Radoslav Brđanin killed no one with his own hands in the war that tore apart northwestern Bosnia in 1992, and the judges who convicted him never said he did. His instruments were decisions, decrees and speeches. As president of the Crisis Staff of the Autonomous Region of Krajina, the Bosnian Serb body that ran the region in the first months of the war, he sat at the center of a campaign that drove most of the Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat population out of their towns and villages. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia found that at least 1,669 of those people, all of them non-combatants, were killed by Bosnian Serb forces in attacks that his Crisis Staff's decisions had helped make possible.
On September 1, 2004, Trial Chamber II in The Hague convicted him of persecution, torture, deportation and forcible transfer as crimes against humanity, of wilful killing and torture as grave breaches of the 1949 Geneva Conventions, and of wanton destruction of towns and villages and destruction of religious institutions as violations of the laws or customs of war. It acquitted him of genocide, complicity in genocide and extermination, and sentenced him to 32 years. In April 2007 the Appeals Chamber reversed part of the torture conviction and cut the sentence to 30 years. He served most of it in Denmark. In September 2022, gravely ill and long past the point at which he became eligible for release, he was allowed to go home to Bosnia. He died four days later.
Brđanin was born on February 9, 1948, in Popovac, a village in the municipality of Čelinac in northern Bosnia and Herzegovina. He trained as a civil engineer. By the time Yugoslavia began to break apart he was a member of the Serbian Democratic Party, the SDS, and sat in the Assembly of the Socialist Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina as the party's delegate for Čelinac.
The tribunal traced the setting of his rise in detail. The secession of Slovenia and Croatia in 1991 shook Bosnia and Herzegovina, and by the second half of that year it looked increasingly unlikely that the republic would stay inside the Yugoslav federation. During that period, the trial chamber found, the Bosnian Serb leadership devised what the judges called the Strategic Plan: to link the Serb-populated areas of Bosnia, take control of them and create a separate Bosnian Serb state from which most non-Serbs would be permanently removed. The leadership knew, the chamber found, that the plan could only be carried out by force and fear.
On September 16, 1991, the Assembly of the Community of Municipalities of Bosnian Krajina became the Autonomous Region of Krajina, known by its initials as the ARK. Brđanin became first vice-president of its Assembly. On January 9, 1992, the newly created Assembly of the Serbian People in Bosnia and Herzegovina proclaimed the Serbian Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, later renamed Republika Srpska, and the ARK became one of its component regions.
Among the political figures of the Krajina, the trial chamber found, it was Brđanin whom the Bosnian Serb leadership identified as best representing its interests and chose to coordinate the plan in the region. The top leadership gave him a high degree of authority and autonomy.
The war in Bosnia had already begun when, on May 5, 1992, the ARK Executive Council decided to form a regional Crisis Staff and appointed Brđanin its president. From then until July 17, 1992, the Crisis Staff took over the powers of the ARK Assembly. The trial chamber found that it was set up chiefly to bring the political authorities, the army and the police together at regional level and to coordinate their work in carrying out the Strategic Plan. It was the highest civilian authority in the region. It exercised de facto authority over the municipalities and the police and had great influence over the army and the Serb paramilitary groups.
Brđanin was not a figurehead. The judges were satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that he was at the very heart of the Crisis Staff, its key figure and the driving force behind its major decisions. The Crisis Staff was later succeeded by the ARK War Presidency, which he also led. Later still he served as acting deputy prime minister for production, minister for construction, traffic and utilities, and acting vice-president of the government of Republika Srpska.
The heart of the case against him lay in a handful of Crisis Staff decisions and in what he said in public.
Between May 9 and 18, 1992, the Crisis Staff issued decisions on disarmament. They were addressed in general terms to all paramilitary units and individuals holding arms illegally, and they came with deadlines, but the trial chamber found that they were enforced selectively against non-Serbs. The judges found that these decisions gave practical assistance to the attacks that Bosnian Serb forces then launched on non-Serb towns, villages and neighborhoods, and that Brđanin knew those attacks would bring killings, torture and destruction.
On May 28 and 29, 1992, the Crisis Staff adopted decisions advocating what it called the resettlement of the non-Serb population. Read alongside the public statements Brđanin had been making since early April 1992, calling on non-Serbs to leave the Bosnian Krajina and saying that only a small percentage of them would be allowed to stay, the chamber found that these decisions could only have been meant as a direct incitement to deport or forcibly transfer non-Serbs from the region. On June 12, 1992, the Crisis Staff set up the Agency for the Movement of People and Exchange of Material Wealth in Banja Luka, which the judges found helped carry out the expulsions. On June 22, 1992, it decided that virtually all non-Serbs in the ARK were to be dismissed from their jobs.
The court gave great weight to his words. The trial chamber found that one of his most substantial contributions to the Strategic Plan was a propaganda campaign against Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats, carried out at every stage of his political career. His posts gave him access to the media, and he used it to make statements that created fear and hatred between Bosnian Serbs on one side and Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats on the other. The judges accepted that the statements may have been driven in part by personal ambition, but found them intentional and disastrous for people of every ethnicity. They incited Bosnian Serbs to commit crimes, helped create a climate in which crimes were tolerated, and discouraged well-meaning Bosnian Serbs from helping their non-Serb neighbors. Non-Serbs understood the statements as direct threats to leave, and many did, fearing for their lives. A number of witnesses testified that his words were the main reason they left.
The people who suffered under the Crisis Staff's rule were the Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats of thirteen municipalities: Banja Luka, Bosanska Krupa, Bosanski Novi, Bosanski Petrovac, Čelinac, Donji Vakuf, Ključ, Kotor Varoš, Prijedor, Prnjavor, Sanski Most, Šipovo and Teslić. The trial chamber found the killing of at least 1,669 of them proved beyond reasonable doubt, all non-combatants. The tribunal's own summary of the convictions lists among them at least three Bosnian Muslim civilians in Hambarine on May 23, 1992; about 140 Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat civilians in Kozarac and the surrounding area around May 24, 1992; at least eight Bosnian Muslims in Kamičani between May 24 and 26, 1992; eight Bosnian Muslim men in the village of Jaskići on June 14, 1992; and at least 300 Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat men in the village of Bišćani on July 20, 1992.
The crimes did not end with the dead. The trial chamber found that the campaign of persecution against Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats in the region included killings, torture, physical violence, rapes and sexual assaults, constant humiliation and degradation, the destruction and seizure of their property and their places of worship, deportation and forcible transfer, and the denial of their rights to work, to move freely, to proper medical care and to a fair judicial process. Camps and detention facilities were set up across the Krajina, and the chamber found that almost all of them came into being after the Crisis Staff was established. Convoys moved tens of thousands of people out of the region, many of them deported to Karlovac in Croatia or forcibly transferred to Travnik in central Bosnia.
Bosnian Serb forces also entered non-Serb towns and villages, looting and burning property that belonged to Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats. The trial chamber found that the purpose of these attacks was to create terror, destroy property and prompt non-Serbs to leave for good.
The tribunal's prosecutors indicted Brđanin, together with Momir Talić, on March 14, 1999. The indictment was kept under seal. It charged both men with individual and superior responsibility for the persecution of Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats in the ARK in 1992.
On Tuesday, July 6, 1999, troops of the NATO-led Stabilization Force, SFOR, detained Brđanin in Bosnia and Herzegovina. He was transferred to the tribunal in The Hague the same day, and the order keeping the indictment secret lapsed with his arrest.
He made his first appearance before Trial Chamber II on July 12, 1999, and pleaded not guilty to every count. The indictment was amended several times before trial, and from the day of his arrest he was never provisionally released.
The joint trial of Brđanin and Talić opened on January 23, 2002. In September 2002 Talić was released on health grounds and his case was separated; he died in May 2003 and the proceedings against him ended, leaving Brđanin to stand trial alone.
The final charges accused him, on the basis of both his own conduct and his authority as a superior, of genocide and complicity in genocide; of persecution, extermination, torture, deportation and inhumane acts (forcible transfer) as crimes against humanity; of wanton destruction of cities, towns or villages, or devastation not justified by military necessity, and destruction or wilful damage done to institutions dedicated to religion, as violations of the laws or customs of war; and of wilful killing, torture, and unlawful and wanton extensive destruction and appropriation of property not justified by military necessity, as grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions. The charges covered April 1 to December 31, 1992.
On November 28, 2003, after the prosecution closed its case, the trial chamber acquitted him of genocide under count 1 insofar as the charge rested on the third, extended category of joint criminal enterprise, and struck out the allegations concerning the municipalities of Bihać-Ripač, Bosanska Dubica and Bosanska Gradiška. On March 19, 2004, the Appeals Chamber reinstated the genocide charge.
Trial Chamber II delivered its judgment on September 1, 2004. It rejected several of the prosecution's theories of liability. Joint criminal enterprise, the chamber held, was not a fitting way to describe the responsibility of a man as remote as Brđanin from the crimes on the ground in a case of such breadth. Planning was dismissed for lack of evidence that he took part in the immediate preparation of specific crimes. Superior responsibility failed because, although the Crisis Staff had de facto authority over municipal officials and the police, the judges found that he lacked effective control over the people who committed the crimes and so could not have prevented or punished them.
He was convicted under Article 7(1) of the tribunal's Statute, individual criminal responsibility, and not as a superior. What remained were aiding and abetting, instigating and, in one respect, ordering. The chamber found that he aided and abetted the wilful killing, torture and destruction committed in the attacks that followed the disarmament decisions; that he both instigated and aided and abetted the deportations and forcible transfers; that he aided and abetted the destruction of religious buildings; and that he ordered the denial of the right to employment through the dismissal decision of June 22, 1992. In every one of these acts, the judges found, he shared the intent to discriminate against Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats. The chamber held that the ethnic cleansing was not a by-product of the criminal activity but its very aim.
On the gravest charges the court acquitted him. It was not satisfied that he knew the disarmament decisions would assist killing on the massive scale that extermination requires, nor that he knew the forces involved meant to kill on such a scale. It did not find it proved beyond reasonable doubt that genocide was committed in the relevant ARK municipalities between April and December 1992. Count 10, the grave breach of extensive destruction and appropriation of property, also failed. Of the twelve counts he faced, he was cleared of four.
In sentencing, the chamber counted as aggravating his leadership position, the status and vulnerability of the victims and the harm done to them, his willing participation and, to a lesser degree, the length of his criminal conduct and his education. In mitigation it considered evidence that he helped Bosnian Muslims from Čelinac find shelter, treated citizens equally in some instances, voiced concern about some paramilitary groups and took part in the decision to arrest members of one of them, along with his family situation and age, several speeches against war profiteering, his respectful conduct in court and remorse shown in individual instances. The chamber imposed a single sentence of 32 years, with credit for the five years, one month and 26 days he had already spent in custody.
Both sides appealed, and the Appeals Chamber delivered its judgment on April 3, 2007. Brđanin had alleged well over 150 errors; the Appeals Chamber dismissed dozens of them summarily and left the core findings undisturbed, including the nature of the Strategic Plan, the authority of the Crisis Staff over the municipalities, among them Prijedor, and his knowledge of and contribution to the plan.
It did reverse him on two points. It found no evidence that the personnel running the camps and detention facilities were even aware of his public attitude toward them, so his conviction for aiding and abetting torture inside those facilities could not stand. Acting on its own motion, it also reversed the conviction for wanton destruction insofar as it concerned the municipality of Bosanska Krupa. It upheld his conviction for wilful killing, rejecting his claim that the forces responsible had not been shown to be Bosnian Serb forces.
The prosecution won on questions of law about joint criminal enterprise, but because both sides had tried the case on the shared understanding that the physical perpetrators had to belong to the enterprise, it entered no new convictions on that basis. It also dismissed the prosecution's appeals against his acquittals for killings in camps and detention facilities, for certain killings in Teslić municipality and for extermination. Because some convictions fell, it reduced the sentence, though only modestly given the weight of what remained: 30 years, with credit for time served.
On March 4, 2008, the tribunal transferred Brđanin to Denmark to serve his sentence, with credit for every day in custody since July 6, 1999. He reached two-thirds of the sentence on July 6, 2019, the point at which prisoners under the tribunal's supervision become eligible to be considered for early release.
His first application for early release was denied on February 28, 2020, by the President of the International Residual Mechanism for Criminal Tribunals. The President held that the high gravity of his crimes weighed against early release and that he had failed to show sufficient rehabilitation. In a second application, filed in February 2021, he said that he accepted the high gravity of his crimes and his responsibility for them, and that he felt regret for all the victims and their suffering; if released, he would live with his family in Banja Luka. Later requests also failed.
Denmark, meanwhile, had found that he was eligible for release under Danish law and told the Mechanism it could no longer go on enforcing the sentence without a final deadline. No other country had been found to take him. On August 25, 2021, the Mechanism's President ordered him returned to the tribunal's custody in The Hague on a temporary basis, and he was moved there in September 2021.
In July 2022 the medical officer responsible for him in The Hague reported a recent and apparently serious deterioration in his health. On August 4, 2022, he applied urgently for early release on compelling humanitarian grounds. On September 3, 2022, after consulting two judges, both of whom agreed, the President granted the application, finding compelling humanitarian reasons for his release.
The release came with strict conditions for the rest of his sentence: supervision by an authority designated by Bosnia and Herzegovina, confinement to his residence except for urgent medical needs, no contact with victims or witnesses, and a ban on discussing his case with the media, denying the crimes, glorifying anyone the tribunal had convicted or taking part in politics beyond voting.
He arrived in Banja Luka the same day, after 23 years in custody. He died in Banja Luka on Wednesday, September 7, 2022.
The genocide charge was the most contested question in the case. The prosecution pressed it through two rounds of litigation, and the Appeals Chamber restored it in March 2004 after the trial chamber had first dismissed part of it, but at the end of the trial the judges found that the evidence did not establish beyond reasonable doubt that genocide was committed in the ARK municipalities in 1992.
The extermination acquittal also survived appeal, but on narrower grounds. The Appeals Chamber agreed with the prosecution that the trial chamber had been unreasonable in failing to find that the men who carried out four specific large-scale killings had the intent required for extermination. It left standing, however, the finding that Brđanin himself did not know that extermination would be committed in the ARK.
Whether he took part in a joint criminal enterprise was never decided against him. The trial chamber rejected the theory, and the Appeals Chamber, while correcting the trial chamber's law, declined to enter any new conviction on that basis. One judge of the Appeals Chamber partly dissented on the issue, and two others wrote separately.
February 9, 1948: Born in Popovac, municipality of Čelinac, Bosnia and Herzegovina.
September 16, 1991: The Autonomous Region of Krajina is formed; he becomes first vice-president of its Assembly.
January 9, 1992: The Serbian Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina is proclaimed.
May 5, 1992: He is appointed president of the ARK Crisis Staff.
May 9 to 18, 1992: The Crisis Staff issues its disarmament decisions.
May 23 to July 20, 1992: Killings at Hambarine, Kozarac, Kamičani, Jaskići and Bišćani, among those the court found he aided and abetted.
May 28 and 29, 1992: The Crisis Staff adopts its resettlement decisions.
June 12, 1992: The Agency for the Movement of People and Exchange of Material Wealth is set up in Banja Luka.
June 22, 1992: The Crisis Staff orders the dismissal of virtually all non-Serbs in the ARK.
July 17, 1992: The Crisis Staff's period exercising the powers of the ARK Assembly ends.
March 14, 1999: Sealed indictment against him and Momir Talić.
July 6, 1999: Detained by SFOR in Bosnia and Herzegovina and transferred to The Hague.
July 12, 1999: First appearance; pleads not guilty.
January 23, 2002: Trial opens.
November 28, 2003: Rule 98bis decision on genocide.
March 19, 2004: Appeals Chamber reinstates the genocide charge.
September 1, 2004: Convicted on eight counts, acquitted on four; sentenced to 32 years.
April 3, 2007: Appeals Chamber reverses part of the convictions and imposes 30 years.
March 4, 2008: Transferred to Denmark to serve his sentence.
July 6, 2019: Reaches two-thirds of his sentence.
February 28, 2020: First application for early release denied.
August 25, 2021: Ordered returned to the tribunal's custody in The Hague.
September 3, 2022: Early release granted on humanitarian grounds; returns to Banja Luka.
September 7, 2022: Dies in Banja Luka.