Robert Card

Victims
18 people killed in Lewiston, Maine, October 2023; never tried. Named in arrest warrants for murder; found dead October 27, 2023, before arrest; 13 others wounded October 25, 2023
Years active
October 25, 2023
Location
Lewiston, Bowdoin and Lisbon, Maine, USA
Method
Murder (warrants only; no charge was ever tried)
Status
Died by suicide October 27, 2023, before arrest; never tried. State commission (final report August 20, 2024) found him solely responsible

On the evening of Wednesday, October 25, 2023, eighteen people were killed and thirteen more were wounded at two businesses in Lewiston, Maine. No killing of its kind in Maine's history had taken more lives. Before the night was over, Maine State Police had named the man they wanted: Robert R. Card II, a 40-year-old sergeant first class in the U.S. Army Reserve who lived in Bowdoin, in Sagadahoc County. The next day police announced a warrant for his arrest on eight counts of murder and said more would follow as the dead were identified.

On the evening of Friday, October 27, Card was found dead in Lisbon. The state's Office of Chief Medical Examiner ruled that he had died by suicide and announced the ruling on November 3, 2023. He was never arrested, never charged before a judge and never tried, so no court has ever heard evidence against him. The legal position has stayed where it stood on the night he died: a man named by police in warrants for murder.

What the state did instead was ask how it had happened. The months before the killings had produced warnings from Card's relatives, his Army Reserve unit and a close friend, and two hospital stays in New York. An independent commission appointed by the governor, an Army investigation and a brain study ordered by the state's medical examiner each examined part of that record.

He studied engineering technology at the University of Maine in Orono from 2001 to 2004 and left without a degree. In December 2002 he enlisted in the Army Reserve, where he would spend more than half his life. He served as a petroleum supply specialist, rose to the rank of sergeant first class and never deployed to combat. His awards included the Army Achievement Medal, the Army Reserve Component Achievement Medal, the Humanitarian Service Medal and the National Defense Service Medal. His unit was the 3rd Battalion, 304th Infantry Regiment, a Reserve unit with a training center in Saco, Maine, and for years he served as an instructor on a training range. His only public criminal record before 2023 was a conviction in 2007 for operating under the influence.

Card's decline, as the commission later reconstructed it, began around January 2023. On May 3, 2023, relatives reported to a deputy of the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office that his mental health had been failing since the start of the year. The deputy contacted the Army Reserve unit in Saco, which said it would inform the company commander, and filed a report in the department's system. In early June, after another call from the family, he texted the unit again and asked for a call back. The commission found that no call came and that the deputy had no further contact with the family before October 25.

In July 2023 Card's unit traveled to West Point, New York, to help train incoming cadets. He behaved erratically, and on July 16 his company commander ordered a mental health evaluation. He was seen first at Keller Army Community Hospital at West Point and then moved to Four Winds Hospital, a private psychiatric hospital in Katonah, New York, where he stayed 19 days. Clinicians diagnosed brief psychotic disorder. A hearing on involuntary commitment was scheduled and then canceled, and he was discharged on August 3, 2023. His mental health providers gave his company commander a set of safety recommendations, including that the Reserve make sure he attended every follow-up appointment; the commission found that the commander did not pass them to the sheriff's office. After his release Card stopped communicating with medical staff and withdrew from the people around him.

On September 15, 2023, a fellow reservist who was one of Card's closest friends warned two of the unit's leaders that Card was refusing help and had made threats. That day the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office was asked to make a well-being check. A sergeant of the sheriff's office went to Card's residence in Bowdoin and found no one there, and he issued a statewide officer-safety bulletin. The sergeant returned on September 16 and Card did not come to the door. After speaking with one of Card's relatives on September 17, the sergeant treated the case as closed. He went on vacation the next day, no one else was assigned, and on October 18, 2023, one week before the killings, he canceled the statewide bulletin.

The dead were Ronald G. Morin, Peyton Brewer-Ross, Joshua A. Seal, Bryan M. MacFarlane, Joseph Lawrence Walker, Arthur Fred Strout, Maxx A. Hathaway, Stephen M. Vozzella, William Frank Brackett, Keith D. Macneir, Thomas Ryan Conrad, Michael R. Deslauriers II, Jason Adam Walker, Tricia C. Asselin, William A. Young, Robert E. Violette, Lucille M. Violette and a boy named Aaron. The Office of Chief Medical Examiner confirmed on October 27 that all eighteen had been identified.

They had come out on an ordinary Wednesday for the things that filled their week. Some had come to play in a cornhole league, a game that more than one of them loved; friends remembered one for the energy and the wide smile he brought to the court, and another for the way he welcomed newcomers to the league. Another loved cornhole, baseball and history, and the friends around him knew him as the life of the party. One woman loved sports, the Boston Bruins above all, played golf and softball and bowled in a winter league, and was known for her warmth; years earlier she had once kept up CPR on a man for twenty minutes. One man had spent years teaching children to bowl and was patient with the ones who struggled. Another woman bowled in leagues of her own and was so kind to the children who bowled that many of them called her the "youth league mom." Another man golfed, bowled in a league once or twice a week and had a knack for making people laugh. Another loved riding his motorcycle and spending time with his dog, and had recently moved back to Maine. One was remembered for his jokes and an upbeat manner that could turn a bad day around; he played hockey on ice and on the floor, softball and cornhole, and liked to umpire softball games. Another loved pool and cooking Italian food. Another was a goofy, down-to-earth man with an uplifting attitude whatever was happening around him; he enjoyed anime, video games and pool, and had just earned a business degree from the University of Southern Maine. One man volunteered with the Sabattus Historical Society, recording the life stories of older residents. Another had come up from Florida to celebrate his birthday in Maine. The youngest was a talented bowler. Another man had played many sports and mentored young children. The thirteen who were wounded survived.

Governor Janet Mills created the Independent Commission to Investigate the Facts of the Tragedy in Lewiston on November 9, 2023. Its 215-page final report, released on August 20, 2024, found Card "solely responsible" for his conduct, found that the sheriff's office had had probable cause by September 17, 2023, to take him into protective custody and that his Reserve unit's leaders had not acted on their own providers' recommendations or shared what they knew, and acknowledged that the killings might have happened anyway. The Army's investigation, released on July 23, 2024, found communication failures within his chain of command and disciplined three unnamed officers for dereliction of duty. It found that his commanders had enough evidence of his decline that he should not have been allowed to attend the training at West Point, that his unit never started the line-of-duty investigation the Army requires after a hospital stay of more than 24 hours, that his diagnosis and discharge instructions never reached his chain of command, and that the Army Reserve's psychological health program closed his case when he stopped responding without adequately reviewing his medical records. A Boston University CTE Center study of his brain, released on March 7, 2024, found white-matter damage but no chronic traumatic encephalopathy.

No court tested the case against Card, and every statement of his responsibility rests on police announcements, the warrants and the findings of the commission. His motive was not established by any of the reviews, and no court or review settled why he acted.

The meaning of the brain study is unsettled: its author could not prove that the injury caused his behavior, and the Army referred the question of a link to his training to its own medical experts without deciding it.

Whether earlier action would have prevented the deaths is also unproven, and the commission's reports were findings of fact, not judgments of a court.

Timeline

December 2002: Card enlists in the U.S. Army Reserve.

May 3, 2023: Relatives report his declining mental health to the Sagadahoc County Sheriff's Office.

July 16, 2023: His company commander orders a mental health evaluation during training at West Point, New York.

August 3, 2023: He is discharged from Four Winds Hospital in Katonah, New York, after 19 days.

September 15 and 16, 2023: A fellow reservist warns unit leaders; a sheriff's sergeant twice tries a well-being check and issues a statewide bulletin.

September 17, 2023: The sheriff's office treats the matter as closed.

October 18, 2023: The statewide bulletin is canceled.

October 25, 2023: Eighteen people are killed and thirteen wounded in Lewiston.

October 26, 2023: Maine State Police announce an arrest warrant for eight counts of murder.

October 27, 2023: Card is found dead in Lisbon; all eighteen victims are identified.

November 3, 2023: The Office of Chief Medical Examiner rules his death a suicide.

November 9, 2023: Governor Janet Mills establishes the independent commission.

March 7, 2024: The Boston University CTE Center's findings are released.

July 23, 2024: The Army releases its investigation; three officers are disciplined.

August 20, 2024: The commission releases its final report.