Ramón Castillo Gaete was a Santiago music teacher and clarinetist who, by his mid-thirties, stood at the head of a small group of followers in central Chile. He was never charged, arrested or tried. Everything a court has said about his part in the death of his newborn son comes from one record: the facts that seven of those followers accepted, and that the Juzgado de Garantía de Quilpué fixed in its judgment of March 6, 2017. In those facts, it was during the first months of 2012, while one of his followers was carrying his child, that Castillo "decided to kill his son, once he was born." The boy was born in a clinic in Viña del Mar on November 21, 2012. On the night of November 23, at a rural property in Colliguay, in the hills above Quilpué, he died, and the court found that he died at Castillo's hands.
By the time that account took shape, Castillo was beyond its reach. When the case broke open in April 2013 he was already in Peru, and on April 25 the Quilpué court issued an order for his immediate capture. The PDI worked the search with Interpol and the Peruvian police. He died in Cusco, where Peruvian police found him on May 1, 2013. The Peruvian police confirmed his identity that day, and Interpol in Chile confirmed it. With his death confirmed, the case against him was closed without any finding on his guilt. No court ever heard his answer to what his followers accepted.
He was born on December 20, 1977, and grew up in Peñalolén, on the eastern edge of Santiago. He studied music at the Universidad Metropolitana de Ciencias de la Educación, the teacher-training university in the capital, where his teachers remembered a natural gift for the clarinet, and for three years he taught the instrument at a public secondary school in Peñalolén. Between 2003 and 2006 he played in Amaru, an Andean music group, and toured China with the band in 2006. After he left it he began offering weekend seminars near Colliguay.
The court dates the group to "at least the year 2009." It was never large: the judge described a community of fewer than twelve people, with Castillo at its head.
The inquiry that would bring the group before a court began with a protected witness, a former member, who gave a statement to prosecutors in Santiago on May 22, 2012. In February 2013 Castillo left Chile for Peru, on February 19. Two months later, on April 18, 2013, the child's mother gave a full statement to the Policía de Investigaciones de Chile (PDI), waiving her right to remain silent, and the case became a homicide investigation. Investigators established the birth and the death from the clinic's records and the statements of the staff who attended it.
On April 25, 2013, the Quilpué court charged four of the followers, one with parricidio and three with homicidio calificado, remanded them in custody and ordered Castillo's immediate capture. Three more members were in custody within days.
The charges did not stay where they began. In January 2014 prosecutors recast five of the members as accomplices rather than authors, leaving only the mother, charged with parricidio, and the second in command, charged with homicide, as principals. In September 2014 they went further and reformulated the case against six of the accused as encubrimiento, the offense of covering up a crime after the fact, and proposed to close the case by abbreviated procedure. On September 9, 2014, the Quilpué court turned that first proposal down. It took until 2017 for the case to end.
The followers' case ended without an oral trial. All seven accepted the prosecution's account under Chile's abbreviated procedure, and the court recorded that they did so freely and voluntarily, knowing their right to demand an oral trial. On March 6, 2017, the judge found the crime and each defendant's participation fully proved. She rejected the central argument of the defense, that the followers had acted under a shared delusion and bore diminished responsibility, and found that they had never lost their liberty of action.
The mother was convicted as author of parricidio consumado, committed "in the person of her son," and sentenced to five years in prison.
The group's second in command was convicted as author of homicidio calificado consumado, with the court finding treachery and premeditation, and sentenced to five years in prison.
Five other members were convicted as accessories (encubridores) to homicidio calificado consumado and sentenced to three years each, served under intensive supervised release.
A woman accused of helping Castillo leave the country had the case against her definitively dismissed in November 2015.
The two prison terms were not yet final. Both defendants remained free while their defenses appealed, asking that the sentences be served under supervised release on the ground of diminished responsibility. On April 18, 2017, the Third Chamber of the Valparaíso Court of Appeals rejected the appeals and upheld the five-year terms. It gave full weight to the psychiatric report the prosecution had commissioned, found that neither appellant "presenta una demencia de base," that is, neither suffered from an underlying mental illness, and held them "plenamente responsables de todos los actos que en el curso de esa adhesión cometieron," fully responsible for every act they committed in the course of their adherence to the group. The defense then brought a recurso de queja, a complaint against the appeal judges, to the Supreme Court. On May 11, 2017, its Second Chamber rejected it, finding no new argument in it, and the judgment that sent both to prison became firm.
Castillo was never charged, never questioned by a court and never tried. Every finding about his role comes from facts accepted by other people who were themselves accused, in a procedure he could not take part in; those facts name him as the person who decided on the child's death, ordered it and carried it out. The followers' own accounts differed on parts of the sequence, including the day of the death, which one member placed anywhere between November 23 and 26 before the court fixed it as November 23.
Whether Castillo himself suffered from a psychotic illness was argued for the defense but never resolved. The trial court accepted that, because he had died, no expert could examine him and the question could not be answered, and it found the followers fully responsible without settling it. The case against him ended with his death, not with a ruling: the regional prosecutor said it would be closed once his death was confirmed and any third-party involvement ruled out, and no court ever weighed the evidence against him. The date of his death is also given two ways: his death certificate, cited in the judgment, is dated April 30, 2013, while Peruvian police found him on May 1.
December 20, 1977: Ramón Gustavo Castillo Gaete is born.
2003 to 2006: plays clarinet in the Andean music group Amaru; tours China with it in 2006.
2009: the group forms around him, by the court's account.
May 22, 2012: a protected witness gives a statement to prosecutors in Santiago.
November 21, 2012: his son is born in Viña del Mar.
November 23, 2012: the newborn dies at Colliguay, Quilpué, at Castillo's hands in the facts the court later fixed.
February 19, 2013: Castillo leaves Chile for Peru.
April 18, 2013: the child's mother gives a full statement to the PDI.
April 25, 2013: four followers are charged in Quilpué; the court orders Castillo's immediate capture.
May 1, 2013: Castillo is found dead in Cusco, Peru; Peruvian police confirm his identity; the case against him is closed.
January 2014: five members are recast as accomplices rather than authors.
September 2014: six of the accused are recharged as encubridores; on September 9 the Quilpué court rejects a first abbreviated-procedure proposal.
March 6, 2017: seven followers are sentenced by the Juzgado de Garantía de Quilpué.
April 18, 2017: the Valparaíso Court of Appeals rejects the defense appeals and upholds the two prison terms.
May 11, 2017: the Supreme Court's Second Chamber rejects the recurso de queja; the sentences become firm.