On the morning of July 4, 2022, the Independence Day parade in Highland Park, Illinois, a lakeside suburb north of Chicago, ended in the deaths of seven people and the wounding of 48 more. Robert E. Crimo III, a 21-year-old who had gone to school in the town, was taken into custody that evening and admitted the killings to investigators. Nearly three years later, on the day his trial was to open in Waukegan, he pleaded guilty to every count left against him: 21 counts of first-degree murder and 48 counts of attempted first-degree murder. In April 2025 a Lake County judge sentenced him to seven consecutive terms of natural life without parole, one for each person killed, and 48 concurrent terms of 50 years for the wounded.
The case did not end quickly. Between his arrest and his plea, Crimo dismissed the Lake County public defender to represent himself, asked for the lawyers back within weeks, came to court in June 2024 apparently ready to plead guilty and then refused, and lost a long fight over whether his recorded statements to police could be heard by a jury. His father, who had sponsored his 2019 application for a state ownership permit, pleaded guilty in November 2023 to seven misdemeanor counts of reckless conduct.
Crimo grew up in Highland Park and attended its schools. In September 2019 the Highland Park police received a report that he had made threats. Officers spoke with him, and no one was arrested. The department sent a clear-and-present-danger report on him to the Illinois State Police, which did not keep it because he held no state permit and had no application pending. Three months later he applied for one, and the state police approved it in January 2020.
The parade in downtown Highland Park was underway when the killings began. Six people died that morning, and a seventh died the next day. Prosecutors put the number of wounded named in the charges at 48.
The seven who died were Katherine Goldstein of Highland Park, an avid bird watcher who loved to travel and to cook; Stephen Straus, born and raised on Chicago's South Side, who had lived in Highland Park for decades and came to its parade every year; Irina McCarthy, Kevin McCarthy and Jacquelyn Sundheim, known as Jacki, all of Highland Park; Nicolas Toledo-Zaragoza, a native of Morelos, Mexico, who had first come to the United States in the 1980s and spent many years in the Highland Park area; and Eduardo Uvaldo, of Waukegan, who died on July 5.
Officers of the North Chicago police arrested Crimo late on July 4, a few hours after the parade, and he admitted the killings once he was in custody. Over two days of questioning he gave investigators a videotaped account and signed written waivers of his rights.
The investigation was led by a Lake County major crimes task force and the Highland Park police, working with the FBI and other federal partners, among them the United States Attorney's Office; the charges themselves were brought in state court by the county. On July 5 the Lake County State's Attorney charged him with seven counts of first-degree murder, one for each person killed, and announced that these were only the first of many charges to come. At a hearing the next day a judge ordered him held without bond, finding that he posed a specific and present threat to the community, and appointed the public defender.
A Lake County grand jury returned an indictment on July 27, 2022, on 117 felony counts: 21 counts of first-degree murder, three for each of the seven dead, 48 counts of attempted murder and 48 counts of aggravated battery, one of each for every person wounded. At his arraignment in Waukegan on August 3, 2022, before the judge who would hear the case to its end, a plea of not guilty was entered on his behalf.
The case moved slowly through 2023. In December of that year Crimo dismissed his public defenders and was allowed to represent himself. The arrangement lasted less than a month: in January 2024 he asked for the public defenders to be reinstated, and the judge agreed.
By the summer of 2024 the State's Attorney's office believed it had a resolution. Under the proposed agreement Crimo would plead guilty to 55 counts, the seven murders and the 48 counts of aggravated battery, and would receive natural life imprisonment. In June 2024 he came to court apparently prepared to accept it, then refused, and the case went back on the trial calendar.
The defense then moved to keep the jury from hearing what Crimo had told the police, arguing that his right to counsel had been violated because a lawyer retained on his behalf was kept out of the interview room. The prosecution answered that Crimo could be heard on the recording turning down the chance to speak with that lawyer.
On December 18, 2024, the judge denied the motion. She found that he had been properly advised of his rights, had understood them and had made "a voluntary, knowing and intelligent waiver" before continuing to talk, and that there had been no coercion, deceit or intimidation. The confession could be used at trial.
Jury selection began on February 24, 2025, in Waukegan, and by the end of that week the jury had been chosen. On the first day of jury selection the prosecution moved to dismiss the 48 counts of aggravated battery, and the judge signed the order, leaving 69 counts for the jury: the 21 counts of murder and the 48 of attempted murder.
On March 3, 2025, with opening statements set for that morning, Crimo told the judge he would plead guilty to all 69 counts. She questioned him closely and accepted the plea, finding that he had knowingly and voluntarily waived his rights. The jurors were never brought into the courtroom. There was no agreement, and he received nothing in exchange for the plea.
The sentencing hearing opened on April 23, 2025, and lasted two days. Crimo chose not to attend, and survivors and relatives of the dead gave their statements in his absence. He offered no statement of his own.
On April 24, 2025, the judge imposed seven consecutive sentences of natural life imprisonment, one for each of the seven murders, and 50 years on each of the 48 counts of attempted murder, those terms to run concurrently with one another. Under Illinois law the life terms carry no possibility of parole. The next morning the Lake County Sheriff's Office moved him from the county jail, where he had been held since his arrest, to an Illinois state prison.
Crimo remains in the custody of the Illinois Department of Corrections under seven terms of natural life.
Crimo pleaded guilty, and there is no dispute over his responsibility for the seven deaths and the 48 attempted murders to which he admitted. He gave no reason in court for the killings, and none was established at a trial. He offered no explanation for refusing the proposed plea agreement in June 2024 or for pleading guilty without any agreement in March 2025, and his lawyers gave none.
The counts in the case changed over time. The indictment charged 117 counts; the agreement he refused in June 2024 would have covered 55; the 48 counts of aggravated battery were dropped before trial, and he pleaded guilty to the remaining 69.
September 2019: Highland Park police receive a report that he has made threats; a clear-and-present-danger report goes to the Illinois State Police.
January 2020: The Illinois State Police approve his application for a state ownership permit.
July 4, 2022: Six people die at the Independence Day parade in Highland Park and dozens are wounded; Crimo is arrested that evening.
July 5, 2022: A seventh victim dies; Crimo is charged with seven counts of first-degree murder.
July 6, 2022: A judge orders him held without bond and appoints the public defender.
July 27, 2022: A grand jury indicts him on 117 counts.
August 3, 2022: A plea of not guilty is entered at his arraignment in Waukegan.
November 2023: His father pleads guilty to seven misdemeanor counts of reckless conduct.
December 2023: Crimo dismisses his public defenders and elects to represent himself.
January 2024: He asks for the public defenders to be reinstated, and the judge agrees.
June 2024: He refuses a proposed plea agreement in court.
December 18, 2024: The judge rules that his videotaped statements may be used at trial.
February 24, 2025: Jury selection begins; the 48 counts of aggravated battery are dismissed.
March 3, 2025: He pleads guilty to 21 counts of first-degree murder and 48 counts of attempted first-degree murder.
April 23-24, 2025: Sentencing hearing; he receives seven consecutive natural life terms and 48 concurrent 50-year terms.
April 25, 2025: He is transferred to an Illinois state prison.