Rosario Alfonso R. was a fisherman from Las Arenitas, a fishing camp near the town of Eldorado on the Sinaloa coast. In September 2015 he was the only survivor of a fishing trip that went wrong in the Gulf of California, rescued by the Mexican Navy after 13 days on the wreck of a small boat. Five years later, in January 2020, he was arrested in Culiacán, the state capital, and the Fiscalía General del Estado de Sinaloa, the state prosecutor's office, went on to charge him with the femicides of four young women killed between December 2018 and January 2020.
The Sinaloa weekly Ríodoce described him in 2020 as the first person in the state to be prosecuted under the femicide statute for more than one killing. In October 2022, after an oral trial, a judge found him guilty of three of the femicides and acquitted him of the fourth. The press in Sinaloa calls him Rosario Alfonso R., the form used by Mexican prosecutors and courts for an accused person, and by two nicknames, "El Chayo" and "El Náufrago," the castaway.
Little is known of his life before 2015. Las Arenitas is a fishing camp in the Eldorado area, south of Culiacán, and he worked there as a fisherman. He was 27 at the time of the 2015 shipwreck, according to the Baja California Sur outlet BCS Noticias and to Ríodoce, which reported his age as 31 in September 2020 and again in September 2021. Ríodoce, drawing on a profile issued by the state authorities, described him as about 1.75 meters tall, stocky and curly haired. His family, schooling and any earlier record were not reported.
On September 13, 2015, he left Las Arenitas in a panga, a small open fishing boat, with two other men. BCS Noticias reported that the trip was for shrimp fishing and that the boat was bound for Puerto San Carlos, in the municipality of Comondú, Baja California Sur, on the other side of the Gulf of California. One of the men was his uncle, a 50-year-old fisherman also from Las Arenitas. The other was a man whose name he said he did not know.
His account of what happened, as BCS Noticias and Ríodoce reported it, was brief. About three hours after setting out, the stern of the panga broke, which he blamed on the large engine fitted to it, and the boat overturned. The three men stayed on the upturned hull. After several days his uncle died. Of the third man he said that he fell asleep one day and when he woke the man was gone. Infobae, retelling Ríodoce's reporting in 2021, quoted him as saying "un día me quedé dormido y cuando desperté, ya no estaba," one day I fell asleep and when I woke up, he was no longer there.
On the afternoon of Saturday, September 26, 2015, personnel of the Armada de México on patrol found him clinging to wreckage from the boat. BCS Noticias placed the rescue near Isla San José, north of Isla Espíritu Santo, off La Paz; Ríodoce placed it near Isla Espíritu Santo. He was taken to the Salvatierra hospital in La Paz with severe dehydration and first-degree burns on both legs. Doctors told BCS Noticias that his life was not in danger and that his recovery would take about 15 days. The same report said that a body found floating at sea the day before the rescue, which the Navy took to Loreto, might be one of his companions; that had not been confirmed. Ríodoce later wrote that both men who had sailed with him died at sea.
Cecilia Guadalupe B. was from Culiacán and lived in the El Mirador neighborhood, according to Ríodoce. The 2022 sentencing reports gave her age as 21; Ríodoce's earlier reports gave it as 22. She disappeared on Saturday, December 15, 2018. Four days later, on Wednesday, December 19, she was found dead in the sindicatura of Costa Rica, a rural district of Culiacán municipality south of the city. Ríodoce reported that she had been stabbed. Her case became criminal file 481/2020.
Her death was, in the account the prosecutor's office later gave, the first of four. At the time no one was charged, and the case stayed open for more than a year.
Melissa Angélica E. was 24, according to Ríodoce. She came from La Cruz, in the municipality of Elota, south of Culiacán along the coast, and was living in Culiacán. She was found dead in the city in the early hours of February 18, 2019. Her case, file 505/2020, was the last of the four to be charged against Rosario Alfonso R., in September 2020, and it is the one on which he was acquitted in October 2022. The court found that the prosecutor's office had not proved his responsibility for her death, and he stands acquitted of it. No one else has been reported charged in her death.
Lucía Mariana M. was 17, a third-year student at a preparatory school of the Universidad Autónoma de Sinaloa (UAS), the state university. On December 11, 2019, the day before the feast of the Virgin of Guadalupe, she left home and sent her mother a message saying she was going to the celebrations. She did not come back. On December 16 her sisters held a press conference to ask the public for help in finding her. Minutes later, Ríodoce reported, she was found dead, also in the Costa Rica district. She had been strangled. Her case became file 693/2020.
Olga Ana Karen was 19, from Hermosillo, the capital of the neighboring state of Sonora. Luz Noticias, reporting her identification in January 2020, wrote that she was about to turn 20. The 2022 sentencing reports described her as living in Culiacán; Ríodoce's 2020 account said she had come to Culiacán with a friend for a party. She was found dead in Culiacán on Sunday, January 26, 2020. The 911 emergency line was called, and investigators and forensic experts of the Fiscalía took up the case and collected evidence. The case was classified as a femicide, which Luz Noticias counted as the fifth in Sinaloa and the third in Culiacán that year. She had been strangled. Her case became file 34/2020.
Her case was the one that broke the investigation open. Ríodoce reported that the investigators identified Rosario Alfonso R. through their inquiries and through witness statements, and that he was arrested a few days after her death. On January 31, 2020, Luz Noticias reported that the Fiscalía had announced his arrest and that a judge had bound him over for trial (vinculación a proceso) on a charge of femicide in her death.
At that announcement the state attorney general, Juan José Ríos Estavillo, said the prosecutor's office had solid information linking the same man to other femicides committed in Culiacán in December 2018, February 2019 and December 2019. He was held in pretrial detention from his first hearing, and by September 2021 Ríodoce reported that he had been held at the Aguaruto penitentiary since then.
The link between the four cases rested on DNA. Ríodoce reported, from the prosecutor's account, that genetic tests in Olga Ana Karen's case had found a male genetic profile, and that the same profile had been found in the cases of the other women. After the arrest a cheek swab was taken from him, and the prosecutor's office said his DNA matched. Ríodoce wrote in 2021 that it was through the fourth femicide that investigators had been able to tie him to that death and to the three before it.
Other evidence the Fiscalía put before the judges, according to Ríodoce, included witness testimony, expert reports and reports on the geolocation of mobile phones. Luz Noticias, reporting the September 2020 hearings, listed testimony, inspections, interviews, forensic medical examinations and field criminalistics. The prosecutor's office said that the work of its agents, police and experts had brought together the evidence of his presumed responsibility.
For more than seven months the only charge against him was the femicide of Olga Ana Karen. In September 2020 the prosecutor's office added the other three. Luz Noticias reported that at a hearing on September 3, 2020, the Ministerio Público charged him with the femicides of Cecilia Guadalupe B. and Lucía Mariana M.; the judge bound him over for trial on both counts, ordered mandatory pretrial detention (prisión preventiva oficiosa) and allowed four months for further investigation. On Monday, September 7, 2020, a control judge bound him over on a fourth charge, the femicide of Melissa Angélica E. Ríodoce's account of the same weeks differs on the order of the hearings, putting the charges over Cecilia Guadalupe and Melissa Angélica first and the hearing on Lucía Mariana's case later.
Ríodoce reported that the hearings were held at the criminal justice center of the Centro region, that he was represented by a court-appointed public defender, and that no relative or friend of his came to them. He used his right not to testify. In court he spoke only to identify himself and to answer the judge's questions about whether he understood and agreed with what was being asked.
The four cases began separately. The Fiscalía later joined them so that a single hearing could deal with all four femicides. The work stopped for a time when the Sinaloa judiciary suspended its activities during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In September 2021 Ríodoce reported that Rosario Alfonso R. had agreed to accept responsibility for all four femicides through a procedimiento abreviado, an abbreviated procedure under Mexico's adversarial criminal system in which a defendant accepts responsibility in exchange for a reduced sentence. Attorney General Ríos Estavillo had authorized it. Lawyers who spoke to the weekly said that if the case went to an oral trial on four femicide counts, the minimum sentence could reach 88 years, and that the abbreviated procedure would bring a lower one. At the next hearing the control judge was to check that the requirements of the penal code were met, ask the defendant whether he accepted responsibility, and approve the agreed sentence and a plan of reparations for the victims' families.
That hearing kept being called off. The first cancellation came because the attorney general's authorization was still pending. Two more followed because one of the victims' mothers had not been notified: court staff were unable to locate her before a hearing set for August 8, or to deliver a later notice to her. The control judge said the hearing could not go ahead unless the victim's family had been informed.
Ríodoce reported that two of the four women's mothers were from Culiacán, one from Elota and one from Hermosillo. The mothers who had been reached attended the hearings and agreed to the abbreviated procedure. One of them, who asked that her name not be published, told Ríodoce in 2021: "Es muy cansado esto, estamos viniendo y las cancelan, ya lo que queremos es que esto termine." This is very tiring, we keep coming and they cancel them; all we want now is for it to be over.
Ríodoce began its 2021 report with the prediction that he would go down in Sinaloa's history as the first person sentenced for multiple femicides. The families' views of the case, beyond the mother's words, were not reported.
The abbreviated procedure did not take place. The case went instead to an oral trial before the trial judge (juez de enjuiciamiento) of the Sede de Justicia Penal, Acusatoria y Oral, zona Centro, the adversarial criminal court seat of the state's central region.
On October 21, 2022, the judge ruled. Weighing the evidence presented, the court found Rosario Alfonso R. guilty of the femicides of Cecilia Guadalupe B. (file 481/2020), Lucía Mariana M. (file 693/2020) and Olga Ana Karen (file 34/2020), committed in 2018, 2019 and 2020. In the fourth case, file 505/2020, the femicide of Melissa Angélica E., the judge acquitted him. Ríodoce reported that the Fiscalía had not been able to prove his responsibility in that case. No further reasons for either the convictions or the acquittal were made public.
For the femicide of Olga Ana Karen the judge sentenced him to 36 years in prison and ordered reparations of 439,612 pesos. For the femicide of Cecilia Guadalupe B. he received 18 years and reparations of 407,836 pesos, and for the femicide of Lucía Mariana M., 18 years and reparations of 427,519.40 pesos. The Fiscalía and the press, including Ríodoce, Quadratín Sinaloa and Luz Noticias, reported the overall sentence as 70 years in prison, with total reparations of 1,274,967 pesos. How the 70-year figure relates to the three separate terms has never been explained.
Ríodoce reported at the time of the verdict that he had once attempted suicide in the Aguaruto prison.
The acquittal. Rosario Alfonso R. was charged with four femicides and convicted of three. In law he is not responsible for the death of Melissa Angélica E. The prosecutor's office had said in 2020 that DNA matching his was found on all four women, but the court found the case on her death unproven. How the judge weighed that evidence has not been made public; the only reason given for the acquittal was the prosecution's failure to prove responsibility.
The plea that did not happen. In September 2021 Ríodoce reported that he had agreed to accept responsibility for all four femicides through an abbreviated procedure. He was instead tried, and no confession or admission is attributed to him.
The total sentence. The 2022 reports gave the per-case terms as 36, 18 and 18 years and the overall sentence as about 70 years.
The rescue. The 2015 rescue was placed near Isla San José, north of Isla Espíritu Santo and about 85 kilometers north of La Paz, by BCS Noticias and Luz Noticias, and near Isla Espíritu Santo by Ríodoce. Infobae's 2021 retelling gave the date he set out as September 26, 2015, the day of the rescue in the other reports.
Dates and ages. Ríodoce's 2021 report dated Lucía Mariana's disappearance to December 2018; its 2020 report and Luz Noticias dated it to December 11, 2019, and the sentencing reports say she was found dead on December 16, 2019. Cecilia Guadalupe's age was given as 22 in 2020 and 2021 and as 21 in 2022. Luz Noticias reported in September 2020 that Olga Ana Karen was killed on January 25, 2020; the sentencing reports give January 26 as the date she was found. Luz Noticias's verdict report said he had been arrested in 2021, which conflicts with its own 2020 reporting and with Ríodoce, which put the arrest in January 2020.
September 13, 2015: Rosario Alfonso R., 27, sets out from Las Arenitas, Eldorado, Sinaloa, in a panga with his uncle and another fisherman, bound for Puerto San Carlos, Comondú, Baja California Sur.
September 26, 2015: Mexican Navy personnel rescue him near Isla San José, off La Paz, after 13 days adrift; his two companions died at sea.
December 15, 2018: Cecilia Guadalupe B. disappears in Culiacán.
December 19, 2018: Cecilia Guadalupe B. is found dead in the Costa Rica district of Culiacán municipality.
February 18, 2019: Melissa Angélica E., 24, is found dead in Culiacán (the count on which he was later acquitted).
December 11, 2019: Lucía Mariana M., 17, disappears in Culiacán.
December 16, 2019: Lucía Mariana M. is found dead in the Costa Rica district.
January 26, 2020: Olga Ana Karen, 19, of Hermosillo, is found dead in Culiacán.
January 2020: Rosario Alfonso R. is arrested, bound over for trial on a femicide charge in Olga Ana Karen's death and held in pretrial detention; a cheek swab is matched to the DNA profile from the cases.
January 31, 2020: the Fiscalía announces the arrest; Attorney General Juan José Ríos Estavillo links him to femicides of December 2018, February 2019 and December 2019.
September 3, 2020: bound over for trial on femicide charges over Cecilia Guadalupe B. and Lucía Mariana M.
September 7, 2020: bound over on a fourth femicide charge, over Melissa Angélica E.
2020 to 2021: the four cases are joined; hearings stop while the Sinaloa judiciary suspends activity during the pandemic.
September 2021: Ríodoce reports he has agreed to an abbreviated procedure on all four counts; the hearing is canceled several times.
October 21, 2022: after an oral trial, the trial judge of the zona Centro criminal court convicts him of the femicides of Cecilia Guadalupe B., Lucía Mariana M. and Olga Ana Karen, and acquits him of the femicide of Melissa Angélica E.; sentences of 36, 18 and 18 years are reported as 70 years in all, with reparations of 1,274,967 pesos.