On the morning of Monday, October 28, 2002, in the middle of midterm examinations, three women who taught at the University of Arizona College of Nursing in Tucson were killed, and the student the police held responsible, Robert Stewart Flores Jr., died by suicide before the morning was over. He was 41, a Gulf War veteran and a third-semester nursing student who was failing his courses. Because he died that day, he was never charged, and no court ever heard the evidence. What is known of the three deaths rests on the findings of the Tucson and University of Arizona police.
The deaths did not come without warning. For years, members of the nursing faculty had written down their unease about him, and two of them eventually took it to the university police. When the university made its file on him public that December, it ran to 331 pages and reached back to 1995.
Flores lived alone in Tucson with a Great Dane named Bridget. After his service in the Persian Gulf War he trained as a licensed practical nurse, and through a nursing agency he worked shifts at the Southern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care System while he studied to become a registered nurse. Between October 1999 and September 2002 he put in 362 days there, and no employee or patient ever filed a complaint against him.
His academic record had been troubled for most of a decade. He had been held back and had rejoined the program with the senior class the year before the deaths, and a letter from the university's Health Sciences Center warned him that his grades could get him disqualified. By the fall of 2002 he had failed one required course and was taking it again, and he was failing another. He refused to withdraw from the program, and an administrator sent him to the university's Learning Center, an office that dealt with academic skills rather than counseling.
The warnings reached the police in April 2001, when two members of the nursing faculty went to the University of Arizona Police Department. Flores, they reported, had said he was depressed, had thought of ending his life and might act against the college. An officer tried to reach him by telephone and could not, and left a message saying he would follow up. The faculty members said they would keep watch and report anything further. No further call about him reached the police before October 2002, and university officials said after the deaths that the report had not been followed up. A witness also told police that Flores had recently threatened the College of Nursing.
Robin Rogers had taught at the college since 1996. She was devout, sang at her church in Tucson every week and helped with its services, and her office door was always open to students. Cheryl McGaffic was born in Phoenix. Faith was at the center of her life, and she was weighing a move into the Episcopal church's chaplaincy; she sat on the board of the Tucson AIDS Project, cared about social justice and had a gift for reaching people in grief, and she wrote stories drawn from her own years at the bedside. Barbara Monroe had come to the University of Arizona only the year before. She was known for her humor and her bright personality, and she pushed her students to learn. On the Monday before her death she came to a college costume contest dressed as a hospital patient.
University and Tucson police secured the building within minutes, confirmed that Flores was dead and that no one else was involved, and named the three women and Flores that day. On the evening of October 29 the Arizona Daily Star received a long typed letter from him, postmarked the day of the deaths, in which he set out grievances against the College of Nursing. Police said the next day that they had no reason to doubt it was genuine and took it as evidence.
No court ever tested the case against Flores. The account of that morning rests on police statements and on what people inside the building saw. His letter is the only statement of his motives, and it denied that he acted from revenge; no court examined it.
1995: The College of Nursing's file on Flores begins.
October 1999 to September 2002: Flores works shifts at the Southern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care System through a nursing agency.
April 2001: Two members of the nursing faculty tell the University of Arizona police that Flores is depressed and has spoken of acting against the college.
October 28, 2002: Three of his instructors die at the College of Nursing in Tucson; Flores dies by suicide the same morning.
October 29, 2002: A letter from Flores reaches the Arizona Daily Star.
December 2002: The university releases 331 pages of records on Flores's years at the college.