Robert Bales

Victims
16 Afghan villagers murdered in Kandahar Province, 2012. Killed March 11, 2012. Guilty pleas to 16 premeditated murders and 6 attempted murders, 2013; life without parole.
Years active
March 11, 2012 (one night).
Location
Alkozai and Najiban, Panjwai district, Kandahar Province, Afghanistan (killings); Joint Base Lewis-McChord, Washington (court-martial); Kansas (military custody).
Method
Shot at close range
Status
Life without parole and dishonorable discharge, August 23, 2013; appeals denied 2017 to 2018; habeas denied 2020, affirmed 2023. In military custody in Kansas as of May 2023.

On March 11, 2012, 16 Afghan villagers were killed and six more were wounded in two villages in the Panjwai district of Kandahar Province, in southern Afghanistan. Most of the dead were women and children; at least seven were children, and 11 came from a single family. They were strangers to the man who killed them, Staff Sgt. Robert Bales of the U.S. Army, who was posted to a small outpost nearby. Soldiers there detained him when he came back, and by that morning he was in American custody.

He was 38, a former stockbroker from Norwood, Ohio, who had enlisted two months after the attacks of September 11, 2001, served three deployments in Iraq, and arrived in Afghanistan in December 2011 on his first tour there. He later admitted drinking contraband alcohol with other soldiers on the outpost and using drugs during the deployment.

On March 14 he was flown out of Afghanistan to Kuwait, and on March 16 he reached a military detention facility in Kansas, where he was held in pretrial confinement. The United States kept the case under its own military law. On March 22, 2012, U.S. Forces Afghanistan preferred charges under the Uniform Code of Military Justice alleging the premeditated murder of 17 Afghan civilians. A revised charge sheet dated June 1, 2012, alleged 16 murders, together with six specifications of attempted murder, seven of assault and further offenses. Premeditated murder carried a possible death sentence, and after an Article 32 hearing that opened on November 5, 2012, the case went to a general court-martial at Joint Base Lewis-McChord, Washington.

The death penalty never reached a jury. On May 3, 2013, Bales signed an offer to plead guilty, and under the pretrial agreement prosecutors would not seek his death. On June 5, 2013, the military judge accepted his pleas of guilty to 16 specifications of premeditated murder and six of attempted murder, along with five of aggravated assault, four of intentional infliction of grievous bodily harm, one further specification of assault, one of violating a lawful general order, one of wrongfully using a Schedule II controlled substance and a further offense concerning the dead. He also pleaded guilty to assault consummated by a battery in a separate 2012 assault on an Afghan truck driver. Questioned by the judge, he said the killings had no legal justification.

The only question left was whether he could ever be paroled. On August 23, 2013, the court-martial sentenced him to a dishonorable discharge and life in confinement without the possibility of parole.

He spent the next decade trying to undo it. The commanding general who had convened the court-martial rejected his request for clemency in March 2015. On September 27, 2017, the Army Court of Criminal Appeals rejected his claim that the government had withheld evidence about Afghan witnesses at his sentencing, and his claim that an anti-malarial drug had affected his mind; it found no evidence that he had taken the drug. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces granted review and summarily affirmed, and the Supreme Court of the United States denied review on June 25, 2018.

He then turned to the civilian courts. On June 9, 2020, the U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas denied his petition for a writ of habeas corpus, holding that the Army Court of Criminal Appeals had given full and fair consideration to each of his claims. On May 11, 2023, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed. It held that the military courts had extensively analyzed and considered his claims, and that his challenges turned on fact-intensive rulings rather than questions largely free of factual dispute, so he could not obtain a fresh review of their merits.

As of May 2023 Robert Bales was serving his life sentence without parole in military custody in Kansas.

From the first days, many Afghans, relatives of the dead among them, said more than one soldier had taken part. The International Security Assistance Force and U.S. prosecutors said he had acted alone, and he pleaded guilty as the sole perpetrator.

The first charges alleged 17 murders; the revised sheet of June 2012 alleged 16, and the conviction is for 16.

His appeal claims about an anti-malarial drug and about insurgent links among the Afghan witnesses were rejected, and the federal courts declined to reopen those findings. Defense accounts of post-traumatic stress disorder and a brain injury were never tested by expert evidence at trial, because the defense called no experts.

Timeline

2001: Enlists in the U.S. Army, two months after the September 11 attacks.

December 2011: Deploys to Afghanistan; posted to an outpost in Panjwai district, Kandahar Province.

March 11, 2012: 16 villagers are killed and six wounded in two nearby villages; he is detained at the outpost.

March 16, 2012: Arrives in military detention in Kansas.

March 22, 2012: U.S. Forces Afghanistan prefers charges alleging 17 premeditated murders.

June 1, 2012: A revised charge sheet alleges 16 murders and six attempted murders.

November 5, 2012: Article 32 hearing opens at Joint Base Lewis-McChord.

May 3, 2013: Signs an offer to plead guilty; prosecutors will not seek the death penalty.

June 5, 2013: The military judge accepts his guilty pleas.

August 23, 2013: Sentenced to dishonorable discharge and life without parole.

March 2015: The commanding general rejects his clemency request.

September 27, 2017: The Army Court of Criminal Appeals affirms.

June 25, 2018: The Supreme Court denies review.

June 9, 2020: The district court denies his habeas petition.

May 11, 2023: The Tenth Circuit affirms; he remains in military custody in Kansas.