Robert Latimer farmed wheat and canola near Wilkie, in west-central Saskatchewan, and on October 24, 1993, he ended the life of his 12-year-old daughter, a child who had lived all her years with a severe form of cerebral palsy. He was 40. Within two weeks he had confessed, and he has never denied what he did. What he has denied ever since is that it was a crime.
Two juries disagreed with him. In November 1994 and again in November 1997, jurors in Saskatchewan found him guilty of second-degree murder, and both juries asked that he be spared the long prison term the law required. The second trial judge went further and granted him a constitutional exemption from that term. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal reversed him, and on January 18, 2001, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled unanimously that the minimum sentence for second-degree murder, life imprisonment with no parole for ten years, must stand in his case. He went to prison that month. He left on day parole in March 2008 and was granted full parole from December 2010, still bound by the life sentence; in 2018 he asked the federal government to reopen his case.
Latimer and his wife married in 1978 and raised their family on a 1,280-acre grain farm near Wilkie, about 35 kilometers south of Battleford. They had four children. Their eldest daughter was born on November 23, 1980, in North Battleford. The youngest child was born in August 1993, two months before her death.
The courts later described the girl in the plain language of a legal record. She was severely disabled and had a rare form of cerebral palsy; she experienced chronic pain; she was said to have the mental capacity of a four-month-old baby and could neither speak nor walk. The parole board's appeal division, reviewing the file in 2008, recorded that her father had cared for her over a thirteen-year period. She had undergone operations at the ages of four and nine, and again in August 1992. Her family kept a diary of her days, and its entries describe her as cheerful. Testimony at the 1997 trial described a girl who enjoyed life, went to school and spent time with her family.
In the summer of 1993, shortly before the birth of the youngest Latimer child, the girl was placed in a group home. She came back to the farm in October. On October 12, 1993, her parents were told that she needed further surgery, an operation on her hip, and that intense pain should be expected afterward. Latimer later explained his decision as a father's duty to protect her from what he regarded as unnecessary torture. Prosecutors and the courts treated the same facts very differently: the Supreme Court of Canada would find that her situation "was not an emergency" and that her health might have improved had her parents not rejected the option of a feeding tube.
On Sunday, October 24, 1993, Latimer's wife and the other children went to church. Latimer stayed behind with his eldest daughter, and while the family was away he ended her life near Wilkie. Her funeral was held on October 27.
On November 1, 1993, police reclassified the death as a homicide. On November 4, they arrested Latimer and charged him with first-degree murder. When police put their evidence to him, he confessed, while maintaining that he had not committed a criminal act. He spent eight days in jail before a court released him on conditions.
Latimer went on trial for first-degree murder in the Court of Queen's Bench for Saskatchewan in November 1994. On November 16, 1994, the jury convicted him of the lesser offense of second-degree murder. The judge imposed the sentence the Criminal Code required for that offense: life imprisonment, with no eligibility for parole for ten years. The jurors had unanimously recommended that he become eligible for parole as early as possible.
On November 25, 1994, Latimer was granted bail pending appeal. By then his case had become a public cause. Grassroots campaigns had begun collecting signatures for a pardon or a lighter sentence, and on December 4, 1994, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association called for his release and for an end to mandatory minimum sentences. Disability organizations took the opposite position, arguing that leniency would place children and adults with disabilities at risk.
Before the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal, the defense asked, among other things, for a suspended sentence in place of the life term. On July 18, 1995, the court dismissed the appeal by a vote of two to one; the dissenting judge would have found the sentence too long under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Latimer then sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Three months later the case turned on a revelation that had nothing to do with Latimer's daughter. On October 25, 1995, it became public that before the first trial, at the request of the Crown prosecutor, officers of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police had gathered information from prospective jurors about their views on religion, abortion and mercy killing. Some of the people questioned had been contacted directly, and two of those questioned had gone on to sit on the jury that convicted Latimer. The defense had uncovered the contacts and passed its information to the Crown.
Saskatchewan Justice moved quickly. On October 26, 1995, the department announced that senior prosecutors had confirmed direct contact between the police and both prospective jurors and jurors. It did not suggest that the jury had been biased, but it accepted that the contact created a perception that Latimer might not have been tried by an impartial jury, and the Crown would consent to his application to the Supreme Court of Canada and to the admission of fresh evidence there. Because the provincial appeal court had already ruled, only the Supreme Court could set the verdict aside.
The Supreme Court granted leave and admitted the new evidence. On February 6, 1997, it ruled: "The appeal is allowed. The order of the Court of Appeal dismissing the appeal and the conviction entered by the trial judge are set aside, and a new trial is ordered." The court did not give Latimer everything he had asked for. The defense had argued that the confession should be thrown out and Latimer acquitted because of how the police had acted; the court declined, leaving any question about the confession to the judge at the new trial. Saskatchewan's justice department announced that he would be retried for second-degree murder.
The retrial opened at Battleford in late October 1997 in the Court of Queen's Bench. The Crown called 17 witnesses to show that her pain had been no greater than that of many children with disabilities, and it put before the jury a journal in which her mother had written warmly of her daughter. The defense argued that Latimer had acted to relieve her pain and had seen no other choice.
The trial judge told the jurors that they had two options: guilty of second-degree murder, or not guilty. Manslaughter was not open to them, he instructed, because Latimer had clearly acted with intent. On November 5, 1997, the jury returned its verdict: guilty of second-degree murder. Latimer said afterward that he and his family had been hoping for an acquittal, and that he did not believe the jurors had understood the extent of his daughter's problems.
After the verdict, the judge told the jurors that the offense carried a minimum of ten years before parole eligibility and that they could recommend a period anywhere from ten to twenty-five years. The jury recommended, unanimously, that Latimer be eligible for parole after one year.
The defense then asked the trial judge to exempt Latimer from the mandatory minimum on the ground that, in his case, it would be cruel and unusual punishment under section 12 of the Charter. On December 1, 1997, the judge granted the exemption, ruling that Latimer's section 12 Charter right had been violated, and sentenced him to one year in jail, to be followed by a year of probation. Latimer was taken to jail that day. The Crown appealed the sentence, Latimer appealed his conviction, and later that month he was released on bail pending the appeal.
Six disability organizations intervened jointly in the Crown's appeal. On November 23, 1998, the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal ruled unanimously. It dismissed Latimer's appeal against conviction, allowed the Crown's appeal against sentence, set aside the constitutional exemption and imposed the sentence fixed by Parliament: life imprisonment with no eligibility for parole for ten years.
The Supreme Court of Canada granted Latimer leave to appeal in 1999, and a long list of groups on both sides of the public argument intervened. The unanimous judgment came on January 18, 2001. Latimer had argued that the trial judge should have let the jury consider the defense of necessity, that his trial had been unfair because the judge delayed ruling on that defense, and that the mandatory minimum was cruel and unusual punishment as applied to him. "We conclude that the answer to all three questions is no," the court wrote, as reports of the judgment quoted it.
On necessity, the court described the defense as one that "is narrow and of limited application in criminal law," and it found "no air of reality" to it on the evidence. The girl's situation, it held, was not an emergency, and the pain she suffered could not be weighed as comparable to the harm of ending a life. The trial judge's delay in ruling on the defense had not made the trial unfair.
On the sentence, the court held that the minimum penalty "is not grossly disproportionate in this case" and that there was therefore no basis for granting a constitutional exemption. Of the purposes of punishment, it found that rehabilitation, specific deterrence and protection of the public were not engaged by Latimer's case; denunciation was. The mandatory minimum, the court wrote, "plays an important role in denouncing murder," and the mitigating factors did not "displace the serious gravity of this case." The court also noted that the royal prerogative of mercy was "a matter for the executive, not the courts," leaving any clemency to the federal government.
The appeals against conviction and sentence were dismissed. A later motion asking the court to rehear the case was dismissed on May 14, 2002.
In January 2001 Latimer was sent to a minimum-security federal institution in British Columbia. His years there are set out in the parole board's later records. He incurred no institutional charges and raised no security concerns. He completed a series of counseling sessions in 2001, worked, and took courses to upgrade his education and job skills; he was not required to take any other correctional program because no outstanding risk factors were found. He was classified as a minimum-security offender from 2003. In 2005 he was allowed out under escort, for compassionate reasons, to attend a family funeral.
The psychiatric and psychological reports in his file, from 2001 to 2007, assessed him as a low risk, with the caution that his risk would rise significantly if he were again responsible for a severely disabled person. A correctional plan report of September 21, 2007, found high reintegration potential and a low risk to public safety, and the Correctional Service of Canada recommended day parole.
On December 5, 2007, a National Parole Board panel turned him down. The board found that he lacked insight and understanding into the factors behind his decision to end his daughter's life, that he struggled to give coherent explanations and that he was unable or unwilling to answer questions. It treated the care of a severely disabled family member as a "normal occurrence" and suggested that his wish to keep pursuing his legal case raised doubts about whether he would comply with parole supervision.
Latimer appealed, and on February 27, 2008, the board's appeal division reversed the decision. It found the panel's conclusions unreasonable and unsupported. Latimer had shown insight, the appeal division wrote, and had been able to explain why he decided to end his daughter's life after thirteen years of caring for her; he had not said he would disobey the law, only that he disagreed with it and would keep challenging it through proper legal channels. His circumstances had been unique, his conduct on bail and in prison had been fully compliant for many years, and both juries had recommended early parole. The appeal division ordered him released on day parole as soon as a halfway house bed was available, under two special conditions: that he not have responsibility for, or make decisions for, any severely disabled person, and that he take part in psychological counseling.
Latimer had asked to live in Ottawa, where he had family support and work prospects and where he planned to lobby politicians over his life sentence; he told the board that, given the attention his case drew, it was better for now not to return to the farm. On March 17, 2008, he began day parole at a halfway house in Ottawa. He told a reporter that he wanted a new jury trial and that he knew his chances were poor: "I don't think anyone has any confidence that I'll get anywhere but if you don't ask, you definitely won't get anywhere."
The National Parole Board granted him full parole in late 2010, effective December 6. He remained subject to conditions and to the possibility that his parole could be revoked. In 2011, in his first interview after full parole, he said that his daughter's death "wasn't sad" and called her surgeries torture, while acknowledging that her own wishes could not be known.
The conditions of his parole became the subject of further hearings. In 2012 the board cleared him to attend a debate on assisted suicide and mercy killing in Britain, but he did not obtain a visa and could not go. In mid-2013 a board panel removed the requirement that he attend one-on-one counseling, agreeing with a psychologist who rated his risk of reoffending as low to very low. It kept the ban on his taking responsibility for anyone with a significant disability, rejecting his case managers' view that monitoring would be enough, and refused his request to travel outside Canada without first applying for a limited-time passport for each trip. The appeal division upheld that refusal in November 2013. In February 2014 the board also turned down his request to travel to Peru, Bolivia and Venezuela to do volunteer work, saying the request lacked detail.
Latimer took the travel condition to the Federal Court, which heard his application in Vancouver. In September 2014 the court ruled that the board and its appeal division "did not exercise their broad discretion in a reasonable, transparent or intelligible manner," noted that his parole team had reported positive behavior, limited risk and full compliance, and sent the matter back to the appeal division. In November 2014 the board again refused to lift the restriction. On March 3, 2015, the appeal division reversed that decision, holding that it conflicted with the Federal Court's ruling and that "a further delay in relieving you from adhering to the condition would be unfair." From then on he had only to notify his parole officer in writing of his destination and the length of any trip abroad.
In February 2015, when the Supreme Court of Canada struck down the Criminal Code's ban on doctor-assisted death, Latimer said the ruling gave hope to people in pain and that he could not see how ending one person's suffering threatened anyone else.
On July 11, 2018, an application on his behalf went to the prime minister and the federal justice minister asking for a new trial or a pardon. It argued a miscarriage of justice that had never been considered at trial or on appeal: that stronger pain relief had been unlawfully and unfairly withheld from his daughter. Latimer, then 65, said he lived under the constant risk that his parole could be revoked and continued to maintain his innocence. The Canadian Association for Community Living urged the government to refuse. The government's response to the application is not on record.
From the first trial onward, the case divided the country, and each side spoke through its own organizations. Latimer's supporters described him as a loving father who acted out of compassion; by the second trial they had contributed more than $90,000 to his legal costs, and by 1997 Parliament had received petitions carrying close to 20,000 names asking that he be pardoned. A 1999 Ipsos poll found a majority of Canadians favoring a lenient sentence. Advocates of a legal right to die cited the case as a reason to reconsider the laws on euthanasia and assisted suicide.
Disability rights organizations, among them the Council of Canadians with Disabilities, the Saskatchewan Voice of People with Disabilities and the Canadian Association for Community Living, argued that leniency would signal that the lives of disabled people were worth less and would put them at risk. Latimer himself has said consistently that, with no lawful way to end her suffering, his decision was the right one.
Accounts of the December 1, 1997, sentence differ: one reference account gives one year in jail followed by a year of probation, a contemporary magazine report gives two years less a day with one year to be served in jail, and other reports call it a two-year sentence.
The extent of the girl's pain was contested at both trials. Latimer and his wife described it as constant; the Crown's witnesses at the second trial set out to show that it was no worse than that of many children with disabilities, and the Supreme Court of Canada held that her situation was not an emergency.
The 2018 application rests on the claim that stronger pain relief was wrongly withheld from her. At trial, doctors testified that stronger drugs could have been dangerous or fatal for her, and the family believed that an ordinary over-the-counter pain reliever was the only medication they could give her. No court has ruled on the claim in the application.
The juror contacts before the first trial led the Supreme Court of Canada to order a new trial on the basis of the perception of unfairness. The province's own position, set out in October 1995, was that there was no actual prejudice and that the jury had done its duty fairly.
November 23, 1980: Latimer's eldest daughter is born in North Battleford, Saskatchewan.
October 12, 1993: Her parents are told she needs further surgery.
October 24, 1993: Latimer ends her life near Wilkie, Saskatchewan.
November 1, 1993: Police reclassify the death as a homicide.
November 4, 1993: Latimer is arrested, charged with first-degree murder and confesses.
November 16, 1994: A jury convicts him of second-degree murder; life, no parole for ten years.
July 18, 1995: The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal dismisses his appeal, two to one.
October 25 and 26, 1995: Police contact with prospective jurors becomes public; Saskatchewan Justice consents to a further appeal.
February 6, 1997: The Supreme Court of Canada sets aside the conviction and orders a new trial.
November 5, 1997: A second jury in Battleford convicts him of second-degree murder and recommends parole eligibility after one year.
December 1, 1997: The trial judge grants a constitutional exemption: one year in jail and one year of probation.
November 23, 1998: The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal restores the life sentence with no parole for ten years.
January 18, 2001: The Supreme Court of Canada dismisses his appeals; he begins serving his sentence.
December 5, 2007: The National Parole Board denies day parole.
February 27, 2008: The board's appeal division orders his release on day parole.
March 17, 2008: He begins day parole at a halfway house in Ottawa.
December 6, 2010: Full parole takes effect.
September 2014: The Federal Court sends his travel condition back to the parole board.
March 3, 2015: The appeal division allows him to travel abroad on written notice.
July 11, 2018: An application on his behalf asks the federal government for a new trial or a pardon.