Ronald Taylor

Victims
3 men killed in Wilkinsburg, Pennsylvania, March 2000. Convicted of three counts of first-degree murder and ethnic intimidation, November 2001; sentenced to death.
Years active
March 1, 2000
Location
Wilkinsburg, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania
Method
First-degree murder, with ethnic intimidation
Status
Three death sentences imposed January 11, 2002, plus 115 to 230 years; affirmed by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania June 21, 2005; never executed

On March 1, 2000, three men were killed in Wilkinsburg, a borough east of Pittsburgh, and two other men were wounded. The men who died were John Kroll, Joseph Healy and Emil Sanielevici; one of them lived until the next day. Ronald Taylor, who lived in the borough, surrendered to police that afternoon. Twenty months later an Allegheny County jury convicted him of three counts of murder of the first degree and of ethnic intimidation, the offense Pennsylvania law uses for crimes driven by hatred of a victim's race, and it sentenced him to death.

That second verdict is the case's central legal finding: the jury found that the men had been targeted because they were white. Taylor was charged with criminal homicide on the day itself, the ethnic intimidation count followed the next day, and counts of aggravated assault, arson and other offenses came with it. The case stayed in the state courts from start to finish.

The trial opened in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas on November 1, 2001. The jury convicted Taylor of three counts of first-degree murder, one for each man who died, and of ethnic intimidation, eight counts of aggravated assault, arson and a long list of lesser offenses. In the penalty phase it found one aggravating circumstance for each murder, that he had been convicted of another murder committed before or at the time of that one, weighed it against the mitigation and returned three sentences of death. On January 11, 2002, the trial judge formally imposed them, together with consecutive terms of 115 to 230 years on the other convictions.

On June 21, 2005, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania affirmed the convictions and all three death sentences. It held that the evidence supported each verdict of first-degree murder, rejected every claim of trial error he raised, and found that the sentences were not the product of passion, prejudice or any other arbitrary factor.

Taylor was never executed. He died in a Pennsylvania state prison in April 2024, of natural causes, at the age of 63, still under sentence of death.

His mental state was contested throughout: the trial court found him incompetent to stand trial in April 2000 and competent later that year, the jury rejected his defense of insanity, and no juror found the mitigating circumstances that rest on a defendant's mental condition.

The outcome of the proceedings after 2005, including a claim the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania left undecided that intellectual disability barred his execution, is unresolved.

Timeline

March 1, 2000: Two men are killed and three wounded in Wilkinsburg; Taylor surrenders to police and is charged with criminal homicide.

March 2, 2000: A third man dies; the charge of ethnic intimidation is added.

April 2000: The trial court finds Taylor incompetent to stand trial.

Later in 2000: He is found competent.

November 1, 2001: Trial opens in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.

November 2001: The jury convicts him of three counts of first-degree murder, ethnic intimidation and other offenses and returns three sentences of death.

January 11, 2002: The death sentences and consecutive terms of 115 to 230 years are formally imposed.

June 21, 2005: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania affirms the convictions and sentences.

April 2024: Taylor dies in prison under sentence of death.