Rosalio Reta

Victims
1 man killed in Laredo, Texas, January 8, 2006. Convicted by a jury in 2008 of murder as a party to the offense; 40 years; affirmed March 3, 2010
Years active
January 8, 2006
Location
Laredo, Texas; Nuevo Laredo, Tamaulipas, Mexico
Method
Murder, as a party to the offense under Texas law
Status
40 years (2007 plea, reversed 2008); 40 years again after a jury verdict (August 29, 2008); affirmed March 3, 2010; in Texas state custody (court letters, November 2016).

On January 8, 2006, Noe Flores died in Laredo, Texas, the border city that faces Nuevo Laredo across the Rio Grande. The State of Texas came to treat his death as a contract killing carried out by a small cell of young men who worked for the Gulf Cartel, and it charged three of them with murder. The youngest was Rosalio Reta, a Houston-born boy raised in Laredo who went by the name Bart. He was 16 at the time of the offense.

Reta's case ran through two trials and two appeals before it was settled. He pleaded guilty in the middle of his first trial in July 2007 and was sentenced to 40 years, but the Fourth Court of Appeals in San Antonio reversed that conviction in June 2008 because a written statement he had signed as a juvenile should have been suppressed. The State tried him again. In August 2008 a Webb County jury convicted him of murder as a party to the offense, and he was sentenced to 40 years once more. The same appellate court affirmed that judgment on March 3, 2010.

Houston and Laredo

Reta was born in Houston and grew up in Laredo, across the river from Nuevo Laredo in the Mexican state of Tamaulipas. He was still a juvenile in the eyes of Texas law when the case against him began.

By the time he came to court, the Webb County Jail had classified both Reta and Gabriel Cardona, an older co-defendant, as registered members of the Zetas, which the court of appeals described as a known gang organization in Laredo. Cardona pleaded guilty to the murder and was sentenced to 80 years in prison.

The cell the State described

At trial, a cooperating witness told the jury that he had gone to work as a member of a group of assassins operated by the Gulf Cartel. The group answered to a local manager in Laredo, who in turn took his orders from a cartel commander in Nuevo Laredo.

The same witness testified that Reta belonged to a sicario, or hitman, cell stationed in Laredo. He said he had seen Reta come back to the group on the night of the killing, that Reta talked about his part in it, and that he knew Reta had been paid for his involvement. He described himself as a member of two associated groups of assassins, and he placed Reta in one of them. Jail records, a recorded conversation and the work of a Laredo police detective supplied the rest of the State's picture of who was in the cell and how its members were connected.

The men above the cell stayed out of reach. By the summer of 2007 arrest warrants had been issued for a man said to have acted as the middleman and for the commander in Nuevo Laredo, and both were believed to be in Mexico. Neither stood trial in this case.

The State's case named three participants. The first was Cardona. The second was a man also indicted for the murder, who posted bail and left for Mexico before he could be tried. The third was Reta. The State never claimed that Reta personally caused the death. Its theory, and the one the jury in his second trial was asked to decide, was that one of the other two men caused it and that Reta acted with the intent to promote or assist the commission of the offense.

The investigation

The Laredo Police Department led the inquiry. A detective assigned to the case followed the evidence in the days after the killing from one contact to the next, and that work led him to a young man known as Bart.

Interviews with two men who had worked inside the same network filled in the structure over him. Their statements connected Reta, Cardona and the third man to the local manager and to the commander across the river. In April 2006 investigators lawfully recorded a conversation between Reta and Cardona. In it, the court later noted, the two talked about drugs and cash that Reta was waiting to be paid. The State would later rely on that recording to show why Reta took part.

By the time the case reached a jury, the detective could lay the whole inquiry out step by step. He testified at length about how each lead had produced the next, and a demonstrative chart of the links between the men stood in front of the jurors for as long as he was on the stand.

In July 2006 Reta, then detained in Mexico, was returned to Laredo to face the charge.

Because Reta was a juvenile when he was taken into custody, his case began in the juvenile system. While he was held, he gave a written statement that implicated him in the killing. His case was certified for trial as an adult, and he was indicted for murder in the 49th Judicial District Court of Webb County. His lawyer moved to suppress the written statement. The trial court denied the motion.

The first trial

The trial opened on Monday, July 16, 2007, in the Webb County Courthouse in Laredo. A Laredo police detective testified about the evidence that tied Reta to the other two members of the cell, and a witness told the jury that the three had been paid for the killing.

Over defense objections, the court admitted the statement Reta had signed in custody, in which he admitted taking part in the killing. Three days into the trial, on Thursday, July 19, 2007, Reta pleaded guilty to murder. His lawyer said the decision to plead followed directly from the court's ruling on the statement, and the plea was entered on terms that kept Reta's right to appeal. The presiding judge sentenced him at once to 40 years in prison. The maximum available was 99 years.

The first appeal

Reta appealed on August 7, 2007, and the Fourth Court of Appeals in San Antonio took the case. Neither side asked to argue it, and the court decided it on the briefs, taking it under submission on May 7, 2008.

The whole appeal came down to one document. Texas law treats a child's confession differently from an adult's. Under section 51.095 of the Family Code, the warnings that protect a juvenile in custody are given by a magistrate, not by the police. The magistrate meets the child alone, explains the charges and gives the warnings before any statement is made. If the child agrees to talk, the magistrate leaves and the officers take the statement. Then the magistrate reviews it with the child, again alone, and must be satisfied that the child understands what the statement says, that it is voluntary and that the waiver of rights was knowing and intelligent, before the child signs and the magistrate certifies it.

On June 4, 2008, the court issued a memorandum opinion reversing the conviction and remanding the case for a new trial. The point on which it turned was the magistrate's role under the Family Code. Reta had appeared before a magistrate twice in connection with the statement. A video of the second appearance showed that the magistrate had made no inquiry at all into the nature and circumstances of the statement. The second appearance was the review that the statute requires before a statement can be used. The court held that the trial court erred in refusing to suppress the written statement, because the magistrate had wholly failed to inquire or examine Reta about it.

The court's mandate issued on August 7, 2008, and the trial court clerk acknowledged it on August 12. The case returned to the 49th District Court for a new trial on the same indictment.

The second trial

The State tried Reta again within weeks. As the court of appeals later summarized it, the State's case came from the men around him, the detective and the recording. The cooperating witness repeated his account of the cell, of Reta's return after the killing, of his talk about his part and of the payment. The detective described how the investigation had moved from contact to contact until it reached Bart. The jury heard the recorded conversation between Reta and Cardona from April 2006, admitted over defense objection.

The jury charge asked whether, on or about January 8, 2006, in Webb County, Cardona or the third man intentionally or knowingly caused the death, and whether Reta "acted with intent to promote or assist the commission of the offense." If so, the jury was told, it was to find him guilty of murder. The defense argued that Reta had not been there and that the cooperating witness could not be believed. In closing, a prosecutor told the jury that it kept hearing that Reta was not there, but that nobody had taken the stand to say where he was that night. Defense counsel objected that the State was trying to shift the burden of proof, and the court sustained the objection.

The jury convicted Reta of murder. On August 29, 2008, the court sentenced him to 40 years in prison, the same term he had received after his plea a year earlier.

The second appeal

He appealed again on September 26, 2008. The transcript of the second trial was slow to reach the court, and the briefing ran most of 2009 before a three-justice panel took the case under submission, on the briefs, on November 10, 2009.

The court delivered a memorandum opinion on March 3, 2010, marked "do not publish." Reta raised four issues, and the court overruled each one.

The first concerned the April 2006 recording. A trial court's ruling on evidence is reviewed for abuse of discretion, and an appellate court leaves it alone as long as it falls within the zone of reasonable disagreement. Reta argued that it was evidence of other crimes or wrongs and should have been excluded under Rules 402, 403 and 404 of the Texas Rules of Evidence. The State answered that the recording went to identity and motive and rebutted his defensive theory. It pointed out that Reta had put identity in dispute by cross-examining an expert witness and the eyewitnesses who had not identified him. Under the Court of Criminal Appeals' precedent, identity can be placed in issue by cross-examination as well as by defense evidence, and once it is, evidence of other acts may come in to prove it, so long as the act bears on a material issue and its value is not substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice. The court agreed with the State. Because the State had to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Reta acted with the intent to assist in the murder, evidence that he was paid for it and associated with the cell was relevant to show that he did. The recording, the court said, was highly probative of motive and identity, and admitting it was within the trial court's discretion.

The second issue was hearsay. Reta complained that the detective's testimony about the connections between the participants rested on records never introduced into evidence, and that the State had filed no business-records affidavit. The court found the point not preserved. Counsel had objected to part of the testimony, but the same evidence came in elsewhere without objection, and a demonstrative chart summarizing it had been admitted over an objection on relevance only, not hearsay. Under settled Texas law, an error in admitting evidence is cured when the same evidence comes in elsewhere without objection, and the ground raised on appeal must match the objection made at trial.

The third issue was the prosecutor's remark in closing. Reta argued that it was a comment on his failure to testify, in violation of the Fifth Amendment and of article I, section 10 of the Texas Constitution. The court agreed that such comments are improper, but held that the objection at trial had been framed as burden-shifting rather than as a violation of the right against self-incrimination. Reta had also not asked for an instruction to disregard or moved for a mistrial. To preserve error, a defendant must carry an objection through to an adverse ruling, and the sustained burden-shifting objection was not the one Reta now pressed. He had therefore forfeited the complaint.

The fourth issue was the factual sufficiency of the evidence. On that question an appellate court weighs all the evidence in a neutral light, but it may second-guess the jury's view of credibility only to a very limited degree. Reta argued that the evidence did not support an implicit finding that he had played the specific role the State attributed to him that night. The court held that this misstated what the jury had to find. The indictment and the charge required only that he was criminally responsible for the conduct of another under section 7.02(a)(2) of the Penal Code. Reta attacked the cooperating witness as unreliable and argued that the rest of the evidence tied him only to the cell in general, and that other members of the Zetas had pleaded guilty to the murder. The court answered that the jury was free to accept or reject any witness and had chosen to believe the State's. Viewing all the evidence in a neutral light, it could not say that the verdict was so against the great weight of the evidence as to be clearly wrong and manifestly unjust.

The judgment was affirmed. The court's mandate issued on May 4, 2010, and the appellate file was closed.

The appellate files opened once more, six years later. In November 2016 Reta, by then an inmate of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, wrote to the Fourth Court of Appeals asking for copies of the records in both of his appeals. The clerk answered on November 14 about the first case and on November 18 about the second. Each reply said the records would be copied and sent once payment arrived. The letters place him in a Texas state prison in November 2016.

Disputed and unproven points

Reta's defense at his second trial was that he was not there. Through cross-examination his lawyers challenged the expert evidence and the eyewitnesses, and on appeal they argued that the cooperating witness was unreliable and that the rest of the case connected Reta only to the cell in general, not to the killing itself. The jury rejected that defense, and the court of appeals held the evidence factually sufficient.

The State's account of the network rested in large part on the testimony of men who had worked inside it. Reta's appeal relied mainly on discrepancies in the cooperating witness's testimony, and the court of appeals deferred to the jury, which had chosen to believe him.

The written statement Reta signed in custody, in which he admitted taking part, was held inadmissible in June 2008.

Timeline

January 8, 2006: Death of the victim in Laredo, Texas.

April 2006: Investigators lawfully record a conversation between Reta and Cardona.

July 2006: Reta is returned to Laredo from Mexico.

2006: Indicted for murder in the 49th Judicial District Court, Webb County, after his case is certified for trial as an adult.

July 16, 2007: First trial opens at the Webb County Courthouse in Laredo.

July 19, 2007: Reta pleads guilty to murder after his written statement is admitted; sentenced to 40 years.

August 7, 2007: Notice of appeal filed.

May 7, 2008: First appeal submitted on the briefs.

June 4, 2008: Fourth Court of Appeals reverses and remands; the written statement should have been suppressed.

August 7, 2008: Mandate issues; acknowledged by the trial court clerk on August 12.

August 29, 2008: After a jury verdict of guilty of murder, Reta is sentenced to 40 years.

October 31, 2008: Second appeal docketed.

November 10, 2009: Second appeal submitted on the briefs.

March 3, 2010: Fourth Court of Appeals affirms the conviction.

May 4, 2010: Mandate issues.

November 14 and 18, 2016: The court of appeals clerk answers his requests, sent from Texas state custody, for copies of the records in both appeals.