Reginald and Jonathan Carr

Victims
5 killed in Wichita, December 2000; both sentenced to death. Each convicted of capital murder (one count upheld, 2014) and first-degree murder; death sentences affirmed 2022 and 2026
Years active
December 7 to 15, 2000
Location
Wichita, Kansas, USA
Method
Capital murder; first-degree murder; attempted murder; further felony counts
Status
Death (jury November 14, 2002; imposed November 15, 2002); affirmed 2022 and June 26, 2026; clemency denied July 14, 2026

In December 2000, over little more than a week, two brothers from Kansas left five people dead in Wichita; two others survived. Reginald Carr and his younger brother, Jonathan, were tried together in 2002 and convicted of capital murder for four deaths on December 15, 2000, of first-degree murder in the death of a woman four days earlier, and of the attempted murder of a woman who lived through the night of December 15 and later testified against them. A Sedgwick County jury sentenced both men to death. The appeals then ran for more than two decades: the Kansas Supreme Court set the death sentences aside in 2014, the United States Supreme Court restored them in 2016 in Kansas v. Carr, and the Kansas Supreme Court affirmed them in 2022 and again in June 2026. In July 2026 the governor of Kansas refused both men clemency. They remain on death row in Kansas.

Reginald Carr was the elder of the two, and both were in their early twenties in December 2000. The Kansas Supreme Court's opinions, issued in pairs, call them R. Carr and J. Carr. Their cases were joined from the first charge to the last ruling.

The first days of December

The run of crimes began on December 7, 2000, with a case in Wichita in which a man survived. Reginald Carr was later convicted on the counts in that case. Jonathan Carr was charged as well, and on that case alone the jury found him not guilty of all four counts.

Four days later, on December 11, 2000, Ann Walenta became the next victim in Wichita. She later died. Both brothers were convicted of first-degree murder in her death. It was not charged as a capital crime, and at sentencing each brother received a life term for it, with no parole eligibility for 20 years.

December 15, 2000

The four people who died on December 15, 2000, were Aaron Sander, Brad Heyka, Jason Befort and Heather Muller. A fifth person, a woman, survived. She became the central witness at the trial, and the United States Supreme Court would later note that the crimes had been described in detail by the surviving victim, whatever the shape of the sentencing hearing.

Each of the four counts that reached the jury for sentencing carried a victim's name. The Kansas Supreme Court would later uphold the multiple-killing count tied to the fourth of those names as the one capital murder conviction that could stand for each brother. That single count, Count 2 of the original charging scheme, became the legal hinge on which more than two decades of appeals turned.

Arrest and charges

Both brothers were in custody in Wichita on December 15, 2000, the day the four deaths came to light. The Office of the District Attorney for the 18th Judicial District, which covers Sedgwick County, charged each of them with eight counts of capital murder that year. The eight counts were built in pairs. For each of the four victims, one count alleged a killing committed in the course of rape or aggravated criminal sodomy, and the other alleged multiple killings committed as part of the same act or transaction, or in connected acts, or as part of a common scheme. Further counts covered the other crimes of December 7 to 15, including the December 11 murder and the December 7 case, and an amended complaint followed on January 4, 2001.

The preliminary hearing was held in April 2001. The woman who had survived December 15 identified Jonathan Carr from the witness stand. She did not identify his brother at that hearing; she would do so only at trial, eighteen months later.

The prosecution announced that it would seek the death penalty against both men.

Both defense teams asked for separate trials, contending that the two defenses would be antagonistic and that a joint trial would put each brother's record before the jury deciding the other's case. The State opposed the motions. In April 2002 the Sedgwick County district judge presiding over the case denied the motions and ordered a joint trial. The defense also asked to move the trial out of Sedgwick County because of pretrial publicity; it stayed in Wichita.

The trial

Jury selection began on September 9, 2002. During selection the defense used a peremptory strike to remove a Black prospective juror; the State objected that the strike was race-based, and the judge sustained the objection and seated the juror. That ruling would return on appeal.

The trial ran for nearly two months in the fall of 2002. In October the woman who had survived December 15 took the stand and identified both brothers in court. Each brother's defense sought, in its own way, to shift responsibility toward the other, the conflict the severance motions had foreseen. Reginald Carr's defense contended that his brother had acted with another man, who was never identified.

The jurors deliberated for nearly 14 hours. On Monday, November 4, 2002, they returned their verdicts. Reginald Carr was convicted on all 50 counts against him. Jonathan Carr was convicted on 43 counts and found not guilty of the four counts in the December 7 case. Both were convicted on all eight counts of capital murder, of first-degree murder for December 11, and of attempted murder of the surviving woman.

The penalty phase

The penalty phase began the next day before the same jury. The prosecution asked for death on the four capital murders and rested without calling further witnesses, relying on what the jury had already heard. The instructions told the jury that it could find aggravating circumstances if the crime was committed for monetary gain or to evade arrest, among the statutory aggravators. In all, the State relied on four statutory aggravating circumstances, among them that the defendants had knowingly killed more than one person, had acted to obtain money or other things of value, and had acted to prevent a lawful arrest or prosecution. The defense presented mitigation built on the brothers' upbringing and asked the jury for mercy.

Defense witnesses filled nearly two weeks of testimony. Brain-scan evidence offered by the defense was answered by a State rebuttal expert.

For sentencing purposes the eight capital counts were merged into one count for each victim. The jury was told that, if not sentenced to death, the defendants would not be eligible for parole for between 50 and 268 years. It found that the aggravating circumstances were not outweighed by the mitigating ones. Its verdicts found all four aggravating circumstances proved beyond a reasonable doubt. On the evening of Thursday, November 14, 2002, it returned death verdicts against both brothers on all four counts.

The next day, Friday, November 15, 2002, the district judge followed the jury's verdict and imposed the death sentences. He also sentenced each brother on the noncapital convictions: a life term with no parole for 20 years for the December 11 murder, and additional terms of 47 years for Reginald and 41 years for Jonathan, to run consecutively. In announcing the death sentences, the judge used the penalty-phase numbering of the counts. That choice of numbers, a routine matter in 2002, would become the subject of a full appeal 24 years later.

The 2014 decisions

The brothers' appeals went to the Kansas Supreme Court and were heard as companion cases: State v. Reginald Carr and State v. Jonathan Carr. The court heard argument on December 17, 2013, and issued its decisions on July 25, 2014, in a separate opinion for each man.

The court was unanimous in reversing three of each defendant's four capital murder convictions. The counts that rested on the rape and sodomy theory, Counts 1, 3, 5 and 7, fell because of faulty jury instructions. Of the four multiple-killing counts, the court held that only one could stand, because the others duplicated it. The one it kept was Count 2, the multiple-killing count that named the fourth victim. Across both cases the court upheld 57 of the 93 convictions the brothers had received.

Beyond the capital counts, the court reversed a group of further December 15 convictions that, it held, had been charged and instructed in a form that left the district court without jurisdiction over them, and one more as a duplicate of another. Reginald Carr was left with 32 convictions and Jonathan Carr with 25. Each still stood convicted of capital murder and of the December 11 murder, and the State kept the right to try the penalty phase again.

The guilt-phase opinion found a long list of errors and divided over what they meant. By six votes to one, the court held that the trial judge had abused his discretion in refusing to sever the brothers' trials: their defenses were antagonistic, the State conceded as much, and the judge had neither carried out the required analysis nor correctly judged what evidence separate trials would admit. By four votes to three, it held that the error did not require reversal, because the independent evidence against each brother was strong and would have been admissible in a separate trial. It was unanimous that the judge had erred in sustaining the State's objection to the defense strike, since he had skipped the final step of the required analysis, but it held four to three that the error did not by itself require reversal, because the juror had properly been kept on the panel when the defense challenged him for cause.

The court went through the rest of the trial issue by issue. Statements the December 11 victim made to three officers were testimonial and should not have come in through them, it held, but the error was harmless because the same account came in properly through other witnesses. The automatic exclusion of a defense expert on eyewitness identification was error, and so was the trial judge's handling of the rules on evidence pointing to a third party and on hearsay, but neither required reversal on its own. By four votes to three, the court found the evidence sufficient for the felony-murder conviction for December 11 and held that the errors taken together did not require a new trial. It rejected the venue challenge by six votes to one.

On the death sentences the court divided six to one. The majority vacated them for both brothers. Its central holding was that the district court's refusal to sever the penalty phase had violated each man's Eighth Amendment right to an individualized sentencing determination. It also found error in the district court's refusal to let the defense remove a juror for cause, and it noted, for guidance on remand, that the jury had not been told that mitigating circumstances need not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The cases were sent back to Sedgwick County for new sentencing proceedings.

The majority did not go as far as three justices wanted. Those three would have found that the cumulative errors at trial required the reversal of every conviction and a new trial; one of them would also have held that pretrial publicity required a change of venue. The lone dissenter on the sentencing question saw no reason to vacate the death sentences at all.

Kansas v. Carr

The State did not accept the ruling. On October 16, 2014, the Kansas Attorney General petitioned the United States Supreme Court for review in Jonathan Carr's case, and a parallel petition followed in Reginald Carr's. Each brother filed a petition of his own against the 2014 decision as well, Reginald Carr's on October 17, 2014, and Jonathan Carr's on November 18. On March 30, 2015, the Court denied both brothers' petitions and, the same day, granted the State's.

The Court granted review limited to two questions, and joined the brothers' cases with that of Sidney Gleason, another Kansas defendant whose death sentence the state court had vacated over the mitigating-circumstances instruction. It did not take up a third question the State had raised, whether the Confrontation Clause applies at the stage of a capital sentencing hearing in which the jury selects the sentence. The cases were argued on October 7, 2015.

The Court decided Kansas v. Carr on January 20, 2016, by a vote of eight to one. On the first question it held that the Eighth Amendment does not require a capital sentencing court to tell jurors that mitigating circumstances need not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, and that the Kansas instructions would not have led jurors to think they could not consider relevant mitigating evidence. On the second it held that "The Constitution did not require severance of the Carrs' joint sentencing proceedings." The test, the majority wrote, was whether the joint proceeding had so infected the sentencing with unfairness as to deny due process, and limiting instructions, together with the presumption that jurors follow them, were enough to prevent that. The one dissenting justice would have dismissed the cases as improvidently granted, reasoning that the Kansas court had not violated any federal right and that its ruling rested on the state's own statute and instruction history. The judgments of the Kansas Supreme Court were reversed and the cases remanded. The mandate issued on February 23, 2016.

On remand

The remand did not end the case; it reopened it. Because the Kansas Supreme Court had decided the sentencing appeals on the two grounds the United States Supreme Court rejected, it had never ruled on the brothers' other penalty-phase claims. The court ordered further briefing and heard argument in both cases on May 4, 2017.

Two years later a new state-law argument appeared. In April 2019 the Kansas Supreme Court held, in Hodes & Nauser, MDs v. Schmidt, that section 1 of the Kansas Constitution Bill of Rights protects rights broader than and distinct from those in the Fourteenth Amendment. Every defendant then on Kansas death row asked leave to argue that the death penalty itself violated the natural right to life in section 1. The court allowed the Carrs to brief the point in June 2019, and later ordered Jonathan Carr's case to be prepared on a further claim that Kansas' death-sentencing scheme violates the "inviolate" right to trial by jury in section 5. The court heard both cases again on May 24, 2021.

The court ruled on January 21, 2022, in Jonathan Carr's case and in a companion opinion in Reginald Carr's. It affirmed both death sentences. On section 1, it held that the right to life is "inalienable," in the sense that it cannot be transferred to another, but that it "is not absolute or nonforfeitable": once a defendant is convicted of capital murder beyond a reasonable doubt, the state may punish that crime under the capital sentencing statute, while other constitutional guarantees continue to limit how it may do so. It rejected the section 5 jury-trial challenge to the practice of death-qualifying jurors. It declined to vacate the sentences on state-law grounds over the mitigation instruction. Among the remaining claims, it held that an earlier ruling, that the trial judge had abused his discretion by refusing a continuance so that a defense expert could answer a State expert, was harmless under either the constitutional or the state statutory test, and that any lack of detail in the instruction on the brothers' terms if not sentenced to death was state-law error only, with no reasonable probability of having changed the verdict. The majority concluded that the brothers had received fair trials.

The 2022 opinions worked through the rest of the penalty-phase record as well. The refusal to sever, a state-law error settled in 2014, had carried over into the penalty phase, the court held, but there was no reasonable probability that it affected the death verdicts. The court narrowed its own 2014 statement on confrontation, holding that in a Kansas penalty phase the Confrontation Clause reaches only evidence bearing on the aggravating circumstances, and it found that the State's rebuttal expert had given his own reading of the brain scans rather than passing on the views of colleagues. It overruled its 2017 holding that Kansas law requires an instruction on the burden of proof for mitigating circumstances. It held that the four aggravating circumstances were not unconstitutionally broad and that the instructions made clear that "the crime" in them meant capital murder. It found other errors, among them a penalty instruction that garbled the weighing standard with an extra negative, the failure to have the jury find that each brother was at least 18 at the time of the crimes, and two misstatements in the prosecution's arguments, and held each harmless. Weighing eleven guilt-phase errors and six penalty-phase errors together, the majority held that their cumulative effect could not have changed the verdicts.

The court did not speak with one voice. The chief justice would have vacated the sentences, and two other justices wrote separately. The court denied rehearing on May 4, 2022.

Reginald Carr petitioned the United States Supreme Court in July 2022, and Jonathan Carr, after an extension of time, in September. On January 9, 2023, the United States Supreme Court declined to review the 2022 decisions. With that, the brothers had exhausted their direct appeals, and the State treated the convictions and death sentences as final, while recognizing that further challenges could still be brought in state or federal court.

The question of the numbers

The next round began in Sedgwick County. The brothers asked the district court for a new sentencing hearing, arguing that because most of their capital convictions had been thrown out, a new sentencing was required. They also raised claims that their trial lawyers had been ineffective and that jurors had not been properly questioned about racial bias. On April 22, 2024, the chief judge of the Sedgwick County District Court denied the request, ruling that he lacked jurisdiction to reexamine sentences that no court had vacated. Both brothers appealed.

The Kansas Supreme Court heard those appeals together on January 28, 2026. The defense argued that the trial judge, in announcing the sentences in November 2002, had used the penalty-phase numbers, so that his "Count 2" referred to the count naming a different victim, a conviction overturned in 2014. On that reading no valid death sentence had ever been imposed on the surviving conviction, and the brothers were entitled to a new jury, new witnesses and a new penalty phase. The State answered that the sentence plainly rested on the capital murder conviction upheld in 2014, which the penalty-phase numbering had called Count 1, and that both men had therefore been validly sentenced to death.

On June 26, 2026, a unanimous Kansas Supreme Court decided the consolidated appeals. It agreed with the State that the trial judge had been clear when he imposed the death penalty, rejected each brother's arguments and upheld both death sentences. The court found no room to resentence the brothers, no basis to take up new legal challenges and no ground to declare the sentences illegal, treating an earlier appellate order as the final judgment that had settled the sentences. Jonathan Carr asked for rehearing; the court denied his motion on August 20, 2026.

While the last appeal was pending, both brothers applied to the governor for clemency, asking that their death sentences be commuted to life without the possibility of parole. On July 14, 2026, the governor of Kansas denied both commutation requests in a single decision. The notice set no execution date.

In November 2026 both brothers remain under sentence of death in Kansas. On November 2, 2026, Jonathan Carr applied to the United States Supreme Court, through the circuit justice for the Tenth Circuit, for more time to petition for review of the June decision. His petition had been due on November 18; on November 9 the application was granted and the deadline extended to December 18, 2026. The application says he intends to argue that the Kansas court decided questions under the state capital sentencing statute in a way that conflicts with the Supreme Court's decisions on liberty interests created by state law.

The brothers have never conceded the convictions. At trial each blamed the other in part, and Jonathan Carr was acquitted of every count in the December 7 case. In 2014 the Kansas Supreme Court held that most of the capital convictions could not stand, and three of its justices would have ordered an entirely new trial. In 2022 the chief justice would have vacated the death sentences. Those views did not command a majority. The one capital murder conviction left for each brother in 2014 has stood through every later review, and the death sentences stand as affirmed in 2022 and June 2026, with Jonathan Carr's petition to the United States Supreme Court due by December 18, 2026.

Timeline

December 7, 2000: The first case, in Wichita, in which a man survives; Reginald Carr is later convicted in it and Jonathan Carr acquitted.

December 11, 2000: The crime in Wichita for which both brothers are later convicted of first-degree murder.

December 15, 2000: Four people die in Wichita; a fifth, a woman, survives. Both brothers are taken into custody the same day.

December 2000: Both brothers are charged with eight counts of capital murder each.

January 4, 2001: An amended complaint is filed.

April 2001: Preliminary hearing; the surviving woman identifies Jonathan Carr.

April 2002: The district judge orders a joint trial.

September 9, 2002: Jury selection begins.

October 2002: The surviving woman identifies both brothers at trial.

November 4, 2002: Reginald Carr is convicted on 50 counts and Jonathan Carr on 43.

November 14, 2002: The jury returns death verdicts against both men.

November 15, 2002: The district judge imposes the death sentences and the other terms.

December 17, 2013: Argument in the Kansas Supreme Court.

July 25, 2014: The Kansas Supreme Court reverses three capital murder convictions for each brother, upholds one, and vacates the death sentences.

March 30, 2015: The United States Supreme Court grants the State's petitions and denies the brothers' own.

October 7, 2015: Argument in Kansas v. Carr.

January 20, 2016: Kansas v. Carr reverses the Kansas decisions, 8 to 1.

May 4, 2017: Argument on remand in the Kansas Supreme Court.

May 24, 2021: Second argument on remand.

January 21, 2022: The Kansas Supreme Court affirms both death sentences.

May 4, 2022: Rehearing is denied.

January 9, 2023: The United States Supreme Court declines review.

April 22, 2024: The Sedgwick County District Court denies a new sentencing hearing.

January 28, 2026: Argument on the sentencing-count appeal.

June 26, 2026: The Kansas Supreme Court upholds both death sentences.

July 14, 2026: The governor denies both clemency requests.

August 20, 2026: Rehearing is denied in Jonathan Carr's case.

November 9, 2026: Jonathan Carr's time to seek federal review is extended to December 18, 2026.