Rahmi Sahindal

Victims
1 woman murdered in Uppsala, Sweden, January 21, 2002. Convicted of murdering his daughter, April 3, 2002, upheld on appeal; he had been convicted of threatening her in 1998.
Years active
January 21, 2002
Location
Uppsala, Sweden
Method
Murder of his adult daughter, whom he had been convicted of threatening four years earlier.
Status
Life imprisonment (April 3, 2002), upheld May 31, 2002; converted to 24 years by Örebro District Court, September 15, 2015; released in 2018 after serving two-thirds.

On the evening of January 21, 2002, Rahmi Sahindal killed his daughter, Fadime Sahindal, in Uppsala, the university city north of Stockholm where the family had lived since the early 1980s. Within hours he gave himself up to police and confessed. On April 3, 2002, Uppsala District Court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment, and on May 31, 2002, Svea Court of Appeal upheld the sentence even though he had by then withdrawn his confession.

The case did not begin that night. Four years earlier a Swedish court had convicted the same man of unlawful threats against the same daughter, and she had spent those years moving between cities, living with a personal alarm and an offer of protected identity, and speaking openly about the pressure her family put on her. Two months before her death she addressed a seminar in the Swedish parliament and described the control and threats she lived under. In the national debate that followed, her death was called an "honor" killing. In court it was a murder, and he was convicted of it.

Rahmi Sahindal was born in the district of Elbistan, in southeastern Turkey. He moved to Sweden in 1981 and worked there until 1998, and his family settled in Nyby, a district on the northeastern side of Uppsala.

Until 1998 he had never been in trouble with the law in Sweden.

She was born on April 2, 1975, in a village near Elbistan, and came to Sweden as a young child. She grew up in Nyby and went to school in Uppsala.

As she grew into her teens, the limits on where she could go and whom she could see tightened.

In 1996 she met a young Swedish man and fell in love. They kept the relationship secret from her family for about a year. In September 1997 her father saw the two of them together in the center of Uppsala. She treated that encounter as a point of no return and left the family. In the months that followed, her father threatened to kill her.

She went to the police. For a long time she felt that the officers and other officials she approached did not understand what she was describing, but one officer did, and she was given a personal alarm and offered a protected identity. She moved away from Uppsala, first to Sundsvall and then to Östersund, both in the north of the country.

She reported the threats, and in May 1998 her father was convicted of unlawful threats and fined.

About a month before the sentencing, she and her partner appeared together on television to talk about their relationship and about the threats against them. It was the first of many public appearances. She later said that turning to the press had been a last resort after other routes for help had failed, and that publicity had become her most effective protection.

Over the next three years she spoke on Sveriges Radio and Sveriges Television, and in the newspapers, about her own situation and about what she called honor-related oppression and the violence that came with it. In a documentary produced by the National Institute of Public Health she described her own life and how honor norms work. By her own description she had become a national celebrity, and the attention had grown beyond anything she had planned. She hoped it would protect her: if enough people knew who she was, she reasoned, her family might not dare to harm her.

In November 2001 she spoke at a seminar in the Riksdag, the Swedish parliament. She told her own story and described how her family saw her. She also argued that it ought to be self-evident for every young woman to be able to keep both her family and the life she wanted to lead.

On January 21, 2002, while she was visiting Uppsala, her father killed her in Nyby.

He surrendered to police in Uppsala that same night.

He confessed at once. By the next day he was in police custody in Uppsala, facing a charge of murder.

Rahmi Sahindal was tried for murder before Uppsala District Court in the spring of 2002. At that stage he did not deny the killing. In court he admitted that he had killed his daughter and said in his defense that he had been ill when he did it.

On April 3, 2002, the district court convicted him of murder and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

He appealed to Svea Court of Appeal in Stockholm. When the appeal hearing opened in May 2002, he withdrew his confession. He now told the court that an unknown man had threatened to kill his whole family unless he killed his daughter, and that this man had forced him to take the blame. He said he knew who the man was but could not name him because he feared for his own life.

On May 31, 2002, Svea Court of Appeal rejected his new account, upheld the conviction for murder and confirmed the sentence of life imprisonment.

Over the years that followed, he served his sentence and went through therapy with a psychologist. At some point in custody he dropped the denial he had put forward on appeal and again admitted the killing.

Under a law that took effect in November 2006, a person serving life in Sweden may apply to have the sentence turned into a fixed term. Rahmi Sahindal's first attempt failed: the court of appeal turned it down two years before he applied again.

In March 2015 he applied again. The application went to Örebro District Court, and at the hearings on it he confessed once more. He said he had been mentally ill at the time. The Prison and Probation Service did not oppose the application.

On September 15, 2015, Örebro District Court converted his life sentence into a fixed term of 24 years. In plain terms, the court found that the risk of his reoffending was low and that his present values did not create a risk for the future. It took into account that he had behaved well in prison and had worked, studied and taken part in sessions with a psychologist. It saw no sign that he would now justify further violence in the name of "honor". Neither the prosecution nor the defense said it would appeal, and the 24-year term stood. Under the ruling he had two years and five months left to serve.

In 2018, after serving two-thirds of the fixed term, Rahmi Sahindal was released.

His accounts of the killing changed three times. At the district court in 2002 he admitted it and pleaded that he had been ill. Before Svea Court of Appeal a few weeks later he denied it and blamed an unnamed man who, he said, had coerced him; the court rejected that account, and he never named anyone. Later, while serving his sentence and again at the 2015 conversion hearings, he admitted the killing once more. His claim that he had been ill was his own explanation. Neither court accepted it as a defense, and both sentenced him to life.

Timeline

1975, April 2: His daughter is born near Elbistan, Turkey.

1981: Rahmi Sahindal moves to Sweden.

Early 1980s: His wife and children join him; the family settles in Nyby, Uppsala.

1996: His daughter begins a relationship with a young Swedish man and keeps it from the family.

1997, September: He sees the couple together in Uppsala; she leaves the family.

1998, May: He is convicted of unlawful threats against her and fined.

2001, November: She speaks at a seminar in the Swedish parliament.

2002, January 21: He kills his daughter in Uppsala, surrenders to police the same night and confesses.

2002, January 22: He is held in police custody in Uppsala, facing a charge of murder.

2002, April 3: Uppsala District Court convicts him of murder and sentences him to life imprisonment.

2002, May: At the appeal hearing he withdraws his confession and blames an unnamed man.

2002, May 31: Svea Court of Appeal upholds the conviction and the life sentence.

2006, November 1: The law allowing conversion of life sentences takes effect.

2015, March: He applies again for a fixed term, after an earlier application was refused on appeal.

2015: He admits the killing again at the conversion hearings.

2015, September 15: Örebro District Court converts his life sentence to 24 years; neither side appeals.

2018: He is released after serving two-thirds of the fixed term.