Five members of one family died in North Epping, in Sydney's north-west, in the early hours of July 18, 2009. They were the man who ran the family's newsagency business, his wife, her sister and the couple's two young sons. Nearly two years later police charged a relative: Lian Bin Xie, known as Robert, a former ear, nose and throat specialist who had come to Australia from China in 2002 and was married to the dead man's sister. He lived in the same suburb, a short walk away.
Xie pleaded not guilty and has never stopped saying he is innocent. His case went through four trials in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Two juries were discharged before they could deliberate, and a third, after a trial of about nine months, could not agree on a verdict. The fourth jury, on January 12, 2017, found him guilty of all five murders by a majority verdict. A month later he was sentenced to life imprisonment on each count without the possibility of parole. The Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed his appeal against the convictions in February 2021.
The dead were Min Lin, known as Norman; his wife, Yun Li Lin, known as Lily; her younger sister, Yun Bin Lin, known as Irene; and the couple's two sons. The family was part of a wider circle of relatives in Sydney who met regularly, and Xie and his wife belonged to that circle. His wife was the dead man's sister.
The family's newsagency business in Epping, and the property the family held, later became part of the Crown's case. In 2014 a court heard that Xie and his wife had wanted to take over the newsagency and were trying to sell a restaurant in Melbourne at the time, and that the head of the Lin family had told Xie he would have to take on the business's loans if he wanted it. The Crown said Xie disputed those terms and never took up an invitation to inspect the books, and that the newsagent tried to keep him out of meetings about a possible sale.
On July 29, 2009, eleven days after the killings, Xie and his wife stood together in public and appealed for help in finding whoever was responsible.
The inquiry ran for almost two years and reached across Australia and China. The New South Wales Crime Commission took part. In May 2010, ten months after the deaths, investigators recovered material at Xie's property, about 300 meters away, that the Crown later said linked him to the killings. It became the most contested evidence in the case.
On the morning of May 5, 2011, police arrested Xie in North Epping. He was 47. He was questioned at Parramatta Police Station and charged with five counts of murder, and bail was refused. In December 2012 he was committed to stand trial in the Supreme Court.
The first trial began on May 9, 2014, before a judge of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Xie pleaded not guilty to all five counts. On June 10, 2014, a month in, the jury was discharged for legal reasons.
A second trial opened on August 5, 2014, before the same judge. On September 23, 2014, that jury too was discharged, this time because the judge had fallen ill.
The third trial began in February 2015 before a different judge of the court. The Crown's evidence was largely circumstantial. The jury began deliberating on November 12, 2015, and on December 1, after about nine months of trial, it was discharged without reaching a verdict. On December 11, 2015, after almost five years in custody without a conviction, Xie was granted bail.
The fourth trial opened on June 29, 2016, before the judge who had presided over the third, and lasted about six months. The Crown relied heavily on expert evidence about the material recovered in May 2010. The defense answered with an alibi: his wife told the court that he had been asleep beside her the whole night. Xie gave evidence himself and told the jury that he had not killed the family.
On December 23, 2016, as the trial neared its end, his bail was revoked. The jury retired on December 30.
On January 12, 2017, on the eighth day of deliberations, the jury returned guilty verdicts on all five counts of murder. The trial judge had allowed a majority verdict, and the jury divided eleven to one. As the jurors left the courtroom, Xie said, "I am innocent."
On Monday, February 13, 2017, in the Supreme Court in Sydney, the judge sentenced Xie to life imprisonment on each of the five counts, without the possibility of parole. Xie, then 53, showed no reaction in court.
The appeal came before the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal on June 22, 2020, more than three years after the verdict, and ran over several days. Xie, then 56, appeared by video link from a New South Wales prison. Three of his grounds attacked the expert evidence on the 2010 material, which the defense said had been misleading, confusing and unfairly prejudicial. Others alleged that his trial barrister had let him down and that the judge had misdirected the jury, including on his alibi and on evidence the Crown had said showed a consciousness of guilt.
On February 15, 2021, a three-judge bench, the Chief Justice of New South Wales and two justices of appeal, dismissed the appeal, finding that Xie had not suffered a miscarriage of justice. He is serving five life sentences in New South Wales and has maintained throughout that he is innocent.
Xie has denied the murders since he was charged in 2011 and denied them again when the verdicts were read. His wife gave evidence supporting his alibi. The defense argued at trial that more than one person had probably taken part in the killings; the jury convicted Xie, and no other person has been charged.
The expert evidence on the material recovered in May 2010 was contested at every stage. The defense disputed what the material was and whose it was, argued that it could have come from other living relatives, among them his wife, and said the evidence did not address when it had been left there. The Court of Criminal Appeal rejected those complaints in 2021. The Crown alleged at trial that resentment of his standing in the extended family drove the killings; the verdict established guilt, not the motive.
Reports give the age of the dead man's wife as 43 or 44, and Xie's age at sentencing as 53 or 58.
2002: Xie, an ear, nose and throat specialist, moves to Australia from China.
July 18, 2009: Five members of his wife's family die in North Epping, Sydney.
July 29, 2009: Xie and his wife make a public appeal for help.
May 2010: Investigators recover the material that later becomes the central contested evidence.
May 5, 2011: Xie is arrested in North Epping and charged with five counts of murder; bail is refused.
December 19, 2012: He is committed to stand trial in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
May 9, 2014: The first trial begins.
June 10, 2014: The first jury is discharged for legal reasons.
August 5, 2014: The second trial begins.
September 23, 2014: The second jury is discharged because the judge is ill.
February 2015: The third trial begins before a different judge.
December 1, 2015: The third jury is discharged without reaching a verdict.
December 11, 2015: Xie is granted bail.
June 29, 2016: The fourth trial begins.
December 23, 2016: His bail is revoked.
December 30, 2016: The jury retires.
January 12, 2017: Xie is found guilty of five counts of murder by an eleven to one majority.
February 13, 2017: He is sentenced to life imprisonment on each count without parole.
June 22, 2020: His appeal against the convictions is heard in the Court of Criminal Appeal.
February 15, 2021: The Court of Criminal Appeal dismisses the appeal.