Robert Lewis Dear

Victims
3 people killed in Colorado Springs, 2015. Charged, never tried; repeatedly found incompetent; died before any trial
Years active
November 27, 2015
Location
Colorado Springs, Colorado (killings); Hartsel, Colorado (residence); Pueblo, Colorado (state hospital); Springfield, Missouri (federal custody and death).
Method
Shot (state charges and the 2019 federal indictment allege it; no court ever tried the charges).
Status
Found incompetent in state court May 11, 2016, and federal court in 2021; forced medication upheld 2024. Died untried in federal custody, Springfield, Missouri, November 22, 2025.

On November 27, 2015, the day after Thanksgiving, three people were killed and nine others were hurt at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado Springs, Colorado. The dead were Garrett Swasey, an officer of the University of Colorado Colorado Springs police department who had gone to help; Ke'Arre Stewart; and Jennifer Markovsky. Robert Lewis Dear Jr., a 57-year-old man who lived on remote land in Hartsel, about 65 miles west of the city, surrendered to police the same day and was taken into custody.

He was never tried. The State of Colorado charged him with 179 counts, including murder and attempted murder, and in December 2019 a federal grand jury in Denver indicted him on 68 more under a 1994 law that protects patients and providers of reproductive health services. Within months of his arrest a state judge found him incompetent to stand trial, and every evaluator who examined him over the following decade reached the same conclusion. Two courts ordered him medicated against his will in an effort to restore his competency, a federal appeals court upheld the second of those orders, and the Supreme Court of the United States declined to disturb it. None of it brought the case to a jury. On November 22, 2025, he died in federal custody in Springfield, Missouri, with every charge still pending. In law he died an accused man, and the three deaths in Colorado Springs were never adjudicated.

Dear had spent most of his life in North and South Carolina and had also lived in Kentucky. An online check of court records after his arrest showed no criminal conviction. Some time before the attack he had moved west and settled in Hartsel, an isolated mountain community, where he lived in a secluded trailer without electricity.

The 2019 federal indictment, which set out the government's case in detail, alleged that he attacked the clinic because it provided abortion services, and that all three deaths came before he surrendered. The final count of the hurt was never fixed in a courtroom. The 4th Judicial District Attorney's Office put the wounded at nine, five of them law enforcement officers and four civilians; the federal prosecutors put them at no fewer than eight, four of them officers. Every one of these facts remained an allegation. No witness ever testified to them before a jury, and no court ever found them proved.

Each of the three who died had come for someone else. The officer belonged to the university's own police department and was not assigned to the clinic; he went when he heard that people were in danger there, and he was the officer who died before the day was over. The second man had made his life in Colorado Springs and had come to the clinic that day to accompany someone, not on any business of his own. The woman had grown up on Oahu, in Hawaii, and had come a long way from the islands to Colorado; she had gone that Friday to support a friend.

The state filed its 179 counts in the 4th Judicial District, the trial court for El Paso and Teller counties, in December 2015. No plea was ever entered. That same month the chief judge of the district ordered an evaluation of his competency to proceed.

Two court-appointed state psychologists examined him over the winter. Their report, filed in March 2016, found that he had a delusional disorder centered on a belief that the FBI was persecuting him, and that the illness left him unable to trust almost anyone, his own lawyers included.

On May 11, 2016, the chief judge ruled him incompetent to proceed. The ruling found that the illness shaped how Dear saw nearly everything about the case, including his belief that his own public defenders were working for the federal government, and that his perceptions of the proceedings were not rational. The criminal case was suspended, and Dear was committed to the state psychiatric hospital in Pueblo for treatment aimed at restoring his competency, with progress reports to the court every 90 days. Prosecutors had not yet decided whether to seek the death penalty, and that decision, like everything else in the case, now waited on his recovery.

The restoration never came. At each periodic reexamination the state psychiatrists found Dear still incompetent, and he refused antipsychotic medication. The state court ordered him medicated involuntarily in August 2017, and the Colorado Court of Appeals affirmed the order, but by the time the appellate court ruled, the order had expired. After further hearings the state court decided that changes in Dear's physical health meant forced medication was no longer in his best medical interests. Another El Paso County judge upheld the incompetency finding in 2020.

By late 2019 he had been in state custody for about four years without a trial date, and federal prosecutions under the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act must be brought within five years. On December 9, 2019, a federal grand jury in Denver returned a 68-count indictment against him: 65 counts of violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act and three counts each alleging a crime of violence resulting in death where the killing was murder. The state case remained open and would proceed separately.

When he sought to waive counsel and represent himself in the federal case, the government asked for a competency evaluation under the federal statute, and he was transferred to the United States Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri, a Bureau of Prisons facility that evaluates and treats defendants with mental illness. On December 2, 2020, federal prosecutors announced that they would not seek the death penalty. The examining psychologist at Springfield concluded that Dear remained incompetent because of his delusional disorder, persecutory type, but that he was substantially likely to be restored with antipsychotic medication. In September 2021 a federal judge declared him mentally incompetent to stand trial, and because Dear would not take the medication voluntarily, the government moved to have him treated against his will.

The district court heard experts on both sides in a three-day hearing in late August 2022, and they disagreed sharply over whether medication could restore him. On September 19, 2022, the senior district judge granted the motion. He found that the government's interest in bringing Dear to trial was important, given the seriousness of the charged crimes and the severity of the possible penalties; that medication was substantially likely to render him competent and substantially unlikely to cause side effects that would interfere with his ability to assist counsel; that no less intrusive treatment offered any real chance of restoration; and that the medication was medically appropriate and in his best medical interest. Dear appealed, and the order was stayed until the appeal was decided.

On June 10, 2024, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed. Its published opinion, United States v. Dear, 104 F.4th 145, held that the district court had made sufficiently detailed findings tied to Dear's own condition and circumstances rather than to the general success of antipsychotics in people with his disorder, and that it had not clearly erred in giving greater weight to the government's experts. The court noted that it was undisputed that Dear posed no danger in a tightly controlled, prison-like setting, so the case turned entirely on competency to stand trial. The full court declined to rehear the appeal that August, and in February 2025 the Supreme Court of the United States denied certiorari in Dear v. United States, No. 24-6395, letting the Tenth Circuit's judgment take effect.

Late in February 2025 the district court ruled that the treatment plan could be carried out by force if necessary, and on April 10, 2025, Dear was returned to the medical center in Springfield to begin it. The state case stayed on hold.

The medication did not do what the government's experts had predicted. On August 8, 2025, a forensic evaluator found that Dear remained incompetent and was unlikely to be restored for the foreseeable future. At a federal hearing in September 2025 the judge announced the same conclusions, which neither side contested. The indictment was not dismissed, and the court granted a joint motion to civilly commit him to a federal medical facility rather than return him to Colorado. No new federal court date was set.

Robert Lewis Dear Jr. died on Saturday, November 22, 2025, at the United States Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri. He was 67. The Federal Bureau of Prisons confirmed the death three days later. The 4th Judicial District Attorney's Office said it would begin the process of dismissing the state case once it received his official death certificate. The federal indictment was still pending when he died. Neither prosecution had ever come within sight of a jury.

Every fact about what happened on November 27, 2015, rests on charging documents, the federal indictment and the courts' summaries of what the indictment alleged; no jury heard evidence and no court made findings of guilt. He never entered a plea, and anything he said about the case was said by a man the courts found unable to understand the proceedings against him. The state charges were never tested, the federal charges never reached trial, and in law he died presumed innocent of all of them.

Whether he could ever have been restored to competency was itself contested to the end. The government's experts thought it likely, the defense experts did not, and the evaluation of August 2025, made after months of court-ordered medication, found him unlikely to be restored. Some local reports placed the Tenth Circuit's decision in June 2023; the opinion itself is dated June 10, 2024.

Timeline

November 27, 2015: Three people are killed and nine others are hurt in Colorado Springs, Colorado; Dear surrenders to police and is arrested the same day.

December 2015: 179 state counts filed in the 4th Judicial District; the chief judge orders a competency evaluation.

May 11, 2016: Found incompetent to proceed; committed to the state psychiatric hospital in Pueblo.

August 2017: State court orders involuntary medication; the Colorado Court of Appeals later affirms after the order has expired.

December 9, 2019: Federal grand jury in Denver indicts him on 68 counts.

2020: An El Paso County judge upholds the state incompetency finding.

December 2, 2020: Federal prosecutors announce they will not seek the death penalty.

September 2021: A federal judge finds him mentally incompetent to stand trial.

September 19, 2022: The district court orders him medicated against his will; the order is stayed pending appeal.

June 10, 2024: The Tenth Circuit affirms the order in United States v. Dear, 104 F.4th 145.

February 2025: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari.

April 10, 2025: Returned to the federal medical center in Springfield, Missouri, to begin medication.

August 8, 2025: An evaluator finds him still incompetent and unlikely to be restored.

September 2025: The federal court accepts that finding and grants a joint motion for civil commitment; the indictment is not dismissed.

November 22, 2025: Dies in federal custody in Springfield, Missouri, aged 67, never tried.