Rodney Charles Collins spent most of his adult life passing through the courts of Victoria, and by the time his name could be published, in September 2012, he had more than fifty convictions to his record. Two of them defined him. In May 2010, at 64, he was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 32 years, for the murders of Raymon and Dorothy Abbey, a married couple killed in July 1987 in West Heidelberg, in Melbourne's north.
The sentence closed a case that had already run its course once. Within about a year of the deaths a coroner had found that another man contributed to them, and that man had been convicted and then acquitted. For two decades no conviction stood. Then, in June 2008, Collins surrendered to Victoria Police and was arrested for the 1987 killings, the result of an investigation by the Petra Task Force.
He was charged in a second case as well. In February 2009 he was charged with the 2004 murders of Terence and Christine Hodson in Kew, and a former detective was charged in the same case. Those charges were withdrawn in June 2010, after the prosecution's central witness was killed in prison, and they never came to trial. A coroner later found that he could not conclude, to the standard of proof the law requires, that either man was responsible. Collins denied any part in those deaths. He died in custody of natural causes in May 2018, at 72, long before he could first have sought parole.
The couple were killed in West Heidelberg in July 1987.
Their deaths would wait more than two decades for a conviction that held.
The first investigation produced a suspect. About a year after the deaths, the state coroner of the day found that a man, M. M., had contributed to the cause of death. M. M. was later tried and found guilty of the murders.
The conviction did not hold. The case came back before the courts, and M. M. was acquitted. By the time Collins was arrested in 2008, he had died. The acquittal left the West Heidelberg deaths in an awkward legal position: a coroner's finding naming one man, a verdict clearing him, and no conviction of anyone at all. So it remained for most of the next twenty years.
On the morning of Friday, June 6, 2008, a man from Northcote surrendered to Victoria Police and was arrested over the 1987 deaths. Police said that day that they expected to lay charges within hours, and that the arrest came out of the continuing work of the Petra Task Force, the unit investigating the Kew murders of 2004.
The man was Collins. He was charged with the two murders and the case moved toward trial. From that point the West Heidelberg prosecution and the Kew inquiry ran side by side, and for the whole of the first, Collins could not be named in public. He was identified only by his age and his record.
The case went to trial, and Collins was found guilty of both murders. On Friday, May 21, 2010, he was sentenced to life imprisonment on each count, with a non-parole period of 32 years. The man sentenced that day was described in public only as a 64-year-old career criminal whose name was suppressed for legal reasons.
He never reached the end of the non-parole period.
The Kew killings took place on or about May 15 or 16, 2004, in Melbourne's east.
On February 13, 2009, Collins was charged with both murders and remanded in custody on the new charges. On the same day a former detective was charged over the husband's death. The prosecution's case against both men depended on Carl Williams, the gangland figure who had given police statements about the killings.
That case did not survive Williams. He was killed in prison in 2010, and on June 7, 2010, the charges against Collins and the former detective were formally withdrawn at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court. Neither man was tried. Both denied any involvement.
The deaths then went to the Coroners Court of Victoria. The inquest opened before the State Coroner on May 19, 2014, by which time Collins was 69 and serving two life sentences, and from its first day he sought to be excused from giving evidence. The hearings ran through May and July of that year, with a last sitting in November. In the end neither Collins nor the former detective gave evidence; both were excused. On July 31, 2015, in Melbourne, the coroner handed down a 55-page finding in which he said he was unable to conclude that the two men were responsible for the deaths to the standard of proof required. Collins stood convicted of two murders, and no more.
Collins came before a court once more. On August 8, 2013, appearing by video-link from custody, he pleaded guilty at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court to one count of arson causing damage to a shop in Campbellfield, in Melbourne's north, in 1997. The fire had caused about $12,000 in damage. Sixteen years after the event, he had approached police about it himself. The magistrate imposed a sentence of two years' imprisonment, to be served concurrently with his sentences for the murders.
Collins died in custody in May 2018, aged 72. Corrections Victoria confirmed that he died of natural causes. By the middle of June, Victoria Police had applied to the coroner to have his guilty verdict formally entered in the coronial records of the 1987 deaths, the records that had once carried the finding against M. M.
From his arrest until September 2012, Collins was known in public only as a man who could not be named. The orders covered him through the West Heidelberg trial and sentence, while the Kew charges were still pending, and they stayed in place after those charges were withdrawn. On September 24, 2012, the Supreme Court of Victoria lifted the suppression orders. Only from that day could the career criminal sentenced in May 2010 be identified in public as Rodney Collins.
The Kew murders were never proved against Collins. He was charged with them on February 13, 2009; the charges were withdrawn on June 7, 2010, without a trial; and the coroner who examined the deaths in 2015 was unable to conclude that he was responsible to the required standard of proof. He denied involvement throughout.
When Collins was arrested in June 2008, police said they believed more than one person had taken part in the West Heidelberg killings and that two of those involved had since died. Neither was ever convicted. The earlier coroner's finding against M. M. was overtaken by his acquittal, and the acquittal stands.
July 1987: A married couple are killed in West Heidelberg, Melbourne.
About 1988: A coroner finds that M. M. contributed to the deaths; M. M. is later convicted, then acquitted.
May 15 or 16, 2004: A married couple are killed in Kew.
June 6, 2008: Collins surrenders to Victoria Police and is arrested over the 1987 deaths.
February 13, 2009: Collins and a former detective are charged with the Kew murders.
May 21, 2010: Collins, unnamed for legal reasons, is sentenced to life imprisonment with a 32-year non-parole period for the 1987 murders.
June 7, 2010: The Kew charges are withdrawn at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court.
September 24, 2012: The Supreme Court of Victoria lifts the orders suppressing his name.
August 8, 2013: Collins pleads guilty to a 1997 arson in Campbellfield; two years, concurrent.
May 19, 2014: The inquest into the Kew deaths opens before the State Coroner; Collins is later excused from giving evidence.
July 31, 2015: The coroner is unable to conclude that Collins and the former detective were responsible for the Kew deaths.
May 2018: Collins dies in custody of natural causes, aged 72.
June 2018: Victoria Police applies to the coroner to record his guilty verdict in the 1987 coronial records.