Late on the morning of Sunday, October 21, 2012, seven women were wounded at a business in Brookfield, Wisconsin, a suburb west of Milwaukee, and three of them died. Police named the man responsible as Radcliffe Franklin Haughton, a 45-year-old from the neighboring village of Brown Deer. One of the dead was his estranged wife, who worked there. Only three days earlier a Milwaukee County judge had granted her a four-year injunction ordering him to stay away from her. Haughton died by suicide in Brookfield the same day, so no charge was ever filed over the deaths and no court ever heard the case.
Haughton had served in the Marine Corps, and the Brown Deer officers who dealt with him knew it. In later years he worked in car sales. He and his wife, Zina Haughton, shared a residence in Brown Deer, and by the time of her death their troubles had been before the police and the courts for almost two years.
On January 8, 2011, she called 911 after an argument. Haughton had thrown her clothes and bedding into the yard and poured tomato juice over her car. When officers arrived he refused to speak with them, and the encounter became a standoff that lasted about 90 minutes before it ended peacefully. Officers believed he had threatened her from a window, but they could not confirm it, because she would not let them inside. He was charged with misdemeanor disorderly conduct. The charge was later dismissed after a prosecution witness failed to appear in court; one wire report said that witness was a police officer.
The marriage was coming apart by the autumn of 2012. On October 4, police said, Haughton damaged the tires of his wife's car in Brookfield while she and two co-workers watched. He was arrested and charged over the damage as a domestic matter. In the days that followed she needed a police escort to return to the Brown Deer residence and collect a few belongings.
On October 8 she went to Milwaukee County Circuit Court and filed a written request for protection. In it she said her husband was convinced she was unfaithful, that he had assaulted her, and that he had threatened to kill her if she ever left him or called the police. She described other threats as well, against herself and against her family. "His threats terrorize my every waking moment," she wrote. A temporary restraining order was issued against him that day on her domestic abuse complaint.
The temporary order held only until a hearing, and that hearing took place on Thursday, October 18, 2012, in Milwaukee County Circuit Court. Haughton appeared. The judge granted his wife a domestic abuse injunction for four years, barring him from contacting her or entering her residence until it expired. Three days after the hearing, she was dead.
Brookfield police received the first calls late that Sunday morning. Haughton had come to the business in Brookfield where his wife worked. Seven women there were wounded, and three of them died. The others in the building got out or were brought out by police. Late that afternoon police established that Haughton had died by suicide in Brookfield.
The Waukesha County Medical Examiner's Office identified the three women on Monday, October 22. Along with Haughton's wife, of Brown Deer, they were Maelyn M. Lind, of Oconomowoc, and Cary L. Robuck, listed as from Racine, though her death notice placed her home in Caledonia. Among her friends and family she was known for the baking she did for others, above all cupcakes, cookies and peanut butter bars.
The four wounded women were taken to a Milwaukee-area hospital. Early on Monday one was in critical condition and three were listed as satisfactory, and three of the four were still in the hospital that day.
The Brookfield Police Department led the investigation, with help from neighboring departments, state agencies and federal investigators. Because Haughton died before any charge could be brought, its findings were never tested in a courtroom, and the inquiry closed without a defendant, a charge or a verdict.
No court ever examined the deaths of October 21, 2012. The account of who was responsible and how the morning unfolded rests on statements by the Brookfield police and the Waukesha County Medical Examiner's Office, and Haughton was never charged.
The January 2011 standoff in Brown Deer left an open question that was never settled. Officers believed Haughton had threatened his wife from a window, but they never confirmed it, and the disorderly conduct charge that followed was dismissed without a trial.
January 8, 2011: Police called to the Haughton residence in Brown Deer after an argument; a 90-minute standoff ends peacefully, and a disorderly conduct charge follows.
2011: The disorderly conduct charge is dismissed after a prosecution witness fails to appear.
October 4, 2012: Police say Haughton damaged the tires of his wife's car in Brookfield; he is arrested and charged.
October 8, 2012: Haughton's wife files for protection in Milwaukee County Circuit Court; a temporary restraining order is issued.
October 18, 2012: At a hearing in Milwaukee County Circuit Court, the judge grants a four-year domestic abuse injunction against Haughton.
October 21, 2012: Three women die and four more are wounded in Brookfield; police attribute the deaths to Haughton, who dies by suicide the same day.
October 22, 2012: The Waukesha County Medical Examiner's Office identifies the three women who died.