Raoul Villain

Victims
1 victim, Jean Jaurès, Paris, July 31, 1914; acquitted by the Seine assize court, March 29, 1919, though he did not deny the act. Never convicted
Years active
July 31, 1914
Location
Paris, France (killing; trial); Reims, France (birth); Sant Vicent de sa Cala, Ibiza, Spain (death).
Method
Shot (as charged; the jury acquitted).
Status
Acquitted by the Seine assize court, March 29, 1919, after about 1,750 days in preventive detention. Killed on Ibiza, Spain, September 1936.

On July 31, 1914, in Paris, Jean Jaurès, the leader of the French socialists and the country's most prominent voice against war, was killed. Two days later Germany declared war on France. Raoul Villain, a young nationalist from Reims who had passed through a Catholic social movement and a patriotic student league, was taken into custody and tried for voluntary homicide, and by the accounts of his trial he never denied the act. He spent the whole of the First World War in preventive detention while his trial was put off again and again. When it finally opened before the Cour d'assises de la Seine in March 1919, the jury answered no to the question of whether he was guilty of voluntary homicide, and on March 29, 1919, he was acquitted. The dead man's widow, who had joined the case as civil party, was ordered to pay the costs.

The verdict was condemned almost everywhere outside the nationalist right, and it hastened the end of the political truce that had held France together through the war. Villain drifted for years afterward and by early 1933 was living alone in a remote valley in the northeast of Ibiza, where his neighbors knew him only as the Frenchman of the Cala. He was killed there in September 1936, in the first months of the Spanish Civil War.

Villain was born in Reims. Those who knew him as a young man described him as quiet and polite, but unsettled and apparently without direction in life. The army turned him down, and by 1914 he was a student of archaeology.

His politics formed in two movements. He first belonged to Le Sillon, the Christian social movement founded by Marc Sangnier, and stayed with it until Pope Pius X condemned it in 1910. He then joined the League of Young Friends of Alsace-Lorraine, a campaigning group sponsored by politicians of the right, Maurice Barrès among them. The league kept alive the cause of the "lost provinces" taken by Germany and prepared students for a possible war with Germany.

Villain was a keen reader of the nationalist press, and above all of L'Action française, the nationalist daily, at a time when that press was repeatedly accusing the socialist leader of treason. On July 18, 1914, less than two weeks before the killing, that paper called openly for his murder. Villain, for his part, held the socialist leader guilty of treason, chiefly for his fight against the law that had lengthened military service to three years.

The victim was a native of Castres and by 1914 the dominant figure of French socialism: the founder of the daily L'Humanité, the man who had brought the country's quarreling socialist parties into one organization, and a pacifist by conviction. He had fought the law of July 19, 1913, which raised the term of military service from two years to three, and in his book L'Armée nouvelle he argued for a defensive army built on reservists rather than a large standing force. Those positions earned him the hatred of nationalists and advocates of war across the spectrum, from the right and from parts of the left.

In the crisis that followed the assassination at Sarajevo, he threw his energy into trying to stop the slide toward a general war. On July 30, 1914, he learned that Russia had mobilized its troops and went to the under-secretary of state for foreign affairs to press the socialist position. He left that meeting discouraged. When he was asked what the socialists would do if war came, he answered that they would go on campaigning against it.

He was killed the next day, at a moment when ordinary people across Europe were only beginning to understand how serious the international situation had become. Within days France was at war, and the parties of the left joined the rest of the country in the wartime truce known as the union sacrée.

Villain was held in custody from the start. The investigation left open the question of whether anyone had encouraged or helped him, and a further inquiry ordered in 1915 did not settle it. The trial was postponed several times during the war, and Villain stayed in preventive detention throughout; by the spring of 1919 he had spent about 1,750 days there.

The trial opened before the Cour d'assises de la Seine on March 24, 1919, with the dead man's widow and daughter sitting as civil party beside the prosecution. Villain was questioned about his upbringing, his political motives and his time in Le Sillon and the Alsace-Lorraine league. Asked whether he had ever attended a sitting of the Chamber of Deputies, read the Journal officiel or heard the socialist leader speak, he answered no to all three questions.

The doctors who had examined Villain's mental state gave evidence. For the civil party and the prosecution, the court then heard the leaders of the socialist party and of the main trade union federation, the man who had been prime minister in July 1914, former ministers and two generals. The defense called witnesses of its own.

The civil party set out to defend the dead man's memory and his patriotism rather than to press Villain's guilt, and it did not ask for the death penalty. The prosecution asked for a conviction without proposing a sentence. The defense denied premeditation, argued that Villain had acted under a force he could not resist, and pointed to the years he had already spent in detention without trial.

The jurors had two questions to answer: whether Villain was guilty of voluntary homicide, and whether he had acted with premeditation. On March 29, 1919, they answered no to the first, which disposed of the second, and the presiding judge pronounced the acquittal. The widow, as civil party, was ordered to pay the costs. The verdict was condemned almost unanimously, and for a few months it pulled the divided socialist party together.

Freed in 1919, Villain led a wandering life. At the end of February or the beginning of March 1933 he appeared in Sant Vicent, a valley in the northeast of Ibiza that the island's roads did not yet reach. He spoke neither Catalan nor Spanish, dressed formally, and attached himself to one of the few foreign residents, a painter, after learning that he spoke French. He settled in the valley, and the local people grew used to him and his eccentricities. They called him the Frenchman of the Cala, and who he was became known there only years later.

He was killed on Ibiza in September 1936, in the first months of the Spanish Civil War.

Whether anyone encouraged or helped Villain in 1914 was never established; the supplementary inquiry of 1915 did not settle it, and the civil party was still pointing to the gaps in 1919.

Who killed Villain in 1936 has never been settled, and the accounts gathered on the island conflict.

Timeline

1910: Pope Pius X condemns Le Sillon; Villain moves to the League of Young Friends of Alsace-Lorraine.

July 19, 1913: The law extending military service from two years to three is passed over the socialist leader's opposition.

July 18, 1914: L'Action française calls for the socialist leader's murder.

July 30, 1914: The socialist leader learns of Russia's mobilization and presses for peace at the foreign ministry.

July 31, 1914: The socialist leader is killed in Paris; Villain is taken into custody.

1915: A further inquiry into possible accomplices is ordered.

March 24, 1919: Villain's trial for voluntary homicide opens before the Cour d'assises de la Seine.

March 29, 1919: The jury answers no on voluntary homicide; Villain is acquitted and the civil party is ordered to pay the costs.

Early 1933: Villain settles at Sant Vicent, Ibiza.

September 1936: Villain is killed on Ibiza during the Spanish Civil War.