Roger Dean was the only registered nurse on duty overnight at Quakers Hill Nursing Home, in Sydney's west, in the early hours of November 18, 2011. Around 80 elderly residents were living there, many of them unable to walk and many living with dementia. Before dawn, Dean committed the crimes that killed 11 of them: four died that day and seven more over the following eleven days. He had been employed at the home for about two months. The evening before, staff had found that more than 200 tablets of a prescription painkiller were missing from the locked medication cabinet, and the police had been called. By the time he acted, his colleagues already suspected him.
He admitted responsibility to police within a day. On May 27, 2013, the day his murder trial was due to open in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, he pleaded guilty to 11 counts of murder and eight counts of recklessly causing grievous bodily harm, having already admitted stealing the medication. On August 1, 2013 he was sentenced to life imprisonment on each murder count, a sentence that in New South Wales carries no parole. The Court of Criminal Appeal heard his challenge to the sentence in 2015 and left the life terms in place, and in November 2016 the High Court of Australia refused him special leave to appeal. A coronial inquest into 14 deaths among the residents reported in March 2015 and traced, step by step, how a nurse with a hidden history had come to be alone with the keys.
Dean was born in 1976. He was registered as a nurse on December 23, 1996, and for the next fifteen years he worked in hospitals and care settings across Sydney. Between 2002 and 2007 he worked for St George Hospital and Community Health Services, in mental health and in drug and alcohol rehabilitation. In September 2005 he also began casual shifts at St John of God Hospital. He left St George in July 2007 and took a permanent registered nurse's position at St John of God, where he worked mainly at night. In 2004 he had started a Bachelor of Laws degree at Macquarie University, and by November 2011 he was one unit short of finishing it.
By his own later account to the psychiatrist who examined him for the prosecution, his misuse of prescription medication began during the years of night work at St John of God and at a community health center in Hurstville. He was prescribed a sedative for a physical condition and began taking it for sleep. He then started seeing other doctors, without telling any of them about the others, to obtain more. By about 2007, he said, he was taking sedatives regularly. The pattern followed him when he moved to Quakers Hill. His medical records showed that between April and November 2011 he saw ten different general practitioners, most of whom prescribed him medication, and that none of them knew the full picture of what the others were giving him.
In June 2011, during a shift at St John of God Hospital, a patient found Dean in the medication room and reported to staff that he appeared heavily drug-affected. The after-hours manager found him sedated and unsteady, with slurred speech, suspended him on the spot, sent him home and would not let him drive. At a meeting with the hospital's director of nursing a few days later, Dean said that he had bipolar disorder and that a change to his antidepressant had affected him badly. He produced a letter in his doctor's name confirming the diagnosis and saying he was fit to return to work, and the suspension ended.
The coroner later found no evidence that Dean had ever been formally diagnosed with bipolar disorder or seen a specialist; the doctor's own statement and notes spoke of treatment for anxiety and panic disorders.
With patient safety in mind, the director of nursing told him he would be taken off night shifts and moved to day work, where he could be supervised. Three days later Dean resigned. His notice, dated September 19, 2011, gave "personal reasons." Nothing about his suspension or the reasons for his departure ever reached Quakers Hill.
Quakers Hill Nursing Home, owned by a company in the group then called the Domain Principal Group and later known as Opal Aged Care, cared for high-care residents who needed help with daily living. The night shift was staffed by one registered nurse, who was in charge, and four assistants in nursing. Only registered nurses could dispense the most closely controlled drugs, the opioids and similar medications listed under Schedule 8, and overnight the registered nurse held the keys to both the treatment room and the drug cabinet inside it.
In September 2011 Dean was living in Quakers Hill with his then partner, within walking distance of the home. Early that month he went in and asked whether there was work. The home needed a registered nurse, and especially one willing to cover nights. His resume listed a cake shop as his only employment since August 2007 and gave St George Hospital, which he had left in July 2007, as his most recent nursing job. It did not mention St John of God at all. His written references dated from 1998, 1999 and 2000, and none of his named referees had worked with him since 2007. No one at the home contacted them or any previous employer. The company's checklist for new staff covered a police check but not references, and the medical screening its own protocols required for new nurses never took place. On the strength of his current registration and a single interview, he was taken on as a permanent part-time registered nurse. His contract was dated September 20, 2011, and employment records show he began working night shifts on September 13. He was on a three-month probation.
Several of the assistants in nursing who worked with him later described things that had worried them from early October: a blank expression, a white residue at the corners of his mouth that one of them suspected came from drug use, a disheveled look in the week before November 18, and a rant about debts during a shift in mid-November. Most of these concerns were not reported to management beforehand, although there was evidence that some complaints reached the facility manager verbally shortly before November 18.
Dean worked the night shift of November 16 to 17, 2011. The assistants on duty noticed him spending long periods alone in the treatment room with the door shut, which was unusual, and the home's security footage later showed that he had spent more than two hours of the shift inside.
On the evening of November 17, during the routine daily count of controlled drugs, the registered nurse on the afternoon shift found that the tablets of a strong opioid painkiller did not tally with the register. With the clinical manager, who came in to recount them, she found that 237 tablets of that drug and one capsule of another opioid were gone. The last person recorded as having given out the drug was Dean. Both the clinical manager and the facility manager suspected him, and they agreed to call the police.
The call went to the local police station late that evening, although the clinical manager did not tell police that the staff had a suspect. Dean arrived for his night shift a little later, and an agency staff member who had been asked to stay back, unaware of an instruction to tell him nothing, told him about the missing drugs and showed him her written report.
Two constables came after midnight, found no sign of forced entry to the drug cabinet and were soon called away to an urgent job. The clinical manager and the afternoon nurse then watched the footage from the previous night, which showed Dean going in and out of the treatment room by himself. One assistant on duty later said Dean seemed restless and anxious, told her "They think it's me," and kept asking when the two managers would go home.
In the early hours the clinical manager rang the police again, described what she had seen and said she was scared to leave her staff alone with him. Police said they could not attend before morning. Two assistants begged her to stay, but she was exhausted, and she went home, leaving Dean on duty with the keys. Later, police rang the home, were told the suspect was working that shift and decided there was no point attending until a manager was on site.
Before dawn, Dean committed the crimes to which he later pleaded guilty. Eleven residents died as a result, and eight more were seriously injured.
In the afternoon police asked him to come to Mount Druitt Police Station to make a statement. The typed statement he gave there was, the coroner found, false or misleading about his duties and movements during the night, and it contained no admission.
That evening, police told him he was a suspect. He said there was something he had left out of his statement, asked to speak to friends, and then admitted responsibility to police. In a long recorded interview that night he admitted it again but went on denying the theft. Asked why, he said he had been "corrupted with evil thoughts" and spoke of Satan telling him it was the right thing to do.
The residents who died had lived through the Depression and the Second World War, and almost all of them, the coroner wrote, had known real hardship in their younger years. Many raised large families on small incomes. Most needed a high level of care because of their age and health.
Four died on November 18. Alma Smith was born in the country and lost her mother when she was two; she was sent to boarding school at 11 while her father was away for work, and her first marriage ended in a car crash. Her family remembered a woman who put others first, refused to be a burden and stayed positive for them as she grew frail. Dorothy Wu had been widowed some years before and was survived by two sisters and two brothers. Dorothy Sterling, born in 1931, made dresses and wedding gowns for others, had two sons and a large family of grandchildren and great-grandchildren, and was known to all of them as "Oma," although she was not German. Her family remembered a warm and generous matriarch.
Lola Joyce Bennett, born in 1925, grew up on a farm, served in the Land Army and was married for 31 years, raising two children, until she was widowed in 1975. The whole family worked the banana plantation they owned. She loved dancing and played the organ, and her family remembered her as strong, industrious, generous-hearted and fun.
Ella Wood died on November 19. Born in 1913, she married in 1939, had one child and was widowed in 2008. She was frail but in relatively good health for her age and saw her family regularly.
Urbana Alipio died on November 20. She was born in the Philippines in 1925 and came to Australia in 1994. She had three children and several grandchildren, and the coroner reflected on what it had taken to live through the war and the Japanese occupation of her country and bring up a family in its aftermath.
Caesar Galea died on November 21. He was born in Alexandria, Egypt, into a Catholic family of Maltese descent, and came to Australia after the Second World War. He had been married for about 62 years when he entered the nursing home. His family described a strong and proud man who adored his grandchildren and loved cooking, fishing, growing vegetables and a day at the greyhound and trotting races. He worked as a leatherworker and served for 20 years as a special constable with the New South Wales Police.
Doris Mercy Becke died the same day. She raised five children during the Depression, and was widowed at 48 and never remarried. Her family grew to 13 grandchildren, 28 great-grandchildren and 24 great-great-grandchildren, and they remembered her as a fighter with a happy and positive spirit to the end.
Neeltje Valkay died on November 22. Born in the Netherlands, she married in 1946, had three children and emigrated with her family to Australia in 1954, looking for opportunity for the children and better weather. She was widowed in 1987. A soprano who had sung in choirs in both countries, she never lost her love of music, and at Quakers Hill she was known as "the Trivia Queen."
Reginald Joseph Green died on November 25. Born in 1924, he was married for 62 years and he and his wife raised two children. His family visited him regularly.
Verna Noeleen Webeck died on November 29. Born in 1928, one of 11 children of a soldier's family, she worked as a shearer's cook and later in a nursing home, raised five children and was admired by a large family of grandchildren and great-grandchildren as a resilient woman used to hard work in hard times.
Eight other residents were seriously injured and became the subject of the grievous bodily harm counts. One of them, Emmanuela Cachia, died in March 2012; her death was examined at the inquest but was not a murder count. Born in Malta in 1935, she came to Australia in 1956 with her parents and three siblings, raised five children and loved family gatherings and trips to the Blue Mountains and La Perouse. Two other residents who had been in the home that morning died in December 2011: Joan Joy, born in England in 1932, who had emigrated in 1969, and Esther Newham. Neither death was the subject of any charge.
By November 19, 2011, Dean had appeared in court on murder charges and been remanded in custody. The counts grew as more of the injured died, and the indictment that went to the Supreme Court of New South Wales charged him with 11 counts of murder, resting on reckless indifference to human life, and eight counts of recklessly causing grievous bodily harm, with a further charge over the theft of the medication. In November 2012 he pleaded not guilty to the murder and grievous bodily harm counts; the Crown had refused his offer to plead guilty to manslaughter.
On May 27, 2013, as his trial was about to begin, Dean changed his pleas and pleaded guilty to all 11 counts of murder and all eight counts of recklessly causing grievous bodily harm. He had already pleaded guilty to larceny over the stolen medication.
For sentencing, Dean admitted that his purpose had been to create a distraction that would deflect management from looking further into the theft. The sentencing judge went further, finding that he had meant either to destroy the evidence in the treatment room or to create enough chaos for him to get into the room and remove it.
How far drugs had clouded his judgment that night was argued at the hearing. A consultant psychiatrist who assessed him at the prosecution's request found poly-substance abuse but no psychiatric illness at the time of the offending: no psychosis, no bipolar disorder, no major depression. The judge accepted that Dean had a poly-substance abuse disorder when he committed the offenses, but she did not accept that the drugs had affected his capacity to form judgments and make calculated decisions in any relevant way.
On August 1, 2013, in the Supreme Court in Sydney, the judge sentenced Dean to life imprisonment on each of the 11 murder counts. She found the murders fell in the worst category of offending because the victims were vulnerable elderly people in his care, and she found no evidence that he had been unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of what he did. He was 37.
Dean appealed against the sentences to the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal, which heard the appeal in Sydney in September 2015 and left the life terms in place. He then sought special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia, which refused it in November 2016. As of November 2016 he was serving life imprisonment in New South Wales.
The Deputy State Coroner of New South Wales held a combined inquest into the deaths of 14 residents at the State Coroner's Court in Glebe over eight days in September and October 2014, and delivered findings on March 9, 2015. For each of the 11 residents named in the murder counts, the coroner found that death had followed Dean's deliberate act in the nursing home.
The coroner found that chances to stop Dean had been missed twice before he ever reached Quakers Hill's night shift. The law already required employers to notify the national regulator when they reasonably believed a nurse had practiced while intoxicated, but Dean's account at St John of God, that he was suffering side effects of prescribed medication, had misled the director of nursing there. Then the nursing home, desperate to fill its night vacancy, did almost nothing to check him beyond confirming his registration. The coroner also examined in detail the decisions made at the home on the last night, when staff who feared Dean were left on shift with him.
The number of tablets taken has been given in several ways: more than 200 in most press accounts, and 237 tablets of one opioid and a capsule of another in the count at the home on November 17.
Dean's statement to police that Satan had told him it was the right thing to do was not accepted as evidence of illness. The psychiatrist who assessed him found no psychiatric illness, and the sentencing judge found that his capacity to make calculated decisions had not been affected in any relevant way.
His claim to St John of God Hospital in 2011 that he had bipolar disorder was not supported by his doctor's records, and the coroner found no evidence that he had ever been formally diagnosed.
Three further residents who died after November 18 were not the subject of murder counts. One of them had been among the eight grievous bodily harm counts; the coroner's findings on all three differ from his findings on the 11 residents named in the murder counts.
1976: Roger Dean is born.
December 23, 1996: Dean is registered as a nurse.
2002 to 2007: He works for St George Hospital and Community Health Services in mental health and drug and alcohol rehabilitation.
2004: He begins a Bachelor of Laws degree at Macquarie University.
July 2007: He takes a permanent night-shift nursing position at St John of God Hospital.
June 2011: He is suspended at St John of God after being found drug-affected at work, then reinstated on a doctor's letter.
April to November 2011: He sees ten different general practitioners and obtains prescriptions from most of them.
September 13, 2011: He begins night shifts at Quakers Hill Nursing Home.
September 19, 2011: He resigns from St John of God Hospital.
September 20, 2011: His contract with the nursing home is dated.
November 16 to 17, 2011: He spends more than two hours of a night shift alone in the treatment room.
November 17, 2011: Staff find 237 tablets of an opioid painkiller missing and call the police.
November 18, 2011: Dean commits the crimes at the nursing home; four residents die; that evening he admits responsibility to police.
November 19, 2011: A fifth resident dies; Dean has appeared in court on murder charges and is remanded in custody.
November 20 to 29, 2011: Six more residents die.
November 2012: Dean pleads not guilty in the Supreme Court; his offer to plead guilty to manslaughter has been refused.
May 27, 2013: On the day his trial is due to start, he pleads guilty to 11 counts of murder and eight counts of recklessly causing grievous bodily harm.
August 1, 2013: He is sentenced to life imprisonment on each murder count.
September to October 2014: The coronial inquest sits at Glebe.
March 9, 2015: The Deputy State Coroner delivers findings and recommendations.
September 2015: The Court of Criminal Appeal hears his sentence appeal and leaves the life terms in place.
November 2016: The High Court of Australia refuses him special leave to appeal.