols on the roads and allowed justice officials to pursue bands across borders. Through 1801 these measures began to work. The patrols of the national gendarmerie made the old trick of slipping into a neighboring territory much harder, and one band member after another was arrested.
The French authorities declared Bückler an enemy of the state. By the end of 1801 the pressure had driven the band onto the right bank of the Rhine, which it believed was safer, and by then many of its members were already in custody. A raid at Offenbach on the Nahe in April 1802 was a modest affair compared with the band's earlier work. In the same month the French authorities in the district put a large reward on Bückler's head.
In the end it was not the French who took him. At the end of May 1802 Bückler was detained near Wolfenhausen, close to Runkel, on the right bank of the Rhine, together with other members of the band. He tried to escape detection by enlisting in the imperial army, but he was recognized and taken to Frankfurt. On June 12, 1802, he admitted to a Frankfurt criminal official that he was the man the French had been hunting. On June 16, 1802, he was handed over to the French authorities in Mainz.
The capture set the whole prosecution in motion. The special court in Mainz, which had been coordinating the inquiry into the band since April 1802, had its investigating judge begin questioning him on June 19, 1802.
Bückler talked. Over the following months he answered 565 questions, and his confessions led to the arrest of many other offenders. He had been promised that his frankness would earn him the clemency of the First Consul. The investigating judge tested his statements again and again against the accounts of robbers already in custody, and what Bückler said opened 47 further proceedings. The preliminary investigation closed on March 18, 1803.
The public trial opened in Mainz on October 24, 1803, sixteen months after Bückler's arrest, before the special court for the suppression of gangs and banditry in the Donnersberg department, sitting with the criminal court at Mainz. The indictment charged him with 53 offenses. He stood trial with 67 co-accused, and the hearing lasted almost four weeks.
On November 20, 1803, the special court gave its final judgment against Johann Bückler and his accomplices. It sentenced Bückler and 19 others to death. Twenty more received sentences ranging from five months in a house of correction to 24 years in chains, two were banished, one was sent to another special court and twenty were acquitted.
Bückler was executed in Mainz on November 21, 1803, the day after the verdict, together with the 19 other men condemned with him. With the executions the robber bands of the Hunsrück were largely broken up.
Bückler's own hand in the two killings is the most contested point in his history. The 2005 national biography records that he took part in both, and the German Historical Institute counts murder among his crimes; the 1890 national biography, written from the parish and court records then known, held instead that he never took an active part in a murder himself, witnessing the 1798 killing, which another band member committed, and acting as an accomplice in the 1797 one.
From 1805 on, books and later writers turned him into a Robin Hood of the Hunsrück, though none of their stories of kindness to the poor can be found in the court files.
Bückler himself blamed his extreme youth and a run of unlucky circumstances for the start of his criminal life.
December 1796: First warrant for Bückler's arrest issued after cattle thefts around Kirn.
1797: Publicly flogged at Kirn; escapes from a second arrest there.
1797: The first of the two killings in which the 2005 national biography records his part.
July 16 to 17, 1798: Brought to Saarbrücken; escapes the next day.
1798: The second killing, in the Soonwald district.
February 25 to 26, 1799: Taken by French gendarmes and held in the tower at Simmern; later escapes.
September 1800: Gathering of the band at Griebelschied.
January 28, 1801: Convention of Wetzlar against the robber bands.
April 1802: Raid at Offenbach on the Nahe; a reward is offered for Bückler.
Late May 1802: Detained near Wolfenhausen and taken to Frankfurt.
June 12, 1802: Admits his identity in Frankfurt.
June 16, 1802: Handed over to the French authorities in Mainz.
June 19, 1802: Interrogation begins.
March 18, 1803: Preliminary investigation closes.
October 24, 1803: Public trial opens before the special court in Mainz.
November 20, 1803: Sentenced to death with 19 co-defendants.
November 21, 1803: Executed in Mainz.