Raymond Leslie Morris: The Monster of Cannock Chase

Victims
1 girl murdered in Staffordshire, 1967, by final conviction. Named in the press as prime suspect in the 1965 deaths of Margaret Reynolds, 6, and Diane Tift, 5; never charged.
Years active
Christine Darby was taken on August 19, 1967, and found on August 22, 1967.
Location
Walsall, Staffordshire (home; where Christine Darby was taken); Cannock Chase, Staffordshire (where she was found); Stafford (trial).
Method
Christine Darby was persuaded into a car near her home and was suffocated, according to the Express & Star. (One 2008 report says she was strangled.)
Status
Life imprisonment, February 18, 1969; appeal dismissed November 1969. Challenges to the conviction failed in 2010 and 2011. Died in custody at HMP Preston, March 11, 2014, aged 84.

Raymond Leslie Morris was convicted of one murder. On February 18, 1969, a jury at Stafford Assizes found him guilty of killing Christine Darby, a seven-year-old girl from Walsall who had been taken from a street near her home in August 1967 and found dead on Cannock Chase, three days later. He was a foreman engineer and a married man who lived in a council flat a short walk from Walsall police station. He was sentenced to life imprisonment, lost his appeal that November, and spent the rest of his life in prison, denying the murder until he died in 2014.

Christine Darby was the third young girl from the towns north of Birmingham to be taken and found dead on the Chase in less than two years. Margaret Reynolds, 6, of Aston, and Diane Tift, 5, of Bloxwich, disappeared in 1965 and were found there in January 1966. The Express & Star in Wolverhampton, the paper that covered the case from start to finish, has repeatedly called Morris the prime suspect in those two deaths. He was never charged with either, and both cases remain on file. In law, he killed one child. The other deaths are unsolved.

The hunt for Christine's killer was one of the largest murder inquiries in British history, larger, the Express & Star has said, than the inquiry into the Moors murders. Before the arrest, 150 detectives visited 39,000 homes, interviewed 80,000 people and checked more than a million car records. Morris was questioned four times and walked away each time, because his wife told detectives he had been with her. When she withdrew that alibi in November 1968, the case against him came together within days.

Walsall, 1929 to 1964

Morris was born in 1929 in Ryecroft, a district of Walsall, in what was then Staffordshire. He had an older sister and three younger brothers. One of those brothers later described him as calm and hard to rattle, and said the children were brought up strictly. Morris was clever and artistic; he painted and played music, but he did not do especially well at school. He went to North Walsall Secondary School and then worked as a pattern maker at a local works. He did his National Service in the Royal Air Force, at stations that included Cosford, Bridgnorth and London.

On July 28, 1951, he married a 19-year-old woman at St Peter's Church in Walsall, and the couple had two sons. He found it hard to keep a job. In 1958 he was tried at Walsall quarter sessions on a charge of stealing or receiving a tape recorder worth 80 pounds, and was acquitted. The marriage broke down, and the couple separated in 1960. His first wife later told of his demands on her and of a time he told her he wanted to kill her, though he never harmed her. They divorced in 1964, on the grounds of her adultery.

In August 1964 Morris married again. His second wife was 21 and had lived next door to his parents. They moved into a fourth-floor council flat in Walsall, about 100 yards from the town's police station. From 1967 he worked as a foreman engineer at a precision instruments factory in Oldbury. Police officers who later sat across a table from him remembered long silences, an unhurried manner and a stare that one of them never forgot.

Two girls in 1965

On September 8, 1965, Margaret Reynolds, six, went home from her primary school in Aston, Birmingham, for her lunch. Her older sister walked part of the way back with her. Margaret never returned to class, and her parents reported her missing. About 2,000 people searched for her in the hours after she vanished, and police questioned more than 25,000 people in the months that followed.

On December 30, 1965, Diane Tift, five, set off on foot between her grandmother's house and her own home in Bloxwich, Walsall. She was carrying a pink plastic handbag she had been given for Christmas. She never arrived, and her parents reported her missing that evening. Decades later her brother told the Express & Star that he had been very close to her and regretted leaving her.

On January 12, 1966, a workman found Diane's body on Cannock Chase. Margaret's body was found on the Chase the same day. The Express & Star has reported that Morris had a business appointment in the Aston area on the day Margaret disappeared. That is the only specific link to him the paper has published for her case, and it is not proof of anything. No one has ever been charged with either death. In 2011 and again in 2014 the paper reported that the two cases remained open on file.

The Express & Star has also linked Morris to an attack in December 1964 on a girl in Bloxwich who was lured into a car by a man who claimed to know her family. She survived. The case was unsolved at the time, and the paper later reported that Morris was found to have owned a car matching the one she described. He was never charged with that attack or convicted of it. The paper has also reported that he was a suspect in the disappearance in 1966 of a 10-year-old girl from Cannock who was never found, and that the inquiry into her case was abandoned. None of these cases was ever put to a court.

Christine Darby

Christine Ann Darby was seven years old in the summer of 1967. She was an only child and lived in Caldmore, Walsall, with her mother, a shop assistant, and her grandparents. On the afternoon of August 19, 1967, she went out to play with two friends near her home.

At some point after two o'clock (the Express & Star has given both "about 2pm" and "about 2.30pm"), a man in a grey car drew up and spoke to the children. He said he was lost and asked the way to Caldmore Green, and he asked Christine to get in and show him, promising to bring her back to her friends. She got in. Her friends watched the car turn and head away, not toward Caldmore Green but in the direction of Cannock Chase. They ran to tell her mother, who called the police from a telephone box.

The children's account became the foundation of the inquiry. They described a clean-shaven white man in his mid-thirties, with dark hair, driving a grey car that might have been an Austin Cambridge or a Morris Oxford, two cars that looked very much alike. One of the boys remembered that the man pronounced the name of the green "Calmer Green," the way local people said it. That small detail persuaded detectives that they were looking for a man from Walsall.

More than 1,000 people joined the search for Christine. Police set up roadblocks and printed 24,000 posters. More than 300 police officers, 200 officers from other forces and 250 soldiers searched Cannock Chase. On August 22, 1967, a soldier taking part in the search found her body on the Chase. She had been suffocated. Scotland Yard was called in.

The inquiry

The murder headquarters was set up in Cannock. Staffordshire's assistant chief constable, Stanley Bailey, who had moved to the force from the Metropolitan Police in 1965, led the hunt, according to his Express & Star obituary. Detective Superintendent Ian Forbes of Scotland Yard ran the murder inquiry day to day. Harry Bailey, head of Staffordshire CID, worked out a plan to close the roads out of Walsall within 20 minutes of any report of a child being taken. (The Express & Star's accounts give these men different ranks in different places.) Pat Molloy, then a detective chief inspector and later a detective chief superintendent, was one of the three leading officers and later wrote a book about the case.

Maureen Freeman joined Staffordshire Police in 1965 at 21 and was two years into her career when Christine was found. Years later, as a Cannock Chase district councillor, she described the work: answering telephones, taking hundreds of statements and searching the Chase. She had to cancel a two-week holiday. She called it the biggest manhunt of its time.

Two adult witnesses who had been on the Chase that afternoon described a grey car and a dark-haired man. From their accounts the police produced what the Express & Star has called the first color Identikit picture used in a British manhunt, and about 2,000 copies were sent out. The paper printed posters and the picture for the police. Detectives traced more than 600 vehicles seen on the Chase and 23,097 owners of Austin Cambridge cars, and interviewed more than 44,000 car owners. One account says about 25,000 vehicles were examined, including every Austin A55 and A60 in the Midlands.

The two earlier deaths gave the inquiry its sense of urgency. Assistant Chief Constable Tom Lockley told the public that the police were hunting a dangerous child killer who might strike again. In January 1968, 200 detectives went from door to door across Walsall, visiting 54,000 homes, and every man between 21 and 50 was asked to fill in a questionnaire about his movements and his car.

Four interviews and an alibi

Morris was questioned four times between 1964 and 1968, the Express & Star has reported, and at first he was treated as a strong suspect. In 1967 detectives asked him about his grey Austin. His wife told them that he had been out shopping with her on the afternoon Christine was taken, and the matter was dropped. Each time his name came up, she backed him, and each time no further action was taken. Officers even traveled to Wales to talk to one of his relatives, Maureen Freeman recalled.

There were other warnings. In October 1966 two schoolgirls who had been hanging around the factory where he then worked complained about him to their parents. He was arrested, his flat was searched, nothing was found and he was released without charge. In 1967 a police cadet, Alan Parker, who had taken part in the search of the Chase, logged an arrest of Morris for indecent exposure and noticed that it was recorded as his second offense. Parker passed the information to Ian Forbes.

In February 1968, two officers who checked Morris's questionnaire noted that his alibi rested on his wife alone and that he looked very like the Identikit picture. His employer's records, later examined by the police, showed that he had clocked out of work at 1:13 p.m. on August 19, 1967, about 75 minutes before Christine was taken. But for the moment, his wife's account stood. In October 1968, Forbes told the press that he was confident the composite picture was a good likeness.

November 1968

What broke the case was a failed abduction. On November 4, 1968 (the Express & Star's 2022 account places it in October), a man in a car stopped beside a girl who was playing on waste ground in Walsall and offered her fireworks. She hesitated, and when he tried to pull her into the car she broke free. A young woman of 18 who saw it happen noted the car, a green Ford Corsair with a cream roof, and its registration number.

She had two of the digits in the wrong order. The police search for the number she gave found nothing, and officers worked through the night until they found an identical car whose registration differed only in those two transposed figures. It was registered to Raymond Leslie Morris of Walsall. He was arrested the next morning and his car was seized. On the way to the police station an officer remarked on the car, and Morris said he had bought it the year before, after owning a grey Austin Cambridge. The young woman did not pick him out at an identity parade, and he was released.

On November 15, 1968, police stopped Morris at 7:30 a.m. as he drove to work and arrested him for the murder of Christine Darby. "Oh God! Is it my wife?" he asked. His wife was taken in and interviewed the same day. At first she repeated the alibi. Within hours she withdrew it. Her husband, she now said, had come home close to five o'clock that afternoon, not two, and had taken her to Marks and Spencer just before the shop closed. Searching the flat, police found indecent photographs of a child that Morris had taken himself. The man in the pictures could be seen only in part, but he wore a watch like one found strapped to Morris's ankle, and the scars on his hands matched Morris's.

Detective Constable Trevor Lowbridge, then three years into a 30-year career, was one of the two officers who interviewed Morris. He played the friendly one, trying to get the suspect talking, and got almost nothing. He remembered long silences, including a pause before Morris would even give his name, and he never managed to build any rapport. "He was cold, calculated and icy the whole time," Lowbridge told the Express & Star in 2015. Maureen Freeman remembered the reaction among the inquiry staff: "When we heard he had been arrested we just collapsed with relief."

Morris was charged with Christine's murder on November 17, 1968. In December further charges followed, among them the attempted abduction of the girl in November. He appeared before Cannock magistrates on January 7, 1969, where, the Express & Star reports, he pleaded guilty to some of the other charges.

Stafford Assizes, 1969

The trial opened at Stafford Assizes in February 1969 before Mr. Justice Ashworth. Crowds queued for seats in the public gallery. On February 10, 1969, Morris pleaded not guilty to Christine's murder and to the attempted abduction. His counsel, Kenneth Mynett, asked for the charges to be tried separately; the judge refused.

His wife was the chief witness for the prosecution. She told the court that she had agreed to back up his account because she "didn't think he could be the person responsible." One of the adult witnesses from the Chase had identified Morris at the police station, and Morris had refused to take part in a second identity parade. In the dock, Morris claimed that police officers had beaten him and that he had never been allowed to stand in an identity parade. Maureen Freeman, the young officer from the incident room, was one of those chosen to attend the trial.

On February 18, 1969, after about two hours, the jury convicted Morris of the murder of Christine Darby, with other charges. He was sentenced to life imprisonment. As the sentence was passed, Morris stared coldly at his wife. The judge thanked Ian Forbes and his officers, and said: "There must be many mothers in Walsall and the area whose hearts will beat more lightly as a result of this verdict."

The case did not end in the courtroom for the people of Walsall. After the verdict a local man began a petition calling for the return of capital punishment, and it gathered more than 18,000 signatures. On March 28, 1969, a car dealer from Dudley who had bought Morris's old grey Austin Cambridge for 195 pounds burned it on his forecourt in front of a crowd. He said afterward that the money had been well spent.

Appeal and prison

Morris appealed against his conviction, and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal in November 1969. He was sent to HMP Durham, where Ian Brady, convicted of the Moors murders, was also held. The two men were later in HMP Preston together again. The Express & Star has described a rivalry between them over which of them was the better known, and has reported that their clashes often turned violent.

Morris was refused parole in 1999. From 2000 he was held at HMP Wymott, near Preston in Lancashire, where he lived a solitary and largely anonymous life among much younger prisoners. By the time he died he was one of the oldest-serving prisoners in Britain.

The challenge to the conviction

Morris never admitted the murder. His legal team spent seven years reviewing the 1969 conviction, and his solicitors argued that police officers had behaved improperly, in particular that interview notes had been tampered with. In June 2010 the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the body that decides whether old convictions in England and Wales should go back to the Court of Appeal, refused to refer his case.

In November 2010 his solicitor, Amy-Jo Cutts, said she had been given permission to seek a judicial review of that refusal, with a hearing due in December at the Administrative Court in Leeds. She said that Morris, then 81, was physically well but that the years had taken their toll. "He lives a quiet and simple prison life and doesn't want that notoriety and huge stigma," she told the Express & Star. "It has been quite a battle for Ray, who has always maintained his innocence." She said that going to the press was a last attempt: "Using the media was not something we wanted to do but this is a last-ditch attempt." Had the conviction been quashed, the paper noted, it would have been the longest-running miscarriage of justice in British history.

At the hearing in December, John McGuinness QC told the court that the claim was bound to fail. On February 7, 2011, at the Royal Courts of Justice in London, Mr. Justice Simon dismissed it. Morris was said to be extremely disappointed, and for a time he considered taking his case to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. In April 2011 a spokeswoman for his solicitors confirmed that the plan had been dropped. "It was the plan to go to the European Court of Human Rights and there were discussions about that, but it has come to an end," she said. That was the end of his attempts to clear his name.

Pat Molloy, by then retired, had always said he had no doubt that Morris was guilty. "I would describe him as cold, cruel, lustful and just plain wicked," he said. After Morris's death he added that he was "quite happy that he is a guilty man and that he is a killer."

Life means life

In July 2013 the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights ruled that prisoners serving whole-life terms should be entitled to have their sentences reviewed, the Express & Star reported, and the paper said that the ruling could in principle allow Morris to seek release. Maureen Freeman, by then 69 and a district councillor in Cannock, was dismayed. She called the ruling a disgrace and said it showed a total disregard for the victims of murder. "I have never seen a man with such cold and calculating eyes," she said of the man she had seen in court in 1969.

In February 2014 the Court of Appeal in London ruled that whole-life sentences could continue to be imposed for the most serious crimes. The Express & Star reported that the ruling confirmed Morris would die in prison. He died within weeks.

Illness and death

Morris had lived a healthy life in prison until 2011, when the first signs of kidney failure and chronic myeloid leukemia appeared. Over the next three years he had blood transfusions, a biopsy and regular dialysis. In June 2012 he instructed a solicitor to apply for his release on compassionate grounds, but the papers were never filed. He asked staff not to resuscitate him if his heart or breathing stopped.

On March 1, 2014, he signed a disclaimer refusing further active treatment. He did not want his family to be told. He ruled out any new application for release, saying he had nowhere to go and no support network. On March 10 he was moved from HMP Wymott to the medical unit at HMP Preston, and he died there the next evening, March 11, 2014, aged 84. Prison officials said at the time that he had probably died of natural causes. He had spent almost 45 years in custody. Prison staff attended his funeral, which was paid for from public funds.

His death was investigated by the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman. The ombudsman, Nigel Newcomen, described the death as peaceful and painless; his report recorded that Morris became unresponsive late in the afternoon and "died peacefully at 7.40pm." A clinical reviewer found that his medical care had been equal to what he could have expected outside prison. But Newcomen criticized HMP Wymott for keeping Morris handcuffed and chained during hospital treatment, including dialysis, in 2013 and 2014, with two officers beside him whenever he left his cell. Restraining a sick and frail prisoner during life-saving treatment, he said, would be considered inhumane under a High Court ruling, and he said the governor must make sure staff understood their legal duties. The report also noted some good practice at both prisons.

The families

The family of Diane Tift has spoken often. Her brother has never accepted that Morris should be freed. "Life should mean life," he told the Express & Star, which printed his words again in its report on Morris's death in 2014.

The family of Margaret Reynolds has spoken less often. In 2017 her older sister joined Diane Tift's family in opposing a stage play about the case.

A play withdrawn

In November 2017 a Cannock amateur company, the Tower Players, announced a play called "Morris: The Cannock Chase Murderer," to be staged at the Prince of Wales Theatre in Cannock the following May. Its writer, Peter Sidgwick, a 70-year-old former teacher from Hednesford who chaired the company, had worked on it for about two years. He drew largely on Pat Molloy's book, on his own research and on Express & Star cuttings. The play was to open in a present-day pub, with Maureen Freeman discussing the case, and the children's parts were to be voice-overs. Sidgwick said the audience would be left to decide whether Morris was responsible for the deaths of Diane Tift and Margaret Reynolds, and he invited the victims' relatives to contact him and read the script.

The families reacted with anger. Diane Tift's niece started a petition, saying the play was extremely insensitive and would reopen wounds that had never healed. Her father, Diane's brother, was reported to be distraught. Relatives of Margaret Reynolds also asked for the play to be stopped. More than 85 percent of the readers who answered an Express & Star poll said the story should not be dramatized. Sidgwick defended the project at first: nothing in it, he said, was not already public, and it praised the diligence of the police and was meant to remind parents to be watchful.

Within two days, after he had spoken to the relatives, Sidgwick canceled the play and apologized for the distress it had caused. "I didn't feel I had any option," he said. Margaret Reynolds's sister said the family was relieved. "We are very relieved he is not going ahead," she said. Diane's niece called it "a real victory."

Disputed and unproven points

The deaths of Margaret Reynolds and Diane Tift. Morris was never charged with either death, and he was never tried for them. The Express & Star has called him the prime suspect, and reports since 2010 have said the cases remain open on file. A 2017 report described him as "thought to have murdered" all three girls and another as "strongly suspected" of the two earlier deaths. He denied any part in them. No court has ever ruled on who killed the two girls.

The 1964 attack and the 1966 disappearance. The Express & Star has linked Morris to an attack on a young girl in December 1964, saying that he was later found to have owned a car matching the one she described, and has reported that he was a suspect in the disappearance of a 10-year-old girl from Cannock in 1966. He was never charged in either case.

His innocence claims. Morris maintained throughout that he did not kill Christine Darby. His challenge rested on allegations that police misconduct, including tampering with interview notes, had tainted the 1969 conviction. The Criminal Cases Review Commission and the High Court rejected it. At trial he said he had been beaten by police; the jury convicted him.

Conflicting details in the reporting. The Express & Star's own accounts differ on several points:

The time Christine was taken: about 2 p.m. (2014) or about 2:30 p.m. (2022).

The cause of death: suffocated (2014, 2015 and 2022 reports) or strangled (2008 obituary of Stanley Bailey).

The date of the attempted abduction in Walsall: November 4, 1968 (2014 and 2015) or October 1968 (2022).

The arrest: the 2014 report says simply that Morris was arrested 15 months after Christine's body was found; the 2022 account gives the first arrest after the attempted abduction, the release, and the second arrest on November 15, 1968; a 2013 report says he was found guilty in November 1968, which is the month of his arrest, not his trial.

The ranks of the leading officers: Ian Forbes appears as both detective superintendent and chief superintendent, and Harry Bailey as both head of Staffordshire CID and assistant chief constable, while the paper's obituary of Stanley Bailey says he was the assistant chief constable who led the hunt.

The trial venue: "Stafford Assizes" in most reports, "Stafford Crown Court" in one.

The number of times Morris was questioned is given consistently as four.

Timeline

1929: Raymond Leslie Morris is born in Ryecroft, Walsall.

July 28, 1951: first marriage, in Walsall; two sons.

1958: tried at Walsall quarter sessions over a tape recorder; acquitted.

1960: separates from his first wife; they divorce in 1964.

August 1964: marries his second wife, who is 21.

December 1964: a young girl survives an attack in Bloxwich; Morris is later linked to it by the Express & Star but is never charged.

September 8, 1965: Margaret Reynolds, 6, disappears in Aston, Birmingham.

December 30, 1965: Diane Tift, 5, disappears in Bloxwich.

January 12, 1966: both girls are found on Cannock Chase. No one is ever charged.

October 1966: Morris is arrested after two schoolgirls complain about him; released without charge.

1967: begins work as a foreman engineer in Oldbury; arrested for indecent exposure.

August 19, 1967: Christine Darby, 7, is taken from near her home in Walsall.

August 22, 1967: Christine is found on Cannock Chase; Scotland Yard is called in.

January 1968: detectives visit 54,000 homes in Walsall.

February 1968: officers note that Morris's alibi rests on his wife alone.

November 4, 1968: attempted abduction of a girl in Walsall; Morris is traced through his car, held and released.

November 15, 1968: arrested for Christine's murder; his wife withdraws her alibi.

November 17, 1968: charged with murder.

January 7, 1969: appears before Cannock magistrates.

February 10, 1969: pleads not guilty at Stafford Assizes.

February 18, 1969: convicted of the murder of Christine Darby, with other charges; life imprisonment.

March 28, 1969: his old Austin Cambridge is burned by a Dudley car dealer.

November 1969: appeal dismissed.

1999: refused parole.

2000: moved to HMP Wymott.

June 2010: the Criminal Cases Review Commission refuses to refer his case.

February 7, 2011: Mr. Justice Simon dismisses his judicial review.

April 2011: plan to go to Strasbourg dropped.

2011: first signs of kidney failure and leukemia.

July 2013: European Court of Human Rights ruling on whole-life terms.

February 2014: Court of Appeal rules that whole-life terms may continue.

March 1, 2014: refuses further treatment.

March 11, 2014: dies at HMP Preston, aged 84.

October 2014: Prisons and Probation Ombudsman's findings reported.

December 2017: a planned stage play about the case is canceled after protests by the families of Diane Tift and Margaret Reynolds.