On the afternoon of July 24, 1998, two officers of the United States Capitol Police died on duty in Washington, D.C. Officer Jacob J. Chestnut Jr. had served on the force for 18 years and was months from retirement. Detective John M. Gibson had also given the department 18 years and was assigned to the security detail of the House majority whip. A third officer and a young woman visiting the city were wounded. The man police arrested that day, and whom a federal grand jury later indicted for both murders, was Russell Eugene Weston Jr., a 41-year-old man from southern Illinois who had spent much of his adult life in the Montana mountains.
Weston has never stood trial. In April 1999 a federal judge found him incompetent to stand trial, and the case became a long contest in the federal courts over whether the government may medicate a defendant against his will to make him fit for trial. The federal appeals court in Washington ruled twice on his treatment, and from January 2002 he was medicated under court order. The treatment never made him fit. In November 2004 the prosecution was put on hold indefinitely, and in August 2005 a federal judge in North Carolina ordered him civilly committed. The indictment has never been dismissed. As of April 2018 he was still held in a federal psychiatric facility in North Carolina, a man legally accused of two murders and legally unable to answer for them.
Weston came from Valmeyer, a small town in southern Illinois, and had lived there for a time before the great flood of 1993 swept through the town. For at least 15 years before 1998 he lived on and off around Helena, Montana, and in the mid-1990s he settled in a cabin in an old mining settlement in a mountain ravine about 18 miles southwest of the city. He came and went, mostly in summer, and had few friends. He had not worked since the mid-1980s and lived on federal disability benefits.
He had a 20-year history of mental illness and had been diagnosed years earlier with paranoid schizophrenia, with delusions that the federal government was spying on him. In the spring of 1996, after he was alleged to have written a threatening letter aimed at federal officials, Secret Service agents visited him, and he was entered in the agency's list of people who might pose a low-level threat to the president. That fall, after he threatened a resident of Helena, a Montana judge found him a danger to himself or to that person and committed him to the state mental hospital for 53 days. He was released when a medical team concluded that he was no longer dangerous. By 1998 he had stopped taking the medication prescribed to him in Montana.
The officer had served in the Air Force before he joined the Capitol Police, as a veteran of the Vietnam War and later in Taiwan. He lived in Maryland. Co-workers knew him for the fresh vegetables he grew and shared with them, and for the time he gave to mentoring young officers.
The detective was a Massachusetts native who had come to Washington for a police job. He went to St. Mary's high school in Cambridge and never lost his loyalty to the Red Sox and the Bruins. By 1998 he guarded the House majority whip as part of the leader's security detail. He lived in Virginia.
Until that summer, only one other Capitol Police officer had ever died on duty.
That Friday afternoon Congress was in session and the city was full of summer visitors. According to the police account and the indictment that followed, Weston killed both officers at the Capitol and wounded the third officer and the visitor before other officers took him into custody. Both officers died at a hospital that evening. Weston was himself wounded and was held under guard at D.C. General Hospital. Within hours it emerged that the Secret Service had listed him as a low-level threat after the contacts of 1996.
On October 9, 1998, a federal grand jury in Washington returned a six-count indictment: two counts of murder of a federal law enforcement officer, one count of attempted murder of a federal law enforcement officer, and three further counts. The murder counts carried a possible death sentence. Prosecutors offered no motive.
A court-appointed federal psychiatrist examined him that fall, and on April 22, 1999, the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found Weston incompetent to stand trial and committed him to the custody of the Attorney General for treatment at a federal correctional complex in North Carolina. The order required the court's approval before any involuntary medication. Weston refused treatment, and his defense team, led by the federal public defender's office in Washington, opposed every effort to medicate him without his consent. In September 1999 the district court ruled that he could be medicated against his will on medical and safety grounds.
On March 24, 2000, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit reversed. It held that the record did not support the finding that medication was essential for safety, because the testimony showed he posed no significant danger in his current confinement. It held as well that the district court should have weighed the government's real purpose, making him fit for trial, and that his Sixth Amendment fair-trial claim was ready to be decided before any drugs were given. It sent the case back.
On remand the district court held new hearings and again authorized medication, finding that it was essential to control his dangerousness, that the government had an essential interest in bringing him to trial, and that medication would not impair his right to a fair trial. On July 27, 2001, a second panel of the D.C. Circuit affirmed. It held that the government may medicate a pretrial detainee against his will to make him competent to stand trial if it shows that restoring competence is necessary to accomplish an essential state policy, and it rested its decision on the government's interest in prosecuting the murders of federal officers rather than on dangerousness. Civil commitment, the court held, was no substitute, because it addressed only confinement and not guilt or the other purposes of a criminal trial. The court found it likely that medication would improve his ability to work with his lawyers and present a defense, and it held that the risks to his memory and demeanor before a jury were small and could be met with protective measures such as jury instructions. In December 2001 the Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
Court-ordered medication began in January 2002 and continued for nearly three years. It did not restore his competence. In November 2004 the court heard that he was still not competent and that his competence was no longer likely to be restored in the foreseeable future. The government declined to dismiss the indictment and sought civil commitment instead. On November 19, 2004, the district court put the criminal prosecution on hold indefinitely and began commitment proceedings, which moved to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina, where he was confined, while the Washington court kept the criminal charges. The facility was to tell the court if he ever regained competence.
On August 15, 2005, a senior federal judge in Raleigh, North Carolina, found by clear and convincing evidence that Weston would be a danger to others if released, and committed him to the custody of the Attorney General for care and treatment. His status was to be reviewed every six to 12 months, and if a court ever found that he had regained competence, the government could resume the prosecution in Washington.
In March 2008 Weston himself asked the North Carolina court to discharge him from that custody. After a hearing on May 6, 2008, the judge denied the request, ruling that he had not met his burden of proof, and returned him to the federal medical center where he was held.
As of April 2018 he remained in custody at the federal psychiatric medical center in North Carolina, still incompetent to stand trial and still subject to the indictment of October 1998.
Every allegation in the case remains untested. Weston was indicted on two counts of murder of a federal law enforcement officer, one count of attempted murder of a federal law enforcement officer and three further counts, but no court has heard the evidence, no jury has been asked to decide the charges, and he has never entered a plea. No court has ever ruled on his mental state on July 24, 1998: the findings in his case address only his fitness for trial and his danger to others. Prosecutors never offered a motive. Whether the government would have sought a death sentence was never decided in open court; the penalty was described only as possible.
1993: The Mississippi River flood strikes Valmeyer, Illinois; Weston later moves away.
Spring 1996: Secret Service agents visit Weston in Montana and list him as a possible low-level threat to the president.
Fall 1996: He is committed to the state mental hospital in Montana for 53 days after threatening a Helena resident, then released.
July 24, 1998: Two U.S. Capitol Police officers die on duty in Washington, D.C.; police take Weston into custody.
October 9, 1998: A federal grand jury returns a six-count indictment.
April 22, 1999: Found incompetent to stand trial and committed for treatment.
September 1999: The district court approves involuntary medication on medical and safety grounds.
March 24, 2000: The D.C. Circuit reverses and sends the case back.
July 27, 2001: The D.C. Circuit affirms a new order allowing medication to restore competence.
December 2001: The Supreme Court declines to hear the case.
January 2002: Court-ordered medication begins.
November 19, 2004: Prosecution put on hold indefinitely; civil commitment proceedings begin in North Carolina.
August 15, 2005: A federal judge in Raleigh orders him civilly committed to the custody of the Attorney General.
May 6, 2008: His request for discharge is denied.
April 2018: Still held at a federal psychiatric medical center in North Carolina, untried.