Richard Allen

Victims
2 girls killed in Delphi, Indiana, 2017; appeal pending. Convicted November 11, 2024, of two counts of murder and two of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping.
Years active
February 13, 2017
Location
Delphi, Carroll County, Indiana
Method
Murder, with other charges (murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping).
Status
130 years (65 on each of two counts, consecutive), December 20, 2024. Motion to correct error denied February 14, 2025. Appeal argued September 21, 2026; no ruling by mid-November 2026.

Richard Allen was a pharmacy technician at the only drugstore in Delphi, a town of about 3,000 people in Carroll County, Indiana, when the Indiana State Police arrested him in October 2022 for the deaths of two girls from the town more than five years earlier. Abby and Libby, two eighth graders, died on February 13, 2017. For five years the case had no name attached to it, only a handful of images and a few seconds of a man's voice that state police had released to the public, and tens of thousands of tips that led nowhere. Allen had been close to the investigation from the start. Within days of the deaths he had told the authorities that he had been in the area that afternoon, and the record of that conversation sat unexamined until 2022.

On November 11, 2024, a jury drawn from Allen County and sitting in the Carroll County Courthouse found him guilty of two counts of murder and two counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping. A special judge sentenced him on December 20, 2024, to 130 years in prison, the maximum available. He has maintained his innocence. His appeal, which argues that his own repeated admissions of guilt were the product of a psychological collapse in pretrial isolation and that the jury heard only part of the defense case, was argued before a three-judge panel of the Indiana Court of Appeals on September 21, 2026. As of mid-November 2026 the panel had not ruled.

Allen had settled in Delphi with his wife by 2006 and worked as a pharmacy technician at the town's drugstore. He had no criminal history.

February 2017

The two girls were eighth graders in Delphi. They died on Monday, February 13, 2017. The police classified the deaths as a double homicide and for years declined to say publicly how they had died.

The Indiana State Police led the investigation. Within days, state police released two images of a man and a short audio clip of a male voice, both recovered in the investigation, and asked the public to identify him. A composite sketch followed in July 2017. The tips came by the thousand, and the inquiry stayed open with no arrest.

A cold case

In April 2019 the state police refocused the inquiry, releasing a new sketch along with further video and audio, and the release brought nearly 3,000 new tips within weeks. By May 2019 the investigation had absorbed more than 42,000 tips without an arrest, and the state police superintendent said he believed the person responsible lived in, worked in or regularly visited the Delphi area.

The break came from the department's own files. In September 2022 a retired state government employee who volunteered with the investigation came across paperwork showing that Allen had contacted the authorities within days of the deaths and said he had been in the area that afternoon. In that 2017 conversation he said he did not know either girl and denied any part in their deaths. The report had never been followed up.

Investigators interviewed him again on October 13, 2022. He again said he had been in the area that day, again denied responsibility, and said he had never seen the girls. The same day, investigators executed a court warrant at his property in Delphi. Over the following two weeks the state police tied him to the case by evidence, and on Friday, October 28, 2022, he was arrested on two counts of murder.

Arrest and charges

The state police announced the arrest at a news conference on Monday, October 31, 2022, and kept the evidence under seal. A judge found probable cause, Allen pleaded not guilty at his first hearing, and he was held without bond in neighboring White County. The original charges were two counts of murder.

The probable cause affidavit was unsealed on November 29, 2022. It set out the account Allen had given investigators in 2017 and again in October 2022, and the evidence the state police said linked him to the deaths. His lawyers, two public defenders appointed because he could not afford counsel, disputed that evidence from the first weeks of the case. A gag order barred the parties from speaking publicly, and the defense sought a change of venue.

The special judge, brought in from Allen County to hear the case, ruled on that request on January 13, 2023. She kept the trial in Carroll County, where the witnesses lived and where moving the case would have carried great expense, but found that it would be impossible to seat a jury there that had no involvement in the case. The jurors would come from somewhere else. Later that month, after the two sides had weighed St. Joseph and Allen counties, she chose Allen County, in the northeast of the state, as the source of the jury, with the trial itself to be held in Carroll County. The gag order stayed in place.

The charges changed shape before trial. In January 2024 the Carroll County prosecutor asked to amend them, saying the change would bring the charging papers into line with the evidence disclosed and the probable cause affidavit. In March 2024 the special judge allowed two further counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping, and refused the request to add separate kidnapping charges. Allen went to trial on four counts.

Pretrial custody

Allen spent the time before trial in state custody under a safekeeping order, held at a maximum-security state facility rather than a county jail. His conditions there would become the center of his defense and, later, of his appeal. He was kept in restrictive housing, in isolation and under constant watch, for more than a year. The state's position is that the restrictive housing was for his own safety.

For months Allen denied the killings. Then, in that custody, he began to admit them, repeatedly, in person, by telephone and in writing, to his wife, to his mother and to a psychologist who treated him at the facility. In one recorded call later played for the jury he told his wife that he had killed the two girls. The prosecution held that these statements were voluntary and made while he was lucid. The defense held that they were the words of a man in a severe mental health crisis brought on by isolation, who had come to believe in his own guilt.

In October 2023, after a breach of defense files by a former employee of one of his lawyers, the special judge removed his two public defenders over his objection. On January 18, 2024, the Indiana Supreme Court reinstated them; it denied his requests for a speedy trial and a new judge. The trial was later set for October 2024.

The rulings before trial

With his lawyers back, Allen's defense attacked the case on several fronts, and the special judge turned each attack aside. In January 2024 she refused to hold a hearing on whether the October 2022 warrant rested on false statements. She found that the affidavit gave a reasonable belief that evidence of the murders would be found at his home and in his vehicles, that it held no false statements, reckless omissions or intent to mislead, and that the warrant was valid, so the search was "reasonable and legal under Indiana law and Fourth Amendment case law." On the same record she denied the motion to suppress what the search had produced, and she refused to exclude the state's comparison of the physical evidence, finding it relevant and admissible and not likely to confuse or mislead a jury.

The defense also asked her to dismiss the charges because recordings of some of the earliest interviews in the 2017 investigation had been recorded over. In April 2024 she refused. The loss was a mistake, she found, not a deliberate act, and the defense had not shown that the lost material could have proved someone else responsible, or that it was destroyed negligently, intentionally or in bad faith. In August 2024 she denied a renewed request to dismiss on the same ground, and a request for sanctions against the prosecution, which she found had not complied with the trial rules.

The defense filed further requests for a hearing on the warrant in March and April 2024, citing evidence it said was newly disclosed, and when the special judge did not rule on them within the 30 days the trial rules allow, it asked in July 2024 that the case be taken away from her. The Indiana Supreme Court's chief administrative officer refused on July 19, 2024. Under the rule, the officer found, a party who lets the deadline pass and then keeps filing new motions with the same judge, instead of seeking withdrawal at once, gives up the right to that remedy, and Allen had done so on both motions. The case stayed with the special judge.

In late August 2024 she ruled that the jury could hear Allen's admissions from custody. She found that his statements to family members were voluntary and not the product of coercion, threats or improper influence; that his statements to other inmates and to correctional officers were unsolicited and not the result of any interrogation, since he had sought out those listeners himself; and that he had not shown psychological coercion. The court was "not persuaded that the detention caused the defendant to make incriminating statements," she wrote.

On September 4, 2024, she granted the state's request to bar the defense theory that people connected to a pagan religious group were responsible, along with any evidence pointing to other suspects. The order held that the defense bore the burden of showing a connection between any third party and the crime, and that the connection "must not be based on speculation, conjecture, rumors, or hearsay" but on admissible evidence. It left one narrow opening: the defense could make an offer of proof at trial outside the jury's presence. The defense asked her to certify the ruling for an immediate appeal, arguing that it denied Allen the right to present a defense under the state and federal constitutions. In September 2024 she refused, and the trial went ahead on schedule.

The trial

The jury came from Allen County, in northeastern Indiana, and was sequestered for the length of the trial, which began on October 18, 2024, in Delphi, the county seat, in the town where the girls and Allen had all lived.

The prosecution's case rested on three pillars. The first was identification: the Carroll County prosecutor argued that Allen was the man in the images and audio released in 2017, that the voice on the recording was his, and that his own account of what he had worn that day matched the clothing of the man in the images. An investigator testified to that account. The second was physical evidence that a state police examiner testified she had tied to property Allen owned. The third, and the heaviest, was his own words: the prosecutor told the jury that Allen had confessed again and again, and the recorded call to his wife was played in court. The psychologist who had treated him in custody testified about what he had told her.

The defense, led by the two reinstated public defenders with a third lawyer, answered each pillar in turn. No witness, they said, had explicitly identified Allen as the man near the trail, and no scientific evidence placed him there. A defense examiner disputed the state's comparison of the physical evidence and its underlying method. A defense psychiatrist testified that months of solitary confinement can cause delirium and psychosis, and the defense told the jury that the confessions were false.

On Monday, November 11, 2024, the jury found Allen guilty on all four counts.

At sentencing on Friday, December 20, 2024, Allen faced 45 to 130 years. The special judge entered sentence on two of the four counts and imposed the maximum, 65 years on each, to be served consecutively, a total of 130 years.

On January 20, 2025, the defense filed a 24-page verified motion to correct error, asking the trial court to vacate the convictions or order a new trial. It questioned the timeline the state had presented at trial, and raised issues about Allen's safekeeping order and about other evidence. The state answered on February 4 that much of this could have been raised at trial. On February 14, 2025, the special judge denied the motion.

The appeal

Allen's appellate lawyers filed a notice of appeal with the Indiana Court of Appeals in March 2025. Their 113-page brief, filed in December 2025, challenged both the convictions and the sentence and described one of its questions as an issue of first impression in Indiana. It raised three groups of claims.

The first concerned the October 2022 warrant. The defense argued that the lead investigator obtained it through false statements and material omissions, misstating what witnesses had described in order to fit Allen to the man in the images and misstating what Allen had said he wore. The evidence gathered under the warrant, the brief argued, should not have been admitted.

The second concerned the confessions. The defense argued that thirteen months of pretrial solitary confinement drove Allen into psychosis and that statements procured by exploiting that decline were involuntary and should have been excluded. It also argued that the trial court cut much of the testimony of the defense's expert on the effects of solitary confinement.

The third was the right to present a defense. The brief listed what the jury did not hear: an eyewitness's original sketch of a man near the trail, which did not resemble Allen; defense expert testimony challenging the state's comparison of the physical evidence; evidence pointing to two other men; the audio from prison videos that showed Allen's behavior while he was confessing, which the jury saw without sound; and the theory, excluded before trial, that the deaths were tied to a pagan ritual.

The state, through the Indiana Attorney General's office, answered in March 2026 with a brief asking the court to uphold the convictions. It argued that the warrant had been obtained properly and contained no false statements, so the search of Allen's home was lawful; that his admissions in custody were voluntary and unprompted, and not the product of his confinement; and that the trial court had been right to exclude the ritual theory as speculative, since the defense had not shown that either of the men it wished to blame had been present when the girls died. It also argued that the defense expert's testimony on ritual killing was properly kept out because she had formed her opinion before reviewing the evidence. The defense filed a reply in April 2026. In June 2026 the Court of Appeals granted the defense request for oral argument.

The argument took place on Monday, September 21, 2026, in Indianapolis, before a three-judge panel. The state asked the court to uphold the convictions, arguing that his admissions were voluntary; the judges questioned both sides on the excluded evidence and on whether any errors were harmless.

The panel took the case under advisement. The Court of Appeals has no deadline for a decision, and as of mid-November 2026 none had been announced. Allen remained in prison in Indiana, serving the 130-year sentence.

Context: the Supreme Court's counsel ruling

The Indiana Supreme Court's written opinion of February 8, 2024, set a rule for the whole state while it decided Allen's case. The court held that the extraordinary circumstances of the case justified taking it up as an original action, and that a trial court may not disqualify court-appointed counsel over the objection of both the defendant and counsel unless disqualification is a last resort, needed to protect specified interests, and those interests outweigh the prejudice to the defendant. Here, the court found, the special judge had not weighed her concerns against the harm to Allen, and the concerns she named could have been met with tools already at hand, among them contempt, sanctions and the protective and gag orders in the case.

The court refused the other two requests. Allen had never asked the trial court for a speedy trial, so there was no refusal to review. On the request for a new judge, the court held that prejudice is not inferred from adverse rulings, and that the special judge's actions reflected concern for Allen's right to effective counsel, not bias against him. Four justices joined the majority opinion. The fifth dissented from the reinstatement of counsel.

Allen has denied the murders from his arrest to his appeal, and his convictions are not final. His case for a new trial rests on four contested questions: whether his admissions in custody were voluntary or the product of a psychological breakdown in isolation; whether the warrant that produced the evidence against him was obtained honestly; whether the state's comparison of the physical evidence was sound; and whether the jury should have heard evidence pointing toward other people. The state disputes each claim. The defense theory that others connected to a pagan religious group were responsible was excluded at trial for lack of admissible evidence and remains part of the appeal.

Timeline

2006: Allen is living in Delphi.

February 13, 2017: Two girls die in Delphi.

February 2017: State police release images and an audio clip of a man; Allen tells the authorities he was in the area that afternoon.

July 2017: State police release a composite sketch.

April 2019: State police release a new sketch and further video and audio.

September 2022: A volunteer comes across the record of Allen's 2017 conversation.

October 13, 2022: Investigators interview Allen again and execute a warrant at his property.

October 28, 2022: Allen is arrested on two counts of murder.

October 31, 2022: The state police announce the arrest.

November 29, 2022: The probable cause affidavit is unsealed.

January 13, 2023: The special judge keeps the trial in Carroll County with a jury from another county.

January 2023: Allen County is chosen as the source of the jury.

October 2023: The two public defenders are removed after a breach of defense files.

January 18, 2024: The Indiana Supreme Court reinstates Allen's original lawyers.

January 2024: The special judge upholds the warrant and refuses to suppress the search.

February 8, 2024: The Supreme Court issues its written opinion.

March 2024: Two counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping are added.

April 2024: The motion to dismiss over recorded-over interviews is denied.

July 19, 2024: The Supreme Court's chief administrative officer refuses to take the case from the special judge.

August 2024: The special judge rules that the jury may hear Allen's admissions from custody.

September 4, 2024: The defense theory blaming others is barred; certification for an immediate appeal is refused later that month.

October 18, 2024: The trial opens in Delphi before a sequestered Allen County jury.

November 11, 2024: Allen is convicted of two counts of murder and two counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping.

December 20, 2024: Allen is sentenced to 130 years.

February 14, 2025: The motion to correct error is denied.

March 2025: Allen files a notice of appeal.

December 2025: The 113-page appellant's brief is filed.

March 2026: The state files its brief asking the court to uphold the convictions.

September 21, 2026: The Indiana Court of Appeals hears oral argument and takes the case under advisement.