Ranko Češić

Victims
10 murders admitted at Brčko, Bosnia, May to June 1992; convicted on his guilty plea of murder, rape and humiliating and degrading treatment
Years active
May 5, 1992 to June 6, 1992
Location
Brčko, Bosnia and Herzegovina (killings); Drvar, Bosnia and Herzegovina (birth); Belgrade, Serbia (arrest); The Hague, Netherlands (trial); Denmark (prison)
Method
Shot (eight victims); two victims beaten to death (agreed factual basis)
Status
Pleaded guilty to all 12 counts October 8, 2003; 18 years, March 11, 2004; no appeal. Status not on record after May 2014. Released early: granted April 30, 2014, effective May 25, 2014.

Ranko Češić was 27 years old when the war reached Brčko, a town on the Sava River in the north-eastern corner of Bosnia and Herzegovina. In the space of about a month, from early May to early June 1992, he killed ten men who were being held by Bosnian Serb forces at two collection centers in the town, the Partizan Sports Hall and the Luka camp. At Luka he also committed rape and humiliating and degrading treatment against two detained brothers. A decade later, after his arrest in Belgrade, he stood before the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia in The Hague and pleaded guilty to every count against him.

The tribunal convicted him of five counts of murder as crimes against humanity, five counts of murder as violations of the laws or customs of war, one count of rape as a crime against humanity and one count of humiliating and degrading treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war. On March 11, 2004, Trial Chamber I sentenced him to 18 years' imprisonment, the top of the range the prosecution had agreed to recommend. He served most of that term in Denmark and was released early, by decision of the tribunal's President, in May 2014.

His case never went to trial. Everything the court established about the killings came from a written factual basis that he signed, and from the documents the two sides filed at sentencing. That record is thin on the dead and detailed on the man who killed them.

Drvar, Brčko and the first weeks of the war

Češić was born on September 5, 1964, in the municipality of Drvar in western Bosnia and Herzegovina. He was brought up by his mother after his parents divorced. By the time the war began he was living in Brčko, and he would stay there until the end of 1996. He worked as a leather craftsman. He had done his compulsory military service in about 1983 or 1984, but he had no military career after it.

Brčko sat in the Posavina corridor, on the border with Croatia. On April 30, 1992, two explosions destroyed the two bridges that crossed the Sava, and the tribunal treated them as marking the start of hostilities by Serb forces in the town. On May 1, radio broadcasts ordered Muslims and Croats to surrender their arms, and Serb soldiers, paramilitaries and police deployed through the town.

The indictment that later named Češić describes what followed: the forcible expulsion of Muslim and Croat residents and their confinement in collection centers. Many of the women, children and elderly people were held at the nearby village of Brezovo Polje. Most of the men of military age, and a few women, were taken to Luka, a former port facility on the river. In early July the surviving detainees were moved to another camp at Batković, near Bijeljina.

Češić joined the Bosnian Serb Territorial Defense in Grčica, a part of Brčko municipality, at the start of May 1992. On May 15 he became a member of the intervention platoon of the Bosnian Serb Police Reserve Corps at the Brčko police station; a certificate from the Republika Srpska Ministry of Interior, put before the court by his own defense, gives that date. In that role, one of his tasks was to arrest named non-Serbs and bring them to the police station or to Luka for interrogation. He served in the police reserve until late June, and then as an ordinary soldier without rank.

The tribunal never fixed his exact place in the hierarchy. The evidence was, in the judges' word, fragmented and inconclusive. He had enlisted only days before the first killing, and the chamber concluded that he held a rather low-ranking position.

The Partizan Sports Hall

The first of the crimes took place on or about May 5, 1992, at the Partizan Sports Hall in Brčko, where Muslim civilians were being confined. Češić admitted that he took five detainees out of the hall and killed them. One was Sakib Becirević, known as Kibe. The other four were known to the court only as a man called Pepa, a man called Sale and the two sons of a man called Avdo.

The court knew almost nothing more about them. They were Muslim civilians, held in a sports hall in their own town, and they died within the first week of the Serb take-over.

Luka camp

The remaining crimes all took place at Luka. On or about May 9, 1992, Češić killed a Muslim detainee known as Sejdo, whose family name the prosecution never established. The indictment had alleged more than the factual basis admitted, and the court, as it did throughout, relied only on what Češić had agreed. The chamber accepted that the killing exposed the man's family to intense suffering.

On or about May 11, 1992, Češić and others took a Muslim detainee away from the men he was being held with and killed him. The indictment and the plea agreement gave the victim a family name that turned out to be wrong; the prosecution's sentencing brief identified him as Mirsad Mujagić, from Brčko. Češić told the court that he had known the man only by his first name and a nickname, and that he would have pleaded guilty in the same way whatever family name had been written down. The chamber ruled that the mistake did not affect the plea.

The same day, Češić committed the offenses that led to the two remaining counts: rape, and humiliating and degrading treatment, against two Muslim brothers detained at Luka. Both brothers were released from Luka within days. Neither has been publicly named.

On May 12 or 13, 1992, Češić and another Serb policeman killed a Muslim detainee at Luka named Nihad Jašarević. Češić acknowledged that he intended to kill him. The tribunal received no further detail about the victim.

The last killings came later in the camp's life. At some point between May 14 and June 6, 1992, Češić took four detainees and, with the help of two guards, killed at least two of them. Their identities were never established.

In all, Češić admitted to killing ten detainees and to the offenses against the two brothers. The court calculated that he committed every one of these crimes within a period of 10 to 32 days. He also admitted that he knew a state of armed conflict existed, that he was bound by the laws and customs of war including the Geneva Conventions of 1949, and that his acts formed part of a widespread or systematic attack on the Muslim and Croat civilian population of Brčko.

After the camp

Češić stayed in Brčko after the camp closed. On February 6, 1993, a man who was his friend died at his hands in the town, during a domestic dispute in which Češić had stepped in to protect the man's wife. The Republika Srpska Military Court in Bijeljina convicted him of involuntary manslaughter on December 26, 1994, and the Republika Srpska Military Supreme Court upheld the conviction on August 11, 1995. That court's judgement recorded that he had no previous convictions.

By then the war crimes tribunal had already charged him. On July 21, 1995, a judge confirmed an indictment against Goran Jelisić and Ranko Češić. Jelisić was tried separately and sentenced to 40 years' imprisonment; when his trial chamber gave judgement in December 1999, Češić had still not been arrested.

Češić left Brčko toward the end of 1996 and moved to Belgrade.

Arrest and plea

The authorities of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia arrested Češić in Belgrade on May 25, 2002. On May 30, 2002, while he was in custody in Belgrade awaiting transfer, he married. On June 17 he was transferred to the United Nations Detention Unit in The Hague, and at his initial appearance three days later he pleaded not guilty to all charges.

The prosecution then narrowed the case. A third amended indictment, filed on November 26, 2002, concerned Češić alone. It charged him with 12 counts arising from six incidents and alleged that he had acted under the apparent authority of the Brčko police.

On October 7, 2003, Češić and the Office of the Prosecutor filed a plea agreement, with a written factual basis attached. He agreed to plead guilty to all 12 counts and to testify in other proceedings before the tribunal if the prosecution called him. The prosecution agreed to recommend a sentence of between 13 and 18 years and not to appeal any sentence inside that range.

At the plea hearing the next day, October 8, 2003, Češić confirmed that he understood the chamber was not bound by the recommended range and that no one had forced or threatened him. He pleaded guilty to each of the 12 counts of the third amended indictment in turn, and the chamber, satisfied that the plea was voluntary, informed and unequivocal and that there was a sufficient factual basis for it, entered findings of guilt the same day. He was the sixteenth person to plead guilty before the tribunal.

Sentence

At the sentencing hearing on November 27, 2003, the chamber heard no live witnesses and worked from written statements, among them victim impact statements, the statements of one of the brothers and about ten character statements gathered by the defense.

Češić addressed the judges. He said that words such as remorse were insufficient to express what someone like him felt, and he described the crimes as belonging to "a time of euphoria, a time when all human dignity was abolished." He told the court he had deliberately not brought friends or relatives to speak for him because he did not want to increase the pain of the victims and their families. He ended by saying that prison was not his only punishment, "because it is even harder to go on living with this feeling of guilt."

The prosecution asked for a sentence at the top of the range. The defense asked for 13 years.

Trial Chamber I delivered its sentencing judgement on March 11, 2004. The judges considered it unlikely that Češić would commit the same kind of crime again, and they treated his guilty plea as an important step toward rehabilitation.

On gravity, the chamber noted that Češić had personally taken part in every crime. He alone committed the killings at the sports hall and the second killing; he committed the third and fourth killings together with others; and he committed the last killings with the help of two guards. He admitted that he intended to kill in each case, which the court treated as the most serious form of murder. The chamber was not persuaded that the presence of other men in some incidents reduced his responsibility. The offenses against the brothers it found particularly serious.

The chamber accepted that the victims' relatives had suffered severely, but held that such suffering is already part of what makes murder so grave, and that the statements filed did not prove, beyond reasonable doubt, suffering beyond what the violent death of a loved one ordinarily causes.

The judges then turned to aggravation. Ten murders in so short a period could not be called isolated acts, though the court counted their number once, as part of gravity, and not again as an aggravating factor. Because he was of low rank, they rejected the argument that he had abused a position of authority. What they did treat as aggravating was the vulnerability of the victims, all of whom were detainees under the control of Bosnian Serb soldiers and policemen, Češić among them, and the cruelty shown in the crimes, including his order to one detainee to take leave of the other men before he was killed.

In mitigation, the chamber accepted three things. The guilty plea had come some 16 months after his first appearance but before trial began, and it spared witnesses from reliving the events in court. His co-operation with the prosecution was substantial: he had given a full interview about what he knew of crimes in and around Brčko during the war and had committed himself to testify. His remorse, the judges found, was sincere.

Ten non-Serb character witnesses described Češić stepping in to stop soldiers mistreating Muslims, supplying food, getting men released from Luka and warning neighbors to stay indoors. The prosecution did not dispute those statements, and the chamber accepted that he had helped detainees and other Muslims and had saved some lives. It drew a harder conclusion from the same evidence: he had influence over other perpetrators and did not use it consistently, and he was capable of benevolent and criminal behavior at the same time. On the balance of probabilities, the court could not find that he was of genuinely good character. The 1993 manslaughter conviction, it decided, carried no weight either way. The judges also noted his good behavior at the United Nations Detention Unit.

Personal circumstances counted for nothing. The court did not accept that his upbringing, his low income, his marriage in custody or his age at the time justified leniency, and it rejected the claim that an acute stress reaction to the war had affected his conduct. Nor did it accept that he had acted under orders or under duress.

The chamber sentenced Češić to a single term of 18 years' imprisonment, with credit for 657 days already served since his arrest. Under the plea agreement, neither side appealed.

Denmark and early release

Češić remained in the tribunal's custody while it arranged a country to hold him. On April 11, 2005, he was transferred to Denmark to serve the rest of his sentence, the first person convicted by the tribunal to be sent there.

The tribunal's President granted him early release on April 30, 2014, effective May 25, 2014, after he had served more than two-thirds of his sentence. The decision pointed to signs of rehabilitation and to his co-operation with the prosecution, which included testimony in other war crimes cases in The Hague. He planned to live with his wife and to support himself from the income of the couple's restaurants.

His whereabouts and status are not on record after May 2014.

Disputed and unproven points

The indictment alleged that Češić held a position of authority at Luka and acted under the apparent authority of the Brčko police. The chamber found his exact rank unclear but undoubtedly low, and it rejected the claim that he abused authority.

The third amended indictment charged him with having committed or aided and abetted the last two groups of killings. In his plea and in the court's findings, he was held to have committed them, together with others.

The defense maintained that Češić acted on orders and under threat. The court found that claim unproven on the balance of probabilities.

The defense also presented him as a man of good character apart from a brief period in May 1992. The chamber held that it could not make that finding.

The identities of at least two of the dead, and the full names of others, were never established.

Timeline

September 5, 1964: Ranko Češić is born in Drvar municipality, Bosnia and Herzegovina.

April 30, 1992: Two explosions destroy the bridges over the Sava at Brčko.

May 1992: Češić joins the Bosnian Serb Territorial Defense in Grčica, Brčko municipality.

About May 5, 1992: He kills five detainees at the Brčko Partizan Sports Hall.

About May 9, 1992: He kills a detainee at Luka.

About May 11, 1992: He kills a second Luka detainee and commits the offenses against two brothers.

May 12 or 13, 1992: He and another policeman kill a third Luka detainee.

May 15, 1992: He joins the intervention platoon of the Bosnian Serb Police Reserve Corps in Brčko.

May 14 to June 6, 1992: He kills at least two more detainees at Luka.

Early July 1992: Surviving Luka detainees are moved to Batković.

February 6, 1993: A friend of Češić dies at his hands in Brčko.

December 26, 1994: The Republika Srpska Military Court in Bijeljina convicts him of involuntary manslaughter.

July 21, 1995: The indictment against Jelisić and Češić is confirmed.

August 11, 1995: The Republika Srpska Military Supreme Court upholds the manslaughter conviction.

End of 1996: Češić moves to Belgrade.

May 25, 2002: Arrested in Belgrade by Yugoslav authorities.

May 30, 2002: Marries while in custody in Belgrade.

June 17, 2002: Transferred to the United Nations Detention Unit in The Hague.

November 26, 2002: Third amended indictment, concerning him alone, is filed.

October 8, 2003: Pleads guilty to all 12 counts of the third amended indictment.

March 11, 2004: Sentenced to 18 years' imprisonment; no appeal.

April 11, 2005: Transferred to Denmark to serve his sentence.

April 30, 2014: The tribunal's President grants early release.

May 25, 2014: Early release takes effect.