On the night of September 22, 2000, Ronald Edward Gay walked into a bar in downtown Roanoke, Virginia. Within moments Danny Lee Overstreet was dead and six other people were wounded. Gay, a 53-year-old former Marine who had been living in the Roanoke Valley for about a year, was arrested within minutes and charged with first-degree murder. In 2001 he pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and six counts of malicious wounding, and on July 23 of that year a Roanoke circuit judge sentenced him to four consecutive life terms. Because his offenses came after Virginia ended parole for new felonies, the sentence meant what it said. He died in the custody of the Virginia Department of Corrections on January 15, 2022, at the age of 75.
By his own account he had come downtown that night to kill gay people. He said so to police after his arrest and again in court, and Roanoke police investigated the killing as a hate crime from the first night. No hate-crime charge was brought, because Virginia's hate-crime law did not then cover sexual orientation; the case went to court as one count of murder and six of wounding.
Gay grew up in Nova Scotia, Canada. At 18 he moved to the United States, became a naturalized citizen and joined the Marine Corps during the Vietnam War. He served one tour in Vietnam on convoy duty, returning in 1969, and later drove trucks for the Corps before leaving with an honorable discharge as a corporal. A back injury from those years brought him a military pension.
The months before September 2000 were a run of losses and trouble. In May a fire destroyed the place he rented in Huddleston, a community about 30 miles from Roanoke. In June a Florida judge issued a protective order against him and ordered him to undergo a mental evaluation. He carried a Florida identification card but had been living in the Roanoke area for about a year.
The warning came first. That evening Gay told an employee at another downtown tavern that he wanted to harm gay people. The employee took it at first for a joke, then called the police. Officers were already looking for him when, less than an hour later, he walked into the bar a few blocks away.
One man died there within minutes. Six other people, four women and two men, were wounded. Police arrested Gay a few minutes later nearby. He confessed soon after his arrest, and the confession was recorded.
The man who died was a regular at the bar and well liked there. Friends remembered him as humorous and easy-going, flamboyant, a strong personality and the kind of man people liked at once. One of the men wounded that night remembered how he loved to sing karaoke with his friends. He had come to the bar that night with a close friend, who was among the six wounded. All six survived, and two of them later spoke publicly about that night.
Gay never went to trial. In 2001 he pleaded guilty in the Circuit Court in Roanoke to first-degree murder and to six counts of malicious wounding, one for each person hurt. On those pleas he faced as much as four life terms plus 60 years in prison.
On Monday, July 23, 2001, the circuit judge imposed four consecutive life terms. Gay was 55. Virginia had abolished parole for any felony committed on or after January 1, 1995, so he would never go before a parole board to ask for release in the ordinary way.
He served the sentence in the Virginia state prison system for more than twenty years. He died on Saturday, January 15, 2022, while in the custody of the Virginia Department of Corrections. He was 75, and the department gave the cause as natural.
Gay's mental state was never tested before a jury. Whether he was competent to stand trial was an open question in the first weeks after his arrest, and three months before the killing a Florida court had ordered him to undergo a mental evaluation. His guilty plea ended the case without a ruling on any mental-state defense.
The anti-gay motive rests on Gay's own words, to the tavern employee, to the police and in court, and on the police decision to treat the killing as a hate crime. It was never the subject of a charge or a court finding. He also gave other explanations for what he did, and none of them was tested in court.
1969: Gay returns from a tour in Vietnam with the Marine Corps.
May 2000: A fire destroys the place he rents in Huddleston, Virginia.
June 2000: A Florida judge issues a protective order against him and orders a mental evaluation.
September 22, 2000: In a bar in downtown Roanoke, one man is killed and six other people are wounded. Gay is arrested within minutes and charged with first-degree murder.
2001: He pleads guilty in the Circuit Court in Roanoke to first-degree murder and six counts of malicious wounding.
July 23, 2001: Sentenced to four consecutive life terms.
January 15, 2022: He dies in the custody of the Virginia Department of Corrections, aged 75.