Roy Whiting was convicted at Lewes Crown Court on December 12, 2001 of the kidnap and murder of Sarah Payne, a child from West Sussex who died in July 2000. The jury was unanimous. The trial judge passed a sentence of life imprisonment and said he would recommend that Whiting never be released. Whiting had denied the charges.
The sentence has had a long legal history. A Home Secretary set a minimum term of 50 years in 2002, and in June 2010 a High Court judge reduced it to 40 years. The offense also became linked in public debate to a national scheme that lets parents ask the police about people who have contact with their children.
In 1995 he was convicted at Lewes Crown Court of kidnapping and indecent assault, and he was sentenced to four years in prison. That conviction was withheld from the jury at the 2001 trial. It was before the High Court in 2010 as an aggravating factor when the judge reviewed the minimum term.
The victim was a child from West Sussex who died in July 2000. She is the only victim in this case. Whiting lived in West Sussex and worked as a mechanic. He was charged, and the trial was held at Lewes Crown Court in 2001.
The trial lasted 16 days. The jury of nine men and three women retired to consider its verdict and reached a unanimous decision after about nine hours of deliberation. On Wednesday, December 12, 2001, it found Whiting guilty of the abduction and murder of the child. The 1995 conviction had been kept from the jurors, and they decided the case on the evidence put to them.
The trial judge sentenced Whiting to life imprisonment. He told the defendant that he was an evil man, and he said that he would recommend that Whiting never be released from prison. Whiting was 42 at the time.
A life sentence in England and Wales is followed by a minimum term, known as the tariff, which is the least time the prisoner must serve before the Parole Board may consider release. In Whiting's case the Home Secretary set the figure, and the views of the trial judge and the Lord Chief Justice were recommendations to him.
The trial judge's recommendation was that Whiting serve the rest of his natural life. The Lord Chief Justice of the time recommended a tariff of 28 years. In November 2002 the Home Secretary set the minimum term at 50 years, overruling the Lord Chief Justice's figure. The decision meant that Whiting would very probably die in prison. A Home Office spokeswoman said the 50-year tariff was consistent with recent decisions in comparable cases.
Whiting's minimum term came before the High Court, and his lawyers asked for a reduction. They argued that 50 years was disproportionate and proposed 28 years. On Wednesday, June 9, 2010, a High Court judge sitting in London announced the result. He cut the minimum term from 50 years to 40, saying that 40 years was the appropriate term.
The judge explained his reasoning in a judgment. Under the sentencing regime in the Criminal Justice Act 2003 the starting point for a case of this kind would have been a whole life order. He described the offense as exceptionally serious. He identified the planning of the kidnap and Whiting's previous conviction for kidnap and assault as aggravating factors, and he took into account a statement from the victim's mother about the effect on the family. He concluded that 40 years met the requirements of retribution and deterrence. He added that Whiting would stay in prison until the Parole Board was satisfied that he no longer presented a risk to the public, and that if he were ever released he would be on licence for life.
Whiting did not attend the hearing. Lawyers for the Crown had told the court that under the current, tougher guidelines a whole life order was the likely outcome for such a case.
The case is linked to the Child Sex Offender Disclosure Scheme, under which a parent or carer can ask the police about a person who has contact with their children; the Home Office said in March 2011 that all police forces in England and Wales would run it by April 2011.
In 2025 Whiting was serving the life sentence in a maximum security prison in England, with the 40-year minimum term fixed by the High Court in 2010.
Whiting maintained his innocence at trial. The jury rejected that, and the conviction has not been overturned.
1995: Convicted at Lewes Crown Court of kidnapping and indecent assault; sentenced to four years.
July 2000: The offense for which he was later convicted takes place in West Sussex.
December 12, 2001: Unanimous jury verdict at Lewes Crown Court; guilty of kidnap and murder; sentenced to life imprisonment.
2002: The Home Secretary sets a 50-year minimum term.
June 9, 2010: The High Court reduces the minimum term to 40 years.
April 2011: All police forces in England and Wales due to run the disclosure scheme.