Reinhold Hanning spent about two and a half years at Auschwitz as a member of the SS guard battalion that secured the camp. No court ever found that he killed anyone by his own hand, and for most of the seven decades after the war that would have been enough to keep him out of a German courtroom. It was not enough in 2016. On June 17 of that year the state court in Detmold, a small city in North Rhine-Westphalia, convicted him of accessory to murder in 170,000 cases and sentenced him to five years' imprisonment. He was 94. He had spent most of his adult life as a dairyman, had never spoken publicly about the camp, and broke that silence only in the courtroom, two months before the verdict.
The Detmold verdict is the only judgment of guilt any court gave against him, and it never became final. Hanning appealed, and he died on May 30, 2017, with the appeal still before the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe. A year later that court closed the case, as German law requires when a defendant dies, but it added a reasoned finding that the core of the Detmold conviction would have survived review. No appeal remains open. He never spent a day in prison.
Hanning joined the Hitler Youth with his school class in 1935, at the age of 13. He left elementary school at 14, and before the war he worked in a bicycle factory. At 18 he volunteered for the Waffen-SS, the armed branch of the SS; the Federal Court of Justice later fixed his membership as beginning in July 1940. He fought with the SS in the Netherlands, in the Balkans and on the Eastern Front.
The Detmold court traced that service in detail. After basic training with an SS replacement battalion in Graz, he joined the SS regiment "Der Führer" of the division "Das Reich" in December 1940. With it he served in the Netherlands, in northern France and in Serbia, and from June 25, 1941 in the invasion of the Soviet Union.
On September 20, 1941, in fighting near Kyiv, he was seriously wounded. By then he had been promoted to SS-Sturmmann. His commander judged him no longer fit for front-line service. In January 1942 he was assigned to the Totenkopfsturmbann, the SS Death's Head battalion at Auschwitz, the unit that guarded the entire camp complex in occupied Poland, its perimeter, its railway ramps and the movement of prisoners within it. The court fixed the day he arrived as January 23, 1942.
He told the court years later that he had not known what Auschwitz was when he arrived, and that he understood quickly. He also said he had twice asked to be sent back to the front, and that both requests were refused.
Hanning first served on registration patrols and on details guarding prisoners at work, and later stood duty in a guard tower. The Detmold court found that his first post was at the gate, in the guardroom at the entrance to the main camp. He was placed first in the battalion's 5th Company and, from June 7, 1942, in its 3rd Company. During the period the prosecution would later charge, from January 1, 1943 to June 12, 1944, he belonged to that 3rd Company. From November 22, 1943 the company was assigned to the main camp, Auschwitz I. Its men guarded the camp's perimeter and the prisoners sent out to labor beyond it. He was promoted twice in his time there: to SS-Rottenführer on February 1, 1943, and to SS-Unterscharführer, roughly a junior sergeant, on September 1, 1943. He was sent on a two-month course at an SS officer school, and the court found that he came to lead a group of up to 15 guards, a link between the company's command and its men.
The Detmold court found that, until a new railway ramp was completed inside Birkenau in May 1944, Hanning stood guard at least three times at the old ramp, where deportation trains were unloaded. Guards on that duty watched the people leaving the trains and escorted those selected for death. The prosecution's case was that guards from the main camp were used as a standing reserve for Birkenau, the vast second camp where most of the victims of Auschwitz died, whenever large transports arrived, and above all during the deportation of Hungarian Jews in the spring of 1944. Hanning told investigators that he had served in the main camp and denied ever serving at Birkenau.
No document placed him on the ramp by name. The court reached its finding from the way the garrison worked. Guard duties rotated week by week among all the companies, with no company kept to a single task, as a historian of the SS and several former guards described it. Surviving orders showed the 3rd Company on standby duty in 1943. And Hanning himself admitted that his company had served on the ramp. The court made no finding that he had been posted to Birkenau, but it found that he could move freely about the Auschwitz camps, Birkenau included.
The court also drew a line in time. From May 17, 1944, trains were unloaded at the new ramp inside Birkenau, and the companies of the main camp no longer guarded those arrivals. The court therefore did not hold him responsible for the murders of the Hungarian deportees who arrived from that day on, although the prosecution had charged him with aiding the Hungarian deportations.
His service at Auschwitz ended in June 1944. The court's figure of 170,000 victims covered the people murdered in the camp during the charge period. The prosecution arrived at that number by working through the surviving transport records. The charge period ran only from January 1943, for legal reasons, though the court weighed his full time at the camp in reaching its verdict.
From Auschwitz he was transferred in June 1944 to Sachsenhausen, the concentration camp north of Berlin, and he signed on to serve twelve years in the SS. In April 1945, in the last weeks of the war, he was sent to a combat group of an SS panzer corps. British forces took him prisoner in May 1945, and he was held until May 1948.
After the war Hanning settled in the Detmold area and worked in the dairy trade, as a dairy and cheese maker and later, from 1969, running a dairy business of his own. He retired in 1984. He lived in Lage, a town next to Detmold, and he had no criminal record. He told the court that he had tried his whole life to forget that time and to push the memory of Auschwitz away.
For most of his life a camp guard who could not be tied to a specific killing was, in practice, beyond the reach of German prosecutors.
That changed in 2011, when a Munich court convicted a former guard at the Sobibor extermination camp as an accessory to murder without proof that he had taken part in any individual killing.
After that verdict the Central Office of the State Justice Administrations for the Investigation of National Socialist Crimes, the federal body in Ludwigsburg that investigates Nazi-era crimes, went back through its files on the Auschwitz garrison. In late 2013 it produced leads on about 30 surviving suspects and sent their cases to state prosecutors with a recommendation to bring charges. Hanning's was one of them.
His case went to the Dortmund prosecutor's office, which handles Nazi-era crimes for North Rhine-Westphalia, and the investigation opened in November 2013. Prosecutors relied on SS company lists to place him in the Auschwitz garrison. When prosecutors and police first questioned him, in February 2014, he admitted serving at Auschwitz I. It was the first time, the court later found, that he had spoken of his service there. The prosecution did not accuse him of taking a direct part in any killing. It charged him with 170,000 counts of accessory to murder on the theory that, as a guard, he had helped the camp to function.
The trial opened in the Detmold state court on February 11, 2016. Hanning declined to make an opening statement, and for weeks he said nothing about the charges. Survivors and the families of victims from Hungary, Israel, Canada, Britain, the United States and Germany joined the case as co-plaintiffs, and about a dozen survivors testified over the four months of the trial.
The first witness, a survivor who had been put to forced labor outside the camp, spoke directly to the man in the dock and urged him to tell the truth. None of the witnesses knew Hanning personally, and none claimed to. Their testimony was about the camp he had guarded, about forced labor and selections and families torn apart there. He sat a few yards away and listened closely, showing no emotion.
On April 29, 2016, Hanning gave the court his account. One of his lawyers read a statement of more than 20 pages on his behalf. It traced his path from the Hitler Youth to the Waffen-SS, the wound near Kyiv and the posting to Auschwitz. It acknowledged that he had known people were being killed in the camp, and that most of those who arrived on the trains were murdered. It did not admit any part in a killing.
Then Hanning spoke for himself. He said he deeply regretted having been part of a criminal organization and that he had kept silent all his life. "I am ashamed that I knowingly let injustice happen and did nothing to oppose it," he said, and he apologized formally for what he had done.
It was the first public account he had ever given of his time at Auschwitz.
The verdict came on June 17, 2016. Hanning listened without visible reaction.
The court convicted him of "Beihilfe zum Mord in 170.000 tateinheitlich zusammentreffenden Fällen," accessory to murder in 170,000 cases joined in a single offense, and sentenced him to five years' imprisonment. The prosecution had asked for six years. The defense had asked for acquittal.
The court found that Hanning knew innocent people were being murdered at Auschwitz every day, and that through his service, wherever he was posted, he helped ensure that the killing ran smoothly. It found that his time on the ramp guarded the unloading of the trains and the passage of those selected for death, and it held him responsible as well for the help given by the other guards with whom he served. In the court's view his role as a guard made a considerable contribution, making the murders possible many thousands of times. Although the charges were confined to 1943 and 1944, the court took into account his nearly two and a half years at the camp.
The written judgment set out how the court reached its figure. It found that more people were murdered at Auschwitz during the charge period than the number in the verdict. It came down to 170,000 by setting aside killings in which it could not rule out that the legal elements of murder were missing, and by leaving out the stretches, of up to three months, when Hanning was away from the camp on courses or on leave and contributed nothing to what happened there.
The judgment explained, too, why he was an accessory and not a co-perpetrator. He had no control over the killings themselves, he had no stake of his own in their outcome, and his SS pay did not depend on how many people died. The court did not find that he had acted from base motives of his own. It rejected any defense of superior orders or duress, finding that he knew the orders were not binding and that no case was known in which an SS man's refusal had been punished with prison or death.
In fixing the sentence, the court counted in his favor his partial admission and his apology, his youth at the time, the fact that he had acted on orders and not on his own initiative, the more than seventy years that had passed, his great age and his clean record. Against him it weighed a position in the camp hierarchy above that of an ordinary guard, the length of his service and the number of victims. Five years, it held, was the least that would reflect his guilt.
The sentence was not enforced while the case was under appeal, and Hanning stayed free.
Hanning's lawyers appealed on points of law, a Revision, to the Federal Court of Justice, Germany's highest court in criminal matters.
On September 20, 2016, in the case of another former SS man at Auschwitz, that court confirmed for the first time that service of that kind could support a conviction for accessory to murder. Hanning's appeal was assigned to the court's 4th Criminal Senate and was still waiting for decision the following spring.
Reinhold Hanning died on May 30, 2017, at the age of 95. The verdict against him had not become legally binding.
On May 24, 2018, the 4th Criminal Senate discontinued the proceedings. Under § 206a of the Code of Criminal Procedure a defendant's death is a bar to further proceedings, and the Detmold judgment lapsed with it. The Senate did not stop there. To decide who should bear the costs, it had to ask whether the appeal would have succeeded, and it gave its answer. The judgment as a whole, it held, showed that Hanning had stood at least one standby duty at the old ramp, guarding deportees as they left the arriving trains and escorting those selected for death, and that this concretely furthered their murder. To that extent the conviction for accessory to murder under §§ 211 and 27 of the Criminal Code would have stood. Whether all three ramp duties had been proven was left open, since that touched only the extent of his guilt and the sentence. The Senate also left open whether his liability reached victims with no proven link to his own duties, noting that membership of the guard battalion alone did not readily justify charging him with every killing that unit protected.
Hanning never admitted taking part in any killing. His defense maintained throughout that he had killed or harmed no one, and that he had served at the main camp and not at Birkenau, the site of most of the murders. The prosecution did not allege that he killed anyone himself, and the conviction did not rest on any such finding. The Detmold court made no finding that he had been posted to Birkenau.
The Detmold court rejected two parts of his own account. It did not accept his denial that he had ever been sent to the old ramp, since he admitted that his company had served there. And it did not accept that his requests to return to the front had been refused. On the evidence of the historian and of former SS men whose own requests had succeeded, it found that voluntary transfers from Auschwitz to the front had been possible throughout.
The extent of his duties at the old ramp was never finally settled. The Detmold court found at least three such duties. The Federal Court of Justice found the evidence of at least one sufficient to sustain the conviction and declined to decide whether the other two were proven.
Whether the full figure of 170,000 victims could properly be laid at his door was also left unresolved. The Federal Court of Justice found the core of the conviction sound but expressly left open whether liability extended to victims with no proven connection to his own service. Because he died before the appeal was decided, the conviction never became final, and no court ever gave a binding ruling on either point.
1935: Joins the Hitler Youth with his school class, at 13.
July 1940: Becomes a member of the Waffen-SS, which he joined as a volunteer at 18.
December 1940: Joins the SS regiment "Der Führer" of the division "Das Reich."
June 25, 1941: Enters the invasion of the Soviet Union with his regiment.
September 20, 1941: Seriously wounded in fighting near Kyiv and later judged unfit for front-line service.
January 23, 1942: Arrives at Auschwitz, assigned to the SS Death's Head battalion.
June 7, 1942: Moves from the battalion's 5th Company to its 3rd Company.
January 1, 1943: Start of the period later charged.
February 1, 1943: Promoted to SS-Rottenführer.
September 1, 1943: Promoted to SS-Unterscharführer.
November 22, 1943: The 3rd Company is assigned to the main camp, Auschwitz I.
May 17, 1944: Arriving trains are now unloaded at the new ramp inside Birkenau; until then he has stood guard at the old ramp at least three times.
June 12, 1944: End of the charge period; in June 1944 he is transferred to Sachsenhausen.
April 1945: Sent to a combat group of an SS panzer corps.
May 1945: Taken prisoner by British forces; held until May 1948.
1969: Begins running a dairy business of his own.
1984: Retires from the dairy trade.
2011: A Munich court's conviction of a former Sobibor guard opens the way to prosecuting camp guards as accessories.
Late 2013: The Ludwigsburg Central Office sends about 30 Auschwitz cases, his among them, to state prosecutors; the Dortmund investigation opens in November.
February 2014: Questioned for the first time, he admits serving at Auschwitz I.
February 11, 2016: His trial opens at the Landgericht Detmold.
April 29, 2016: A statement is read on his behalf, and he apologizes to the court in his own words.
June 17, 2016: Convicted of accessory to murder in 170,000 cases and sentenced to five years' imprisonment; he appeals.
September 20, 2016: In another former SS man's case, the Federal Court of Justice upholds the legal theory used against him.
May 30, 2017: Dies at 95 with his appeal pending.
May 24, 2018: The Federal Court of Justice discontinues the proceedings, finding that the core of the conviction would have stood; the case is closed.