Early on Saturday, April 4, 2009, two officers of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police were sent to a domestic call in Stanton Heights, a residential neighborhood of the city. Both officers died there, and so did a third officer who came to help them. Other officers were wounded before Poplawski was taken into custody later that day.
In June 2011 a jury from Dauphin County, sitting in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in Pittsburgh, convicted him of three counts of first-degree murder and 25 further counts. Three days later the same jury sentenced him to death. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania upheld the sentences in December 2015, and the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear his case the following year. An execution date set for March 2017 was stayed while he pursued post-conviction relief, and in April 2025 he was still on Pennsylvania's list of prisoners under sentence of death.
Paul Sciullo II grew up in the Pittsburgh neighborhood of Bloomfield and had been a police officer for less than two years. Stephen Mayhle had joined the force within the same span. They were the two officers dispatched to the call that morning.
Eric G. Kelly had served with the bureau for 14 years and lived in Stanton Heights himself. His shift had already ended when he learned that fellow officers needed help, and he went to them in uniform. He died that morning as well.
Poplawski was arraigned by a district judge on Sunday, April 5, 2009, while under police guard. The charges were three counts of criminal homicide, nine counts of attempted homicide, four counts of recklessly endangering another person, covering neighbors, and a further count under the Crimes Code. None of the neighbors was hurt. By April 9 he was being held in the Allegheny County Jail on the homicide charges and related counts. As the case moved toward trial, the charges also came to include nine counts of assault of a law enforcement officer.
The Allegheny County District Attorney's Office prosecuted the case as a capital case, seeking death on each of the three murder counts. On April 23, 2009, the Commonwealth filed its formal notice that it would ask for the death penalty. Lawyers from the county's public defender's office represented him at trial. A judge of the Court of Common Pleas presided, and the jury that heard the case was drawn from Dauphin County rather than from Allegheny County. It was made up of seven men and five women.
The case took more than two years to reach a jury, and much of that time went to fights over what the jury would be allowed to hear.
The first was over his own words. After his arrest a detective began to question him, and he demanded a lawyer. The questioning stopped. Later, after a district judge had advised him to stay silent, he sent for a detective himself and said he wanted to talk. The detective told him they could not speak because of his earlier request for counsel. Only after Poplawski withdrew that request did the detective read him his rights again, take a signed waiver and record a statement, and Poplawski made written corrections to the detective's account of it. The defense moved to suppress everything he had said. The trial court heard the motion over two sessions, on February 5 and April 6, 2010, found that the officers had honored his request for a lawyer, that he had been alert and coherent, and that the statement was voluntary, and denied the motion on September 20, 2010.
The second fight was over where the jurors would come from. Coverage of the case in Pittsburgh had been so extensive that the defense moved for a change of venire, asking for a jury from outside Allegheny County to be brought to the city. The trial judge granted the motion, and the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania directed that the jury be chosen in Dauphin County, around Harrisburg. Jury selection there was completed on June 10, 2011, with 12 jurors and six alternates, who were then brought to Pittsburgh for the trial.
The third concerned his beliefs. Before trial the judge granted a defense motion barring testimony about 41 pages of his postings on a white nationalist website, while leaving open whether any of that material could be used at a penalty phase. In April 2011 the judge also settled the terms of a mental health examination by a psychiatrist retained by the prosecution: defense lawyers could attend but not interfere, and any mental health evidence would be offered only at a penalty phase, if there was one.
Testimony began on Monday, June 20, 2011. Over the following week the Commonwealth called 41 witnesses and put about 500 exhibits before the jury. Part of the evidence came from his postings on a Nazi website and from his internet history, material that became the center of his later appeal.
The most contested exhibit was the recording of an emergency call he made that morning, about 41 minutes long, in which he could be heard using racial epithets. The judge first sustained the defense's objections to those passages, then reversed course and admitted them for the context they gave, and the whole recording was played. The jurors were told that the remarks were gratuitous and prejudicial, that they must not let them stir their emotions or suggest bad character, and that any verdict of guilty had to rest on proof beyond a reasonable doubt rather than on offensive language.
A second running dispute concerned the Commonwealth's expert witnesses, forensic pathologists and a forensic examiner, whom the defense accused of offering opinions that had never appeared in their written reports. During the examiner's testimony the defense moved for a mistrial on that ground. The judge denied it.
The prosecution rested on Friday, June 24. The defense entered exhibits, among them photographs and diagrams, but called no witnesses, though its lawyers had listed dozens of possible witnesses before trial. In closing, the defense argued that the Commonwealth had not proved that he intended to kill the officers, an element required for a conviction of first-degree murder, and it challenged the Commonwealth's handling of the physical evidence.
The jury received the case on Saturday, June 25, 2011. It found him guilty on all 28 counts, including three counts of first-degree murder, attempted murder and reckless endangerment. He was 24.
The same jury then had to choose between death and life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The penalty phase began on Monday, June 27. The Commonwealth relied on statutory aggravating circumstances. The defense presented testimony from relatives and others about his upbringing and asked the jury to weigh it in mitigation.
On Tuesday, June 28, 2011, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of death on each of the three counts of first-degree murder. In its later review the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania described the verdict as resting on three aggravating circumstances, which the jury found outweighed two statutory mitigating circumstances.
The aggravating circumstances came from three separate subsections of Pennsylvania's capital sentencing statute. The victims were peace officers killed in the performance of their duties. He had been convicted of more than one murder arising from the same episode. And in committing the murders he had knowingly created a grave risk of death to people other than the victims, among them a fellow officer. Against those findings the jury set two mitigating circumstances, drawn from the statute's provisions for a defendant without a significant history of prior criminal convictions and its catch-all for any other evidence bearing on character and background.
The trial judge imposed sentence on Tuesday, September 6, 2011. Poplawski received three sentences of death for the murders. On the attempted homicide, assault and other counts arising from the wounding of the other officers and the danger to neighbors, the judge added an aggregate term of 85 to 190 years in prison, imposed so that he would remain in custody even if the death sentences were later set aside. With that sentencing he joined 211 other prisoners then under sentence of death in Pennsylvania.
The trial court denied his post-sentence motions on March 6, 2012, and he filed his notice of appeal on March 22. The appeal from the judgment of sentence entered on September 6, 2011, was argued before the justices of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in Pittsburgh on Wednesday, April 9, 2014. He asked for a new trial or, failing that, a new sentencing hearing. His main complaint was that evidence of his online postings should never have reached the jury and that it had unfairly branded him as a racist, coloring both the verdict and the sentence.
The court ruled on December 29, 2015, in an opinion joined by the justices who took part. The justices held that the evidence against him had been properly tested and was admissible, and they affirmed the judgments of sentence. On the penalty, they examined the jury's weighing of the three aggravating circumstances against the two statutory mitigating circumstances and found no basis to vacate the death sentences. The court denied reargument on February 1, 2016.
The opinion worked through the case one claim at a time. The justices began with a question he had not raised, because in every capital appeal the court must satisfy itself that the evidence supports a conviction for first-degree murder. It found that a reasonable jury could conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that he had killed with the specific intent the charge requires.
On the statement he gave after asking for a lawyer, the court deferred to the trial judge's findings. The record showed that the officers had stopped questioning him when he invoked his right to counsel, that he himself had started the later conversation, and that he had freely given up the right before he spoke. The denial of the suppression motion stood.
The epithets on the emergency call recording produced a closer question. The court found no abuse of discretion in admitting them and held that any error was harmless: the evidence of guilt was overwhelming, the case was not close, and jurors are presumed to follow a cautionary instruction like the one they had been given. The claim about the expert witnesses failed for want of prejudice. Where an expert had gone beyond a written report, the court found, either independent evidence established the same point or cross-examination had blunted the opinion, and the claimed violations did not add up to prejudice when taken together. The refusal of a mistrial was upheld.
The complaint he had pressed hardest, about the white nationalist website, was held waived. At the guilt phase the jury had heard only that he had visited the website, as one step in a timeline, and the defense had not objected on that ground; at the penalty phase it had not objected when the prosecution referred to the material, though the pretrial order barring evidence of his beliefs was still in force. A claim that the prosecution had argued his future dangerousness to the jury met a mixed answer. The court found nothing of the kind in the opening statement. It agreed that part of the closing argument, about the danger he might pose in prison, was not a fair response to the defense's character evidence, but held that it had not so inflamed the jurors that they could no longer weigh the evidence, given the aggravating circumstances, the instruction they received on life imprisonment without parole, and the two mitigating circumstances they found. A claim about the memorial and funeral evidence put before the jury at the penalty phase was also held waived, because no specific objection had been made at the time it was offered; a motion before trial was not enough. That claim, the court said, could be raised, if at all, only in a later challenge to the performance of his trial lawyers.
Finally, in the review the statute requires in every death case, the court concluded that the sentences were not the product of passion, prejudice or any other arbitrary factor, and that the evidence supported each of the three aggravating circumstances. The Chief Justice wrote separately. Concurring in the result, he joined the court's treatment of sufficiency and suppression but expressed doubt about treating the epithets as harmless at the penalty phase, would have regarded the website claim as preserved at least for the guilt phase, and would have left those questions, and an overall assessment of the prosecution's conduct, to post-conviction review.
He then petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States for a writ of certiorari. After a justice granted an extension of time, the petition was filed on May 24, 2016. The Commonwealth filed a brief in opposition, the justices considered the petition at their conference of September 26, 2016, and they denied it on October 3, 2016. That ended the direct appeal.
On January 18, 2017, the Pennsylvania Secretary of Corrections signed a Notice of Execution scheduling his execution for March 3, 2017.
By then he had started the next stage of litigation on his own. Acting without a lawyer, he filed a 144-page petition under Pennsylvania's Post-Conviction Relief Act. It set out 16 ways in which, he argued, his trial lawyers had failed him. Among them were their failure to object to passages of the prosecution's opening and closing arguments, which he said had been aimed at the jury's sympathy rather than the evidence, and their failure to object to language the prosecution had used about him in the penalty phase. He asked the court to dismiss all the charges, or at least to grant him a new trial.
On February 16, 2017, he appeared before a judge of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, who had to decide whether he would go forward on his own or with appointed counsel. He accepted court-appointed lawyers, who were given time to review his petition and to file amendments to it. The next day, February 17, 2017, the Court of Common Pleas stayed the March 3 execution date. His new lawyers were given until May 20 to file amendments to the petition.
The post-conviction case was still in the Court of Common Pleas in the fall of 2024. At a hearing on Monday, November 18, 2024, before a judge of that court, his lawyers asked for time and public funding to find and interview the Dauphin County jurors who had convicted him and sentenced him to death. They wanted to learn whether influences outside the judge's instructions had reached the jury while it was in Pittsburgh, among them the heavy police presence in and around the courthouse during the trial. The defense sought about 500 hours of investigative work and years to present what it found. The judge granted a small part of the funding and gave the defense 60 days to bring its findings to the court. Poplawski watched the hearing by video from prison and said nothing.
In the spring of 2025 he took an appeal to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. On April 30, 2025, the court quashed the notice of appeal in a short order. It explained that no appeal lies from an order denying reconsideration, and that the collateral order doctrine, which allows some appeals before a case ends, is narrowly construed and applies only when all three of its requirements are met. The order left the post-conviction case in the Court of Common Pleas.
As of April 2023 he remained on death row under the 2017 stay of execution. The Pennsylvania Department of Corrections' execution list of April 2025 still carried him as a prisoner with three execution sentences, prosecuted in Allegheny County and sentenced on June 28, 2011, and held in a Pennsylvania state prison. The department's listing of warrants and notices shows no further execution notice for him after the one signed in January 2017.
The March 2017 date was set while Governor Tom Wolf was using his reprieve power to postpone executions until a state task force reported on whether the death penalty in Pennsylvania was being applied fairly and effectively, a policy he had begun in 2015. The department's warrant listing for the Wolf years records notices of execution signed by the Secretary of Corrections rather than warrants signed by the governor, and Poplawski's notice was one of several issued on January 18, 2017. His was stayed by the trial court in Allegheny County, because of the post-conviction petition then before it, two weeks before the scheduled date.
The defense contested one element of the first-degree murder charges at trial: it argued that the Commonwealth had not proved a specific intent to kill. The jury rejected that argument, and the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania left the convictions in place.
His 2017 post-conviction petition claims that his trial lawyers were ineffective in 16 respects and that the prosecution's arguments to the jury went beyond the evidence. They are his allegations, not findings of any court.
The 2024 request to investigate the jurors rests on a suspicion that outside influences reached them during the trial. No court has found that any did.
September 12, 1986: Richard Poplawski is born.
April 4, 2009: Three officers of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police die in Stanton Heights, Pittsburgh; he is taken into custody the same day.
April 5, 2009: He is arraigned on three counts of criminal homicide, nine counts of attempted homicide and other charges.
April 23, 2009: The Commonwealth gives notice that it will seek the death penalty.
September 20, 2010: The trial court denies the motion to suppress his statement.
June 10, 2011: Jury selection is completed in Dauphin County.
June 20, 2011: Trial opens in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas before a jury from Dauphin County.
June 25, 2011: The jury convicts him on all 28 counts, including three counts of first-degree murder.
June 28, 2011: The jury returns three verdicts of death.
September 6, 2011: Formal sentencing: three sentences of death and 85 to 190 years on the remaining counts.
April 9, 2014: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania hears the direct appeal in Pittsburgh.
December 29, 2015: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania affirms the death sentences.
February 1, 2016: Reargument is denied.
October 3, 2016: The Supreme Court of the United States denies certiorari.
January 18, 2017: The Secretary of Corrections signs a Notice of Execution for March 3, 2017.
February 16, 2017: He accepts court-appointed counsel for his post-conviction petition.
February 17, 2017: The Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas stays the execution.
November 18, 2024: The Court of Common Pleas grants his lawyers limited funding and 60 days to investigate the jury.
April 30, 2025: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania quashes his appeal.
April 2025: The Department of Corrections execution list still carries him under three sentences of death.