Richard Hickock and Perry Smith

Victims
4 members of one family murdered near Holcomb, Kansas, 1959. Each man convicted in March 1960 on four counts of murder in the first degree; both executed April 14, 1965
Years active
November 15, 1959
Location
Holcomb and Garden City, Kansas; Las Vegas, Nevada; Lansing, Kansas
Method
Murder in the first degree, four counts each, committed in the course of a robbery
Status
Sentenced to death March 1960; upheld by the Kansas Supreme Court and on state and federal habeas; US Supreme Court denied review January 18, 1965; executed April 14, 1965

On November 15, 1959, four members of one family were killed near Holcomb, a small community in Finney County in western Kansas. At the end of December, police in Las Vegas, Nevada, arrested two Kansas parolees, Richard Eugene Hickock and Perry Edward Smith, as parole violators. Both men confessed during questioning by officers from Kansas, and in March 1960 a jury in the District Court of Finney County, sitting in Garden City, found each of them guilty of four counts of murder in the first degree and returned a verdict of death.

The convictions survived every court that examined them. The Kansas Supreme Court affirmed them. A former chief justice of Kansas, appointed as a commissioner to take fresh evidence, found that the two men had received a fair and impartial trial. A federal district court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit rejected their claims that their lawyers had failed them, that publicity had tainted the jury and that their confessions had been coerced, and the United States Supreme Court declined three times to take the case. Hickock and Smith were executed in Lansing, Kansas, in April 1965. The case later became the subject of Truman Capote's book In Cold Blood.

Neither man was a newcomer to the criminal courts, and the Tenth Circuit said so in its 1964 opinion. Both had served time in the Kansas state penitentiary, Smith for breaking and entering and Hickock for fraud and passing bad checks. For about a month in 1959 the two shared a cell there, until Smith was paroled in July of that year. Hickock was paroled later in 1959 and went back to Olathe, the town where he had grown up.

Smith's road to the penitentiary had been the longer of the two. In July 1955 he was arrested in Phillips County, Kansas, on a burglary charge, and three days later he got out of the county jail and disappeared. He was picked up again the following year, identified as an escapee, and on March 13, 1956, he was sentenced to five to ten years in the state penitentiary for the burglary and the jail break. Hickock's record was thinner, built mostly on bad checks and petty theft, and on March 15, 1958, he was sentenced to five years in the same penitentiary. Inside, his conduct record was clean.

Smith walked out on parole on July 6, 1959. One condition of his release was that he stay out of Kansas, and he left the state. Hickock followed him out of the penitentiary on August 13, 1959, three months before the killings.

Smith gave Las Vegas, Nevada, as his place of residence.

Herbert W. Clutter was born in Ingalls, Kansas, and settled in Finney County in 1934. Over the next quarter century he became one of the best-known figures in the farm organizations of Kansas, and in 1953 President Eisenhower appointed him to the Federal Farm Credit Board. Closer to Holcomb, he was a steady supporter of 4-H, the Methodist church and the civic clubs of the county.

His wife, Bonnie Clutter, and their children, Nancy and Kenyon, lived with him near Holcomb, and the family took a full part in the community's groups, its school and its church.

Hickock and Smith reached Holcomb in the early hours of November 15, 1959. The four members of the family were killed that night, in the course of the robbery the two men had planned. The two men then left Kansas.

The Kansas Bureau of Investigation took charge of the inquiry. The decisive lead came from the penitentiary. Hickock's former cellmate came forward, hoping to collect a reward that a newspaper had offered, and on December 4, 1959, a KBI agent interviewed him. He said that Hickock had planned the robbery, that Hickock meant to carry it out with Smith, and that he himself had given Hickock inside knowledge of the family's money.

By then both men had broken their paroles by leaving the state, and a federal warrant for unlawful flight and parole violation was filed. On December 16, 1959, a KBI agent briefed police in Las Vegas about the two suspects.

On December 30, 1959, Las Vegas police arrested Hickock and Smith as parole violators. The arrest was made at the request of the Kansas Bureau of Investigation, and the two men waived extradition.

The Kansas officers questioned the two men on January 2 and 3, 1960, after advising them of their rights. Hickock gave a detailed confession, which he signed and initialed as correct, and which placed the blame for the killings on Smith. Smith at first denied any part in the crimes. On January 4 the officers began the return journey to Kansas, and during that trip Smith admitted his part.

The two men reached Garden City on January 6, 1960.

The proceedings moved quickly. On January 7, 1960, the county judge advised both men of their right to a preliminary hearing and to counsel. Each waived the preliminary hearing, and both were bound over for trial in the district court. When they appeared there the next day they asked for lawyers, and the court appointed two experienced local attorneys, one for each defendant.

On February 9, 1960, the two men were arraigned on an information charging murder in the first degree in four counts. Both stood mute, and the court entered pleas of not guilty for them. Trial was set for March 22.

Defense counsel asked the court to send both men to the state hospital at Larned for psychiatric examination. The court refused but ordered an examination by a panel of three doctors under Kansas law.

The trial opened in Garden City on March 22, 1960, and the jury was chosen and sworn on the first day. No one asked for the questioning of prospective jurors to be taken down, so none was made. Most of the jurors knew of the family, and some had been acquainted with its members, but none had a close relationship with them. All had heard of the case through newspapers or broadcasts. Each testified that he held no bias and could decide the case on the evidence, and those who admitted to preconceived ideas said they could put them aside.

The defense did not ask to move the trial out of Finney County, and the reasons were later laid out in the federal record. The community was generally opposed to capital punishment. The defendants and their counsel, the federal courts found, had agreed together on a course of conduct for the trial: given the confessions and the rest of the evidence, the aim was to save the two men from execution rather than to win an acquittal.

The confessions went in without objection, along with the physical evidence gathered by investigators. Photographs were admitted over a defense objection. Neither defendant testified. The defense relied on a limited report from a psychiatrist, who found that Hickock knew right from wrong and gave no opinion on Smith. No objection was made to the court's instructions to the jury.

The jury deliberated for about 40 minutes. It found both men guilty on all four counts of murder in the first degree and imposed the penalty of death.

From the county jail in Garden City the two men were moved to death row at the state penitentiary in Lansing, the institution both had left on parole the summer before the killings. They would stay there for the five years their appeals took.

Both men appealed to the Supreme Court of Kansas, which affirmed the convictions and sentences. The court held that the confessions had been given voluntarily.

While a petition for rehearing was still pending, the Kansas Supreme Court appointed a prominent Kansas attorney, the chairman of a Kansas State Bar Association committee, to bring a petition for a writ of habeas corpus on the prisoners' behalf. It named a former chief justice of Kansas as commissioner to take evidence on their complaints about the trial.

The commissioner's hearing went back over the trial from the inside. The jurors themselves were called as witnesses and questioned about what they had known of the case before they were sworn. Smith testified as well, and on the question of his confession he described the pressure he had felt as mental duress, not physical.

The commissioner heard the evidence and reported that the petitioners had received a fair and impartial trial and that their confessions had been voluntary. The Kansas Supreme Court adopted his report and denied the writ. On February 18, 1963, the United States Supreme Court denied certiorari in that case.

A separate attempt to carry the direct appeal to Washington also failed. On May 27, 1963, the Supreme Court granted the state's motion to dismiss Smith's appeal from the Kansas Supreme Court, treated his papers as a petition for a writ of certiorari, and denied it. Smith had filed that appeal without a lawyer.

Having exhausted their remedies in the Kansas courts, the two men wrote to the chief judge of the United States District Court for the District of Kansas. The court appointed two lawyers to represent them, and each man filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus. The district court consolidated the two cases, denied both petitions and remanded the prisoners to the custody of the warden.

The Tenth Circuit heard the consolidated appeals and affirmed on July 1, 1964. The panel began by marking the limits of its own review. In a federal habeas proceeding, it said, "the only errors of a state court which may be considered are those which deprive an accused of fundamental rights," and habeas corpus is no substitute for an appeal.

On the claim that trial counsel had been ineffective, the court held that the lawyers' strategy had been to avoid execution rather than seek acquittal, in the face of the confessions and the evidence, and that the trial court's finding that the defendants had agreed to that course was supported by the record. "Counsel's duty in a criminal case is to demand and obtain a fair trial for the accused," the court wrote, and "success is not the test of effective assistance of counsel."

On publicity, the court accepted that the jurors had heard of the case but noted that each had sworn he could decide it on the evidence. It distinguished the Supreme Court's decision in Irvin v. Dowd because no change of venue had been sought, and it held that the decision to stay in Finney County had been made by the defendants and their counsel after weighing local conditions, so that they were bound by it.

On the confessions, the court agreed with the trial court and the Kansas Supreme Court that they had been "voluntarily given," and held that their admission did not violate due process. On insanity, it found that counsel had no substantial evidence, then or later, on which to build a defense, and that the injuries and symptoms Hickock claimed did not supply one. It also turned aside the remaining complaints: that the examination of jurors had not been recorded, that evidence obtained without a warrant had been admitted, and that photographs had gone to the jury. Counsel's failure to press those points, the court held, did not deny the defendants a constitutional trial. Its conclusion was direct: "we are of the opinion that the petitioners were not denied the constitutional protection of a fair and impartial trial." The judgments denying the petitions were affirmed.

The two men asked the Supreme Court to review that decision. On January 18, 1965, it denied certiorari in both cases. Both men then asked the Court to reconsider, and at the start of March 1965 it denied the two petitions for rehearing. Nothing remained before the courts.

Hickock and Smith had spent more than five years under sentence of death while court-appointed lawyers carried their appeals through the state and federal courts. With the last of those appeals refused, both men were executed at the state penitentiary in Lansing on April 14, 1965.

The two confessions did not agree on who had done what. Hickock's signed statement placed the killings on Smith. Smith at first denied any involvement, then admitted his part, and his own account of how the acts were divided between the two men changed afterward. In the end Smith said that he alone had killed all four. The jury found both men guilty of all four counts of murder in the first degree.

Insanity was raised and rejected at every stage. The psychiatric report used at trial found that Hickock knew right from wrong and offered no opinion on Smith, and the Tenth Circuit found no substantial evidence of insanity at the time of trial or afterward.

Timeline

July 1955: Smith escapes from county custody in Phillips County, Kansas, three days after a burglary arrest.

March 13, 1956: Smith is sentenced to five to ten years in the Kansas state penitentiary.

March 15, 1958: Hickock is sentenced to five years in the same penitentiary.

July 6, 1959: Smith is paroled, on condition that he stay out of Kansas.

August 13, 1959: Hickock is paroled.

November 15, 1959: four members of one family are killed near Holcomb, Finney County, Kansas.

December 4, 1959: a KBI agent interviews Hickock's former cellmate, who names Hickock and Smith.

December 16, 1959: a KBI agent briefs police in Las Vegas.

December 30, 1959: Hickock and Smith are arrested in Las Vegas as parole violators.

January 2 to 3, 1960: questioning in Las Vegas; Hickock signs a confession.

January 4, 1960: the return journey to Kansas begins; Smith admits his part.

January 6, 1960: the two men are jailed in Garden City.

January 7 to 8, 1960: preliminary hearing waived; counsel appointed.

February 9, 1960: arraignment on a four-count information; pleas of not guilty entered by the court.

March 22, 1960: trial opens in the District Court of Finney County.

March 1960: guilty verdicts on all four counts of murder in the first degree; death sentences.

1961: the Kansas Supreme Court affirms.

1962: state habeas corpus denied.

February 18, 1963: the U.S. Supreme Court denies certiorari in the state habeas case.

May 27, 1963: the U.S. Supreme Court dismisses Smith's appeal and denies certiorari.

July 1, 1964: the Tenth Circuit affirms the denial of federal habeas corpus.

January 18, 1965: the U.S. Supreme Court denies certiorari.

March 1965: the U.S. Supreme Court denies rehearing in both cases.

April 14, 1965: Hickock and Smith are executed in Lansing, Kansas.