On Halloween night in 1974, a boy died in Pasadena, Texas. Within days the police had charged his father, Ronald Clark O'Bryan, of nearby Deer Park, with his death. In 1975 a Harris County jury convicted O'Bryan of capital murder, and the same jury sentenced him to death. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, which stated that the crime was motivated by financial gain, affirmed the conviction in 1979. The Fifth Circuit denied federal habeas relief in 1983. He maintained his innocence to the end. On March 31, 1984, O'Bryan was executed in Huntsville, Texas, the third person put to death in the state since the death penalty returned.
O'Bryan lived in Deer Park, a suburb on the east side of Houston. His son died in Pasadena on the night of October 31, 1974.
The charge that followed concerned only the one death. The Court of Criminal Appeals, in the opinion that closed the direct appeal, treated evidence concerning four other children as conduct outside the charge and used it only on the question of future dangerousness. No count in that opinion charges an offense against any of them.
The inquiry was led by the Pasadena police, with the Harris County district attorney's office. Investigators learned that O'Bryan held life insurance on his children.
O'Bryan was arrested late on Monday, November 4, 1974, five days after the boy's death. He was charged with murder in the death of his son and held under a bond of $100,000. His lawyer, a Dallas attorney, said he would seek an early examining trial, the hearing at which a court decides whether the state has enough evidence to send a case to a grand jury. The prosecutor and the police declined to discuss details but said they believed they had sufficient evidence. O'Bryan told his pastor he was innocent. A Harris County grand jury later indicted him for capital murder.
The offense charged was capital murder under section 19.03(a)(3) of the Texas Penal Code. That provision makes a murder capital when it is committed for remuneration or the promise of remuneration. The State alleged that the murder of O'Bryan's son was committed for the proceeds of a life insurance policy on the child. The case was tried before a Harris County district court and a jury in 1975, and the Court of Criminal Appeals later stated that O'Bryan murdered his child in order to collect life insurance money.
Jury selection was later the subject of the main federal challenge. Three prospective jurors who opposed the death penalty were excused for cause, and the defense argued on appeal that this violated the rule in Witherspoon v. Illinois. O'Bryan denied the charge, and the defense said the killing was the work of someone else. The jury deliberated for 46 minutes before returning its verdict of guilty. The punishment phase followed under Article 37.071 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in which the jury answers special issues put to it by the court. It answered them affirmatively, and the court sentenced O'Bryan to death. The jury's deliberations on punishment lasted about an hour and five minutes.
O'Bryan's appeal to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals was decided en banc on September 26, 1979, in O'Bryan v. State, 591 S.W.2d 464, with rehearing denied on October 24, 1979. The court rejected each of the grounds raised. It held that the three jurors excused for cause were unambiguously opposed to the death penalty, or in one case unable to consider it, and that the Texas capital sentencing statute was constitutional, relying on its earlier decisions and on the Supreme Court's decision in Jurek v. Texas. It held the evidence sufficient on the issue of future dangerousness, citing the planning, the motive and O'Bryan's conduct and attitude afterward. It also rejected a challenge to the prosecutor's argument at the punishment stage, and the contention that the jury should have been told about parole. One judge dissented from the ruling on the evidence of future dangerousness. The conviction and the death sentence were affirmed. The United States Supreme Court denied certiorari in 1980.
State habeas proceedings followed. The first application was denied, and a second was denied on September 1, 1982, after which an execution date of October 31, 1982, the eighth anniversary of the offense, was set. A first federal petition, filed in July 1980, had been dismissed without prejudice so that O'Bryan could exhaust further claims. He filed a second on September 29, 1982, and the federal district court denied the writ and a stay on October 20, 1982. Two days before the scheduled date, on October 27, 1982, a panel of the Fifth Circuit granted a stay and a certificate of probable cause, with one judge dissenting.
The Fifth Circuit decided the appeal in August 1983, in O'Bryan v. Estelle, 714 F.2d 365, affirming the denial of habeas relief. One judge filed a special concurrence. The court held that the three jurors had been properly excluded under Witherspoon because each had made clear at some point that he could not vote for a death sentence. It held that O'Bryan's failure to ask at trial for an instruction on mitigating circumstances barred that claim in federal court, that the prosecutor's comments had not deprived him of a fair trial, and that the complaint about the jury not being told the parole law for life sentences could not be heard on federal habeas.
By March 1984 the sentence had been upheld by eight courts over nine years. On Wednesday, March 28, his lawyer filed a further federal habeas petition and a request for a stay in Houston, and on the same day the Court of Criminal Appeals in Austin denied a stay without giving reasons. A separate civil action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 was filed in the federal court in Houston the same day. The federal district judge denied the relief sought on March 29, 1984, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed the same day, holding that the claims had already been decided in earlier appeals. The district judge also denied the stay request that Thursday, and a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union said he would appeal to the Fifth Circuit.
O'Bryan also wrote by hand to the governor to ask for a 30-day reprieve. The governor, in Houston, said he would not be inclined to grant a stay without good reason. O'Bryan kept to the end that the evidence against him was circumstantial and that the person responsible had never been found. A friend said that the life insurance had been taken out years earlier and often updated. Supporters and opponents of the death penalty were expected to gather outside the prison at Huntsville.
Ronald Clark O'Bryan was executed in Huntsville, Texas, on March 31, 1984, at the age of 39. He was the third person executed in Texas since the death penalty returned, and he was from Harris County.
Texas defined capital murder in section 19.03 of its Penal Code, and subsection (a)(3) covers a murder committed for remuneration or the promise of remuneration. At sentencing the jury did not weigh the case freely. Under Article 37.071 it answered special issues put to it by the court, the second of which concerned future dangerousness, and a death sentence followed when the answers were affirmative. The Court of Criminal Appeals relied on its earlier decisions and on the Supreme Court's decision in Jurek v. Texas when it rejected O'Bryan's challenges to this statute.
By 1984 only two inmates had been put to death in Texas since the Supreme Court reinstated the state's death penalty, so O'Bryan's execution was the third.
O'Bryan always denied the offense. He called the evidence against him "100 percent circumstantial" and said the real culprit, a man he did not know, had gone free. His defense at trial was that an unknown person was responsible. The courts rejected every challenge to the verdict, and none of the appeals concerned the guilt finding itself; they were directed at jury selection, the sentencing statute, the prosecutor's argument and the parole instruction. A friend said the life insurance policy dated from 1971 and was frequently updated. The Court of Criminal Appeals stated that the crime was motivated by financial gain.
October 31, 1974: Offense in Pasadena, Texas.
November 4, 1974: O'Bryan arrested by Pasadena police; charged with murder; held under $100,000 bond.
1975: Tried in Harris County; jury returns a verdict of guilty of capital murder after 46 minutes; sentence of death.
September 26, 1979: Court of Criminal Appeals affirms conviction and sentence; rehearing denied October 24, 1979.
1980: Supreme Court denies certiorari; first federal habeas petition filed in July 1980 and later dismissed without prejudice.
September 1, 1982: Second state habeas application denied; execution set for October 31, 1982.
October 20, 1982: Federal district court denies writ and stay.
October 27, 1982: Fifth Circuit grants stay.
August 1983: Fifth Circuit affirms denial of habeas relief.
March 28 to 29, 1984: Final applications for a stay denied by state and federal courts.
March 31, 1984: Executed in Huntsville, Texas.