Rae Carruth was a wide receiver for the Carolina Panthers when Cherica Adams was attacked in south Charlotte, North Carolina, in the early hours of November 16, 1999. She lived in the city, had been in an on-and-off relationship with Carruth and was expecting his child. Her son was born that night and survived with permanent injuries. She lived four more weeks and died on December 14, 1999.
The State of North Carolina charged Carruth with first-degree murder and sought the death penalty, on the theory that he had arranged the attack to avoid paying child support for a second child. On January 19, 2001, a Mecklenburg County Superior Court jury acquitted him of first-degree murder and convicted him of conspiracy to commit murder and two further felonies arising from the same night. Every appeal failed, in the state courts and then in the federal courts, and on October 22, 2018, he walked out of a North Carolina prison having served his sentence.
He was born Rae Lamar Wiggins in Sacramento, California, on January 20, 1974, a name he would go back to after prison, and he played college football at the University of Colorado before the Panthers drafted him in 1997.
Carruth had spent the evening of November 15 with her. Shortly after midnight she was attacked by men in another car, and Carruth left.
She was alive and conscious, and she called the emergency dispatcher. What she said on that recorded call became the spine of the case. She named Carruth as her baby's father, described his part in what had just happened and said that he had left afterward. Later that night she gave statements to a police officer and wrote notes to a nurse. Whether a jury should ever have heard those statements would occupy the courts for the next eleven years.
Police moved against Carruth nine days after the attack. On November 25, 1999, he was arrested on charges of conspiracy and attempted murder and released on a $3 million bond, on the understanding that he would surrender if she or the baby died.
When she died, he did not surrender. He left the Charlotte area, and on the day after her death FBI agents located him in Tennessee. He was returned to North Carolina and held without bond, and the charge became first-degree murder. The Panthers released him, and the NFL suspended him indefinitely.
Three men had been in the other car, and all three were charged. The gunman pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, which spared him a possible death sentence, and agreed to testify. The driver, facing the death penalty himself, took the stand at Carruth's trial without any plea agreement in place and later pleaded guilty to second-degree murder. The third man did not testify.
The trial opened in Mecklenburg County Superior Court in Charlotte on October 23, 2000. The driver was the State's central live witness. He testified that Carruth had recruited him and that Carruth wanted to avoid paying more child support, and the defense cross-examined him at length on his bias and on the inconsistencies in his accounts. A friend of Carruth's, testifying under a grant of immunity, described remarks he had made to her after the attack. She had come forward late, and the defense attacked her credibility.
Then came the recorded call. Played to the jury, it put the victim's own account of those minutes into the courtroom, and the State built its case around it.
Carruth's position never changed. He denied any part in planning what happened. His defense was that the gunman had acted on his own, angry that Carruth had backed out of financing a drug deal hours before, and in December 2000 a sheriff's office jailer testified that the gunman had told her as much.
Because the prosecution had chosen not to call the gunman, the defense called him. It did not go as the defense had hoped. On the stand he said that Carruth had hired him as a hit man to kill the mother and the child. He denied making any confession to the jailer and corroborated the driver on motive and on Carruth's part in the planning.
The jury deliberated over four days and at one point told the judge that it was divided. On January 19, 2001, it returned its verdict. Carruth was not guilty of first-degree murder. He was guilty of conspiracy to commit murder and of the two other felonies charged over the same night. The acquittal ended any possibility of a death sentence.
On January 22, 2001, the judge refused a defense request to set aside the convictions as inconsistent with the murder acquittal and imposed a minimum of 18 years and 11 months and a maximum of 24 years and 4 months, with credit for the roughly 14 months Carruth had already spent in jail. That evening he entered the state prison system. The gunman was later sentenced on his plea to a term with a minimum of 40 years, and the driver was released in July 2011 after about eleven years.
The appeal went first to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, where Carruth was named by his birth name, Rae Lamar Wiggins. In 2003 that court found that the trial judge had erred in admitting the handwritten notes the victim gave a nurse at the hospital, but it held the error harmless in light of the rest of the State's evidence. The Supreme Court of North Carolina denied review the same year, and in 2004 the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear the case.
Carruth then went back to the trial courts under North Carolina's post-conviction procedure. By then the Supreme Court of the United States had decided Crawford v. Washington. The court that heard his motion found that admitting all three of the victim's statements to the officer and the nurse had violated his Sixth Amendment right to confront the witnesses against him, since she had died before he could ever question her. It held, though, that the errors were harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, and the North Carolina Court of Appeals declined to review that ruling.
In federal court Carruth petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus in the Western District of North Carolina. The district court denied relief but allowed one question on appeal: whether the confrontation error required that he be freed or retried. On February 15, 2011, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit answered it. The court did not decide whether the statements to the officer and the nurse should have been excluded. It assumed that they should have been and asked only whether their admission had a substantial and injurious effect on the verdict.
It concluded that it had not. The recorded emergency call, which Carruth had never challenged, was the heart of the State's case, and the contested statements were mere drops in the sea of evidence. Nothing in them went beyond what the jury had heard from the call itself, from the driver and from Carruth's friend, and the defense had been free to attack the victim's condition and reliability through its own witnesses. The evidence of flight and of motive made the case a strong one. The denial of relief was affirmed, and no further court disturbed the convictions.
Carruth served his sentence in the North Carolina prison system. In October 2015 he was moved to a minimum-custody prison work farm, and he later finished his sentence at a minimum-security prison in the state, working as a barber for about a dollar an hour.
He never admitted guilt in court. In February 2018, in a letter to a Charlotte television station, he wrote that he felt responsible and apologized to the victim's mother.
He was released on Monday, October 22, 2018, at 44, after more than 18 years, and he did not speak to reporters. He was placed on nine months of post-release supervision, which required him to meet with a probation officer and to get permission before leaving the state or the country. Two days later the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections confirmed that the supervision had been transferred to Pennsylvania. As of that report he was using his legal name, Rae Lamar Wiggins. The gunman died in custody on December 3, 2023, at 63.
Carruth denied the motive the State put to the jury and denied any part in planning the attack. His defense offered a different explanation, a falling-out with the gunman over money for a drug deal, and a jailer testified that the gunman had told her as much; the gunman denied it under oath and said Carruth had hired him. The jury rejected first-degree murder while convicting him of conspiracy to commit murder. The trial judge declined to set that split aside, and the federal courts later treated it as no sign of prejudice. Carruth's 2018 letter accepted responsibility in general terms. He did not admit in any court that he arranged the killing.
January 20, 1974: Born Rae Lamar Wiggins in Sacramento, California.
1997: Drafted by the Carolina Panthers.
November 16, 1999: The victim is attacked in south Charlotte; her son is born that night.
November 25, 1999: Carruth is arrested on conspiracy and attempted murder charges and later released on a $3 million bond.
December 14, 1999: The victim dies; the next day FBI agents locate Carruth in Tennessee.
October 23, 2000: His capital trial opens in Mecklenburg County Superior Court.
December 2000: The gunman, who had pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, testifies that Carruth hired him.
January 19, 2001: Acquitted of first-degree murder; convicted of conspiracy to commit murder and two further felonies.
January 22, 2001: Sentenced to 18 years 11 months to 24 years 4 months.
2003: The North Carolina Court of Appeals finds a harmless error and affirms; the Supreme Court of North Carolina denies review.
2004: The Supreme Court of the United States declines to hear the case.
February 15, 2011: The Fourth Circuit affirms the denial of federal habeas relief.
October 2015: Moved to a minimum-custody prison work farm.
February 2018: Writes that he feels responsible and apologizes to the victim's mother.
October 22, 2018: Released after more than 18 years.
October 24, 2018: Pennsylvania confirms that his supervision has moved there.