Ray Ferritto

Victims
2 killings admitted; indicted for aggravated murder in the 1977 Lyndhurst case; a 1969 Los Angeles death, his own claim, never charged.
Years active
1969 (his own claim) to October 6, 1977
Location
Lyndhurst, Ohio (killing); Los Angeles, California (killing, his own claim); Erie, Pennsylvania (residence); Cuyahoga County, Ohio (trial); Sarasota, Florida (death)
Method
Bombing or explosives (Greene; he testified he took part); shooting (Petro; his own account, never tested in court).
Status
Indicted 1977, aggravated murder; prosecution witness; plea and sentence not on record; died 2004. Released after under four years in prison for the two murders (AP); to Florida, 2000.

On October 6, 1977, in the Cleveland suburb of Lyndhurst, Daniel J. Greene was killed outside an office building where he had kept a dental appointment. The man brought in from out of state to arrange his death was Raymond W. Ferritto of Erie, Pennsylvania, who had no standing in the Cleveland underworld and had been chosen for exactly that reason. Less than two months later Ferritto was under indictment in Cuyahoga County with eight other men on charges that included aggravated murder. He was never tried. He turned, gave his account to the FBI, and in 1978 took the witness stand to tell a Cuyahoga County jury that he had been under contract to an Ohio crime family and had taken part in the murder.

His testimony helped send two men to prison for life, and four years later federal prosecutors called him again in the racketeering case that convicted the reputed head of the Cleveland Mafia. Ferritto himself, by the Associated Press's account, spent less than four years in prison for the two killings he admitted: the Lyndhurst murder and a 1969 death in Los Angeles that he claimed as his own. He went back to Erie, moved to Florida in 2000, and died in Sarasota in May 2004, at 75.

Ferritto came out of Erie, the lake port in the northwest corner of Pennsylvania, and it stayed his base for most of his life. By 1977 he had worked, at one time or another, as a bookmaker, a nightclub operator and an employee of a vending machine company. He had also spent years in California, and there he served prison time alongside a West Coast Mafia member who would later become a secret FBI informant and enter the federal Witness Protection Program in 1977. That acquaintance, made inside a California prison, is what eventually brought Ferritto to Cleveland.

He came to the job as an Erie man by way of Los Angeles, and that outsider status was what the men who hired him wanted. Neither their target nor the people around him knew his face.

Before Cleveland there was Los Angeles. In 1969 Julius Anthony Petro, a man formerly of Cleveland, died there, and Ferritto later claimed responsibility for the death. He was never charged with it, and no court ever heard evidence about it. It rests on his own word.

The death of John Scalish in 1976 left the Cleveland family without a clearly chosen successor, and a fight for control of racketeering across northern Ohio followed. James T. Licavoli emerged as the family's reputed boss. Against his organization stood a faction that, in the authorities' later account, was trying to take the area's rackets away from it, and the man at its head was the man who would die in Lyndhurst. John Nardi, a Teamsters leader, died in May 1977. The faction's leader had already survived earlier attempts on his life, among them one in Collinwood in 1975, and he was the next target.

He was born on November 14, 1929, and grew up in Collinwood, on Cleveland's East Side. He dropped out of high school and in time became a major figure in Cleveland racketeering, a public man who sat for a television news interview as late as June 1977. He was also an FBI informant. In the autumn of 1977, by one account, he was planning a cattle and meat venture in Texas.

The West Coast man later said that he had recommended Ferritto to Licavoli and others in the Cleveland organization. Through him Ferritto met Licavoli and one of Licavoli's associates, and he was told not to worry, that he would be taken care of. He was promised help and money in advance. Little of it arrived. Over the summer of 1977 he made repeated trips from Erie to Cleveland on the job, and by late summer he was disgusted with the arrangement. He stayed with it anyway.

He did not act alone. Pasquale Cisternino, a member of Licavoli's organization, worked with him on the preparations. Ronald D. Carabbia, a reputed organized crime figure from Poland, Ohio, near Youngstown, was with him in Lyndhurst on October 6, by Ferritto's account and by the verdict of the jury that later heard it. Ferritto told that jury that Carabbia carried out the final act of the killing. Carabbia denied being there at all and said he had been at a football game in Struthers that day.

The killing in Lyndhurst did not go unseen. Witnesses and records led investigators to Ferritto in Erie. He was among six men arrested for the killing.

Less than two months after the death, a Cuyahoga County grand jury indicted nine men, among them Ferritto, Carabbia, Cisternino and Licavoli, on charges that included aggravated murder, conspiracy and organized crime.

Ferritto's position changed quickly. Investigators persuaded him to talk, and he became a protected government witness. He gave statements to FBI agents, including an account of Licavoli's part in the plan, and Ohio prepared to put him on the stand against the men he had worked for.

The state's case against Ferritto's co-defendants went to trial in Cuyahoga County in 1978. Ferritto was named in the murder indictment but was not tried; he appeared as a prosecution witness, and on the stand he would not be moved from his account.

The jury split the verdicts. Charges against one defendant were dismissed. Licavoli and two other defendants were acquitted of every charge. Cisternino and Carabbia were found guilty of aggravated murder and a further offense and cleared of the organized crime count, and both men were sentenced to life in prison.

The state verdicts did not end it. Federal prosecutors in Cleveland went on to indict Licavoli and five others in U.S. District Court under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, and three of the acts charged in the federal indictment concerned the planning and carrying out of the 1977 deaths of Nardi and the Collinwood faction leader. By March 1982 Ferritto had been subpoenaed to testify for the government along with two other former insiders. His testimony, with information from the West Coast man, had been instrumental in the state convictions in the Lyndhurst killing.

On July 8, 1982, a federal jury in Cleveland convicted Licavoli and five co-defendants, Carabbia and Cisternino among them, on racketeering charges. Licavoli received 17 years in federal prison. The appeals court rejected the defendants' appeal in 1984, and Licavoli died in prison three years after his conviction. Carabbia's 12-year federal sentence ran concurrently with his Ohio life term.

After his prison term Ferritto returned to Erie, and in 2000 he left it for Florida. Carabbia, the man he named as his partner in Lyndhurst, served about 22 and a half years in Ohio before he was paroled in May 2002.

Ferritto died in Sarasota, Florida, in May 2004. He was 75.

Ferritto never stood trial for either death he admitted. The Lyndhurst case against him rests on his indictment, his own sworn account and the prison time he served. The 1969 death in Los Angeles rests entirely on his own claim; it was never charged, and no court tested it.

The division of tasks between Ferritto and Carabbia on October 6, 1977, was contested at trial. Ferritto testified that Carabbia carried out the final act. Carabbia denied being in Lyndhurst at all, and the jury convicted him.

The state jury did not accept the whole of the case built around Ferritto's word. Three defendants, Licavoli among them, were acquitted in 1978, and only two were convicted. Licavoli's later federal conviction came under a different statute and with other witnesses beside Ferritto.

Timeline

1969: A man formerly of Cleveland dies in Los Angeles; Ferritto later claims responsibility.

1976: John Scalish dies; a struggle for control of the Cleveland rackets follows.

May 1977: John Nardi dies.

Summer 1977: Ferritto takes the contract and makes repeated trips from Erie to Cleveland.

October 6, 1977: The leader of the rival faction is killed in Lyndhurst, Ohio.

Late 1977: Ferritto is arrested and indicted in Cuyahoga County with eight other men; he becomes a government witness.

1978: Ferritto testifies at the state trial; Cisternino and Carabbia are convicted of aggravated murder and a further offense and sentenced to life; three defendants, Licavoli among them, are acquitted.

March 1982: Ferritto is under subpoena as a witness for the federal racketeering trial of Licavoli and five others.

July 8, 1982: A federal jury in Cleveland convicts Licavoli and five co-defendants; Licavoli receives 17 years.

1984: The appeals court rejects the federal appeal.

2000: Ferritto moves from Erie to Florida.

May 2002: Carabbia is paroled.

May 2004: Ferritto dies in Sarasota, Florida, at 75.