Ronald True was a former airman who stood trial at the Old Bailey in May 1922 for the murder of Gertrude Yates in London. Four doctors told the jury he was certifiably insane, and the prosecution called no medical evidence in reply. The jury convicted him of murder anyway, and he was sentenced to death. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed his appeal. Then the Home Secretary, acting under a statute that left him no choice once he had reason to doubt a condemned man's sanity, ordered a medical inquiry. The doctors certified True insane, and he was reprieved and removed to Broadmoor.
The decision set off a fierce public quarrel. Newspapers accused the Home Secretary of overriding a jury, a member of the House of Commons tried to force a debate, and the case was set against that of an 18-year-old who was executed in the same weeks. True himself stayed in Broadmoor, and his case came back before the Commons in 1931 and again in 1936.
True had served as an airman before the killing, and members of Parliament who pressed the Home Office about him in the 1930s still called him the ex-airman. His youth and early history came up only after his conviction, when a relative gave evidence about them to one of the doctors in the medical inquiry; what that relative said was not made public.
The victim died in London in 1922. When a member of the House of Commons raised the case in 1931, he placed her death in Fulham, in west London. Her life before that year is not on record.
True was held on remand in London before the trial. Two prison doctors kept him under close observation for nearly two months, and both later gave evidence at the Old Bailey that in their judgment he was insane.
While he was on remand, True and Henry Jacoby, an 18-year-old held on a separate murder charge, were both kept in prison hospital wards. A prison officer described at True's trial a conversation between the two men. That evidence led a member of the House of Commons, on May 17, 1922, to ask the Home Secretary whether older and younger prisoners on remand were kept apart. The Home Secretary answered that the two were in separate wards and had never met or spoken to each other. The words the officer described, he said, had been called out by True as he passed the ward where Jacoby was held.
The trial took place at the Central Criminal Court in London in May 1922. The defense was insanity.
The medical evidence ran entirely one way. The two prison doctors who had watched True for nearly two months told the court he was certifiably insane, and two other medical men gave evidence to the same effect. The prosecution called no evidence to rebut them, because, as the Home Secretary later told the House of Commons, it could not obtain any.
That did not decide the case. The question for the jury was whether True was criminally responsible at the time of the killing, judged by the legal test of insanity, not whether doctors thought him insane. The jury found him guilty of murder, and the judge passed sentence of death.
In his report on the sentence to the Home Secretary, the trial judge drew special attention to the medical evidence as matter for consideration. That remark would matter once the appeal was over.
True appealed to the Court of Criminal Appeal, where the Lord Chief Justice presided. The court dismissed the appeal, and in giving judgment the Lord Chief Justice pointed to the powers of the Home Secretary. The judgment appears in the Criminal Appeal Reports.
With the conviction final, the Home Secretary turned to section 2(4) of the Criminal Lunatics Act, 1884. If the Home Secretary had reason to believe that a prisoner under sentence of death was insane, he was bound to order an inquiry by medical men into the prisoner's mental state.
He had several reasons for that belief. Two prison doctors who had watched True for nearly two months reported that he was insane. The same two doctors and two others had said so on oath at the trial, and no one had contradicted them. The trial judge had drawn attention to the medical evidence, and the Lord Chief Justice had pointed to the Home Secretary's powers.
He appointed two senior official doctors, and they found True insane and certified him so. The law then bound the Home Secretary to grant a reprieve. True was removed to Broadmoor as a criminal lunatic, his sentence of death respited. While the inquiry was under way, True's solicitor sent in a petition for a reprieve.
The reprieve was attacked in the press. Critics said the Home Secretary had flouted the verdict of a British jury. The attack drew sharper edges because Jacoby, the 18-year-old who had been on remand at the same time, had been convicted of murder in a separate case, and his jury had recommended mercy. Jacoby was executed. The two outcomes were held up side by side as proof that the law treated a rich man and a poor boy differently.
On June 13, 1922, a member of the House of Commons asked the Home Secretary, by private notice, to explain his action in ordering True's detention in a criminal lunatic asylum, and he answered at length.
He denied that there had been any miscarriage of justice. The jury had answered one question: whether True was responsible in law for what he did at the time. The statutory inquiry answered another: whether he was insane while waiting under sentence of death. The two findings did not conflict. He set out the long rule of English law that an insane person may not be executed: once the doctors had certified True insane, he had no discretion left.
The member who had asked the question then moved the adjournment of the House to debate the Home Secretary's conduct in starting the inquiry. The Speaker ruled that the House could not debate advice given to the Crown about a reprieve, only whether the Home Secretary had acted within his statutory powers, and the motion failed for want of support.
A week later, on June 20, the Home Secretary told the House that he knew of only one earlier case like True's, a prisoner found sane at trial who became insane under sentence of death, and that it dated from 1864.
True stayed in Broadmoor. In 1931 his case came back to the Commons three times. On April 30 the House was told that his case had last been reviewed the previous summer and that he was still detained in Broadmoor as a criminal lunatic. On July 16 the Home Secretary confirmed that True was subject to the ordinary rules on buying food and receiving visitors. On July 30 he told three members who pressed him that the case had been reviewed that month, when the annual report arrived, and that the report showed no change.
The questions continued into 1936. On March 12 the Home Secretary told the House that the latest annual report, received in June 1935, showed no material change in True's condition. Asked about press claims that True enjoyed special treatment, he said that True was treated properly, but without any special privileges.
The last firm date in True's story is March 1936, when he was still held in Broadmoor. The date of his death is not on record.
What True called out to Jacoby on remand was put before the jury by a prison officer, but the words themselves were never repeated in the Commons, and the Home Secretary insisted the two had never met or spoken.
Claims that True was spared because his family had influence were made at the time and repeated for years. The Home Secretary denied them in the Commons in June 1922, saying he had not known who True or his relatives were and had received no representations beyond his solicitor's petition.
1922: The killing in London; True is charged with murder and held on remand, where two prison doctors observe him for nearly two months.
May 17, 1922: The Home Secretary answers a Commons question about remarks True called out to another remand prisoner.
May 1922: True is tried at the Central Criminal Court, found guilty of murder and sentenced to death.
1922: The Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses his appeal.
June 1922: A statutory medical inquiry under section 2(4) of the Criminal Lunatics Act, 1884, certifies True insane; he is reprieved and removed to Broadmoor.
June 13, 1922: The Home Secretary explains the reprieve in the Commons; a motion to adjourn the House fails.
June 20, 1922: The Home Secretary tells the Commons he knows of only one earlier case like True's, from 1864.
April 30, 1931: The Commons is told True's case was last reviewed the previous summer and that he remains in Broadmoor.
July 16 and July 30, 1931: The Home Secretary answers further questions on True's treatment and condition.
March 12, 1936: The Home Secretary tells the Commons that True's condition shows no material change and that he receives no special privileges.