Robert Chambers

Victims
1 death in Manhattan, August 26, 1986; manslaughter plea. Murder jury deadlocked; pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter and burglary, March 25, 1988; drug sale and assault pleas, 2008.
Years active
August 26, 1986
Location
Manhattan, New York City; New York State
Method
Manslaughter in the first degree (charged as murder in the second degree).
Status
5 to 15 years (April 1988), served in full, released February 14, 2003; 19 years (September 2008) on the drug and assault pleas; released July 25, 2023; supervised to July 2028.

Jennifer Dawn Levin died in Manhattan in the early morning of August 26, 1986. Within hours the police were questioning Robert Chambers, a 19-year-old from the Upper East Side who had known her and had been with her that night. He admitted that he had caused her death and insisted that it was an accident. The district attorney charged him with murder in the second degree, and in early 1988 a Manhattan jury heard nearly three months of testimony before deliberating for nine days without reaching a verdict. On March 25, 1988, with the jury still out, Chambers pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the first degree. He was sentenced in April 1988 to 5 to 15 years in state prison and served every day of the maximum.

The plea did not end his history with the courts. He left prison in February 2003 with no parole supervision, because he had served his full term. Within a year he was arrested on a drug charge, and in October 2007 he was arrested again after an undercover investigation of drug sales in Manhattan. In August 2008 he pleaded guilty to criminal sale of a controlled substance and assault on a police officer, and the following month he was sentenced to 19 years. He was released from a New York state prison on July 25, 2023, and remains under state supervision until July 25, 2028.

Chambers was born on September 25, 1966, and grew up in New York City. By the summer of 1986 he lived on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. Investigators later estimated that he and a partner had taken more than $70,000 in jewelry and other valuables in thefts from people they knew, an episode that would later add a burglary count to his case. The thefts dated from 1985 and were taken from three apartments.

The victim and Chambers had known each other before that summer.

She died before dawn that morning. Police came to Chambers later the same day, and within hours he gave a statement, later recorded on videotape, in which he admitted that he had caused her death. He was arrested on August 26, 1986, and charged with murder in the second degree.

His account to the police became the core of his defense. The defense said the death was an accident; the prosecution said it was an intentional killing. That disagreement, rather than any question of identity, was what the jury would be asked to decide.

In September 1986 a Manhattan grand jury indicted him on two counts of murder in the second degree. One count charged an intentional killing, the other a killing committed with depraved indifference to human life. Either carried a maximum sentence of 25 years to life. In December 1986, with the murder case still pending, the district attorney's office added burglary charges over the thefts of 1985.

The trial opened in early 1988 in state Supreme Court in Manhattan, with opening statements in early January. The central evidence was Chambers's own videotaped statement, together with medical testimony about the cause of death, on which the prosecution's and the defense's forensic pathologists disagreed.

Testimony ran for close to three months. In mid-March the jury received the case. It was told it could return a verdict on either murder count or, if it found neither proved, on lesser charges: manslaughter in the first or second degree, or criminally negligent homicide.

The jury then deliberated for nine days. It could not agree on a verdict on the murder charge.

With the jury deadlocked, the district attorney's office offered a plea: guilty to manslaughter in the first degree, with a sentence of 5 to 15 years. The offer came with a condition. Chambers would have to stand in open court and admit that he had intended to harm her. On March 25, 1988, while the jurors were still deliberating, he interrupted the proceedings and pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the first degree.

As part of the same disposition he also pleaded guilty to burglary in the second degree, the count that arose from the thefts of 1985. The plea was entered that evening. The next day he surrendered to custody.

Chambers was sentenced in April 1988 to 5 to 15 years in state prison. Later that month he was moved from city custody into the state prison system. Under the sentence he would become eligible for parole after five years.

He served the full 15 years. Over its course he was charged with 27 disciplinary violations, among them possession of drugs, possession of contraband and assaulting a corrections officer, and he lost up to six years of the good-time credit that could have shortened his stay. The state parole board considered him five times and turned him down five times.

The first hearing came in 1992, after he had served 58 months, and ended in a denial. The board refused him again in 1998 and again in 2000. At the last of the five hearings he refused to appear for the personal interview, the second time he had done so, and parole was denied once more. After that, the only way out was the end of the sentence itself.

He was released from a New York state prison on February 14, 2003. Because he had served his maximum term, he left without parole supervision of any kind.

Within a year of his release he was back before a court. In 2004 he was arrested on a charge of drug possession and for driving with a suspended license. The possession charge was a misdemeanor, and he pleaded guilty. In 2005 he was sentenced to 100 days in jail and fined $200.

The next case was much larger. The police opened an undercover investigation that ran for about three months, during which undercover officers bought drugs from him eight times, and in October 2007 they arrested him in Manhattan.

He struggled with the officers, and two of them were hurt. He was charged with several counts of criminal sale of a controlled substance, a felony, and with resisting arrest.

He had first pleaded not guilty. On August 11, 2008, Chambers pleaded guilty in state Supreme Court in Manhattan to criminal sale of a controlled substance and assault on a police officer. The assault count carried six years, to run concurrently with the drug sentence. He was sentenced in Manhattan in September 2008 to 19 years in prison, a longer term than the one he had served for manslaughter.

Chambers served about 15 years of the 19-year sentence. The New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision released him from a state prison on July 25, 2023, after he met the criteria for a limited credit allowance, which took six months off his minimum term. He remains under state supervision until July 25, 2028.

What happened in the hours before dawn on August 26, 1986, was never settled by a verdict. Chambers said the death was an accident; the prosecution said it was intentional. The jury that heard the evidence could not decide between the two accounts on the murder charge, and the case closed on a plea in which Chambers admitted intending to cause harm. The conviction is for manslaughter in the first degree, and nothing more.

Timeline

September 25, 1966: Robert Chambers is born.

August 26, 1986: The victim dies in Manhattan; Chambers is questioned, gives a videotaped statement and is arrested and charged with murder in the second degree.

September 1986: A Manhattan grand jury indicts him on two counts of murder in the second degree.

December 1986: Burglary charges are added over thefts from three apartments in 1985.

January 1988: Trial opens in state Supreme Court in Manhattan; nearly three months of testimony follow.

March 1988: The jury receives the murder counts and lesser charges, and deliberates for nine days without reaching a verdict.

March 25, 1988: Chambers pleads guilty to manslaughter in the first degree; he also pleads guilty to burglary in the second degree.

April 1988: Sentenced to 5 to 15 years in state prison.

1988 to 2003: 27 disciplinary violations; parole denied five times, first in 1992 and again in 1998 and 2000.

February 14, 2003: Released after serving the full 15 years, without supervision.

2004: Arrested on a drug possession charge and for driving with a suspended license.

2005: Sentenced to 100 days in jail.

October 2007: Arrested in Manhattan after a three-month undercover investigation; charged with criminal sale of a controlled substance and resisting arrest.

August 11, 2008: Pleads guilty to criminal sale of a controlled substance and assault on a police officer.

September 2008: Sentenced to 19 years in prison.

July 25, 2023: Released from a New York state prison under a limited credit allowance.

July 25, 2028: Scheduled end of state supervision.